Category: Editorial

  • Cyber threats

    Cyber threats

    • Nigeria needs an all-embracing strategy to curb the incidence

    Nigeria may already be in a state of undeclared war – that is if the disclosure by the Minister of Communications and Digital Economy, Isa Pantami, about the scale and intensity of cyber-attacks targeted at the country in the past few weeks are anything to go by.

    According to the minister, the country recorded a total of 12.9 million cyber-attacks during the presidential election. To understand the context, threats to public websites and portals before then averaged around 1.5 million daily; this would skyrocket astronomically to 6.9 million on the election day.

    How many of these attacks were specifically targeted at election infrastructure?

    Although the minister alluded to heightened threat intelligence in the run-up to the general elections, he would not be explicit on the nature.

    As for the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), it would

    neither confirm nor deny that any attacks took place. In the end, discerning Nigerians are left to

    making wild guesses in the aftermath of the glitches that attended the upload of the data captured by the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) into the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IREV).

    Most certainly, it could not be mere happenstance that the attacks still came long after the swirling rumours of impending attacks on INEC systems.

    From the terror of the ballot-box snatcher in broad daylight, Nigeria’s brood of electoral robbers

    would appear to have switched to a new mode of ‘thuggery’ adorned in digital cloak, united in the same shared objective to upend the electoral process. It is a threat that the Federal Government cannot afford to treat with levity.

    The leadership of the Ministry of Communications and Digital Economy obviously deserves praise for anticipating and hence spearheading the initiative which led to foiling of the attacks.

    More especially so is the ministerial standing committee on the protection of Nigerian cyberspace and ICT

    infrastructure. The committee, with membership drawn from the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC),

    National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) and Galaxy Backbone (GBB), was charged with the responsibility of monitoring of telecommunication infrastructure for the successful conduct of credible, free, fair, and transparent elections. The committee was also charged with developing and implementing plans to enhance the resilience of critical digital infrastructure against cyber threats, designing procedures and using technologies to prevent, detect, and respond to cyber-attacks, as well as developing the ability to recover from any damage that is done quickly.

    As far as we can see, the body has done a fairly good job.

    But then, cyber-attacks come in diverse, multi-dimensional forms. Indeed, no sector of the economy is immune to cyber-attacks. From power systems to manufacturing processes right up to the

    financial services sector, etc., the potential for disruptions could sometimes prove incalculable.

    Only last week, this newspaper, while reflecting on the newly introduced open banking regulatory framework raised the million naira poser on the dire implication of its coming at this time for

    cybercrimes and data breaches.

    We also recall that the director-general of NITDA, Kashifu Inuwa, had, at a cyber security event in faraway Dubai, United Arab Emirates, called attention to the intensity and cost of cyber-attacks. He drew a citation from Check Point Research Report of 2022: “African countries experienced an average of 1,848 cyber attacks per week, per organisation in 2022, compared to 1,164 globally. Nigeria, the most populous African country, accounted for the largest number of users, with over 100 million internet users, followed by Egypt with 76 million and South Africa with 41 million…these countries, along with Kenya, also account for 60% of the $4 billion annual cost of cybercrime in Africa.”

    In other words, the dangers are real just as the incidences are global and extremely costly. It explains why countries and organisations spend billions of dollars to ensure the protection of their data and their systems from possible compromises and subversions. Nigeria therefore cannot be an exception.

    However, rather than ad hoc schemes to combat specific attacks as is currently the case, what is needed is a national strategy that is inclusive and all-embracing. And then of course a task force of sorts to co-ordinate and lead the charge against cyber threats in its varied forms.

  • Joseph Wayas as mirror

    Joseph Wayas as mirror

    Political office holders have a lesson to learn from his abandoned body abroad, 15 months after his death, due to lack of funds

    In the pathetic and ironic tale of the widely reported abandonment of the body of Dr Joseph Wayas, President of the Nigerian Senate in the Second Republic from 1979 to 1983, in a morgue in London since his death 15 months ago on November 30, 2021, apparently for financial reasons, the Nigerian political elite has a mirror that brings into sharp focus its individual and collective dereliction as regards its moral responsibility to society. It is a story that speaks graphically to such issues as the transience of power, the obligation of the individual in private life and public office as well as the persistent perversion of values that is at the heart of the country’s protracted underdevelopment.

    Born on May 21, 1941, in Basang, Obudu, Cross River State, Wayas was one of the most colorful and flamboyant public office holders in the Second Republic, an era decried for the reckless opulence and pervasive corruption of the political class, although the moral depravity of that time pales into insignificance compared with what the country was to witness thereafter, up till now. The squandering of the country’s riches largely through the misappropriation of her earnings from oil funded the ostentatious lifestyle of a decadent and visionless elite of which Wayas, even if indirectly, was a complicit part. As the number three citizen and part of the powerful inner circle of the ruling National Party of Nigeria (NPN) at the time, Wayas, as routinely reported in the media then, undoubtedly enjoyed the best of times and basked in the aura of his influence.

    It is thus a grand irony that the same Wayas would have his body stranded in London over a year after his demise due to unavailability of funds to fly him back home and give him the decent burial befitting his status. As has become the norm with the wealthy and privileged sections of our populace, Wayas had to seek succour in the advanced medical facilities and expertise of highly developed countries like the UK when he fell Ill. This is against the background of the near total collapse of effective and efficient health care services in Nigeria, with millions of our poverty-stricken people forced to make do with Ill-equipped and poorly staffed public clinics and hospitals as they cannot afford exorbitantly priced private medical care. Thousands of our skilled medical specialists are known to have left the country and continue to do so in droves as they utilise their skills in countries where they are not only appropriately rewarded financially for their services, they have the conducive environment and requisite facilities to guarantee professional fulfillment.

    It is thus sad that when Wayas became sick, President Muhammadu Buhari had to make funds available to facilitate his being flown abroad for proper health care.

    The first son of the deceased, Joseph Wayas jnr, as reported in the media, has been profusely thankful for President Buhari’s intervention, saying that the government’s financial assistance enabled his father have access to the best medical care in London. Unfortunately, he lamented, the resources made available got exhausted within three months and before Wayas died, it was his sister in London who was responsible for his treatment and has also been responsible for maintaining the corpse since 2021.

    To be fair to him, Wayas was not found personally culpable for any acts of corruption during his tenure as Senate President despite the venal moral climate of the time. Many politicians of that dispensation were found guilty of misappropriation and embezzlement of public funds and were given long prison sentences by anti-corruption tribunals set up by the succeeding military regime, even though the military, thereafter, demonstrated that it was no less susceptible to corruption than the civilian politicians it demonised.

    Wayas’ plight illustrates how it is most times impossible for high public office holders in the country to maintain their often profligate lifestyles in private life when they no longer have free access to public resources, especially when they have not made the investments necessary to sustain their high tastes.

    No less embarrassing and distasteful is the controversy that has surrounded the utilisation of the substantial funds reportedly made available by Governor Ben Ayade of Cross River State to a burial committee he set up to facilitate a befitting burial for the eminent son of the state. The committee, which was headed by a two-time Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Mr. Kanu Agabi, also had as member Mr. Ntufam Fidelis Ugbo, a former Executive Secretary of the National Planning Commission. Unfortunately, there has been nothing but buck-passing between some members of the committee and the Wayas family on why the deceased’s transportation home as well as his burial remain stalled.

    Directing those who sought information from him to Joseph Wayas jnr, Mr. Ugbo said “He cannot say he does not have explanation to give about why the funeral is delayed. He is the first son. He should be in charge”. But the former referred inquirers back to the committee saying “I heard there are issues surrounding the funeral funds. And some members are said to have resigned. I cannot go back to the state government or the Federal Government now due to election issues. The governor has done well already”.

    Given the high offices they had held in the past and their status and experience, Mr. Agabi and Mr. Fidelis Ugbo should have handled their assignments on the committee better. It is not helpful that they are both said to have quit membership of the burial committee, possibly out of frustration. After all, scarce public funds had been made available by the governor to facilitate the burial so it is no longer strictly a private affair of the Wayas family. Any misgivings or disagreements on use of funds or other matters should have been brought to the attention of the state government which would have given necessary directives binding on all. These controversies are damaging to the image of the Wayas family, members of the burial committee, Cross River State and indeed Nigeria, since this is the body of a former number three citizen trapped in a foreign land.

    Wayas was an amiable and affable gentleman who played politics without bitterness or antagonism. Before going into politics, he had worked as a manager in a number of companies in Nigeria and the UK and later joined the federal public service where he served between 1969 and 1972. Educated at the Dennis Memorial College, Onitsha, he also studied at the Higher Tottenham Technical College, London, the West Bromwich College of Commerce, Science and Technology, Birmingham and Aston University, Birmingham.

    He was appointed Commissioner for Transportation in the former South-Eastern state from 1972 to 1974 and was a member of the Constituent Assembly that debated and ratified the 1979 Constitution from 1977-1978. Although a founding member of the defunct All Peoples Party (APP) at the inception of this dispensation in 1998, he joined the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) in 2001 and was awarded the national honour of Grand Commander of the Order of the Niger ( GCON) in 2010 by former President Goodluck Jonathan.

    Wayas who was a household name and one of the most visible and influential personalities of the Second Republic had sunk into veritable political anonymity long before his death. His life is a lesson in the transience of power, and as the country enters a new phase in its ongoing political evolution in this dispensation, all incoming political office holders must always bear this in mind. Public office offers an opportunity to bequeath a worthy and enduring legacy through selfless, committed and altruistic public service or be, sooner or later, relegated to the negligible footnotes of history as life moves on inexorably.

    All said, we urge eminent indigenes of Cross River State to step in to resolve the contentious issues on his abandoned body abroad and ensure that the burial is done as soon as possible.

    May Joseph Wayas rest in peace.

  • Ismaila Mabo (15 July 1944 – 13 March 2023)

    Ismaila Mabo (15 July 1944 – 13 March 2023)

    •Winner or loser, he was the quintessential athlete and unassuming coach nurturing stars

    Not a few still savour the winning start of Ismaila Mabo, the young schoolboy international and his fellow Nigeria Academicals, in 1966.  For the first time, the Nigerian Cadet Internationals went to Accra to beat their Ghana counterparts, 1-0.  In the return leg in Lagos, they would repeat the same feat, beating Ghana, 2-1.  

    It was the first time ever any Nigerian national side would beat Ghana — and it was fine augury for the glittering club career that awaited the young lad who, straight from school in 1966, joined the formidable but ill-fated Jos XI (later, Mighty Jets of Jos), the township darling club of his native Jos.

    Mabo’s schoolboy jump into a Nigerian side would open the doors for many fledgling ex-school boys that later would “breeze” into the national team, by the sheer audacity of their skills: Haruna “Master Dribbler” Ilerika, Stephen “Big Boss” Keshi and Henry Nwosu, the youngest lad in the Green Eagles that won the African Cup of Nations, for the very first time in 1980, in Lagos.

    Sadly, however, Mabo’s winning start with Nigeria would not translate into club glory, with the Mighty Jets, perhaps the most ill-fated club in the Nigerian football firmament.  

    Mighty Jets (as Jos XI) first reached the final of Nigeria’s FA Cup (now the Aiteo Federation Cup, then popularly known as Challenge Cup) in 1951.  Jos lost 2-3 to Lagos Railways, then the Lagos powerhouse of Nigerian football.

    Then, from 1962 to 1967, Mighty Jets reached six straight FA Cup finals and lost all! — 1962: 0-1 loss to Nigeria Police FC; 1963: 0-1 (Port Harcourt FC); 1964: 1-3 (Lagos Railway FC); 1965: 1-3 (Lagos ECN FC); 1966: walk-over loss to Ibadan Lions (since pre-Civil War tension prevented the Jos club’s many Igbo players from travelling to play the final in Lagos); 1967: 1-3 (Stationery Stores FC of Lagos).

    The young Mabo joined Mighty Jets in 1966, and but for the walk-over, would have played in that 1966 final loss.  But he would suffer two further future FA Cup final losses with the team: 1970: 1-3 (Lagos ECN) and 1972: 2-3 loss in the Ibadan replay, after a 2-2 draw in Lagos, a week earlier (Bendel Insurance FC).  

    By that time, the Lagos sporting press had dubbed Mighty Jets the “Soroye” (Yoruba regal quip for near-miss: one who ‘sees’ the throne but would never mount it!). That was the perennial fate of the Jets, even with talented defender, Mabo and iconic attackers, Sam Garba Okoye and Layiwola Olagbenro in their ranks!  

    Besides, the Jos quest as the first northern side to win the FA cup eluded them.  BCC Lions of Gboko, Benue State (ironically from the old Benue-Plateau corridor), would earn that record in 1989.

    Mabo’s FA Cup crashes with Mighty Jets would rank among the epochal failures of Nigerian club football.  But that was as depressing as Mabo’s success with the Super Falcons, Nigeria’s women national team, was spectacular.

    In 1998, Coach Mabo propelled the Falcons to their first African Women’s Championship (AWS) title in Lagos, with his girls scoring 28 goals and conceding none, at that inaugural championship on home soil.  He would boss that team till 2001/2002, when the Falcons were well-neigh invincible, thrashing all comers.

    What is more?  During his reign as Falcons boss, he produced two African Women Players of the year, in Cynthia Uwak and Perpetua Nkwocha.  During that era too, the Falcons’ safest pair of hands was reported to have hidden an advanced pregnancy just to be between the sticks!

    Mabo would also drive Falcons to the quarter-final of the 1999 FIFA Women’s World Cup — the farthest any Nigerian or African side has so far gone — only stopped by Brazil by a lone golden goal, in extra-time, after a 0-0 draw at full-time.

    The Falcons would build on that mighty Mabo foundation to annex nine AWC titles — a record by miles, compared with their other African female rivals.  Besides, that foundation has produced the likes of Barcelona FC of Spain’s Asisat Oshoala, current African women footballer of the Year.

    Something remained constant with Ismaila Mabo — at the dale of club cup failure with Mighty Jets and at the peak of sterling coaching success with the Super Falcons: he was the quintessential athlete and coach, totally devoted to his craft on the pitch and to his stupendous nurturing of his girls, turning many of them into African champions and world beaters.

    Mabo lived the conclusive phase of his long life in ill health.  He died reportedly after a bout of illness.  

    The epigram on his grave may well read: Here lies the athlete, true to his craft and to his sporting country, in seasons of club adversity and national team glory, without a shred of scandal to his name.

    He died a hero and fit road model for up-coming footballers, coaches and sundry athletes.  His family should take huge comfort in that stellar image, as they mourn his passage in ripe old age.

  • Last lap

    Last lap

    •With state polls, the 2023 general election rounds up

    Nigeria goes into the concluding phase of the 2023 general election tomorrow, with the state-level polls. The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) will be conducting elections into governorship seats in 28 states of the federation and house of assembly elections in all the 36 states. Governorship election will not hold in Anambra, Bayelsa, Edo, Ekiti, Imo, Kogi, Osun and Ondo states because those states are off the general election cycle grid.

    The first phase of the general election held on February 25 and involved the national-level polls that were conducted into the presidency and all seats of the National Assembly (NASS) comprising 109 seats in the Senate and 360 seats in the House of Representatives. The presidential poll produced Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu of the All Progressives Congress (APC) as winner and the president-elect.

    This second phase was scheduled to have held on March 11 but INEC shifted it by a week after obtaining the nod of the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal to reconfigure the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) devise it used for the national polls, for use in the state polls. The tribunal’s approval was obtained on March 8, three days ahead of March 11, with the electoral body saying there were some 176,000 BVAS units to be reconfigured and it needed more time than was available with the earlier timeline.

    Tomorrow’s election will feature 837 contestants seeking the 28 governorship offices to be filled, and 10,231 candidates jostling for a total of 993 state assembly seats nationwide. For the governorship race, incumbents seeking re-election to a second term include the governors of Lagos, Nasarawa, Kwara, Adamawa, Borno and Bauchi states. Others are the governors of Zamfara, Ogun, Yobe, Gombe and Oyo states. There are 176,846 polling units across the country, but elections won’t hold in those within the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) where there are no constituencies to be contested.

    The balloting process remains as it was for the national elections. Polling units will open from 8:30a.m. and will so remain till 2:30p.m. for voters to join the queue. Any voter who is on queue by 2:30p.m. will be eligible to vote, no matter the time of the day and how long the queue may be. The voting procedure will be by open-secret ballot. Voters will be required to present their Permanent Voter Card (PVC) to polling unit officials to get accredited with BVAS, after which they will be handed the ballot paper to proceed to the voting cubicle, privately thumbprint their choice of party and thereafter return to drop their folded ballot paper in the transparent ballot box placed in open view of all. It is at the conclusion of voting that the presiding officer will sort the ballot papers, announce the score by respective political party, and complete the prescribed INEC form for collation.

    At a parley with Resident Electoral Commissioners (RECs) penultimate weekend, INEC Chairman Professor Mahmood Yakubu, affirmed that BVAS will be used for the state polls like it was for the national elections. “Since last week, the commission has intensified the review of the technology to ensure that glitches experienced, particularly with the upload of results, are rectified. We are confident that going forward, the system will run optimally,” he said, adding: “The issues of logistics, election technology, behaviour of some election personnel at different levels, attitude of some party agents and supporters added to the extremely challenging environment in which elections are usually held in Nigeria. A lot of lessons have been learnt.” The INEC boss directed that all issues of election logistics be handled by electoral officers at the council area level and must be finalised a day before the polls. According to him, RECs will be held liable for shoddy arrangement regarding the polls. Good soundbites. It is expected that INEC will fully walk the talk.

    As the electoral commission tightens loose ends, it is required of political actors and their supporters to as well clean up their acts and ensure civility of conduct in the polling environment. Early last week, the Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Usman Alkali Baba said the force recorded and responded to 185 major incidents, arrested 203 electoral offenders and recovered 18 firearms from political thugs nationwide during the conduct of the February 25 national elections. Speaking at a meeting to debrief senior police chiefs posted on election security management duties during the national polls, he added: “All the cases are at various stages of investigations at the Nigeria Police Electoral Offences Desks and I assure you that in due course, they will be concluded and processed to the legal department of INEC for prosecution.” The police must ensure this is unfailingly done and culprits brought to book, because impunity thrives where there’s no recompense for misbehaviour.

    It will be helpful for overall credibility of the elections if political actors put up their best conduct and rein in supporters from fomenting disruptive behaviour. The success of the elections must be a collective endeavour of all stakeholders, ranging from INEC to politicians, security agents and voters themselves.

  • Resurgent herdsmen attacks

    Resurgent herdsmen attacks

    • The Buhari administration must not rest on its oars until terror is defeated

    After several months since mid-last year, of restoration of relative calm, with the drastic reduction in the violent clashes between herdsmen and farming communities, particularly in the Benue and Plateau states of the North-Central region, there are reports of renewed incessant attacks launched by the herdsmen in a number of states. The security agencies appeared to have at last effectively responded to President Muhammadu Buhari’s serial directives to decisively deal with all forms of violence, including banditry, terrorism, kidnapping and herdsmen-farming community clashes, but that success seems to be waning towards the tail end of the administration’s tenure, particularly with regard to reported recent attacks by herdsmen on a number of communities in some states.

    For instance, early this month, armed herdsmen reportedly launched apparently coordinated attacks on several communities in Kwande Local Government Area of Benue State. In the violent invasion which affected such council wards as Moon, Mbaikyor, Mbadara and Ilyav in the local government, over 36 persons were killed, scores of others injured and large numbers of people chased away from their ancestral homelands, with the attacks coming from diverse directions. This reminds us of the large scale killing of residents in several communities across the state which used to be a near daily occurrence. We surely can’t afford regression to those gory days.

    In a similar vein also in the first week of March, there were attacks by alleged herdsmen on the Ajegunle/Powerline community in Akure North Local Government Area of Ondo State which reportedly followed closely on similar onslaughts against residents in the Arimogija community in Ose Local Government Area of the state. The five separate attacks within one week, during which several persons were injured, were reportedly ignited by protests by the communities against the destruction of their farms by cows owned by the herdsmen. As in many other states which have passed anti-open grazing laws, the herdsmen allegedly graze their cattle openly with impunity. While the residents deserted their homes for fear of further attacks, the herdsmen were said to have extended their offensive to other communities in the area such as Ago-Dada and Ago-Onyinbo. Apparently, reports to the Ala Police Division as well as the Amotekun Corp yielded no positive results.

    Again, no less than 35 persons were reported killed in clashes in some Zango-Kataf communities of Southern Kaduna last weekend. The clash was ignited by a disagreement between security operatives and some Fulani men at a checkpoint in Ungwan Waikiki which led to the death of a Fulani man and a policeman before flaring into a larger crisis. In the case of Katsina State, there was a slight variant as the violence there last week was said to be as a result of a clash between suspected terrorists and local vigilantes, leading to the death of 18 villagers in Kankara Local Government Area and several others injured.

    All these suggest that there may be a deliberate attempt by the sponsors of violence to derail the current delicate and sensitive transition from the incumbent to an incoming administration, resulting in programmed widespread chaos. The security agencies cannot avoid to discount any possibilities as they discharge their mandate of protecting lives and property as well as maintaining stability and national cohesion. Exploiting known fault lines to instigate violence within the context of the inevitable bitter fallouts of highly competitive elections can further destabilise the polity and deepen divisions among people. More than ever before, there is need for efficient and effective intelligence gathering to help nip planned attacks in the bud before they become destructive realities.

    The outgoing Buhari administration cannot afford to take its eyes off the ball with regard to sustaining its recent successes in containing insecurity until the very end of its tenure. And, for the incoming administration, it has its work cut out in this regard; it  must hit the ground running in introducing measures that will help guarantee the security of lives and property in a complex, plural polity like Nigeria.

  • Avoidable tragedy

    Avoidable tragedy

    • Mishap shows how a nut case could cause misfortune for others

    No fewer than six persons were confirmed dead and more than 100 others injured in an accident last Thursday involving a train and a Lagos State Government staff bus in Sogunle area of Ikeja. It was reported that the driver of the government staff bus adamantly tried to get across the level crossing at PWD, Agege Motor Road, when the train coming in from Abeokuta rammed into it and dragged it to Sogunle before the train could stop.

    Bus passengers were ostensibly headed for work Thursday morning when the accident occurred. Two of them died on the spot, with four others dying while being accorded emergency medical attention. Fatalities included a member of the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) scheme. Of the 102 injured victims rushed to hospitals, more than 50 had been discharged by last Sunday while others remained on admission at different medical facilities across the metropolis.

    It was one accident wholly avoidable had the bus driver, said to be an employee of Lagos State Ministry of Transport, better applied his discretion.  Eyewitnesses said he refused to stop at the level crossing despite the oncoming train being close by, and in defiance of Nigerian Railway Corporation (NRC) personnel stationed there who flagged him down. Survivors of the mishap were reported saying the 44-year-old driver had his earpiece on while driving and ignored warnings by flag officers at the level crossing. In his bid to hasten through the crossing, the bus got trapped on the rail and was hauled onwards by the train until the train stopped.

    Whereas he put innocent lives at needless risk, the bus driver survived the accident and is being held at the State Criminal Intelligence and Investigations Department (SCIID) of the police. He was reported early this week blaming the incident on a mechanical fault with the vehicle he drove. But the police said they were awaiting the outcome of medical tests conducted on him, which included blood sampling to ascertain whether he was on drugs or mentally fit. Meanwhile, reports cited persons who claimed to have been regular passengers on the driver’s route before the accident saying he had shown tendencies of being reckless. One particular source said she stopped going on his bus upon her observation of unwholesome tendencies.

    The Lagos State Government and city residents rose to the occasion in rescue efforts and providing succour to accident victims. The survivors were speeded to hospitals for medical attention, while Lagosians rallied to donate blood and provide other forms of support as were needed. Lagos State Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu visited the accident scene and led the way in according priority attention to the victims. It was one communal moment in the megacity that is highly commendable.

    But the tendencies reported to have been exhibited by the bus driver, who is named Oluwaseun Osinbajo, again highlights the need for closer oversight on drivers of the Lagos Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) fleet. This fresh incident echoes circumstances of the murder of 22-year-old fashion designer, Bamise Ayanwole, in February 2022 after she boarded a BRT bus driven by Andrew Ominnikoron in Ajah axis of the state. There should be a functional training school for the fleet drivers, and regular competency evaluation to ensure they remain in perfect shape to serve the public. Lagos State government as well as other fleet owners may also consider imprinting on their fleet vehicles phone numbers to be called and report any driver observed by members of the public as showing reckless traits on the city highways.

    On the part of the rail corporation, there is need for gated level crossings, especially in busy urban centres. NRC Managing Director Fidet Okhiria was reported saying the corporation contemplates erecting overhead bridges at 11 level crossings in Lagos. “We are going to have 11 flyovers within Lagos and we cannot do all at the same time. We are constructing them in batches,” he disclosed, adding: “Before now we constructed barriers and they were vandalised. We even constructed automatic barriers, which were also vandalised. Although we have been repairing them, especially the automatic barriers, they do not last for a week after such repairs. It is either they hit the barriers with vehicles or people vandalise them overnight.” But it is not a sufficient reason to leave level crossings bare just because barriers previously installed were vandalised. The proposed flyover bridges are a long shot and there is no guarantee they’ll be diligently put to use by reckless motorists. Public safety dictates that NRC maintains barriers at the level crossings and secure them however it can. But they have to be there.

    This latest accident should be a learning curve towards ensuring there is no recurrence in the future.

  • Not well enough

    Not well enough

    • •It’s high time we replaced wells with modern day technology of water access

    The idea of a well is anathema in a 21st century society. The paradox is that it is the chief source of water for the vast majority of Nigerians.

    But it is not only a source of ill-health, but of deaths. This justifies the movement around the world that now projects the right to potable water as a fundamental human right. In most rural and parts of many urban communities, our wells are not only lethal, they present a state of hopelessness among the population.

    According to WaterAid Nigeria, three in 10 persons in Nigeria do not reside close to water or even wells while four out of every five persons have no water for hygiene, including washing their hands. On its website, the WaterAid announced, “Unless there is a monumental shift in ambition and approach, the global promise made in the Sustainable Development Goals for everyone, everywhere to have access to safe and lasting water and sanitation and basic hygiene by 2030 will not be fulfilled for many decades to come.”

    In 2020, the World Health Organisation (WHO), revealed that deaths from drowning in Nigeria reached 6,584 or 0.44 per cent of total deaths.

    One tragedy that examples the severity of the story was about two brothers. The two brothers, Lateef Adediran, 22, and Waliu Adediran, 31, who died in a well, followed by a failed rescuer, Pastor Adebayo Oluwasina, 46, who also died in the same well. This happened in Ede, Osun State.

    Both brothers were bricklayers working at Adebayo’s construction site, as reported by The Punch newspaper.

    In Kano, it was a tragedy of father and son. Malam Bala and Sunusi Bala, his son, fell into a well and both died of asphyxiation.

    Part of the problem is connected with the wells themselves. Many of the wells have no walls around and, even the ones that have walls, are not covered. People simply walk to the wells with their wet grounds from previous users and this makes drawers to slip and fall into the holes.

    Again, some others have died from getting into the wells to clean  them up and have been trapped. Others who tried to save them have also suffered suffocation. This is due to ignorance as well. They do not understand that wells have little oxygen supplies and once in the nether parts of the earth, they would gasp for breath.

    But the worry for most citizens is how they live daily with not only scarcity of water but also unclean supplies. If they have to move long distances to obtain water and it is clean, that would be seen as only a little, if safe, inconvenience. But the water in the wells and in other places like rivers and ponds tends to be source of slow death and many illnesses.

    Some have water, and are often jubilant only when they can get it. For many, it is a scramble. Some have to wake up in the pre-dawn hours to secure it. The wells of ponds may have run dry if they do not have early dry eyes.

    Many people say the problem is with the governments and, especially the local governments, that have rather seen water as low in their priorities. Citizens have come to live with the hard reality that water is a scarce commodity.

    We are also experiencing the trouble of climate change that is afflicting many countries with droughts. It is big issue that we have to address not only as state governments but as a society.

    Water is becoming the next focus of superpower conflict as scientists are looking for ways to manufacture water.

  • Unfair representation

    Unfair representation

    •Nigeria can do with more women in political positions

    This year’s international Women’s Day (IWD) came amidst the global outrage over the poor representation of Nigerian women in politics after the announcement of the February 25 presidential and National Assembly elections. It is a socio-economic tragedy that women that make up almost half of the population is not present in the political field in significant numbers in an era when ideas from both genders rule the world.

    In 2021, a Senator Enyinnaya Abaribe had during a speech at Nkata Ndi Inyom (a discussion group and think-tank for Igbo women) event predicted that there might soon be no women in the two chambers of the National Assembly. His prognosis seems to be unravelling. For the 2023 elections, none of the four frontline political parties, the All Progressives Congress (APC), People’s Democratic Party (PDP), Labour Party (LP) and New Nigeria People’s Party (NNPP) had either a female presidential or vice presidential candidate. The APC is the only big political party that has a female governorship candidate in Adamawa State.

    Of the 423 National Assembly (NASS) seat results that have been released by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) so far, only 15 seats have been won by women, down from 22 in the 9th NASS at the House of Representatives. The Senate has just three women elected as against the seven in 2019.  The male politicians have the lion’s share of 96.5% in the legislative chambers.

    Global economic and political analysts have through research proved that the countries with the least empowered women are the most underdeveloped and Nigeria is a good example. With a staggering 133 million Nigerians living in multi-dimensional poverty, it is obvious Nigeria is not utilising its vibrant population to full capacity. The political structure seems to be fatally flawed in ways that women, no matter how qualified, do not get their fair share of the opportunity to contribute to the development of the country politically.

    Sadly though, the lack of sizeable female presence in the political space is rooted in socio-religious beliefs that start from the cradle, as women are raised and nurtured as followers, not leaders. The average girl child is raised to be subservient and nurtured to believe that leadership is a male affair. The patriarchal practice is propagated and perpetuated by men through culture and religion. In different ways, women are conditioned to believe that culture and religion are divinely ordained to subjugate women.

    So, the political party structure pushed the narrative further by making sure that women in political parties do not get to have a strong and influential presence at the party executive levels. Parties are run by men who often have the economic power, and in a system with an unstructured political party administration, economic influence is often exploited to male advantage. No political party in Nigeria has been able to explain the reasons for the establishment of ‘women’s wings’. There are no ‘men’s wings’, so, invariably, it is a subtle way of making women second-class party members whose job is to mobilise votes for men.

    Ironically, Nigerian women have always held leadership positions from pre-colonial to post-colonial era and distinguished themselves. Queens Amina of Zaria, Idia of Benin, Moremi of Ife and several others are legends. Late Margaret Ekpo, Gambo Sawaba and Funmilayo Rasome-Kuti are known more for their political contributions than for their works as homemakers.

    In post-colonial era, people like Regina Amadi-Njoku who became the first Nigerian woman to get to the level of United Nations Assistant Secretary General from 2000-2008, Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, Arunma Oteh, Amina Mohammed, late Dora Akunyili, Ibukun Awosika, Doyin Abiola, Amma Ogan, etc., have all become global icons. It is curious though that in all sectors where merit is the criterion for growth, Nigerian women have excelled.

    It amounts to self-inflicted injury for Nigerian men in politics to continue to subtly and steadily exclude women through obvious structural and socio-religious hurdles. The country has the poverty capital tag to show for the political recalcitrance. Leadership in global terms has moved beyond the primordial sentiments that exist in Nigerian political space. The men must realise the worth of women, especially in this era of increased political awareness and education of women. The world is today ruled by ideas and technology and none of these is gender sensitive. In fact, many of the good leaders in the world, in comparative terms, are women.

    We urge the few women in politics in the country to, on their own, make more assertive moves to change the sad narrative about gender equity.

  • Light up the way

    Light up the way

    • Lagos-Ibadan Expressway could benefit immensely from Governor Makinde’s idea

    It took Governor Seyi Makinde of Oyo State to unfold a plan to light up the entire stretch of Lagos-Ibadan Expressway. The governor, who was on Splash FM  radio station last week disclosed that he was already discussing with the Chief Executives of Lagos and Ogun states to light up the 120-kilometre road in the interest of the people.

    If this is accomplished in good time, it would improve safety along the corridor, as many motorists end up by the road side, given poor visibility at night. The Federal Road Safety Commission (FRSC) had said many times that the road that has been under construction for about two decades is the busiest in the country.

    Security, too, would receive a boost when the road is lit up. Many passengers are kidnapped at night, while it also serves as a get-away route for those unlucky to be abducted from any of the three states. Although kidnappers are known to have sometimes struck in broad daylight, the incidence would be reduced when the road is lit up as the security agents are likely to step up their activities at night under the proposed scheme.

    One positive development when the programme takes off is that it would promote cooperation among the states. We hope all the states would be equally committed to the plan. As Governor Makinde pointed out, the burden is unlikely to be borne equally as Lagos territory terminates shortly after the Berger Bridge, with Ogun taking off from there up to Onigaari. Oyo then takes off from there. Besides, the Oyo State governor has only broached the plan with Lagos State Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu. It’s not certain Ogun State Governor Dapo Abiodun would see it as a priority.

    We enjoin the states to bring the Federal Government on board since it is a Trunk A road. Where possible, the Federal Ministry of Works and Housing should be committed to making a refund of whatever would have been spent by the states.

    It is unfortunate that the original design and contract did not incorporate the new plan. We call on the collaborating governors to make full disclosure of the cost implication. From the start of execution of the project, the Nigeria Police Force should be fully involved as highway robbers and thieves are known to regularly strike, carting away cables and other electric materials. 

    This should be seen as building blocks for regional cooperation in the Southwest.  The Development Agenda for Western Nigeria  (DAWN) could benefit from such socio-economic programmes involving Ondo-Ekiti, Oyo-Osun, and Lagos-Ogun states.

    Other regions in the country could borrow such ideas that could catalyse development.  Nigeria has been promoting the need for a Trans-Sahara Highway across the African continent for some years, while failing to construct an ultra modern highway in the country. Lagos-Ibadan Expressway is where to start, with facilities such as clinics, inns, restaurants and electricity.  The governors should meet soon after the general elections, and call for bids with a view to speeding up the work. 

  • Anchor Borrowers Programme

    Anchor Borrowers Programme

    • CBN needs to review its modus operandi for greater efficiency

    Whether repayment rate of loans disbursed under the Central Bank of Nigeria’s (CBN) Anchor Borrowers Programme (ABP) is 24 per cent as claimed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), or 48 per cent as countered by the CBN, the point is that none is impressive. The IMF made the claim in its Selected Issues Paper on Nigeria completed on January12, 2023. “For the Anchor Borrowing Programme, repayment is also low at 24 per cent, especially since repayment can be made in kind, thereby limiting the tenor of the loans to one year.”

    The CBN, on its part, has claimed that total repayments expected under the programme stood at N503 billion, representing 52.39 percent of total monies disbursed  as of February 28, 2023.

    The truth of the matter is that, while it is always good to have statistics right for record purposes, neither 24 per cent nor 48 per cent repayment rate is good enough for loans of the magnitude under consideration. This dampens optimism on the prospects of the scheme. Indeed, indications from both claims are that a substantial percentage of the loans would end up as bad debt. Yet, more people can only benefit when those who have benefitted pay up as and when due.

    The ABP was launched in 2015 with the sole aim of providing farmers with the critical funds and inputs needed to increase local production. Under the programme, the apex bank initially set aside N40bn to support farmers by offering single-digit interest rate loans. However, over N1tn had been disbursed through mid-2022 for the programme.

    This is a laudable programme. But it should not have been handled directly by the apex bank which is not properly equipped for such function. The commercial banks would have handled both the disbursement and recovery of the loans better. They have the capacity to check collaterals as well as monitor developments on the farms to see if the loans are being appropriately utilised.

    There seems to be a problem of balancing both the welfare and investment objectives of the programme. While the CBN sees the programme from the investment angle, many of the beneficiaries probably see the loans as grants, or part of their own share of the national cake, hence, the low rate of recovery.

    This impression would appear to be corroborated by the IMF when it said in its report that “Part of the problem is that the incentive structure for repayment is weak, the recipient loans are not always well targeted and occasionally the funding is used for other purchases (e.g., new agricultural input trading companies to elicit trading rents).”

    While we must admit that COVID-19, flooding, banditry etc. contributed significantly to the low repayment rate, there are other problems as well.

    National Secretary of the All Farmers Association of Nigeria (AFAN), Yunusa Yabwa, shed more light on these problems: “Our members have benefitted from the programme, but most people who benefitted from the ABP are not Nigerian farmers. I must confess that to you.

    “That is why you see today that the CBN, NIRSAL, commercial banks, who were the channels for the distribution of this fund, are complaining that these beneficiaries are not repaying the loans.” NIRSAL is the Nigeria Incentive-Based Risk Sharing System for Agricultural Lending created by the CBN to redefine, measure, re-price and share agribusiness-related credit risks in the country. Because most of the ABP loan beneficiaries do not belong to AFAN, the association could not trace them.

    Simon Irtwange, President, Yam Farmers and Marketers Association of Nigeria, also gave his members’ experience on the programme. Irtwange said his members were largely sidelined: “As an association we followed the due process to ensure our members benefit from the programme but were rather harassed by the NIRSAL boss.” He said the programme was designed to favour a few Nigerians from the onset.

    Claims such as these fuel the impression, rightly or wrongly, that ABP is more or less a campaign fund for the crashed presidential ambition of the CBN governor, Godwin Emefiele.

    Expectedly, the CBN has denied that the programme has been abused. But it cannot deny that it is also not comfortable with the percentage of those who are repaying the loans. Just last September, the apex bank mooted the idea of considering the Global Standing Instruction (GSI) to recover the loans, following the debtors’ failure or refusal to heed the apex bank’s appeals to pay up.

    GSI allows deduction of money in a debtor’s account in another bank to recover past due obligations, both principal and interest, minus penal charges, without recourse to the borrower. This is possible because the accounts are linked by bank verification number (BVN). But the apex bank said this, as usual, would be a last resort.

    As can be seen from both the yam sellers association and AFAN’s submissions, programmes like ABP can only succeed when critical stakeholders are carried along.

    Irrespective of the claims and counter-claims on repayment rate, the fact on ground is that agricultural credit in the country has not significantly boosted production despite the huge money allegedly disbursed under the scheme. Meaning that the purpose for which the ABP was set up is far from being achieved.

    For greater impact, the apex bank must  carry critical stakeholders along. The bank must also be ready to allow commercial banks that are better equipped to handle such projects do the job. As the scheme stands, it represents a most expansive definition of the role of the CBN. And it is counter-productive.