Category: Law

  • Farmer sues ex-commissioner for N130m

    Farmer sues ex-commissioner for N130m

    By Raymond Mordi

     

    A pineapple famer, Blessed Utomi Farms Ltd, has sued a former Commissioner for Lands and Survey in Delta State, Mr Raymos Guanah, for breach of contract with the Blessed Utomi Farms Ltd.

    The suit marked No.0/6/2021 was filed by counsel for the claimant, Larry Olisa, at the Ogwashi-Uku High Court in Aniocha South Local Government Area (LGA) of the state, alleging that the farmer, as a result of the breach, suffered a loss of N130million

    The defendant was alleged to have purchased 50,000 pineapple suckers valued at N1m with a promise to defray the cost of the suckers.

    Read Also: Lawyer sues lawmakers over legal fees

     

    Olisa added the defendant failed to keep his side of the bargain on the payment, and all entreaties fell on deaf ears.

    “As a fallout from this, Blessed Utomi Farms Limited is claiming the sum of N30m being loss of earnings for the farming season of March 2017 to August 2018 and an additional sum of N90m for the loss of business earnings for the farming season commencing from March 2019 to August 2020 among other damages, as well as N10m for future losses,” the claimant averred.

    The court fixed August 19, 2021 for pre-trial.

    An ex parte order was also granted by the presiding judge, Justice Kwame Okpu, for a substituted means of service on the defendant.

  • Court directs AMCON to seize Doggi Continental’s Abuja assets

    Court directs AMCON to seize Doggi Continental’s Abuja assets

    By Robert Egbe

     

    A Federal High Court in Abuja has granted an ex-parte application authorising the Asset Management Corporation of Nigeria (AMCON) to seize the Abuja properties of Doggi Continental Nigeria Ltd and Alhaji Abdullahi Umaru Baba.

    Justice Taiwo Taiwo ruled that the order subsists pending the institution and disposal of proceedings for debt recovery against the duo pursuant to Section 49 of the AMCON Act 2010.

    The properties are Plot No. 1274 Katampe Hills, Katampe District, Abuja, F.C.T., and Plot No. 3810 Cadastral Zone A04 Asokoro, Abuja with File No. FCT/ABU/ZA/10124 all belong to the Respondents.

    The judge made the interim order after reading the affidavit in support of the motion ex-parte deposed to by Nelly Ebegboni and after hearing Mr C. Ezeokwuora with O. Audu and J. Ozioko, move the motion paper.

    He held: “An order of interim is hereby made attaching, taking possession and custody of the properties being Plot No. 1274 Katampe Hills, Katampe District, Abuja, F.C.T., and Plot No. 3810 Cadastral Zone A04 Asokoro with file Number FCT/ABU/ZA/10124, all belonging to the respondents.”

    He further restrained the respondents from interfering with the AMCON’s possession of the properties.

    In addition, the judge granted an interim Mareva Injunction attaching all sums standing to the credit of the respondents in any bank in Nigeria up to the amount of the outstanding indebtedness of the Respondents to the applicant.

    Read Also: AMCON recovers N1.48tr from debtors

     

    “The properties shall not be sold by the applicant until the disposal of ceedings for recovery of the debt. The interest of any third party occupying the properties must be respected by the Applicant.

    “Nobody with third party interest shall be ejected as a result of the orders now granted. Any person with third party interest shall be notified of the orders of this court which shall be pasted in a conspicuous part of the property,” Taiwo held.

    In addition, the court held, among others, that any rent due and yet unpaid and any outstanding rent including rents due from the time of these orders shall be paid into an interest yielding account to be opened for that purpose by the applicant, while none of the Respondents shall be ejected from the properties.

    Lastly, it directed all the banks upon being served with the orders to file an affidavit showing the balance of the respondents jointly and severally in their respective banks.

    Justice Taiwo adjourned till September 22, for hearing of the substantive suit.

     

  • Malami, Adamu, Tallen, others advocate enhanced access to justice for young Nigerians

    Malami, Adamu, Tallen, others advocate enhanced access to justice for young Nigerians

    By Eric Ikhilae, Abuja

     

    Three ministers, the Chief Judge of Kano State, Justice Nura Sagir and others have advocated for measures to enhance access to justice for young offenders and victims of domestic violence and related crimes.

    The ministers – Abubakar Malami (Justice), Adamu Adamu (Education) and Pauline Tallen (Women Affairs) – called for collaborative efforts of all stakeholders to address the current growing challenge of access to justice for young Nigerians.

    They spoke in Abuja at the launch of “the European Union (EU)/United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF) Access to Justice Programme for Children on the Move and Other Vulnerable Children/Inauguration of the Justice For Children Coordination Forum.”

    Malami, represented by the Special Assistant to the President on Research and Special Duties, Office of the Attorney- General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Professor Muhammad Lawal Ahmadu, identified efforts by the Federal Government to improve access to justice for young Nigerians.

    “My office is currently engaging with respective Heads of Courts to establish Specialised Courts for the speedy and seamless trial of Rape/Gender-Based Violence Offences in the country.

    “It is hoped that these specialised courts will fast track such cases and result in justice for child victims of sexual violence.

    “Additionally, the Federal Ministry of Justice has continued to partner with UNICEF and other donor agencies, and the respective Heads of Courts to train Judges and Magistrates on the implementation and enforcement of the Child Rights Act especially in the arrear of the effective use of Family Court Rules and Procedures.

    “These trainings which commenced in June 2021 is aimed at strengthening the justice system towards the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goal 16.3 which aims at promoting the Rule of Law at national and sub-nation levels and to ensure equal access to Justice for all Children

    Malami added that his ministry was working partnered with respective Heads of Court in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) to review and upgrade the FCT Custodial and Non-Custodial Sentencing Practice Directions to include non-custodial and alternative measures to detention in cases of minor offences by adult offenders.

    Represented by Mrs. Grace Ekanem, Adamu called for a review of the current practice of criminalisation and incarceration of children.

    Tallen, who was represented by Mrs Mariam Shuaibu said her ministry was working with other stakeholders to ensure the domestication of the Child Rights Act by all states.

    Justice Sagir, who was represented by Justice Maryam Sabo, regretted the growing cases  of Sexual and Gender Based Violence (SGBV) in the country.

    “In Kano alone, as per statistics, about two years back, we have 3.2 million out of school children wondering about, some hawking, begging, truants, drug addiction etc.

    “In 2018, 1,142 cases were reported at Waraka SARC, while in 2019, 741 cases were received and only 194 were disposed of because of the high demand nature of proving the offence and stigma associated with offence.

    “Poverty and lack of awareness on parents are other factors. This year, the centre received 57 and 68 cases of GBV in April and May respectively,” he said.

    Justice Sagir, who suggested ways to address the challenges, said there was the need for the government to strategise more on women empowerment and to make it a policy all over the country.

    In his contribution, UNICEF Country Representative, Peter Hawkins assured of his organisation’s support for the project and commended the enthusiasm exhibited by agencies in the country to address the challenge of access to justice.

     

  • ‘Governors are chief security officers in name only’

    ‘Governors are chief security officers in name only’

    Mr Ike Ofuokwu is the Managing Partner at Ike Ofuokwu and Company, a corporate and commercial law firm. He is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Administration and a former adjunct law teacher at Chrisland University. In this interview with Deputy News Editor JOSEPH JIBUEZE, Ofuokwu speaks on secession agitations, the Senate’s rejection of electronic transmission of results, open-grazing ban and sundry national issues.

     

    Southern governors met recently in Delta and Lagos states and demanded power shift to the South. Do you agree with the call?

    For me, the solution to our problems does not lie in power shift or otherwise but on quality leadership devoid of ethnicity/religion and equal representation from every section of this country. So, whether power is in the South or North, what we crave are leaders and not rulers; the rule of law and not the rule of men; a just society where everyone is subject to the law and where there are no sacred cows.

    What are your thoughts on the governors’ ban on open grazing?

    Open grazing is an aberration. It is mundane, anachronistic, archaic and primitive. If the herders cannot ranch their cows, then I suggest they remain in their land where open grazing is allowed and make others buy it at a higher cost or even refuse to sell. It’s a private business like other private businesses. I particularly frown at the ugly narrative of farmer/herders clash. The farmers have not trespassed rather it’s the other way round. Therefore, these herders hooliganism must be properly addressed and condemned by every right-thinking person. States like Kano have agreed to accommodate them. So what else are they looking for?

    Were you surprised by the rejection of Lauretta Onochie as a national commissioner of the Independent National Electoral Commission?

    The nomination of Lauretta Onochie as INEC commissioner was an arrogant display of executive impunity and the height of political insensitivity. Therefore, rejecting her was tantamount to protecting the integrity and independence of the electoral body. Nevertheless, I’m troubled with the reasons adduced by the Senate for her rejection. It presupposes that at the expiration of Ms. Agbamuche Mbu’s tenure at INEC, Lauretta Onochie might be forwarded again for reconsideration. Nigerians have never had it this bad with this present rubber-stamp Senate. We have never had such a disastrously run, out-of-reality, inept and anti-people National Assembly where the majority are rascal, wasteful and indolent.

    Are you disappointed with the Senate’s rejection of electronic transmission of results?

    The rejection of electronic transmission of election results has further made the Senate clownish and laughable. How can the very same people who insist on JAMB, NIN, BVN, education and many others be electronic and online be afraid for electronic transmission of the election result? It’s all an attempt to whittle down and compromise the integrity of the elections. Contrary to the Act that established INEC, they have further made the independence of the electoral body subject to Nigerian Communications Commission and Senate’s approval, which in effect is subject to the executive that controls NCC. Most of these present crop of out-of-control rulers and not leaders are certain that they cannot win in any free and fair election, hence their strongest desire is to determine the outcome of the elections even before the elections.

    The National Assembly also came under fire over the allocation of three per cent to host communities in the Petroleum Industry Bill? Do you think it should have been more?

    Three per cent for host communities in the PIB is a gratuitous insult and a further attempt at dehumanising and impoverishing the host communities especially in the light of the 30 per cent allocated to exploration in the frontiers. This is in addition to all the gas flaring and degradation of the host communities’ homes and land. By the time we are done with this reckless, self-indulgent, and insensitive leadership of the current National Assembly who has ensconced itself from the harsh reality of the pains that they have inflicted on Nigerians, I’m afraid there would be no dignity and humanity left in us as a nation.

    Are you worried about attacks on security agencies in parts of the South?

    The attack on law enforcement agents and public institutions in the Southsouth and Southeast are crude and condemnable and no sane person would applaud it. No society can make any meaningful progress with the wanton destruction of its national edifice and public facilities. However, it’s also been alleged from some quarters that all these attacks are premeditated and a decoy to label these zones as restive and by so doing unleashing our security agents on them. That is to say, giving a dog a bad name to hang it. It is inconceivable that considering the security commands within and around the correctional centre in Owerri, such barbaric acts could be carried on for hours unchallenged. Even if we attribute these attacks to the prevailing injustices, they cannot in any way be justified. You don’t address injustice by destroying public properties and national edifice.

    What are your thoughts on the security situation in the country? 

    The security situation in this country seems to have broken down irretrievably and there appears to be no hope to restore it. This is not restricted to any geo-political zone in particular but to the entire country. If the truth must be told, we have never had it this bad. No amount of state-sponsored propaganda can cover this inherent fundamental lapse in our security architecture.

    Are you satisfied with the government’s efforts to address the problem?

    There has been no meaningful effort whatsoever to tackle this situation from the President who ought to be the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. Rather, what you find is apparent complicity on the part of agents of the state who should nip it in the bud. The governors on their own cannot even order the commissioners of police unless there’s an order from Abuja. Yet they are supposed to be their states chief security officer, a mere glorified title. Today, we have more policemen guarding politically exposed persons and the affluent in society than the ones protecting and guarding the entire citizenry.

    There have been calls for secession to have Biafra and Yoruba nation. Is disintegration the answer?

    The call for secession from various quarters is simply a product of great injustice in our nation such as has never been witnessed before in the history of this country. The Federal Government is running a sectional government favourable to a particular geo-political zone at the exclusion of all other zones. If we cannot accommodate the other zones due to this born-to-rule mentality by people who cannot even run a local government, then why not let the marginalised go? Why hold them together in this ill-conceived contraption? Must we continue in this unholy and parasitic alliance? The answer simply is No. A cursory look will reveal to you that our leaders over the years have been very inept at managing our multicultural and religious diversity due to their overbearing alliance to their ethnic and religious inclinations but we have never been as divided as we are as of today with this present government. An injustice to one section is an injustice to all except for those who are benefiting from it.

    When you speak of injustice, what exactly do you mean?

    What is the justice where we go after peaceful protesters, rights agitators who are unarmed with various ‘python dances’ and what have you and you find a state governor, a sheikh, the police, military and other security agencies dining, winning and taking pictures with fully-armed bandits clutching to their AK-47’s? And to justify this obvious insanity, you find a nerd and obtuse state governor drawing very strange distinctions between the evil of Boko Haram, herders and bandits in the North on the one part and that of unarmed protesters and harmless secessionist agitators on the other part. Honestly, I wonder who did this to us as a nation.

    How do you react to the arrest of Nnamdi Kanu and the raid on Sunday Igboho’s home?

    The arrest of Nnamdi Kanu just goes to portray how this government is desperate to silence every opposing voice. Otherwise, they should have acted in accordance with the rules of International Law in dealing with repatriation. The recent event was just a subtle repeat of the Umaru Dikko abduction saga, designed to ridicule Nigeria within the comity of nations.

    The nocturnal raid, murder, wanton destruction and brutal vandalisation of Sunday Igboho’s home has become an ugly trademark of the Department of State Services (DSS). It is a primitive and lazy approach to modern espionage which must be condemned in a democratic setting. We saw this shameful conduct at play not too long ago at the home of judges and justices, the custodians of the temple of justice and to date, no one has called them to order.

    Some have called for dialogue as a way out of the agitations. Do you think the government should heed this call?

    To resolve these agitations, we must resort to dialogue, justice and fairness to ensure that no single part of this country is lording it over another. We must put an end to this bigotry and ethnicity that is fast tearing the country apart. With the glaring injustice at play, we cannot be able to make any meaningful development. A cursory visit to public offices will reveal to you demoralised public servants where mediocrity and ethnicity reign far and above merit. I’m, however, shocked and baffled as to why this government is reluctant to concede to dialogue or in the alternative address the perceived injustices. Every advanced and orderly society is founded on justice and fairness. Wherever you allow injustice to prevail, chaos is bound to be the order of the day as witnessed presently in our nation.

    The Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) recently complained of non-lawyers encroaching on their work. How can this be tackled?

    Non-lawyers encroaching on professional duties of legal practitioners is fast becoming endemic and this must be handled with very stiff measures and followed with stiffer penalties. The NBA must no longer treat them with kids gloves. Otherwise, the integrity of the profession will be endangered.

  • Lawyer sues lawmakers over legal fees

    Lawyer sues lawmakers over legal fees

    By Robert Egbe

     

    A lawyer, Kabir Akingbolu, has sued Senator Olubunmi Adetunmbi and a member of the House of Representative, Peter Owolabi, at an Ado-Ekiti State High Court over his legal fees.

    Akingbolu alleged that both lawmakers are yet to pay him, two years after he won election petitions for them both at the Election Tribunal and the Court of Appeal.

    He made the allegations in separate suits, the first of which numbered HAD/70/2021, listed Adetunmbi, representing Ekiti North Senatorial District, and his party, the All Progressives Congress (APC), as defendants. It was filed on June 30.

    Akingbolu listed Owolabi, of Ekiti North Federal Constituency II, and the APC as defendants in the second suit marked HAD/71/2021 filed on July 2.

    Read Also: Plateau PDP sues electoral body over exclusion

     

    In the suit against the Senator, the claimant prayed for two reliefs.

    The first is an order directing the defendants to pay a sum of N10million being his professional fees in respect of the legal services rendered to them in Appeal Number: CA/EK/EPT/SEN/3/2019.

    He is also seeking an order directing the duo to pay him another N10m as damages for breach of contract.

    In the other suit, Akingbolu prayed for an order directing the defendant to pay N7million as professional fees in respect of the legal services rendered to them in petition No: EPT/EK/LEGH/REP/02/19 and Appeal Number: CA/EK/EPT/REP/2/2019.

    He is also seeking an order directing the defendants to pay him N10m as damages for breach of contract.

    The defendants are yet to file a defence to the suit.

  • Court orders Ogun govt  to pay firm N608m

    Court orders Ogun govt to pay firm N608m

    By Adebisi Onanuga

     

    An Ogun State High sitting in Abeokuta has ordered the state government to pay a construction firm, Contemporary Group Limited, the sum of N608,867,925.

    The amount represents the outstanding balance for the construction of two state-of-art model secondary schools and hostels in the state.

    The claimant, Contemporary Group Ltd, through the law firm of Charles Mekwunye and Co., had sued the state government before the court in 2020 for breach of the terms of the contract for the construction of the two model secondary schools with hostels located at Ewekoro and Ago-Iwoye areas of the state.

    The firm averred that by two contracts dated May 22, 2012, the state government engaged its services for the construction of the two schools at the cost of N750million each and an additional N50.8million cost for the two attached hostels.

    After the state government’s initial payment of N525million and a letter for 65 percent irrevocable standing payment order which amounted to N867.8million, the firm claimed that it went to work and completed the construction for the two schools in 2015.

    It claimed that on completion of the project,  a work certification letter was issued to Contemporary Group Ltd, by the State Bureau for Public Monitoring and Concession.

    According to the firm, the two schools and hostels were commissioned with fanfare and have since being put to use.

    After making an additional payment of about N568m between 2016-2018, the firm claimed that all its subsequent requests for payment of the outstanding balance of N608million inclusive of interest have been rebuffed to date by the state government.

    Read Also: Court declines to hold Lekki Gardens for contempt

     

    In a judgment delivered on the matter in March 2021, by Justice O.J Bamgbose, the court found the state government liable for breach of the contract terms for the construction of the two schools which are still being used by students in various locations.

    The judge held that there was clear evidence that the claimant had completed the construction of the two schools and the additional hostel.

    He further held that the defendant certified the works, vide the letter of certification issued by the defendant on January 27, 2015, and February 2, 2015 upon being satisfied with the completion and the work done.

    The court affirmed that the defendant was therefore in breach of the contract terms.

    “All these facts and further documents are not denied by the defendant or controverted in any way. My answer to the question of whether the defendant is in breach of the terms and conditions for repayment to the claimant under the contract agreement is therefore in the affirmative”, the court held.

    On other reliefs sought by the claimant, the judge held: “ a declaration is hereby made that the claimant is entitled to the balance payment of contract sum plus interest thereon for the project executed under the terms of the contract agreement for the construction of Model Secondary School at Ewekoro local government area and Model Secondary School, at Ijebu North Local Government between the government of Ogun State and Contemporary Group Ltd dated May 22, 2012, and the terms of the defendant’s letter from Ogun State Ministry of Works and Infrastructure to the claimant date December 10, 2013.

    “ A declaration is hereby made that the defendant is liable to pay the claimant the outstanding costs of construction of the additional hostel per Model Secondary School as contained in the defendant’s letter from the Ogun State Ministry of Works and Infrastructure to the claimant dated December 10, 2013.

    “ An order of this court is hereby made compelling the defendant to pay the claimant the outstanding sum of N608,867,935.”

    Earlier before considering the substance of the suit, the judge had noted that the defendant failed to file any response despite being served thrice by the claimant with proof of service which has the stamp of the governor’s office tendered before the court.

     

  • Court declines to hold Lekki Gardens  for contempt

    Court declines to hold Lekki Gardens for contempt

    By Robert Egbe

     

    A Federal High Court in Lagos has turned down an application by Osborne Foreshore Resident Association (OSFRA) seeking to hold 1st and 2nd defendants, Lekki Gardens Estate Ltd and Foreshore Waters Ltd for contempt.

    Justice Nicholas Oweibo held that the case upon which the court was expected to act had no time limit and as such the application could be heard at any material time.

    The judge noted that the substance of the argument put forward by the petitioner lacked merit as there was no cogent or valid reason why the application should be heard when the court was on vacation.

    He held further that the case should be transferred to another judge and be heard after vacation for the purpose of fair hearing, stating that all the parties involved should maintain status quo pending the determination of the case whose ruling has been reserved till August 10.

    This court’s decision followed an earlier ruling delivered on the committal application filed by the plaintiff, through their counsel, Kemi Pinheiro (SAN), against the first and second defendants for allegedly disobeying a court order.

    Read Also: Lekki Gardens denies violating court order

     

    The Federal High Court had earlier made an order restraining the defendants from constructing developing, building or carrying out any further construction, development or building activities in Osborne Foreshore Estate II, Ikoyi, Lagos.

    The order restrained the defendants from acting on any approvals granted by the 4th defendant (Lagos State Physical Planning Permit Authority) pending the hearing of the motion on notice for interlocutory injunction

    In his argument, defence counsel  Mr Tola Oshobi (SAN) said the interim order of the petitioner could be said to be null, void and invalid and an abuse of court process since both courts were of coordinate jurisdiction.

    According to Oshobi, there was a subsisting court order on the same matter obtained from Lagos State High Court.

    He urged the parties to maintain status quo ante as there is nowhere stated in the law where a court decision, obtained later, with similar jurisdiction can override the other.

    Arguing his position, plaintiff’s counsel, Adebowale Kamoru asked the court to disregard the argument of the defendant on the ground that the first defendant, National Environmental Standards and Regulations Enforcement Agency’s, NESREA, falls within the purview of the jurisdiction of the court.

     

  • SERAP inaugurates accountability clubs in tertiary institutions

    SERAP inaugurates accountability clubs in tertiary institutions

    By Adebisi Onanuga

     

    The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) has inaugurated a SERAP Accountability Club (SAC) to promote accountability and transparency in tertiary institutions across the country.

    The inauguration with the theme: ‘Open Society or Secrecy?: The Role of Students in Promoting Transparency and Accountability in Nigeria’ held in Ikeja, Lagos.

    The inauguration of SAC, organised in collaboration with Luminate Foundation, aims at promoting inclusion of students and student bodies in accountability processes and awareness among students on procedures for activating accountability mechanisms to contribute to the fight against corruption and to improve transparency and accountability in the management of public resources, and respect for human rights.

    The club drew its pilot members from the University of Lagos (UNILAG), Akoka, Lagos.

    SAC  is to have a national, unified voice and network for advocacy, information sharing and capacity building whilst mobilising and engaging Nigerian citizens, particularly students of tertiary institutions across the country in promoting transparency and accountability in Nigeria.

    Read Also: Fed Govt, SERAP bicker over litigations

     

    Activist-lawyer, Femi Falana, SAN, who spoke virtually, urged the students to support only political parties with an ideology to implement the fundamental objectives contained in Chapter II of the constitution.

    The African Associate of Luminate, Mrs Toyin Akinloye, said accountability and transparency are central to the heart of any society and stressed the need for more participation of the people in governance.

    SERAP Deputy Director Oluwadare Kolawole educated the students on what the club is not about, adding that the club is a coalition of student volunteers across tertiary institutions  and working together to promote transparency and accountability.

    Kolawole said corruption is one of the many ways that take away many things from Nigerians, adding that the country is in a bad shape because there is so much stealing and corruption because there is no transparency.

    “The burden is on you students to fight for accountability and transparency, not just in your school, but also in government.

    He said government can be made accountable through advocacy, inclusion and collective action.

  • 1,329 adults, 288 children suffer SGBV in Lagos in six months

    1,329 adults, 288 children suffer SGBV in Lagos in six months

    By Adebisi Onanuga

     

    The Lagos State Domestic and Sexual Violence Response Team (DSVRT) recorded a total of 1,617 cases of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV) for the period between January and June, 2021.

    This is contained in the bi-annual report of the DSVRT for the last six months.

    An analysis of the report showed that a total of 1,329 adults, representing 82 per cent of the total number of cases reported for the period under review, suffered one form of assault or the other.

    288 children were also assaulted during the period under review.

    Of this figure, 1,125 females, representing 85 per cent were assaulted by men while 194 male, representing 15 per cent suffered assault in the hands of their women.

    Of the reported cases of 1,329 involving adults, 77 per cent were reported by married women, 11 per cent by single parents, seven per cent by widowed and divorced parents while five per cent were reported by couples co-habiting.

    Domestic Violence top the chart with 954 reported cases, rape accounted for 53 cases; attempt to commit rape and assault accounted for 29 cases; sexual assault by penetration and threat was 24 reported cases while other forms of domestic and gender based violence accounted for 269 reported cases.

    Read Also: SGBV: NAPTIP rescues 150 in Sokoto

     

    In respect of  the 288 cases reported for children, there were 124 reported cases on emotional abuse; 70 reported cases were on child defilement ; 53 cases on Physical violence and child abuse; 18 cases were reported on sexual harassment; five cases of defilement perpetrated by minors to minors while 18 cases bordered on child neglect.

    An analysis of the reported cases involving adults, 1,236 of the survivors were between the ages of 18 and 45 while 93 adults were above 45 years of age.

    Out of the 288 cases of children, four were between age 0 and one; 142 between age one and nine and another 142 between ages 10 and 17.

    The analysis also revealed that amongst the 20 Local Government Areas (LGA) within Lagos State, Alimosho recorded the highest number of cases that were reported.

    It was followed closely by Ikeja, Kosofe, Ikorodu, Oshodi-Isolo and Ifako Ijaiye.

    The report further revealed that six survivors out of the 1, 617 cases reported suffered disability.

    DSVRT Coordinator, Mrs Titilola Vivour-Adeniyi said the analysis implies that advocacy would be intensified in these areas based on the trends observed in the areas.

  • El-Zakzaky: A2J seeks prosecution of indicted military officers

    El-Zakzaky: A2J seeks prosecution of indicted military officers

    By Robert Egbe

     

    Access to Justice (A2J) has urged the Kaduna State Government to prosecute the military officers indicted by the Justice Mohammed Garba Lawal Panel report following Sheikh Ibraheem El-Zakzaky’s acquittal last Wednesday by a Kaduna State High Court.

    It condemned the state’s decision to appeal the judgment while ignoring the panel’s recommendation to prosecute soldiers for “atrocities”, including the killing of hundreds of El-Zakzaky’s followers.

    El-Zakzaky, leader of the Islamic Movement in Nigeria (IMN), also known as Shiite or Shia sect, was acquitted alongside his wife, Zeenat Ibrahim, after a four-year trial for homicide and other related charges.

    The El-Zakzakys were prosecuted following the recommendation of a 13-member Judicial Commission of Inquiry headed by Justice Lawal.

    It was set up by the Kaduna State Government to investigate the December 12-14, 2015 clash between the Army and IMN members.

    The report held El-Zakzaky responsible for alleged acts of lawlessness by his members.

    Read Also: Kaduna files fresh terrorism, treason charges against El-Zakzaky

     

    It also accused the Army of “disproportionate use of force contrary to its rules of engagement”, declaring that soldiers and officers of the Nigerian Army who were involved in the killing of 348 members of the Shiite sect should be prosecuted.

    “Out of the said 349 dead persons, 347 (excluding the soldier) were buried in a mass grave,” said the report.

    In a statement, Access to Justice accused the state of pursuing an “egregious, apartheid-like pattern of selective justice on the ensuing deaths.

    “It arraigned hundreds of IMN members for the murder of one soldier but no soldier has been prosecuted for the murder of at least 348 members of IMN. Not one!

    “The Kaduna State government – a democratic, constitutional government – has thereby abused and corrupted the criminal justice process of the state by using it to perpetuate a toxic form of unconstitutional bias and discrimination, elevating one life above those of at least 348 other lives.”

    Access to Justice, therefore, calls on the Kaduna State Government to stop “political persecution of IMN members and leadership,” and begin a constructive dialogue with the group.

    It urged the state to “Turn its attention now to the prosecution of all the military officers indicted by the Justice Garba Panel report now.

    “If the government fails to do this, it will remain an enabler of the culture of impunity, and of war crimes.

    “The government would also have strengthened the hands of those whose desire is to live above the rule of law, and not under it.”