Tag: Bi-Courtney

  • AMCON urges court to restrain Bi-Courtney from executing judge’s ruling

    The Asset Management Corporation of Nigeria (AMCON) has prayed the Federal High Court in Lagos for an order restraining Bi-Courtney Limited and its Chairman, Dr. Wale Babalakin (SAN) from executing the September 29 ruling by Justice Ibrahim Buba.

    In an Application with Notice for Injunction Pending Appeal, AMCON is seeking an order restraining the respondents, their agents or subsidiaries “from giving effect to the order.”

    Justice Buba, in his ruling, made an order nullifying and discharging the ex-parte order of receivership, possession and freezing granted it by Justice Okon Abang on September 22.

    Justice Abang had appointed a former Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) president, Dr. Olisa Agbakoba (SAN), as AMCON’s receiver/manager over the assets of Bi-Courtney, Chartered Investment Limited, Resort International Limited, Roygate Properties Limited and their chairman Babalakin for allegedly owing AMCON N50billion.

    AMCON is urging the court to grant the injunction restraining the companies from “dissipating their assets.”

    It said if they are not restrained, they could manage the assets in a way that could adversely affect its case at the appellate court.

    The applicant’s grounds are that after Justice Abang made the order, Justice Buba, based on oral application by the respondents’ counsel, vacated it.

    AMCON said because it was dissatisfied with Justice Buba’s ruling, it filed an appeal at the Court of Appeal, seeking to set it aside.

    “The present application is necessary to restrain the respondents from dissipating their assets and rendering nugatory the possible outcome of the appeal at the Court of Appeal.

  • Court sacks Agbakoba as Bi-Courtney assets’ receiver

    Court sacks Agbakoba as Bi-Courtney assets’ receiver

    Justice Ibrahim Buba of the Federal High Court, Lagos on Monday vacated an order appointing a former president of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Olisa Agbakoba (SAN) as receiver over the assets of Bi-Courtney Limited, its chairman Chief Wale Babalakin (SAN) and three others.

    The Murtala Muhammad Airport 2 (MMA 2) is owned by Bi-Courtney pursuant to a concession agreement with the Federal Government.

    Justice Buba said the order made by another judge, Justice Okon Abang, was in error.

    The judge held that the order should not have been made when there were related cases on the same issue before him.

    According to him, the whole facts were not disclosed to Justice Abang before he made the order.

    Saying his “brother judge” was misled, he declared Agbakoba’s appointment null and void and adjourned hearing on the substantive suit.

    Agbakoba was also appointed receiver over the assets of Chartered Investment Limited, Resort International Limited and Roygate Properties Limited.

  • N50bn debt: AMCON, Bi-Courtney in counter claims

    N50bn debt: AMCON, Bi-Courtney in counter claims

    A former president of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Dr Olisa Agbakoba (SAN), has been appointed as receiver over the assets of Bi-Courtney Limited, Dr.Wale Babalakin (SAN)  and three others.

    The appointment is on the strength  of a motion without notice of September 22 granted by  the Federal High Court in Lagos between Asset Management Corporation of Nigeria (AMCON), Bi-Courtney and three others.

    Four days later, however, Bi-Courtney obtained from another Federal High Court, Lagos,an interim injunction restraining AMCON, Agbakoba and the law enforcement agencies from “commencing, taking and/or continuing any steps or actions to appoint a receiver over,or in any manner howsoever take-over or interfere with the operation and/or control of the MMA2” pending the determination of the substantive suit on the matter.    In the AMCON motion, Agbakoba was also appointed receiver over the assets of Chartered Investment Limited, Resort International Limited and Roygate Properties Limited.

    Bi-Courtney owns the Murtala Muhammad Airport 2 (MMA 2) Ikeja, pursuant to a concession agreement with the Federal Government.

    The Old Federal Secretariat building in Ikoyi Lagos  belongs  to Roygate Properties on account of a separate  concession agreement between Roygate and the Federal Government.

    AMCON, through Agbakoba, had applied to the court for orders of possession and receivership over the assets due to the companies’ alleged failure to pay a cumulative debt of about N50 billion owed it.

    Babalakin is said to have interest in the companies.

    In a statement, Agbakoba said his appointment was by a court order made by Justice Okon Abang on September 22.

    The appointment, he said, is “to realise their assets, enforce the individual liability of the shareholders and directors and to manage the affairs of the above mentioned companies for the purpose of recovering debts owed to AMCON.”

    He warned the public against dealing with the companies except through him.

    “The public is hereby notified not to carry on business with any of these companies without my authority and reference.

    “The public is notified that any person(s) that carries on business with any of the companies without my authority will be liable to contempt of the Orders of Court,” he said.

    Agbakoba also notified all commercial banks of the court order, saying the companies’ accounts remain frozen until the case is determined.

    “The banks are hereby directed not to deal with any of the officers of the above stated companies in relation to operating the companies’ bank accounts in whatever form or description without my authority or reference,” he said.

    According to him, the court also made an order restraining the banks from allowing the companies operate the bank accounts.

    The order, he said, is to subsist until the substantive suit is determined.

    “The Federal High Court has ordered that the banks shall file and serve on Olisa Agbakoba and Associates, within seven days, an affidavit disclosing the balance on all accounts held with your banks jointly and severally as at date.

    “Please note that any bank that acts contrary to the orders of court will be liable to contempt,” Agbakoba added.

    In the counter order,the court directed the defendants particularly AMCON “either by themselves or through  their agents, officers, privies, proxies, assigns, receivers, solicitors or otherwise howsoever, from commencing, taking and/or continuing  any administration or extra judicial steps or actions to seize, freeze, take-over, encumber, undermineand/or interfere with, in any manner  whatsoeverthe assests, bank accounts, business and operations of the applicants and related antities pending the hearing and determination of motion on notice for interlocutory injunction.”

    Joined as defendants in the suit are the Attorney Generl of the Federation, AMCON and the Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria (FAAN).

  • ‘Why Bi-Courtney prefers foreign firms’

    INDIGENOUS contractors and suppliers of some equipment at the Domestic Terminal of the Murtala Muhammed Airport, Ikeja, Lagos lack the expertise to offer world-class services, the Chief Executive Officer, Bi-Courtney Aviation Services Limited, Mr Christophe Pennick, has said.

    He said some equipment, including escalators and elevators, installed by some indigenous firms had broken down due to poor installation.

    Pennick said such shoddy service accounts for why the firm is utilising  foreign manufacturers and suppliers.

    The firm, he said, spent over N500 million on the upgrade of  equipment at the Domestic Terminal to enable it attain world-class standard.

    Pennick said the investment covered the replacement of escalators, elevators, cooling system and other  facilities that would change the travel experience.

    Pennick said the Bi-Courtney engaged a foreign firm to intall the new escalators and elevators.

    The firm has concluded plans to replace the check-in counters and increase those at Departure Hall.

    Pennick said: ”We have embarked on serious upgrade of our operational equipment to improve the culture of maintenance. We do not have to wait for the regulatory agency to clamp down on us. But, we have had a bad experience with Nigerian contractors,  either vendors or suppliers of airport equipment.

    “Their technical maintenance and supervision for such airport facilities is below the bar. Less than nine years that this terminal was built, some of the equipment they installed are already below the standard, perhaps due to issues arising during the construction.

    “That is why we are using foreign companies. We went through a rigorous process of tendering before we concluded on the suppliers to fix project at this terminal.

    “The firms have handled related projects with technical expertise in other countries and even Nigeria. Besides, there would be after SA les maintenance of the equipment.”

    Pennick spoke of plans by the firm to expand facilities at the terminal to enable it become one of the best airport terminals in West Africa.

    He said an aggressive expansion plan was ongoing to attract many finiancial institutions into the terminal.

    Beside former EcoBank, Access Bank and SkyeBank that left the terminal, Union Bank and UBA Bank have their expressed readiness to open outlets at the terminal.

    The firm’s Chief Operating Officer, Adebisi Awoniyi, said the upgrade of facilities was caused by the need to uphold a maintenance culture.

  • Bi- Courtney to invest N500m in equipment

    Bi- Courtney to invest N500m in equipment

    Manager of new domestic terminal Two of the Murtala Muhammed Airport (MMA2) yesterday said  it would invest over N500 million on the upgrade of operational equipment at the terminal to enable it attain world class standard.

    The Chief Executive Officer of Bi- Courtney Aviation Services Limited,  Christopher Pennick, said the N500 million investment would cover the replacement of escalators, elevators, cooling system and other operational facilities that would change the travel experience.

    Pennick said  the firm has engaged the services of a foriegn company to fix the newly installed escalators and elevators, for which the terminal manager has spent over one hundred million in the acquisiction of equipment.

    The foreign company , he said would also train some staff of Bi-Courtney  on how to fix the equipment .

    He  said the firm has concluded plans to replace the existing check in counters and increase it from 31 to 45 at the departure hall to enhance capacity for new airlines .

    He  said the terminal manager had to engaged the services of foriegn suppliers and vendors of airport equipment because it has reduced costs and enhanced capacity of the facility.

    He  said the firm’s experience with local contractors and suppliers has been unsavoury, as most of them lack capacity to deliver on world class facilities .

    The terminal manager said the company decided to upgrade facilities at the MMA 2, to give airlines and passengers who utilise the terminal value for their money.

    He spoke of plans by the firm to expand facilities at the terminal to enable it become of the best airport terminals in West Africa.’

    He said an aggressive expansion plan is on going to attract many finiancial institutions into the terminal. aside a few banks including former EcoBank , Access Bank and SkyeBank that left the terminal, Union Bank and UBA Bank have expressed readiness to open outlets at the terminal.

  • Court adjourns Babalakin’s trial till February 17

    Court adjourns Babalakin’s trial till February 17

    A Lagos High Court, Ikeja, on Monday adjourned the trial of the Chairman of Bi-Courtney Limited, Wale Babalakin till February 17, to enable the defence lawyers to regularise their applications.

    The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that Babalakin is being prosecuted for an alleged N4.7 billion fraud before Justice Lateef Lawal-Akapo.

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) had charged him for allegedly transferring the monies on behalf of convicted former Delta State Governor, James Ibori.

    He is standing trial alongside Alex Okoh and their companies – Stabilini Visioni Limited, Bi-Courtney Limited, and Renix Nigeria Limited.

    The defendants are facing a 27-count charge bordering on conspiracy, retention of proceeds of a criminal conduct and corruptly conferring benefit on account of public action.

    During Monday’s proceedings, the judge informed the parties that he needed time to examine some of the processes filed by the defence lawyers.

    He said, “Apart from Roland Otaru (counsel to the third defendant), all the other applications were brought to my attention about 20 minutes ago.

    “In a matter of this nature, it is always good to study the processes and ask pertinent questions as the matter goes along.

    “What I will suggest is that counsel to the defendants sit and identify all these processes and their facts to be sure that all the processes are filed.’’

     

     

  • FAAN never approved N38b MMA 2 terminal design for Bi-Courtney

    FAAN never approved N38b MMA 2 terminal design for Bi-Courtney

    The Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria ( FAAN) clarified yesterday that at no time did it approve the design of the domestic terminal two of the Lagos Airport , otherwise known as MMA 2, for the cost of N38 billion for a 12, year concession agreement . FAAN stated that the design it considered for approval for the terminal was the one put at N3.9 billion, which concession tenure was supposed to run for 12 years.

    The authority said it does not make any economic sense for it to have approved design for a terminal to cost N38 billion for a concession tenure of 12 years, which is not realistic anywhere in the world.

    FAAN, according to its spokesman, Yakubu Dati, said such information is false, misleading and not a true representation of the circumstances surrounding the terminal.

    Dati said in a statement :” The attention of the Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria (FAAN) has been drawn to information quoting Bi-Courtney Aviation Services as saying that “the design of the terminal (MMA Domestic Terminal 2) was approved by the federal gtovernment and FAAN after due consultation with their consultants.”

    The Bi-Courtney source also said that “FAAN was involved at every stage of the redesign and redevelopment of the project. We wish to state categorically and for the umpteen times that nothing could be further from the truth!”

    Expatiating, the FAAN spokesman said: “The design that FAAN approved was for a terminal costing a total of N3.9 billion. However, without approval from FAAN, Bi-Courtney went ahead of its own volition to build a terminal different from the one originally approved by FAAN, the cost of which it put at N38 billion, nearly 10 times the approved cost.

    “There was no way FAAN could have approved a terminal at a cost of N38 billion for a 12, year concession because it did not make common economic sense. We hereby urge members of the public, especially aviation stakeholders, to disregard that bogus claim by Bi-Courtney Aviation Services which we believe was designed to deceive members of the public as usual.”

     

  • Money laundering: Babalakin challenges court’s jurisdiction to hear suit

    Money laundering: Babalakin challenges court’s jurisdiction to hear suit

    The Chairman, Bi-Courtney Limited, Chief Olawale Babalakin, on Monday challenged the jurisdiction of a Lagos High Court, Ikeja, to entertain the N4.7 billion fraud charges preferred against him by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC).

    Babalakin is being tried by the commission alongside four others – Alex Okoh, Stabilini Vision Limited, his company Bi-Courtney Limited and Renix Nigeria Limited for fraudulently transferring N4.7billion out of the country on behalf of the convicted former governor of Delta State, James Ibori.

    The defendants were billed for a fresh arraignment before a new trial judge, Justice Lateef Lawal-Akapo.

    This was sequel to the transfer of the former trial judge, Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo to the Commercial Division of the High Court from the Criminal Division.

    The EFCC had alleged that Babalakin and other defendants fraudulently assisted Ibori to transfer huge sums of money through various parties to Erin Aviation account in Mauritius for the purchase of a Challenger Jet aircraft.

    They had pleaded not guilty to the charges preferred against them by the anti- agency.

    At the resumed trial on Monday, Babalakin and co-defendants rejected being arraigned on the basis of their pending applications, challenging the court’s jurisdiction.

    But counsel to EFCC, Mr. Rotimi Jacobs (SAN) expressed disappointment that Babalakin was not in court.

    He urged the court to revoke the bail earlier granted to him for failing to attend proceedings twice.

    He argued that Babalakin’s absence in court was a breach of his bail conditions and that the act was disrespectful to the court.

    But Babalakin’s counsel, Mr. Wale Akoni (SAN) urged the court to discountenance Jacob’s appeal for revocation of Babalakin’s bail.

    Akoni submitted that Babalakin’s absence was on the ground of his pending application, challenging the charges and jurisdiction of the court.

     

  • Bi-Courtney to resume work on MMA2 hotel

    Bi-Courtney to resume work on MMA2 hotel

    Work is set to resume on the hotel and conference centre projects owned by Bi-Courtney Aviation Services Limited (BASL), operator of the Murtala Muhammed Airport Terminal Two (MMA2), Ikeja. The twin projects are located opposite MMA2, also operated by BASL.

    Sources in Bi-Courtney said the contractor for the projects, Stabilini Visinoni, would soon mobilise to site and complete the two projects “once and for all”.

    According to the source, “all is now set for our contractor to move to site and see to the end of the projects, which have been there for a few years now. This time, we are determined to complete the projects and change the face of the Murtala Muhammed Airport environment for the better”.

    The two projects have become a subject of litigation between Bi-Coutney and the Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria (FAAN), the lessor of the land in which they are sited, following which a Federal High Court barred the agency from tampering with the project and the lease agreement in any form whatsoever.

    The firm and the agency had entered into a 40 years lease agreement over the land on February 2, 2007.

    But, while the projects were ongoing, a dispute arose over the lease agreement following which Bi-Courtney challenged the purported revocation of the lease by FAAN at the Federal High Court.

    The matter, however, took a new turn as Justice Mohammed Idris assumed jurisdiction on the suit, despite the preliminary objection filed by the Federal Government.

    The judge said Bi-Courtney’s action was properly filed, adding that “it is competent and the court has jurisdiction to hear it”.

    In two letters, dated April 19, 2012, FAAN had informed Bi-Courtney that the leases granted it in respect of the two projects had been terminated. The agency hinged its action on alleged breaches committed in the agreements signed on the projects.

    The court consequently stopped FAAN from interfering in the projects paving the way for Bi-Courtney to resume work.

     

     

     

  • FAAN alleges attack on general manager by Bi-Courtney thugs

    •It’s a  spurious allegation,full of mischief-firms reacts

     

    Another crisis between Bi Courtney Aviation Services Limited (BASL) and the Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria (FAAN) erupted last Wednesday when the General Manager, Corporate Communications, Mr. Yakubu Dati, was allegedly stopped from driving off in his car at the Murtala Muhammed International Airport domestic terminal (MMA2) by the Chief Executive Officer of BASL, Mr. Christopher Penninck.

    Dati alleged that Penninck “personally led thugs to block the car conveying me out of the MMA2 official car park on the fateful day.”

    He added:”He offered no explanation as he made frantic phone calls. Sensing danger, I took pictures of the scene.

    “He sent thugs to forcefully take my phone. It took the intervention of the police officer on duty to rescue me. The police removed the barricade and allowed my car to drive off.”

    He also alleged that Bi Courtney CEO threatened to deal with him.

    “What surprised me was that other cars with FG registration numbers, same as mine, were neither harassed nor molested but given free access. In fact, our Director of Legal that arrived with me was allowed to leave.”

    However, spokesman for BASL, Steve Omolale-Ajulo dismissed the allegation as spurious and mischievous .

    His words:”I should not reply to this kind of petty allegation but, there is the need to set the records straight .

    “Mr Dati drove his car to MMA2 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 and parked illegally at our protocol car park, instead of the multi storey car park. All pleas by our security personnel to make him park at the right place, being the car park was ignored.

    “While doing his usual work round , Mr Pennick saw the illegally parked car and challenged Bi-Courtney security men why they should allow the owner to park there .

    “While he was talking with his men, Dati emerged from our arrival hall and started taking photographs , an action he protested.

    “ A senior security personnel intervened and the matter was settled in minutes. However, the questions to ask Mr Dati are: Does he have right to park anywhere at MMA2 or any other airport terminal for that matter? Is he above the law? Does Bi- Courtney now keep thugs at MMA2? Why did he not go to the police if he was really attacked by the so- called thugs.

    Can somebody being attacked by thugs take the photographs of the same attack? We see some element of mischief and blackmail in this . But, we would not succumb to such dervish antics.”

     

    In the last few weeks FAAN and Bi Courtney officials have been locked in confrontations over the placement of billboards at the uncompleted hotel which BASL is building opposite MMA2, a structure that is strategically located at the link road to the international terminal of the airport.

    FAAN officials removed the BASL billboards saying that the concessionaire, which built and operates the MMA2 on Build, Operate and Transfer (BOT) has no right to place advert billboards on the building which has ceased to belong to the organisation.

    Besides, FAAN said only it has the control over advert placements at the airport and should be consulted before any billboard was placed.