Tag: Cynthia

  • Cynthia: Court berates defence counsel for stalling trial

    Cynthia: Court berates defence counsel for stalling trial

    Justice Olabisi Akinlade of a Lagos High Court sitting in Igbosere yesterday chastised the defence counsel in the trial of the four men charged with the murder of Cynthia Osokogu for stalling proceedings.

    The proceedings of the trial of the alleged killers of Cynthia were stalled for the second time yesterday by the absence of one of the defence counsel.

    The prosecution had on September 19 closed its case at the court.

    The defence was  to open its case yesterday.

    But at the resumed hearing of the matter, the counsel for the second defendant, Mr. Micheal  Ajayi from the Chambers of Mike Igbokwe (SAN), sent a letter to the court for a stand down of the case till 12.30 pm.

    A little after 12.30pm, Ajayi failed to show up.

    Also at the last hearing,  counsel for the first defendant, Mr. Victor Opara,   failed to appear in court.

    Opara  sent a text message to the Attorney-General, informing him he had to undergo an urgent eye operation.

    Counsel for the fourth defendant, Mr. C. Achomanu, simply failed to appear without any form of excuse.

    Justice Akinlade berated the defence counsel for employing various  tactics to delay trial.

    The trial judge noted in particular  the attitude of the second defence counsel in delaying the matter  since the commencement of the trial.

    She said their attitude was unbecoming of learned counsel.

    The trial judge reminded a lawyer that the defendants are presumed innocent until proved guilty.

    Two of suspects, Okwumo Nwabufor and Olisaeloka Ezike, are standing trial for felony, conspiracy to commit murder and the murder of  Cynthia Osokogu.

    The third suspect, Osita Orji, the pharmacist who sold the Rophynol drug used on Cynthia to the alleged murderers, is standing trial along with the other two for his reckless and negligent act, while the fourth suspect, Nonso Ezike, who pawned her Blackberry phone, is charged with the possession of stolen property.

    The men are facing a six-count charge bordering on conspiracy, murder, stealing, negligence and possession of stolen goods.

    The offences contravene  Sections 221,231,409 and 285[1] of the Criminal Law of Lagos State, 2011.

    Justice Akinlade adjourned the matter  to October 31 and November 7 for the defendants to open their defence.

  • How suspects plotted to kill Cynthia, by witness

    How suspects plotted to kill Cynthia, by witness

    A Lagos High Court, Igbosere, was yesterday told that the suspected murderers of Cynthia Osokogu hatched their plan few days before she was killed.

    A prosecution witness (pw), Joseph Edo, told the court how Olisaeloka Ezike (second defendant) went to Agboju Market at the instance of Okumo Nwabufo (first defendant) to get the chain and selotape, which they used in to bind Cynthia.

    Led in evidence by the Commissioner for Justice and Attorney General, Mr Ade Ipaye, said: “It is the defendants’ stock-in-trade to invite women to hotels, drug and rape them.

    He told Justice Olabisi Akinlade that Okumo and Ezike had it in mind to kill Cynthia on her arrival in Lagos.

    “From my investigation, I discovered that the first defendant sent the second defendant to Agboju Market to buy the instruments they used for the operation – chain and selotape – few days before Cynthia was killed. The second defendant (Ezike), after getting the items used his phone to snap them and forwarded the picture to the first defendant (Nwabufo).

    “He equally sent Nwabufo a text message from his phone, asking if ‘this was the chain and seliotape you asked me to buy?’. Nwabufo replied Ezike that it would be okay for the job. The messages are all in their phones,” Edo said.

    The witness said that he also discovered that the third defendant, Orji Osita, who is a pharmacist, supplied the suspects with the Rohypnol used to sedate Cynthia.

    He said the fourth defendant, Nonso Ezike, “dishonestly” received Cynthia’s Blackberry phone from his elder brother, who is the second defendant.

    “It was discovered that it was not the first phone he (Nonso) bought from the second defendant and he has knowledge of the first and second defendants’ stock-in-trade. They specialise in bringing in ladies into hotel rooms, enticing them with one or two things and then rape them,” Edo said.

    Earlier, Justice Akinlade admitted in evidence, the confessional statements and the video evidence made at Festac Police Station on August 20, 2012 by Nwabufo and Ezike, on the case.

    In a ruling on the admissibility of their statements after they alleged that the statements were obtained under duress, Justice Akinlade held that their allegations in court were concocted as there was no evidence to back them up.

    The prosecution, he said, had proved beyond reasonable doubts that the statements were voluntarily made, adding that from her examination of the confessional statements, the handwritings of the defendants did not show they were under torture to write them.

    “The defendants were questioned in an open place and were also asked by the Area Commander if they made their statements voluntarily, which they attested to in the affirmative. Moreover, from the video evidence, the defendants looked well and untortured. It was when the Area Commander realised that their narrations were the same as contained in their confessions that he requested a camera man to video them.

    “I hereby rule that the prosecution has proven its case in the trial-within-trial to determine the admissibility of the confessional statements made by the first and second defendants on August 20, 2012 at Festac Police Station. I hereby admit the confessional statements and video evidence made by the defendants and tendered by the prosecution as exhibits,” she held.

    Justice Akinlade adjourned the case till March 13.

  • Cynthia: Police tortured us, say suspects

    Cynthia: Police tortured us, say suspects

    Two suspects in the murder of Cynthia Osokogu, Okwumo Nwabufo and Olisaeloka Ezike yesterday told a Lagos High Court how the Police forced them to admit that they killed her.

    Nwabufo (34), Ezike (24), who are standing trial with Orji Osita, 33; and Ezike Nonso, 25, said they were tortured to make the statements that are being used against them.

    The defendants were charged to court for Cynthia’s murder at Cosmilla Hotel in FESTAC Town, Lagos, on July 22, last year.

    The late Cynthia came to Lagos on the invitation of the defendants, some of who she met on facebook.

    Nwabufo and Ezike were led in evidence by their counsel, Victor Okpara and Michael Ajayi.

    Nwabufo, who at the last hearing, told the court that his confessional statements were made under duress, relived how the police tortured him.

    At the trial within trial to determine how the police obtained statements during investigation, Nwabufo said those who arrested him, called him a murderer and beat him up.

    “On the day I was arrested, up to 20 policemen broke into my apartment and asked for my name after which they called me a murderer and started beating me.

    “I was later blindfolded while I was putting on only pant and taken into their vehicle; then we drove to the police station,” he said.

    He said, he asked the police to allow him contact his lawyer or relatives but they refused.

    “When we got to the police station, I was taken to the Area Commander, Dan Okoro’s office who showed me a lady’s picture and asked if I knew her.

    “I said yes, she is my friend and he immediately called me a murderer while he pinched the upper part of my left eye with a plier.

    “I was then taken to a room where I was chained and tortured to accept whatever they (the police) told us concerning the murder,” said Nwabufo.

    During the torture, he said, the police “brought out a suspect and shot him on the leg to show that they would shoot us if we do not comply”.

    “One of the policemen released teargas into my left eye and I have not been able to see with it since then,” he said.

    The torture, he claimed, led him to make the statements that were being dictated to him at different times.

    Ezike told the court that he was also tortured and statements dictated to him.

    He corroborated Nwabufo’s claim that the police shot a suspect on the leg to intimidate them to admit to Cynthia’s murder.

    Justice Olabisi Akinlade adjourned the case to January 13.

  • Cynthia: Drama as suspect alleges shortage of food in Ikoyi Prisons

    Cynthia: Drama as suspect alleges shortage of food in Ikoyi Prisons

    There was a drama at a Lagos High Court, Igbosere yesterday, following the allegation by one of the suspected murderers of Cynthia Osokogu that there was insufficient food in the Ikoyi Prisons.

    Okwumo Nwabufor (first defendant), while praying the court for his transfer to the Kirikiri Prisons, alleged that there was food shortage in the prisons.

    But his claim was swiftly debunked by a warder identified as John who told Justice Olabisi Akinlade that Nwabufor was caught with a mobile phone.

    He said: “The main reason the defendant is seeking transfer is because his cell was changed after he was caught using a mobile phone in the prison yard.

    “Since no one knew how he came about the phone, prison authorities decided to change his cell.”

    Akinlade, having listened to the prison warder, turned down Nwabufor’s request.

    Earlier, the court heard from an Assistant Commissioner of Police, ACP, and Area E Commander, Dan Okoro, that Nwabufor and the second defendant, Olisaeloka Ezike, made voluntary confessional statements when they were arrested last year in Festac, Lagos.

    Contrary to the claims by counsel for the defendants, Victor Okpara and Micheal Ajayi, Okoro said both defendants were not tortured and asserted their written statements in a video recording.

    He gave the testimonies at the trial-within-trial to ascertain the admissibility of the confessional statements made by Nwabufor and Ezike.

    Nwabufor and Ezike are standing trial for conspiracy, rape and murder, while a pharmacist, Osita Orji, who sold the Rophynol drug to the alleged murderers, is standing trial for reckless and negligent act. Nonso Ezike is also in court for possessing Cynthia’s stolen phone.

    Led in cross-examination by Ajayi, Okoro said he had asked Nwabufor and Ezike when they were brought to his office with their statements if they were tortured and they said no.

    He said: ‘’When the first and second defendants were brought to my office, I read through their confessional statements and I asked them whether they made them voluntarily and they answered in the affirmative.

    “I then asked them to narrate to me what they actually wrote in their statements. In the midst of their narrations, I stopped them and sent the Investigating Police Officer (IPO), Inspector Joseph Edo, to arrange for a video coverage of their oral testimony and it was recorded.”

    Okoro said when the video recorder was brought, he told the suspects that their oral statements would be recorded and that whatever they said would be used against them in court.

    ‘’They were willing and narrated what transpired during the period they were with the late Cynthia. They were very free. It was like a drama session.

    “While the first defendant said it was the second defendant that held Cynthia at the throat, the second defendant also accused the first defendant of chaining Cynthia’s hands backwards’’, he said.

    Led in evidence by the state’s Attorney General, Ade Ipaye, IPO Edo and a Deputy Superintendent of Police, Gregory Imoh, told the court the roles they played in obtaining statements from the defendants.

    Edo said that Nwabufor and Ezike made voluntary statements on August 20, last year after they were duly cautioned that the statements would be used against them in court.

    He told the court that the two defendants voluntarily made confessional statements and that they were not brutalised or pressured to do so as alleged by the lawyers.

    Corroborating Edo,  Imoh said when the defendants were brought to his office by the IPO and his team members, he read the statements aloud to them (suspects) and asked if they made them voluntarily and they said yes.

    After listening to the prosecution witnesses, Akinlade adjourned the matter to November 20 and December 11 for the continuation of the trial-within-trial.

  • Pathologist gives more details on how Cynthia was murdered

    Pathologist gives more details on how Cynthia was murdered

    The Consultant pathologist at the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH), Prof. John Obafunwa, on Friday gave more insight into how Cynthia Osokogu was killed by two young men she met on Facebook.

    According to Obafunwa, the late Cynthia’s Osokogu’s mouth was stuffed with a black and yellow hair net, a white handkerchief and the attachment of the weaveon.

    He said that a tape was also fixed before her mouth.

    Obafunwa revealed these while showing pictures of the autopsy activities on the late Cynthia from the beginning to the end of the procedure.

    He was giving evidence before Justice Olabisi Akinlade of a Lagos High Court sitting in Ikeja.

    The pathologist testified as a prosecution witness in the ongoing trial of the suspected killers of Cynthia.

    Cynthia, 24, was allegedly drugged and murdered in a hotel room in Lagos last July by the duo of Okwumo Nwabufor and Olisaeloka Ezike, who are facing charges bordering on conspiracy to commit murder, murder and felony.

    Also, Osita Orji, a pharmacist who sold the Rophynol drug to the alleged murderers, is accused of reckless and negligent act, while Nonso Ezike, who pawned the deceased’s Blackberry phone, is charged with possession of stolen property.

    The professor of pathology stated further that the late Cynthia’s lungs were heavily engorged with blood weighing 400-500 grammes rather than the normal 250-300 grammes, adding that there were also tiny beads on the surface, which he attributed to blood accumulation called pulmonary oedema.

    Obafunwa explained further that there were also tiny beads in the lining of her voice box while the kidney when sliced had dark spots in some areas, indicating a shut down of blood circulation due to shock.

    Prof Obafunwa, who was being cross examined by defence counsels, maintained that there was no evidence that the late Cynthia was suffering from any disease like asthma or tuberculosis, based on their examination and microscopic study.

    According to him, the seven bruises on Cynthia’s thighs were suspected to be bite marks while when the corpse was skinned, deep bruises, which couldn’t be seen on the skin were found on various parts of her legs.

    The autopsy pictures revealed that Cyhthia’s hands were tied with tape and a chain covered with blue plastic wrap and there were bruises at the back of her right hand and her mouth was disfigured.

    The pathologist stated that Cynthia’s corpse was labelled unknown when brought in, and that the only clothing she had on was an under shirt with pink stripes

    The professor of Forensic Medicine had earlier testified that Cynthia died from asphyxia, that is, absence of oxygen supply to the body, adding that the blockage of the deceased’s upper respiratory airways was the immediate cause of her death.

    The matter was adjourned till May 31, 2013.

  • Cynthia and the beastly cousins

    Parents and children alike have lessons to learn here

    Sometimes, I feel tempted to agree with former Chief of General Staff, Admiral Augustus Aikhomu, who once said (I think at a press briefing) that the Babangida government that he was second-in-command in would ‘arrest and jail’ some suspects. Aikhomu characteristically forgot that after the police have made arrest, the judiciary is supposed to take over, and that it is only the judiciary that has the power to jail or convict. Even after one of his aides had allegedly reminded him of this serious error of omission, Aikhomu amended his statement to read that yes, they would ‘arrest, prosecute and jail’ the felons! The point, nonsensical as it seemed, was that the military had no patience for the rule of law. The point I am also making is that there are times when matters have resolved themselves, and we need not belabour issues by looking for what is not missing all in the name of rule of law.

    Two recent incidents in the country seem to have vindicated this position. The first was the death, on August 17, of Clifford Orji, and the second, the brutal murder of pretty Cynthia Osokogu, the daughter of Major-General Frank Osokogu (rtd), by two satanic cousins, on July 22. Orji came into limelight when people began to suspect his activities under the bridge at the Toyota Bust Stop area of the Oshodi- Apapa Expressway in Lagos in the late 1990s. He was arrested and subsequently arraigned on February 19, 1999, at the Ebute-Metta Magistrate’s Court in Lagos.

    Perhaps the most curious thing in his case was that for the 13 years that he was at the Kirikiri Prison, he was never tried in court for the allegations of cannibalism and being in possession of human parts over which he was arrested, ostensibly because he was mad. And no psychiatric hospital in the country could treat him! The next thing we were told was that he has died. So, we may never know whether it was some big men that actually planted him under the bridge to source for human parts for them, or not.

    We were yet to digest this when Cynthia’s death hit the news waves. The 24 year-old was the last child and only daughter of Major-Gen. Osokogu (rtd). She was killed in an hotel in FESTAC Town in Lagos. Two men who had reportedly admitted that they murdered her were paraded on August 22 by the Lagos State Police Command, Ikeja. The suspects are Echezona Nwabufor, 33, and Ezekiel Nnechuwu Olisa Eloka, 23. Eloka said they killed Cynthia because they thought she had a lot of money in her possession.

    From what they reportedly said, and as captured by journalists during the police parade of the duo, it would seem Cynthia’s blood was crying for vengeance. Otherwise, the two suspects would not have been singing like canaries the way they did, after they were caught. When the story broke, some people felt there might have been more to it than was initially reported. Unless those paraded are later found not to be the ones that lured pretty Cynthia to Lagos, or unless they repudiate the story they told the press when they were being paraded, it was clear there was nothing between the suspects and the late Cynthia. The suspects themselves admitted that they met on Blackberry group chat and began communicating from there.

    No doubt, one expected a lady doing post-graduate programme to have been more circumspect about the kind of people to trust, and not to jump at offers, particularly from strangers (that was a creed many of us were taught when we were growing up; I do not know whether such things are still being taught today), that might have been a weakness, and Cynthia’s eventual undoing. From what is in the public domain however, one gets the impression that she possibly might not have been in dire need of the free air ticket and hotel accommodation that her suspected murderers used to lure her. Parents have a job to do here. People addicted to the social networks also have to watch it. At any rate, whatever Cynthia might have been, sinner or saint, she did not deserve to die the way she did in the hands of the brutes in human skin that killed her.

    The suspects themselves probably realised this, and the consequence; hence, the song they have been singing that they never meant to kill her; that all they wanted to do was dispossess her of money and other valuables. As a businesswoman, they had thought she would come to Lagos with a lot of money to buy the cheap goods they promised they were going to offer her. But one should wonder what that means, considering that they admitted drugging her with 10 tablets of Rohypnol, which they injected into three packs of Ribena juice that they served her in her hotel room. They did not meant to kill her, yet, they kept her under ruffling sheets for 12 long hours, a thing they denied, yet, traces of semen were found on her private part! I do not know whether even professional prostitutes could have survived such assault.

    Again, the suspects denied having sex with her; they denounced the condoms found in the hotel room and stuff like that. Yet, they claimed she was about their fifth victim and that they had only always robbed and raped the other victims, that none of them ever died in their ‘protective custody’. The kind of stupid things they have been saying, and so incoherently too, once again shows that many criminals hitherto thought to be men become lily-livered when finally apprehended. How do people who claimed they had only been raping their other victims now say they never did in Cynthia’s case? And they want us to believe that? What pleasure would the lady have derived from using a vibrator (sex toy) on herself when she had two able-bodied suspected serial rapists in the same room with her? They want us to believe that, too? Cynthia’s first striking feature was her captivating beauty. Not to have ‘known her’ as the suspects want us to believe would probably have meant that their other victims were paragons of beauty too, whose shoe laces Cynthia would not have been qualified to untie. They did not mean to kill her, yet, they tied her mouth and hands; they also chained her legs! What bunkum? These beastly cousins should go tell all these to the marines! They did not mean to kill her, yet they referred to her as ’bastard’ after they were through with her.

    If we take into cognisance the items allegedly recovered from the suspects: seven driving licences (three belonging to Ezekiel, four belonging to Okumo with different names); the deceased’s belongings, including her shoes (found in Okumo’s house); 17 mobile phones, two Diamond Bank rubber stamps, two syringes, a pack of Ribena, 22 SIM cards, a chain, 12 debit and credit cards, we will know that they are big time suspects.

    In conclusion, it was a lawyer friend of mine who led me into the temptation of wanting to see some sense in what Admiral Aikhomu said: that we don’t have to take the luxury of the rule of law in cases that seem to have decided themselves; we should just ‘arrest and jail’ the suspects, when she said that if the suspects in Cynthia’s matter get a good lawyer, they might escape being charged with murder, or even receive a mere slap on the wrist for whatever the court eventually finds them guilty of. However, we should wait to get to that bridge before crossing it.

  • Who is the next victim of social media?

    Who is the next victim of social media?

    Sometime in July, I received a broadcast message on my Blackberry Messenger (BBM) from a friend that reads: “The lady I use as my display picture is Cynthia. She left her home for Lagos to get market for her business but at the moment, nobody knows her whereabouts. Anybody with useful information about Cynthia should contact the police. Please re-broadcast and use her picture as your display picture for five minutes.”

    I did use Cynthia’s picture but for less than five minutes and hoped she would be found alive.

    However, when the news of her death was broken, tears dropped down my cheeks. When I read her profile, I had no doubt in my mind that she was such a promising young lady who, at 24, could control a business of her own without depending on his well-to-do family.

    The gruesome murder or accidental murder (as the perpetrators put it) of Miss Cynthia was unearthed by the Nigerian Police that, for the first time, got my respect for the feat. This is not time to tackle our government that has made the security system ineffective.

    The deceased, Miss Cynthia Osokogu, met Okwoma Nwabufor, 33, last November on a Blackberry group chat. For close to six months, she must have been in touch constantly with her killers on the messenger. They must have exchanged pictures and calls to their satisfaction and Cynthia would have thought Okwoma is an innocent young man who would not hurt an insect.

    She visited Lagos to get market for her boutique and decided to see her “friend” with whom she had been exchanging conversation in the last six months of her life but that decision took her life.

    Two of the culprits Okwoma Nwabufor and Odera Ezekiel looked too innocent to hurt a fly when I saw their pictures.

    Cynthia’s case in one in many of the sad events that have been perpetrated through social networks such as Facebook, Blackberry Messenger, Mocospace, Eskimi and so on. There have been series of sex videos being spread through these media.

    These videos always show how young ladies engage guys in sex. There are videos that show how a group of youths gang rape girls in their rooms. There was one I saw and it appeared the crime was perpetrated in the eastern part of the country because of the accent of the characters involved the tragic video. It was a sad game of four hefty guys between the age of 26 to 32 having their turn on a young lady who could not be more than 23.

    In the video, the girl continued to plead with this guys who found delight in their act and took turns without being disturbed by their conscience. The title of the video was “2go package”.

    The second video I saw had three guys taking turn on young lady who was calling the rapists names: “ Brother Seun”. This act was perhaps committed in the Southwest. The victim could not be more than 20 years. Cynthia’s case have only gone public because of the personality of her father. Many of such cases have gone without being reported.

    Most of these social media were created with good intention but they are fast becoming slaughter slab for youth in Nigeria.

    We saw the good side of social media during the subsidy protest last January. It is also being used to conduct lawful business by numerous online firms.

    Bloggers like Ayodele Obajeun, Dayo Ibitoye are dishing out good stuffs with through their blogs. It is high time to put inplace measures to checkmate this menace. Youth and those who use the social networks should be extra careful because nobody can tell who is the next victim in the online slaughterhouse.

     

    Olatunji, 200-Level Political Science, EKSU

     

  • Police set to release Cynthia’s body

    Police set to release Cynthia’s body

    Nine days after the
    burial rites of late
    Cynthia Osokugo were performed in her Bebe, Ovia Agbor hometown in Ika South Local Government Area of Delta State,without her corpse, the police in Lagos say her family can now  come and collect  her remains for burial.
    The Area Commander in charge of Area ‘E’, FESTAC Town, Mr Dan Okoro, said last night that Cynyhia’s corpse has been transferred to the mortuary from pathologist theatre following the completion of the autopsy on it.
    Okoro,an assistant commissioner of police, said Cynthia’s family was being contacted to  go to the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital mortuary to collect her remains.
    Okoro had said on Wednesday that the family would  not be able to collect the corpse until the police were in possession of the autopsy report.
    He did not however say yesterday if the police had received the autopsy report. He only said the pathologist was through with  the corpse.
    A casket suspected to be Cynthia’s was seen at Lekan Ogunshola Memorial Mortuary.
    Cynthia, daughter of Major-Gen Frank  Osokogu(rtd),  was murdered in Cosmilla Hotel. Lake View Estate, Amuwo-Odofin, Lagos on July 22 allegedly by her Facebook friends, Okomu Nwabufor and Eike Odera.
    The suspects and two others have already been charged to court in connection with her murder.