Tag: degree

  • Fake degree mills, fake professors!

    Fake degree mills, fake professors!

    By EmekaOMEIHE (PIX)

    Three recent but closely related events again brought to the fore all that is wrong with the Nigerian education system. First was a report published by an online medium over alleged certificate racketeering at the Lagos State University, LASU.

    The medium claimed that a certificate racketeering syndicate operating within the university, sold authentic LASU degree certificates to willing buyers for between N2million to N3million depending on the intricacies of the course under bargain. Given the position of LASU as a highly rated state university in the country, the report must have come to many as a huge surprise.

    But in a very swift response, the management of the university said it had brought the allegations to the attention of the law enforcement agencies which are yet to conclude their investigations. It promised that its inquiries into the allegation will be published and appropriate action taken.

    There has been ‘no cover-up’ and there will be ‘no cover-up’ LASU management reassured.

    The second was the shutdown by the federal government of 18 foreign university campuses operating illegally in the country and the temporary suspension of evaluation and accreditation of degree certificates from the Republic of Benin and Togo. Five of the universities which the federal government described as degree mills are domiciled in the USA, six in the UK and three in Ghana among other countries.

    The action followed revelation by an investigative reporter that he secured a degree certificate from one university in the Republic of Benin within six months after paying an agreed sum of money. That was not all. Having been armed with the procured degree certificate, he successfully enrolled for the compulsory National Youth Service Corps NYSC programme.

    The suspension will subsist pending the outcome of an investigation by the ministries of foreign affairs and education of the countries involved; the Department of State Services DSS and the NYSC.

    There was also the altercation between the National Universities Commission, NUC and some universities following the publication of a list of universities allegedly harbouring fake professors indicted by the NUC. The publication raised so much dust that some universities were compelled to issue statements dissociating their institutions from the alleged fake professors listed against their establishments.

     But the NUC denied the report that it uncovered a list of 100 fake professors in some universities across the country. It clarified that though it initiated a verification process for academics in 2019 with the intent of compiling and publishing a list of full professors in the Nigerian university system, it found some anomalies such as associate professors being listed as full professors. The commission said it shared the collated data with the universities for authentication as to who qualified to be a full professor and that at no point did it release a list of fake professors in 2024.

    That clarification would seem to have put paid the controversy over the purported list of fake professors that surfaced in the public domain. But this is not the first time the NUC would be raising issues on the abuse the ‘professor’ title has been subjected to in the country.

    In 2011, the commission had cried out that the university tradition in the appointment of professors which requires peer-review and assessment by at least three external professors in the same field from both within and outside the country was being breached. That tradition also requires that appointees to the rank of professor must have a “professorial chair”.

    That is not all. The commission equally complained of instances where some individuals parade themselves as professors without evidence of affiliation to any recognized university or the academic field they made such scholarly contributions.

    The NUC further highlighted instances where parastatals, research institutes and allied establishments which have neither an academic senate nor affiliation to any recognized university awarded professorships.

    Even as the NUC denied publishing a list of fake professors as bandied in some sections of the media, the reality is that this country is home to fake professors. There are fake professors because some of those who parade themselves in that garb did not meet the conditions for adorning such titles. They were neither assessed by at least three external professors in the relevant fields from within and outside the country nor do they have a professorial chair.

    Some others who adorn the title without evidence of affiliation to any recognized university or the academic field they made such scholarly contributions fall within the fake category. Professorships awarded by parastatals, research institutes and allied establishments in contravention of extant regulations are also fake. These breaches demonstrate very clearly, the existence of a pool of fake professors both within and outside the university system.

    Read Also: Tinubu to grace Uzodimma’s swearing in ceremony Monday

    That may be the real source of the fake professorship controversy which the NUC is reluctant to expose. But the NUC as a regulatory body is not really helpless in this matter. It is curious however that more than 12 years after the commission exposed the abuse the title of professorship was being subjected to, it is not on record that any effort has been made to address the problem.

    It is not just enough to lament the abuse to which some universities, research institutes and allied establishments have subjected the title of ‘professor’, the NUC must go beyond lamentations to wield the big stick to tame the monster.

    The commission and the relevant ministries should share the blame for inaction in sanctioning institutions and persons known to have run against extant regulations in the appointment of professors. One quick way of weeding out the fake from the rank of genuine professors is a prompt compilation and publication of the authentic list of genuine professors which NUC commenced in 2019 with dates of their elevation and institutions. With such data, it will become easy to fish out the fake professors from within our midst.

    But then, it remains a sad commentary that parastatals, research institutes and allied establishments under the federal government ministries go outside their mandate to appoint professors in contravention of subsisting regulations without sanctions. This shows how disorganized, disorderly and uncoordinated planning and supervision within our education have remained.

    The same confusion is manifest in the existence of fake campuses of foreign universities within our shores awarding fake degrees with the authorities looking the other way. The existence of illegal campuses is more worrisome given that this is not the first time the government would declare them illegal.

    How many of them continued to operate for years in the face of their illegality is a measure of the seriousness of the government in enforcing standards in the country’s education system. It is not just enough to shut down these campuses. The government must move further to seal all the premises to demonstrate unambiguously the illegality of their activities. 

    But these fake degree awarding mills thrive because Nigerians show uncommon interest in the patronage of their services. This should not be surprising given the penchant by both the high and the low in the country to discard the rules of decent conduct.

    The desecration and debasing of all institutions in the country have been so much so that it is difficult to make significant progress without serious ethical redirection and moral re-orientation. With the size, influence and prominence of the country within the sub-region, the bug that is afflicting universities in Benin and Togo must have crept from the domino effect of the breakdown of standards in Nigeria. The leadership is to blame.

    Even then, our universities are not free from those allegations for which the federal government suspended the evaluation and accreditation of universities in Benin and Togo. Not with the proliferation of federal, state and private universities. Not with the indecent haste with which the National Assembly is moving to pass a law for the approval of 47 additional federal universities without a template for their funding – a move ASUU president, Prof Emanuel Osodeke blames for the falling standards of education.

    The investigative panel by the government yet offers another opportunity for a total re-evaluation and re-examination of the entire gamut of the nation’s education system to re-position it to meet world class standards. That our universities trail behind in the world university ranking index, is a measure of the incalculable harm wrought by the lowering of standards, fake degree mills and fake professors.

  • Fed Govt to probe degree racketeering in foreign, private varsities

    Fed Govt to probe degree racketeering in foreign, private varsities

    The Federal Government yesterday launched a probe of degree racketeering in foreign and local private universities.

    A seven-member inter-ministerial committee will investigate the allegations within eight weeks.

    Minister of Education, Prof. Tahir Mamman, mandated it to review the role of any ministries, departments and agencies (MDAs) or their officials in the facilitation of the recognition and procurement of fake certificates in question. 

    The committee has the Chairman, Board of Trustees, Committee of Vice Chancellor of Nigerian Universities (CVCNU), Prof. Jibrila Amin, as the head. 

    Other members are Acting Executive Secretary of the National Universities Commission (NUC), Chris Maiyaki; Lazarus Ikpadaba from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Mr Abel Olanrewaju from the Office of the National Security Adviser.

    Others are Omeh Nwokpoku from the Office of the National Security Adviser, Amina Lugga from the Federal Ministry of Youth Development, and Mrs Doam Iyortyom from the Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board (JAMB).

    The minister, while reading the terms of reference, urged the committee to review existing policies and procedures on accreditation and certification.

    Read Also: Fed Govt inaugurates inter-ministerial committee on allegations of degree racketeering

    He said: “The committee must also examine the rules, procedures and processes for recognition and accreditation of foreign universities and programmes by the Federal Ministry of Education.”

    “Establish if unapproved foreign institutions (Degree Mills) exist or not in Nigeria in whatever form with their identities and locations if any.

    “Make appropriate recommendations for review of any rules, procedures, processes to prevent re-occurrence and sanctions for identified erring officials.

    “Make other recommendations that will strengthen the system of recognition, accreditations and quality assurance of degrees in Nigeria.

    “Examine the extant rules, procedures and processes for granting of provisional licences to new universities by the NUC.”

    The Federal Government last week announced the suspension of accreditation of degree certificates from Benin Republic and Togo.

    The decision followed an investigative report titled: “How Daily Nigerian reporter bagged Cotonou varsity degree in six weeks.”

  • Fed Govt inaugurates inter-ministerial committee on allegations of degree racketeering

    Fed Govt inaugurates inter-ministerial committee on allegations of degree racketeering

    The Federal Government has inaugurated an inter-ministerial committee to examine the veracity of allegations of degrees racketeering within foreign and local private universities in Nigeria.

    Inaugurating the committee in Abuja yesterday, the Minister of Education, Prof. Tahir Mamman, mandated the committee to review the role of Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs) or its officials in facilitating the recognition and procurement of fake certificates in question.

    The committee is chaired by the Chairman, Board of Trustees, Committee of Vice Chancellors of Nigerian Universities (CVCNU), Prof. Jibrila Amin.

    Other members of the committee are Chris Maiyaki, Acting Executive Secretary, National Universities Commission (NUC), Amb. Lazarus Ikpasaba from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Mr Abel Olanrewaju from the Office of the National Security Adviser

    Others are Omeh Nwokpoku from the Office of the National Security Adviser, Amina Lugga from the Federal Ministry of Youths, and Mrs Doom Iyortyom from the Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board (JAMB).

    The committee had, however been mandated to complete the investigation within eight weeks from the date of inauguration.

    The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that in December 2023, an investigative journalist with the Daily Nigerian Newspaper released a publication on fake degree certificates from Benin Republic and Togo.

    The minister, while reading the terms of reference, urged the committee to review existing policies and procedures related to accreditation and certification to identify weaknesses contributing to the issue.

    Read Also: Fake degrees: Fed govt orders probe of private universities in Nigeria

    ”The committee must also examine the rules, procedures and processes for recognition and accreditation of foreign universities and programmes by the Federal Ministry of Education. It will also establish if unapproved foreign institutions (Degree Mills) exist or not in Nigeria in whatever form, with their identities and locations if any.

    “The committee will make appropriate recommendations for review of any rules, procedures, and processes to prevent re-occurrence and sanctions for identified erring officials”.

    It will further “make other recommendations that will strengthen the system of recognitions, accreditations and quality assurance of degrees in Nigeria”.

    According to the terms, the members should examine the extant rules, procedures and processes for granting of provisional licences to new universities by the National Universities Commission (NUC).

    Mamman charged the committee to be deliberate about their assignment and deliver within the period.

    Prof. Amin assured the Federal Government and Nigerians of a good job within the stipulated time.

  • On the Cotonou degree certificate

    On the Cotonou degree certificate

    • By Zayyad I. Muhammad

    Sir: The excellent investigative report by the Daily Nigerian and the subsequent suspension of accreditation of degree certificates from Beninois and Togolese universities by the federal government of Nigeria have put a dent on every certificate obtained from institutions in these West African countries as indeed other African countries..

    The urge for these certificates among young Nigerians is simply the price we pay for our inclination towards easy solutions and allowing personal interests to override the national image.

    One interesting aspect of the Cotonou ‘easy’ certificates is that they predominantly attract young people from Nigeria’s ‘semi-middle’ class and lazy individuals from wealthy families. For them, obtaining a bachelor’s degree often involves pursuing studies at Benin or Togo universities, which admit anyone able to pay for the desired degree.

    Another unfortunate aspect is that someone who obtains a bachelor’s degree in less than two months can easily secure a job in a sector involving life and death, make critical decisions in vital areas of Nigerian public life, or lead a group of competent individuals who have diligently earned their certificates. We hope there are no doctors, pharmacists, engineers, etc., practicing in Nigeria who obtained their certificates through ‘crooked ways’ from Benin, Togo, etc. It is a challenge for Nigeria’s professional and regulatory bodies.

    Fake certificates pose a serious threat to the nation. In more developed countries, this issue would be treated as a ‘war’ against the country.

    However, Nigeria shouldn’t throw away the baby with the bathwater; there are individuals who have genuinely obtained certificates from reputable institutions in these African countries. Nigeria should address the issue from both ends—domestically and with these countries. Domestically, authorities need to address why our young people are opting for universities abroad. The answer lies in our universities being plagued with incessant strikes, some lecturers being unnecessarily sadistic, and at times, foreign certificates being undeservedly celebrated.

    Secondly, serene learning environments are attractive; however, some of Nigeria’s university lecture classrooms and theatres are overcrowded and in poor condition. In contrast, foreign universities provide beautiful and appealing learning spaces. Additionally, it raises questions about why graduating from a private university in Nigeria is often easier than from a public university, especially when many lecturers at private universities are the same individuals teaching at public universities.

    Read Also: APC pegs Edo guber nomination fee at N50m, holds primary Feb. 17

    To address the issue at source, Nigeria should leverage its diplomatic influence in West Africa, compelling these nations to mandate that private universities adhere to established standards and penalize offenders. Those implicated should face legal consequences, as certifying unqualified individuals is akin to waging a war on Nigeria’s human resources development and socio-economic sectors.

    Fake degrees certificates from Benin and Togo involve two actors: the institutions in those countries and their collaborators in Nigeria. Moreover, fake degrees are not confined to Benin and Togo; they are a global issue. According to a report by the Academic Credentials Evaluation Institute, Inc. (ACEI Global), based in Los Angeles, CA, USA, on December 2, 2023, Israeli police arrested 40 Israeli doctors, medical interns, and pharmacists who had presented false credentials to Israel’s Health Ministry. These individuals were suspected to have purchased medical and pharmacy degrees from three universities in Armenia, despite never completing studies at those institutions—St. Tereza Medical University, Haybusak University, and Mkhtiar Gosh Armenian-Russian International University. The report also highlights controversies surrounding Punjab Technical University (PTU), India, including the issuance of fake degrees, leading to the arrest of four administrators for aiding failed students in passing.

    If someone has genuinely obtained their degree from Benin or Togo, the current controversy has cast a shadow over it, and it may take some time to restore its credibility.

    •Zayyad I. Muhammad,

    Abuja.

  • Ajimobi’s wife gets honorary doctorate degree

    Ajimobi’s wife gets honorary doctorate degree

    •Governor, wife offer scholarships to indigent students

    Oyo State Governor Abiola Ajimobi, and his wife, Florence, last Friday offered scholarship to indigent students of Ajayi Crowther University at Oyo town, where the governor’s wife got an honorary Doctor of Science in Public Administration.

    The Alaafin of Oyo, Oba Lamidi Adeyemi and a philanthropist, Chief Tunde Afolabi, were also honoured with doctorates.

    The occasion was the university’s ninth convocation ceremony, where first and postgraduate degrees were awarded.

    The governor announced the scholarship in his remarks at the event, while his wife earlier, in her acceptance speech, promised to sponsor 10 students as part of her contributions to the education of youths.

    Responding to an appeal by the Vice Chancellor, Prof. Dapo Asaju, Mrs Ajimobi also promised to buy a generator for the Information Communication Technology centre she recently donated to the university.

    “I want to thank the governing council of this university for the honour done to me. I stand here this afternoon with a promise to continue to engage in activities that will advance the course of education.

    “Ajayi Crowther University has done well as it has turned out brilliant graduates who are making waves all over the world. This is the best period to renew my pledge and commitment to the service of humanity as well as service to the less privileged.

    “I will install a generator to provide power to the ICT centre I donated to this university few months ago. In addition to this, I will give scholarships to 10 girls to study Business Administration from next session, as part of my contributions to the education of the girl-child.”

    The governor pledged to also sponsor the education of undisclosed number of students.

    He urged parents, institutions and public-spirited individuals to assist the government to fund education.

    Given the parlous state of the economy, Ajimobi said, it was no longer realistic to expect the government to solely fund education because of many competing demands.

    He said: “The story of Ajayi Crowther University has confirmed that well-meaning Nigerians can come together and promote a noble cause that will have multiple advantageous effects on the society.

    “We are today empowering our younger ones to be productive to the nation by unleashing the new graduands to make better changes for our country.

    “This is an institution that does not take subvention from anybody; yet, it is producing quality products yearly. I can tell you that Ajayi Crowther University is an epitome of quality.

    “This is a clarion call to parents, guardians and the rest of the society that we should not leave the education of our children to government alone. Everybody must participate to bring back the glory of the yesteryears in education.”

    The vice chancellor advised the graduating students to be good ambassadors of the university.

  • Nigerian counts gains of online degree

    Oluchi Anih was among the inaugural 2016 cohort of the Roehampton, London Online programmes that graduated recently.

    The Abuja-based banker joined the campus-based students and other online graduates across the world for the graduation at the university’s Royal Festival Hall in London.

    Oluchi is one of the first to earn the university’s MSc in Information Systems Management, which she said is already adding value to her career.

    “Having worked in the financial sector for nine years, I consider the Nigerian banking industry to be one of the most technologically driven sectors in the country. I chose Roehampton’s online programme because I wanted to develop my managerial competencies and be able to make strategic decisions that would support my organisation through using innovative technology. Since beginning my degree, I have been promoted, and recently, I received a commendation from management. so my efforts have paid off more than I could have imagined,” said Oluchi, who attended the graduation with her family.

    Many graduates from more than 150 countries also earned MBA and MSc in Project Management from the university’s online programmes.

    Vice-Chancellor of the institution, Prof Paul O’Prey, said the university is opening up access to quality education through the online programmes.

    “The University of Roehampton, through our colleges, has a long tradition of providing higher education, lasting 175 years. We are committed to expanding access to education, ensuring that all of our students become the kind of graduate employers value. We introduced online masters programmes in 2012, to provide the opportunity to gain a Roehampton degree to a wider range of students from across the world. We are delighted to see so many of our online students graduate this year,” he said.

    Through these programmes, students gain the critical thinking skills and practical knowledge they need to expand their expertise and advance their careers.

    Roehampton Online offers a portfolio of online masters degrees in areas of study, including business and management, psychology, public administration, public health, education and theology.

  • Tinubu bags Danfodiyo University Honourary doctorate degree

    Tinubu bags Danfodiyo University Honourary doctorate degree

  • Eleven-year medical degree misadventure

    SIR: At the matriculation and inauguration of the University of Medical Science, Ondo, it was reported that the Executive Secretary of the National Universities Commission, Professor Okojie stated that “… students to spend four years studying basic sciences after which they would proceed to medical school to spend another seven years.”

    One error in this policy is that in the present medical curriculum, medical students spend three years in RELEVANT basic sciences before the clinical studies.  One year at 100 level for pure sciences, two years of relevant sciences namely: Anatomy, Physiology, Biochemistry, and in some cases, also Pharmacology. If the candidate entered by Direct Entry and did Higher School Certificate, he/she spends two years of Physics, Chemistry Zoology and Botany (or Biology) at advanced level before entering the university for the initial two years of Anatomy, Physiology, Biochemistry and Pharmacology before proceeding to study clinical work.

    It is superfluous to study science subjects to make him a rocket or space scientist.

    Also, from the address one can infer that one of the reasons adduced for this was “…in order to enable the student to mature psychologically for the profession.”

    The youngest age one enters the university for any course of study is 18 years.  If one spends seven years studying Medicine, one will graduate at the age of 25 years.  Is a 25-year-old boy or girl not “psychologically mature”?  Don’t some countries have Head of States at around that age?  Even if we have a precocious student that enters the university at the age of 16, (which is not very common) he/she will graduate at the age of 23 years.  Is this not mature enough?  Don’t people marry successfully at the age of 23?  If one is not mature enough at this age one can never mature even if one is as old as Methuselah!

    I think the reason behind all these beating around the bush and groping in the darkness is because we are looking for a way of improving on our health delivery system which is sub-standard when compared with other countries.  I agree totally with this assertion, but not with the solution proffered.  If not, why are Nigerians going to India and Germany etc for medical treatment?  Yet we have professors in Nigeria in every medical discipline?

    If we can go back memory lane, some years ago, the late Professor Adeoye Lambo suggested that the years of study of medicine in the universities should be reduced to four years instead of what we have at present.  The basic fact is that the number of years a candidate spends in the medical school does not necessarily make one a good doctor.  The medical curriculum as designed at present produces the best and optimum requirement for producing good doctors.  One year at the university 100 level where they study basic sciences, two years of RELEVANT basic sciences, then three years of clinical studies which include the study of all clinical disciplines including PSYCHIATRY;  one year of Housemanship and one year of National Youth Service, before being allowed to practice medicine – a total of eight years.

    Some scientific studies abroad have shown that the performance of a doctor (whether good or bad, knowledgeable or not, dedicated or not) bears little relevance to the performance in the medical school.  The reason is that about 90% of the course is more theoretical than clinical.  And the clinical component depends on the number of patients available in the institution, number of students in the group, the enthusiasm of the students themselves to the clinical postings, and the diligence of the teachers in clinical teachings.

    There are many medical students who distinguished themselves in the medical school but just turned out to be “average” doctors and yet there are many “average” medical students who turned out to be excellent doctors after graduation.

    Some studies have also shown that the performance of a doctor, however, bears great relevance to the performance during the years of residency training programme.  This is because the residency training programme is about 90% clinical and 10 % theory.  The years of residency training programme can be four years to about seven years post NYSC depending on the specialty.  No doctor now stops after NYSC. Practically all go into a residency training programme after NYSC, whether it is General Practice or Surgery. So, if improvement is needed in our medical education, the focus and emphasis should be on the residency training programme and not on the number of years to spend in the medical school.

    However if this 11-year-medical school programme consists of seven years of university training and four years of specialty (residency) programme, then it can be justified.  But the snag is that first medical degree is awarded by a university Senate, and the postgraduate (fellowship) award is not an award by the university Senate but an award by a professional body that constitutes a College and has no connection with any university.

    • Oluwole G. Ajao

    Professor of Surgery (Rtd)

    College of Medicine, and University College Hospital, Ibadan.

  • College gets degree status

    Authorities of the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria have approved the running of Bachelor of Education degree programme at the Kaduna State College of Education, Gidan Waya.

    Acting Provost of the College, Mallam Lawal Abdullahi Tukur, made this known during the 2013/2014 matriculation.

    The courses to be run, he said, included English, Christian Religious Studies, Islamic Studies, Geography and Social Studies.Others were Educational Administration and Planning, Guidance and Counselling, Economics, Agricultural Education and Home Economics.

    He said lectures for all approved courses will begin during the 2014/2015 academic session.

    Congratulating the new students, he urged them to make the best use of the opportunity by putting in their efforts to achieve their goals.

    The Provost warned that the college had zero tolerance for examination malpractice, adding that the punishment was outright expulsion and subsequent prosecution.

    He commended the State Government under Dr Mukktar Ramalan Yero for granting approval for the recruitment of staff, urging the Governor to expedite action on the construction of the network of roads within the permanent site of the College.

  • ‘Make Masters degree benchmark for college teachers’

    The Provost, Kogi State College of Education, Ankpa Prof. Isa Ochepa has advocated a Masters Degree qualification as minimum entry point for its lecturers.

    He spoke during the 26th-29th combined convocation of the college.

    However, he, said it would be better for a larger percentage of teachers in a college to have the PhD, which is the minimum benchmark for teaching in the university.

    He said: “To strengthen our academic system, we have to encourage our staff to pursue further studies. Personally, it is my conviction that an academic environment of this nature should be dominated by Ph.D holders. It is through such that we will be able to provide the quality of instructions expected of us.

    “Through that, we can also embark on meaningful research which will promote the dynamism of the academic system. That is why I insisted and still insist that Masters degree should be the minimum qualification for appointment into the college. As for those already in the system, I have challenged everyone to sit up in this regard.”

    Ochepa, who also chairs the Forum of Provosts, called on the Kogi State government to help the institution address the menace of erosion and provide funds for accreditation of its courses.

    In his address, Governor Idris Wada warned residents not to encroach on land belonging to tertiary institutions across the state.  He warned that the government would demolish any structure built on such land without paying compensation.

    He urged management of the institution to always make results available to students as soon as they graduate, to avoid certificate forgery.