Tag: EFCC

  • EFCC to arraign Babalakin, others tomorrow

    EFCC to arraign Babalakin, others tomorrow

    The embattled chairman of Bi-courtney Limited, Chief Olawale Babalakin may be arraigned before a Lagos High Court in Ikeja tomorrow by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) over alleged money laundering for former Governor of Delta State, Chief James Ibori.

    He, along with four others are to face a 27-count charge of money laundering involving about N3.4billion before Justic Adeniyi Onigbanjo, according to EFCC sources.

    The EFCC, had last week filed the charges, but was silent on when they would be arraigned.

    Those named with Babalakin are Alex Okoh, Stabilini Visioni Limited, his company, Bi-courtney Limited and Remix Nigeria Limited.

    The charges are, that Babalakin allegedly conferred benefits with the former Delta State governor, Chief James Ibori “to wit N1,356,600.00 on contract awarded to Stabilini Visioni Limited by transferring the sum through a third party to Erin Aviation account in Mauritius for the procurement of an aircraft

    It also accused the five suspects of siphoning $11.3million abroad for Ibori through Erin Aviation Account in Mauritius.

    The charge sheet, dated November 21, was filed by A.M. Yusuf Esq., on behalf of the EFCC and the Attorney-General of the Federation.

     

  • N1.4b subsidy scam: EFCC  insists suspects must face trial

    N1.4b subsidy scam: EFCC insists suspects must face trial

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) yesterday told a Federal Capital Territory High Court that it has enough evidence to put three suspects on trial for alleged N1.4billion fuel subsidy scam.

    The suspects are Helyn Aninye, Chizobam Ben-Okafor and Pon-Specialized Services Limited.

    They are being tried before Justice Olusumbo Goodluck for offences bordering on forgery and obtaining money under false pretence.

    A statement by the Head of Media and Publicity of the EFCC, Mr. Wilson Uwujaren said: “The suspects were to have been docked on an 18-count criminal charge on November 26 but their pleas could not be taken as their counsel, Olisa Agbakoba (SAN) opposed their arraignment on the grounds that the proof of evidence did not disclose a prima facie case against his clients.

    “My lord, assuming there are offences to be disclosed, they have not in any way been linked to the applicants, and these links must have a prima facie elements to the applicants.”

    “He further said that in a case of forgery, it is required to be proved in a particular way and that no maker of the alleged forged document had been called or identified.

    “But Steve Odiase, counsel to EFCC in his application for leave to prefer criminal charge against the accused persons under Section 185 (b) of the Criminal Procedure Code, noted that the proof of evidence speaks for itself.

    “He stated that the prosecution has formulated three issues for determination by the court in granting the application which include whether the proof of evidence discloses an offence known to law and whether there is a linking of the charge to the applicants.

    “My lord, the statement of one (name withheld) of Quality Marine Services limited is enough link to the accused persons.

    “Besides, it has been established that in a case of forgery the accused must not be the maker of the said document before being liable.”

    “The judge who advised counsel not to jump the gun by addressing issues in the substantive case, adjourned to February 21, 2013 for ruling on both applications.

    “The accused persons were said to have on or about the 3rd day of March, 2011 at Abuja within the Jurisdiction of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja with intent to defraud, conspired to obtain N1.413, 507,951.50 under false pretence from the Federal Government of Nigeria as subsidy for the importation Premium Motor Spirit under the Petroleum Support Fund”.

    “The offence according to the charge sheet was contrary to Section 8(a) and punishable under Section 1 (3) of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Related Offences Act. 2006.”

     

  • EFCC re-arraigns Ali’s son for N4.4b subsidy scam

    EFCC re-arraigns Ali’s son for N4.4b subsidy scam

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) yesterday re-arraigned Mamman Nasir Ali, the son of former Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Chairman, Ahmadu Ali, and three others before a Lagos High Court, Ikeja for alleged N4.4 billion fuel subsidy fraud.

    They were re-arraigned before Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo on a 13-count charge of conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretence, forgery and use of false documents.

    One of the defendants, Abdulazeez Afeez, is said to be at large.

    Those arraigned with the younger Ali yesterday included Christian Taylor, Oluwaseun Ogunbambo and Nasaman Oil Services.

    The defendants pleaded not guilty to the 13-count charge.

    Justice Onigbanjo ordered that Ali and Taylor should continue to enjoy the N20 million bail granted them on July 26, when they were first arraigned.

    The EFCC had initially arraigned Ali with Christian Taylor and Nasaman Oil Services on July 26 on a 13-count charge for an alleged N2.2 billion fuel subsidy fraud.

    It later amended the charge to re-arraign the defendants.

    In the amended 13-count charge, the EFCC alleged that the defendants were involved in fuel subsidy fraud to the tune of about N4.4 billion.

    The commission alleged that the defendants conspired to obtain the money from the Federal Government for the purported importation of 30.5million litres of Premium Motor Spirits (PMS).

    It said the alleged offences are punishable under Section 1(3) of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act of 2006.

    Justice Onigbanjo fixed tomorrow for ruling on the bail application filed by Ogunbambo’s counsel, Adebayo Adenipekun (SAN).

     

  • EFCC: Same old story

    EFCC: Same old story

    Are you a businessman or woman with substantial dealings with the Federal Government, or a politician fiercely opposed to the sitting government at the centre and eyeing a top position in Abuja? If you are, then take heed of this warning, it is in your own interest; don’t do or say anything that could make the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) come after you, because that could spell danger for you as the commission appears poised once again to go after the supposed enemies of their paymaster, the Presidency.

    Why am I saying this?

    Have you not been following the travail of Lawyer/Businessman Dr Wale Babalakin (SAN), the billionaire with connections in high places, who wines and dines with the high and mighty; the businessman who sits atop an emerging conglomerate that includes Bi-Courtney Highway Services, the firm that won the concession agreement to fund, build and manage Lagos/Ibadan Expressway for 25 years and recoup his money (of course plus profit) within that period, but has done little or nothing on the road almost four years after; the owner of the rebuilt terminal (MM2) at the Murtala Mohammed International Airport, Ikeja?

    Yes, the same man who has been battling the Federal Government to stop the construction of another domestic terminal at MMIA, which he claims contravenes the terms of the agreement with Bi-Courtney Aviation Services, leading to the construction of MM2. Recall that the Federal Government recently revoked that concession on the Lagos /Ibadan Road citing non-performance on the part of Bi-Courtney Highway Services? Now the man is in trouble, real trouble, multi-billion naira trouble, courtesy EFCC.

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission has brought charges of money laundering against Babalakin and four others totaling N3.4billion. The 25-count charge were slammed on the accused barely 48 hours after the revocation of the concession agreement raising concern that the Federal Government could be using the EFCC to prosecute a political agenda of witch hunting and vendetta against its opponent. It also raises doubts about the sincerity and impartiality of the commission in its drive to rid Nigeria of corruption.

    Make no mistake about it, this is not a defense of Babalakin or a call on EFCC to go soft on the anti corruption crusade, but then it must be seen to be working devoid of government influence for it to continue to enjoy the support and confidence of all Nigerians, including the accused.

    Ordinarily, matters like this should not raise dust anywhere other than in the camp of those involved, but the timing of EFCC’s move against the accused when the man is involved in a contractual dispute with the government definitely points at more than ulterior motives on the part of the commission. Did this money laundering issue come up just yesterday? Why immediately after the man lost his contract for the Lagos/Ibadan Expressway reconstruction? Couldn’t EFCC have waited for this contractual problem between Babalakin/Bi-Courtney and the Federal Government to be resolved or even go down before bringing these corruption charges against him? All the commission needed to do if it was convinced it has a strong case against Babalakin and others, was to put them under watch while their contractual dispute with the government lasted and move in immediately. No matter the merit of their case against the man, the timing of their action has tainted the motive behind it and the public is likely to view it as such, whether the man is freed or convicted if and when the matter gets to court.

    Pursuit of vendetta by our leaders against political opponents in particular has been part of our politics for long. But this was raised to its peak by former President Olusegun Obasanjo, who deployed every tool, trick and power at his command to fight his political opponents both real and imagined. The Nigeria Police used to be the willing tool for this, but since everything is a matter of cash to our policemen as they are always on the side of the highest bidder, the government, it seems needed a super agency with enough teeth and muscle and which enjoys public support and confidence to fight its dirty war against its opponents. I am not saying this was why the EFCC was created but over the years, especially under Obasanjo, the agency was used effectively to fight opponents of that presidency.

    Recall the K-Leg story of then candidate Rotimi Amaechi who was running for the governorship seat of Rivers State in 2007 on the platform of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP)? He was stopped by Obasanjo and his clique using the EFCC to cook up and manufacture evidence of corruption against him. Eventually nothing was established against the man, but Obasanjo had his way as he was dropped as PDP’s candidate in the election. I am sure you know the rest of the story. Amaechi is today the governor of Rivers State.

    The story of the failed presidential ambition of a former Governor of Rivers State, Dr. Peter Odili and the role played by Obasanjo’s EFCC in his botched attempt to clinch the presidential ticket of the PDP in 2007 is known to not just a few. There were many people like that who were politicians in PDP and who at one time or another were close to Obasanjo but fell apart with the former president when their interests collided and the man punished them using EFCC.

    Some opposition politicians also suffered similar fate, but just as this was going on, a whole lot of Obasanjo’s friends politicians and businessmen alike accused of one form of corruption or another were left untouched. The EFCC pretended not to see them. They were untouchable. You still remember the story of Chief Olabode George, the erstwhile deputy National Chairman of PDP, who wielded so much power and influence under Obasanjo that he became untouchable. Until he fell out of favour with Obasanjo the EFCC defended him stoutly against accusations of corruption during his tenure as chairman of Nigerian Ports, but once he became an “enemy” of the Villa, the EFCC story changed and Bode George went to jail.

    I am not sure to what extent this trend continued under President Umaru Yar’Adua but definitely it wasn’t as rampant as it was under Obasanjo if it did happen. But then who knows, maybe illness and eventual death robbed us of knowing what kind of leader Yar’Adua would have been and how he would have deployed the EFCC under his watch. But this move against Babalakin by EFCC could eventually lead us into a clearer picture of what the anti-graft agency would look like under a Jonathan presidency. His EFCC is beginning to bear its fangs now and ready to bite. Good. But how far he can go, remain to be seen, especially considering the fact that he might need to bite some of the fingers that put him in the Presidential Villa. But if he has to bite and even cut off some of those fingers in the fight against corruption Nigerians won’t mind, but then he shouldn’t do it selectively; nobody should be untouchable. No sacred cow.

    The untouchables have been the pillars of successive administrations in this country and are somehow linked to this corruption we are all talking about. Until last week, Dr Wale Babalakin could rightly be classified as one of them, but whether he remains so after Jonathan’s EFCC onslaught or if indeed the onslaught can stand the stern test of the judiciary remain to be seen. But as things stand now, the man and his co-accused are innocent until found guilty by competent authorities.

    The lesson for EFCC here is that if it doesn’t assert its independence and be seen to be doing so by the public, it risks the erosion of its fragile credibility with the public and could easily go the way of the Nigeria Police. It should not allow itself to be used by anybody or be seen to be used by anybody, especially the government. It is about time it focuses attention on the government especially those ministers perceived to be corrupt to prove its independence. Let charity begin at home.

    To Babalakin and his co-businessmen/politicians, I don’t envy them. Mixing business with politics is tough and navigating that dangerous terrain requires tact and delicate balancing in order not to breach any unwritten rules. My advice to them is to stick with the international best practices in business relations especially with government and be fair and even handed/minded in their dealings with politicians. They could be dangerous.

     

  • Subsidy scam: EFCC re-arraigns ex-PDP chairman, Ahmadu Ali’s son

    Subsidy scam: EFCC re-arraigns ex-PDP chairman, Ahmadu Ali’s son

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) on Monday re-arraigned Mamman Nasir Ali, the son of former Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Chairman, Ahmadu Ali, and three others before a Lagos High Court, Ikeja for alleged N4.4 billion fuel subsidy fraud.
    They were re-arraigned before Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo on a 13-count charge of conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretence, forgery and for the use of false documents.

    One of the defendants, Abdulazeez Afeez is said to be at large.

    Those arraigned alongside Mamman Nasir Ali on Monday included Christian Taylor, Oluwaseun Ogunbambo and Nasaman Oil Services.

    When charges were read, the defendants pleaded not guilty to the 13 count charge against them.

    The trial judge, Justice Onigbanjo ordered that Ali and Taylor should continue to enjoy the N20 million bail earlier granted to each of them on July 26, 2012 when they were first arraigned.

    The EFCC had initially arraigned Ali alongside Christian Taylor and Nasaman Oil Services on July 26, 2012 on a 13 count charge for an alleged N2.2 billion fuel subsidy fraud.

    It later amended the charge in order to re-arraign the defendants.

    In the amended 13 count charge, the EFCC alleged that the defendants were involved in fuel subsidy fraud to the tune of about N4.4 billion.

    The commission alleged that the defendants had conspired to obtain the money from the Federal Government for the purported importation of 30.5million litres of Premium Motor Spirits (PMS).

    It said that the alleged offences contravened and punishable under sections 1(3) of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act of 2006.

    The trial judge, Justice Onigbanjo, has however fixed November 28, 2012 for ruling on the bail application filed by Ogunbambo’s counsel, Mr Adebayo Adenipekun (SAN).

  • EFCC, NIBSS, others to fight e-fraud

    The Nigerian Electronic Fraud Forum (NeFF) is partnering with the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Nigerian Inter-Bank Settlement System (NIBBS), among others, to check electronic payment frauds and related offences.

    NeFF’s Chairman Mr Emmanuel Obaigbona, told The Nation that the development was borne out of the need to boost confidence in the electronic payment system.

    He said: “We are trying to bring together the tradition of electronic payment system in Nigeria. We are seriously working with the EFFC, NIBBS, CBN, owners of switches, and industrial workers on the issue of checking electronic payment frauds. We are working on how to educate the law enforcement agents, and the judiciary on what e-frauds is all about.“

    According to him, the body has created a lot of awareness on fraud issues to enlighten people on the causes of e-payment frauds.

    “We have tried to let people know some of the likely fraudulent activities, arising from the use of electronic payment channels such as Automated Teller Machines (ATMs), Point of Sale (PoS) terminals, mobile phones, among others. Also, we have taught them how to mitigate such risks to stimulate the growth of the financial system,” he added.

    Obaigbona said the relevant stakeholders were being carried along to check fraud in e-payment transactions.

    He said the anti-fraud committee set up by the CBN to tackle e-payment frauds has been working to proffer solutions to the problems, adding that the committee has been consistent with its mandates to fight e-payment frauds among the stakeholders in the nation’s financial chains.  580

    Similarly, an official of the Shared Services Office, Governor’s Department, Mr Chidi Umeano, said the committee, which has been upscaled to e-payment fraud forum has, as members, managing directors of the banks, and the electronic payment card companies, such as MasterCard, Visacard among others.

    He said the forum holds meetings regularly to discuss and fine- tune plans on how to solve problems relating to e-payment frauds in the industry.

    “There has been growing concern on the part of the forum to address the issue of frauds relating to electronic payment transactions in Nigeria. The forum hopes to provide solutions to the problems”, he said.

  • ‘Assets seizure ’ll check money laundering’

    The Managing Director, DataPro, Abimbola Adeseyoju, has called for the implementation of the asset seizure, confiscation and forfeiture policy of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to check money laundering.

    Speaking at the DataPro Inaugural Lectures in Lagos, he said the anti-money laundering/combating the financial terrorism (AML/CFT) initiative was instituted by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to ensure that financial crime perpetrators are punished to ensure they do not benefit from their crimes.

    He advised that an acceptable framework that tallies with ‘Recommendations Four of the Financial Action Task Force 2012 Principles’, which is on asset seizure, confiscation and forfeiture be implemented as one of the deterrents to money laundering and terrorists financing.

    He said the government should ensure that competent authorities have powers to freeze or seize laundered property or proceeds including instrumentalities used or intended to be used for money laundering or terrorism financing.

    Besides, he said there is also need to allow such proceeds to be confiscated without requiring criminal prosecution otherwise called a Non conviction based confiscation approach.

    According to him, it is no longer required for an offender to demonstrate the legal ownership of the property before it is confiscated. For him, once the offender’s known source of income cannot provide the basis for such property, it should be enough room for confiscation and conviction.

    He said DataPro is committed to supporting banks, regulators and other stakeholders in fighting money laundering in the country, adding that the firm was established to supply information and data on individuals, entities, agencies central authorities and institutions in the country to the relevant authorities.

    The firm had also partnered with Dun & Bradstreet International to offer services to banks, manufacturers and other conglomerates around the world.

    Meanwhile, the apex bank has started full implementation of its anti-money laundering/combating the financial terrorism (AML/CFT) risk-based supervision framework, it issued in 2011.

    The CBN said the measure was further supported by the importance the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) attached to the risk-based approach to AML/CFT supervision in its revised recommendations issued last February.

  • Group petitions  EFCC, ICPC on  ‘scam’ in Ondo

    Group petitions EFCC, ICPC on ‘scam’ in Ondo

    A group, the Ondo Elites for Good Governance (OEGG), has petitioned the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) and the Special Anti-Fraud Unit (SAFU) on the alleged misappropriation of funds by some top government officials in the state.

    In the petition signed by its Chairman, Dr. Peter Ogunferanmi, OEGG said it is not out to witch-hunt anybody, but to expose the corrupt activities of some political office holders.

    It said an influential government official and some commissioners were linked with financial misappropriation in eight ministries.

    It was learnt that the top government official always pretends to be a saint before the governor.

    The group said the fraud, which allegedly runs into several billions of naira, was uncovered with the help of some civil servants, commissioners and government officials.

    OEGG said: “In our petition, we attached documents to show that we are not out to malign anybody’s image and are not paid agents of anybody. Ours is to expose corrupt officers, who may want to ruin the state’s economy at the expense of the people.

    “Some of our members have been appointed to monitor the petitions at the three commissions to prevent government agents from playing any fast game.

    “We are ready to give more evidence to substantiate our claims. The evidences attached to the petitions were not cooked-up. Operatives of the anti-graft agencies can cross-check the facts at the places stated in the petition.”

    Early this year, some top government officials in the state were invited for interrogation by the EFCC following an alleged financial scam.

    It was learnt that the investigation is still on-going.

  • EFCC arraigns oil marketer for N963m ‘fraud’

    Tukur’s trial now Dec 13 

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) yesterday arraigned another oil marketer, Rowaye Jubril, at a Lagos High Court, Ikeja, for alleged N963.7 million fuel subsidy fraud.

    Jubril was arraigned with his company, Brila Energy Limited, on a 13-count charge of obtaining money by false pretence and forgery.

    EFCC’s counsel Seidu Atteh told the court that the defendants between October 2010 and May, last year in Lagos fraudulently obtained N963.7 million from the Federal Government.

    Atteh alleged that the defendants obtained the money from the Petroleum Support Fund under the pretence of importation of 17.3million litres of Premium Motor Spirit (PMS).

    The EFCC also alleged that the defendants forged documents, including certificates of cargo transfer, origin and cargo manifest.

    The prosection said their alleged offences contravened Section 1(3) of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act of 2006.

    He said their offences also contravened sections 467 and 468 of the Criminal Code Laws of Lagos State (2003).

    Jubril pleaded not guilty to the charges.

    The defence counsel, M.T. Giwa, pleaded that his client be granted bail.

    He said the defendant has no criminal record and is a first time offender.

    Justice Lateefa Okunnu admitted him to bail on N75 million with two sureties.

    Justice Okunnu said the sureties must be employed and deposed to an affidavit of means.

    She ordered that one of the sureties must own a property in Lagos State and the other a director in a public or private quoted company in Nigeria.

    Justice Okunnu said the sureties must produce three years tax clearance to be verified by an EFCC officer.

    The judge ordered that the defendant must not travel without the court’s permission.

    She ordered him to deposit his passport and other travelling documents with the court’s chief registrar.

    The judge also directed Jubril to report monthly to the EFCC office throughout the trial.

    She adjourned the matter till January 23.

    In another development, the trial of Mahmud Tukur and three others accused of N1.8 billion fuel subsidy fraud was adjourned till December 13 by Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo.

    Tukur is on trial with Abdullahi Alao, Ochonogor Alex and Eternal Oil and Gas Plc.

    At the hearing yesterday, the defence counsel, Wole Olanipekun (SAN) and Taiwo Osipitan (SAN), said their clients were discussing with the EFCC over the charges preferred against them.

    Olanipekun said: ”We have studied the processes filed by the prosecution against our clients.

    “As senior counsel, we owe it as a duty to our clients to discuss with the prosecution regarding the charges.

    “We are therefore asking the court to give us more time to discuss so that the matter can be speedily resolved.”

    EFCC counsel Rotimi Jacobs (SAN) did not oppose the request for an adjournment.

    Jacobs confirmed that talks were going on between the parties, adding that there was no need to oppose the adjournment.

     

  • Subsidy fraud: ‘Tukur, Alao sons discussing with EFCC’

    Subsidy fraud: ‘Tukur, Alao sons discussing with EFCC’

    Two oil marketers, Mahmud Tukur and Abdullahi Alao on Tuesday informed the Lagos High Court, Ikeja, that they were in discussion with the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, regarding the charges preferred against them.

    The News Agency of Nigeria reports that Tukur and Alao were charged to court for an alleged N1.8 billion fuel subsidy fraud.

    The defendants are sons of Alhaji Bamanga Tukur, the National Chairman of the Peoples Democratic Party and prominent businessman, Alhaji Abdulazeez Arisekola-Alao, respectively.

    They were arraigned alongside Ochonogor Alex and Eternal Oil and Gas Plc before Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo of a Lagos High Court.

    The defendants had pleaded not guilty and were each granted bail in the sum of N20 million.

    At the resumed proceedings on Tuesday, the defence counsel, Chief Wole Olanipekun and Prof. Taiwo Osipitan (both Senior Advocates of Nigeria), hinted the court of the talks between the parties.

    Olanipekun said:”We have studied the processes filed by the prosecution.

    “We as senior counsel, owe it as a duty to our clients to enter into discussion with the prosecution regarding the charge.

    “That is why we did not challenge the charge when it was filed.

    “We are, therefore, asking the court to give us more time to engage in this discussion, so that the matter can be speedily resolved.”

    EFCC counsel, Mr. Rotimi Jacobs (SAN) also confirmed that both parties were talking.

    The judge acceded to their request and adjourned the matter to December 15 for mention.