Tag: Emefiele

  • Witness: how Emefiele withdrew $6.23m from CBN with forged documents

    Witness: how Emefiele withdrew $6.23m from CBN with forged documents

    The 11th prosecution witness (PW11), Bashirudden Muhammed Maishanu, yesterday told the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Abuja how $6.23 million was allegedly withdrawn from the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) using forged documents during Godwin Emefiele’s tenure.

    Testifying before Justice Hamza Muazu, Maishanu, an Assistant Director at the CBN, said the cash was withdrawn from the Garki branch of the apex bank on February 8, 2023, purportedly to fund election observers and logistics.

    Led in evidence by the prosecution counsel and Director of Public Prosecution, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), the witness said he became acquainted with Emefiele in 2015 through one Eric, identified as the former governor’s personal assistant.

    Maishanu told the court that in early January 2023, he was approached by one Alhaji Ahmed, who claimed to be working with a special committee in the Office of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF).

    Ahmed, he said, informed him that they were processing a payment from the CBN based on presidential approval.

    “I demanded his identification and also asked him to call Mr Eric to confirm his claim.

    “When Mr Eric confirmed knowing him, Ahmed explained that once presidential approval was obtained, payment would be processed through the CBN,” the witness said.

    About a week later, Ahmed allegedly returned with what he claimed was presidential approval and informed Maishanu that they would seek Emefiele’s consent for a cash withdrawal.

    He said Ahmed requested his assistance or a recommendation of someone who could accompany them for the cash transaction.

    Maishanu told the court he declined to participate but introduced a friend.

    Read Also: Emefiele urges court to foreclose prosecution in alleged procurement fraud trial

    According to him, on February 8, 2023, the friend and his driver withdrew $6.23 million from the Garki CBN branch.

    “After the withdrawal, my friend told me that Ahmed left with $2.5 million in cash alongside others,” he said.

    The witness said the remaining cash was brought to his friend’s residence at Ibrahim Coomasie Crescent, Abuja, where he described the amount left behind as “outrageous.”

    “I told my friends that we should keep the money because we never negotiated for any payment with Ahmed,” he said.

    Under cross-examination by defence counsel, Mathew Burkar (SAN), Maishanu said he was certain the approval was fraudulent.

    “I am sure because the CBN has rigorous procedures for payments, especially for cash transactions of that magnitude,” he said.

    He admitted receiving part of the $2.5 million left behind but insisted it was not his personal share and that he did not initially know the transaction was fraudulent.

    The witness further stated that he later saw forged documents shown to him by one Mr Obazi, adding that he accepted responsibility because of his involvement.

    Maishanu further explained CBN’s disciplinary process, noting that sanctions for erring officials range from warnings to dismissal, following investigations by a disciplinary committee.

    He added that he was not sanctioned by the CBN Board over the matter.

    He told the court that while he did not personally witness the approval signature, the withdrawal was traceable through internal documentation bearing signatures of all officials involved.

    He also stated that approvals for such transactions rest with the CBN Governor or the Committee of Governors.

    Trial continues today.

  • Emefiele’s Naira notes redesign brought untold economic hardship to public – EFCC witness

    Emefiele’s Naira notes redesign brought untold economic hardship to public – EFCC witness

     A  High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) in Maitama heard on Thursday that the naira redesign exercise carried out by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) under Godwin Emefiele as the Governor brought hardship on Nigerians.

    A prosecution witness in the ongoing trial of Emefiele over alleged unlawful naira redesign, Chinelo Eneanya said he was one of those who investigated the case.

    Eneanya, an Investigator with the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), spoke while testifying as the seventh prosecution witness in the case.

    The witness, who was led in evidence by prosecuting lawyer, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), said by the video evidence tendered in court,  the new naira redesign exercise injured the public.

    He said his presence in court was to give evidence on the investigation carried out in the case by his team of investigators and their findings.

    On whether the investigation covered allegations in the case against the defendant, the witness said his team  investigated the allegations that the conduct of the defendant caused injury to the people.

    He added that the currency redesign exercise severely affected the public, adding: “We looked at the documentary,  electronic  and audio visual evidence of the effect of the naira redesign on the public.”

    Oyedepo then, proceeded to tender documents,  some video recordings, the certificate of identification, certified true copy of bundle of documents  labelled delivery notes and notice of meeting were also tendered admitted.

    Six video evidence were played in the court. They were recordings made by four television stations – News Central,  Channel Television News, TVC News and Arise News.

    The prosecution also tendered the bill of settlement in respect of the redesigned naira notes, 2022 and 2023 were tendered and marked as evidence.

    Lawyer to the defendant, Olalekan Ojo (SAN) did not object to the tendering of the documents and videos.

    Read Also: Court admits more evidence against Ex-CBN Gov Emefiele over alleged $4.5bn fraud

    On what the investigators’ findings were from the video recordings, which were shown in court, Eneanya said it revealed that there were widespread frustration from the members of the public, who experienced difficulties in meeting their daily needs, adding that their businesses were equally affected.

    The witness said their investigation also showed that board members and members of the CBN’s Committee of Governors got to know about the approval of the president after the exercise was approved.

    He added: ”In the course of the investigation, we set out to determine how the laws on change of policy on Naira redesign was applied or abused”.

    Ojo, however, objected when the witness wanted to speak on the Supreme court ‘s judgment on naira redesign notes.

    He said no witness could give evidence on a public document, he did not make.

    But in a brief ruling, Justice Maryanne Anenih agreed with the prosecution and overruled Ojo’s objection saying that the argument was about giving evidence on a document and dumping evidence on the court.

    The witness confirmed that the defendant was interviewed in the course of their investigation and proceeded to tender in evidence the extra judicial statements made to investigators by Emefiele .

    He also confirmed that in the course of investigation the defendant was confronted with the question about whether the Board of Governors approved the naira redesign exercise.

    At a point, Ojo prayed the court for an adjournment till a later date to enable him cross examine the witness.

    Oyedepo did not object, following which the judge adjourned till November 26.

  • Court admits more evidence against Ex-CBN Gov Emefiele over alleged $4.5bn fraud

    Court admits more evidence against Ex-CBN Gov Emefiele over alleged $4.5bn fraud

    Justice Rahman Oshodi of the Special Offences Court sitting in Ikeja, Lagos, on Thursday, admitted additional evidence in the ongoing trial of the former Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Godwin Emefiele, who is facing charges over an alleged $4.5 billion fraud.

    Emefiele is standing trial on a 19-count charge bordering on receiving gratification and corrupt demand, filed by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC).

    His co-defendant, Henry Omoile, is facing a separate three-count charge relating to unlawful acceptance of gifts by agents. Both defendants have pleaded not guilty to all charges.

    At the resumed hearing, Justice Oshodi overruled the objections of the defence counsel, led by Senior Advocates of Nigeria Olalekan Ojo and Kazeem Gbadamosi, and admitted as evidence a bundle of documents extracted from the mobile phone of John Adetola, a former Executive Assistant to Emefiele.

    Read Also: Obidient Movement congratulates Amupitan on appointment as INEC chairman

    Ruling on the admissibility of the materials, Justice Oshodi stated, “The court overrules the objection of the defence counsel and admits the documents as Exhibit G.”

    Following the court’s ruling, the prosecution’s witness, Alvan Gurumnaan, continued his testimony and read out WhatsApp conversations contained in Exhibit G. The chats allegedly revealed that Omoile instructed Adetola to deliver $400,000 to “Oga,” a term the witness said referred to Emefiele.

    Led in evidence by EFCC counsel, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), Gurumnaan testified that Adetola had confirmed during interrogation that the $400,000 was handed to a CBN official named Ayo, who served as Emefiele’s personal assistant.

    “John Adetola confirmed that he went to Lekki, Lagos, where he met Ayo and delivered the $400,000. He later proceeded to the CBN office in Lagos, where he handed the money over to Mr. Emefiele,” Gurumnaan told the court.

    He further alleged that another $200,000 was delivered through the same channel. “This time, Ayo personally handed the money to Emefiele in his office,” the witness added.

    According to Gurumnaan, a CBN contractor, Victor Oyedua, confirmed providing the $400,000 and $200,000 to Ayo as part of an arrangement to “settle management” to facilitate payment for pending contracts with the CBN.

    The prosecution also tendered additional documents obtained from the apex bank and a company letter dated February 24, 2024, which Justice Oshodi admitted as Exhibit H despite objections from the defence.

    A Mi 10T smartphone belonging to Adetola, which was reportedly seized while still powered and in flight mode, was admitted as Exhibit I.

    The EFCC further sought to tender statements allegedly made by Emefiele during investigation. However, the defence objected, claiming the statements were obtained under duress.

    Following the objection, Justice Oshodi ordered a trial-within-trial to determine the voluntariness of the statements. He directed both parties to report on the progress of forensic inspection by November 21, 2025.

    The case was subsequently adjourned till December 2 and 3, 2025, for continuation of trial.

  • Emefiele, EFCC disagree on modalities for forensic examination of WhatsApp messages

    Emefiele, EFCC disagree on modalities for forensic examination of WhatsApp messages

    An Ikeja Special Offences Court yesterday heard that forensic examination ordered into WhatsApp messages on the phone of the former Governor of Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Godwin Emefiele did not go as planned.

    This was because, the examination, intended to be conducted by experts from the defence and prosecution failed to agree on modalities.

    The court had during the last sitting ordered the forensic examination of a phone and WhatsApp conversations, central to the alleged $4.5 billion fraud trial against Emefiele.

    During resumed proceedings yesterday, Emefiele, through his counsel, Olalekan Ojo (SAN) raised concerns over the issue before the court.

    Ojo alleged that the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), on two separate occasions blocked the successful execution of the court’s order.

    The trial judge, Justice Rahman Oshodi, had at last sitting of the court, ruled that the mobile device, marked “iPhone 2,” and its WhatsApp contents, which were tendered by the EFCC as evidence, must be subjected to a scientific, forensic examination.

    The judge issued the order following an application by Emefiele’s defence team who argued for the necessity of the examination in the interest of justice.

    They had also pointed out that the exercise would require the presence of experts from both sides.

    Ojo told the court that on September 24 and 25, the dates ordered by the court, nothing could be accomplished despite the presence of representatives from both parties and the court’s Registrar.

    “The first brick wall we faced was that the EFCC said the device cannot be exposed to the entire team,” Ojo said.

    He said same was raised by the EFCC team on the second day.

    He said in spite of clarification by the Registrar that the court directed for the examination of the phone and WhatsApp, the EFCC representatives failed to produce the phone when the Apple expert demanded for it.

    He said the EFCC team gave a “categorical No” to the request.

    He emphasised the need for what he termed as an unfettered access for the experts to perform their duty, insisting that the EFCC’s actions had blocked the process.

    Ojo urged the court to issue a fresh directive to ensure proper access to the phone and its WhatsApp content.

    Responding, the counsel for the EFCC, Rotimi Oyedepo, (SAN) stated that the initial forensic examination conducted by the defence’s expert was flawed and non-compliant with forensic standards.

    According to him, the expert in question had no physical laboratory, no verifiable office, and reportedly carried out parts of the examination via a live internet connection, risking data compromise.

    He said: “the implication of their request is that Exhibit E may be altered. The data could auto-sync and change the integrity of the exhibit.”

    Oyedepo confirmed that the iPhone remained in flight mode, ensuring it remains untampered with.

    He assured the court of the prosecution’s commitment to transparency:

    “The prosecution has never, and will never, prevent the defence from accessing the facility. But handling of the exhibit must be done properly,” he said.

    Read Also: Nigerians expect more deliberate action from lawmakers, says Speaker Abbas

    However, in their responses, defence counsels to first and second defendant, Ojo (SAN) and Adeyinka Kotoye (SAN) urged the court to defer further testimony until the forensic analysis is completed.

    They argued that the WhatsApp chats are central to their case and proceeding without the full report would be premature.

    Justice Oshodi acknowledged their concerns and ruled that the prosecution must file the forensic report within 24 hours.

    He allowed the continuation of the prosecution’s witness testimony, noting that the witness had travelled from Abuja for the hearing.

    He also directed both parties to adopt electronic service of documents moving forward to prevent further delays.

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) is prosecuting Emefiele on 19 counts bordering on receiving gratification, corrupt practices, and abuse of office.

    The co-defendant, Henry Omoile, on the other hand, is facing a separate three-count charge relating to unlawful acceptance of gifts.

  • Emefiele urges court to foreclose fraud trial

    Emefiele urges court to foreclose fraud trial

    Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) former Governor Godwin Emefiele has urged the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) to discontinue  his ongoing trial for alleged procurement fraud.

    Emefiele is being prosecuted on a 20-count  bordering on criminal breach of trust, conferring corrupt advantage, forgery, conspiracy to obtain by false pretence and obtaining money by false pretence.

    The case marked CR/577/2023 was filed by the office of the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF) and is before Justice Hamza Muazu.

    Yesterday, Emefiele’s lawyer,  Matthew Burkaa (SAN),  noted that the prosecution was not represented by any lawyer.

    Burkaa, who recalled that the matter was adjourned till yesterday for continuation of the hearing, said that the prosecuting lawyer, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN),  did not even send a representative.

    Read Also: Army recovers 10 AK-47 rifles, five bombs, 36 hand grenades from terrorists

    The defence lawyer said he was informed by the court’s Registrar through a WhatsApp message on Monday that there was a letter before the court, requesting an adjournment.

    He said upon arriving at the court yesterday, he was shown a document by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) which, he argued, was not the agency that filed the charge.

    Burkaa recalled that the charge was brought by the office of the Attorney-General of the Federation and wondered why the EFCC prayed to have the case adjourned.

    He told the court that Emefiele and his lawyers came to Abuja from Lagos only to observe that the prosecution had no lawyers in the court.

    Burkaa objected to the   request by the EFCC    for an adjournment and prayed the court to foreclose the prosecution because there was no formal application from the office of the AGF for adjournment.

    Ruling, Justice  Muazu elected to accord the prosecution one last opportunity to prosecute its case.

    Justice Muazu said the court will do the needful should the prosecution fail to appear on October 22 and 23, the next adjourned dates, for the continuation of the hearing.

  • Emefiele urges court to foreclose prosecution in alleged procurement fraud trial

    Emefiele urges court to foreclose prosecution in alleged procurement fraud trial

    A former Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Godwin Emefiele, has urged a High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) to foreclose the prosecution in his ongoing trial for alleged procurement fraud.

    Emefiele is being prosecuted on a 20-count charge bordering on criminal breach of trust, conferring corrupt advantage, forgery, conspiracy to obtain by false pretence, and obtaining money by false pretence.

    The charge, marked CR/577/2023, filed by the office of the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF), is before Justice Hamza Muazu.

    On Tuesday, defence lawyer Matthew Burkaa (SAN) noted that the prosecution was not represented by any lawyer.

    Read Also: 753 housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    Burkaa, he recalled that the matter was adjourned till September 23 for continuation of the hearing, noting that the prosecuting lawyer, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), was absent and failed to send a representative.

    The defence lawyer said he was informed by the court’s Registrar the previous day, through a WhatsApp message, that there was a letter before the court, requesting an adjournment.

    He said upon arriving at the court on Tuesday, he was shown a document sent by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), which, he argued, was not the agency that filed the charge.

    Burkaa claimed that the charge was brought by the office of the Attorney-General of the Federation and expressed surprise that the EFCC was the agency praying to have the case adjourned.

    He told the court that the defendant and his lawyers came from Lagos and wondered why none of the lawyers in the prosecution’s team of lawyers was in court.

    Burkaa objected to the prosecution’s request for an adjournment and prayed the court to foreclose the prosecution on the grounds that there was no formal application from the office of the AGF for adjournment.

    Ruling, Justice Hamza Muazu elected to accord the prosecution one last opportunity to prosecute its case.

    Justice Muazu said the court will do the needful should the prosecution fail to appear on the next adjourned date.

    He then adjourned till October 22-23 for the continuation of the hearing.

  • Alleged $4.5b fraud: Emefiele gets court’s nod for phone’s forensic examination

    Alleged $4.5b fraud: Emefiele gets court’s nod for phone’s forensic examination

    • By Adebisi Onanuga and Khafilat Lawal

    Justice Rahman Oshodi of an Ikeja Special Offences Court yesterday granted the application of former Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor, Godwin Emefiele, to engage forensic experts to examine his WhatsApp conversations.

    A mobile device, marked “iPhone 2”, which was tendered as evidence in his ongoing trial, is also to be examined scientifically.

    Emefiele is facing a 19-count charge of alleged $4.5 billion fraud alongside a co-defendant, Henry Omoile.

    The former CBN governor is also accused of abuse of office, receiving gratification, accepting gifts through agents, corruption, and fraudulent property transactions to the tune of $4.5 billion and N2.8 billion by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC).

    Emefiele’s legal team, led by Olalekan Ojo (SAN), had asked the court to allow an independent forensic expert to inspect the mobile phone and verify the authenticity of the extracted WhatsApp messages presented as exhibits.

    He said: “The defence is seeking the leave of the court to call a forensic expert to examine both the mobile device and printed conversations allegedly linked to the defendants.”

    But EFCC counsel, C. C. Okezie, opposed the request, arguing that the exhibits admitted during the trial were in the custody of the court and must remain in their original form until the conclusion of the case.

    The lawyer said the defence had not disclosed the name of the forensic laboratory or the qualifications of the personnel to handle the device.

    She urged the court to appoint the EFCC’s Director of Forensic Department to select the laboratory.

    Okezie said such a person must also ensure that the exercise is monitored by a prosecution-nominated representative and maintain a strict chain of custody.

    Read Also:753 housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    Ruling on the matter, Justice Oshodi held that the defence had the right to conduct an independent forensic review, provided safeguards were in place to protect the integrity of the evidence.

    The judge ordered that the inspection be conducted in the presence of representatives of all parties.

    He ordered that each party would be allowed no more than one lawyer and one forensic expert.

    The court directed that the process be supervised by a court representative and conducted between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m. on September 24 and 26.

    Justice Oshodi also ruled that the chain of custody of Exhibit E (iPhone 2) must be preserved and that the exhibit must remain in the court’s custody at all times.

    Justice Oshodi adjourned the matter till October 7, 8, and 9, for continuation of trial.

  • 753 housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    753 housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    • Ex-CBN gov gets two days to meet conditions

    A High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT)  has granted bail at N2 billion to a former Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Godwin Emefiele.

    This was after Emefiele was arraigned on an eight-count charge in which, among others, he is accused of unlawfully acquiring a housing estate comprising 753 units, alleged stealing and having billions of naira in proxy accounts.

    While granting the bail, Justice  Halilu Yusuf noted that Emefiele had earlier been given bail by two judges in separate criminal cases, which he did not jump.

     “In the absence of any evidence of bad conduct as it relates to the bail earlier granted to the defendant, I am mindful to grant the bail sought,” Justice  Yusuf said:

     He then proceeded to grant bail to Emefiele on the condition that his travel document, earlier deposited in respect of charge FCT/CR/577/2023, is attached as part of the conditions for the bail.

    The judge ordered him to produce two sureties, who must be residents of Abuja and own landed property within the jurisdiction of the court, particularly in Asokoro, Maitama, Wuse 2 and Life Camp.

    He said the property, cumulatively,  must be of the value of N2 billion.

    Read Also: JUST IN: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    The judge proceeded to order  Emefiele to perfect the bail by tomorrow, failing which he would be remanded in prison.

    The sureties, said the judge, shall also undertake to produce him in court throughout the trial.

    Justice Yusuf added that in the event that the defendant jumps bail, the sureties shall be put in prison and the said property shall be forfeited to the Federal Government.

     He adjourned till July 11 for the commencement of the trial.

  • UPDATED: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    UPDATED: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    …gives him two days to meet conditions

    A High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) on Monday granted bail at N2 billion to a former Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Godwin Emefiele.

    Justice Halilu Yusuf, in a ruling, granted the bail after Emefiele was arraigned on an eight-count charge in which he is accused of, among others, unlawfully acquiring a housing estate comprising 753 units, allegedly stealing and taking control of billions of naira in proxy accounts.

    Justice Yusuf noted that Emefiele had earlier been granted bail by two judges of the same High Court of the FCT in separate criminal cases and that there was no evidence that he jumped bail.

    The judge said, “In the absence of any evidence of bad conduct as it relates to the bail earlier granted to the defendant, I am mindful to grant the bail sought.”

    Justice Yusuf proceeded to grant bail to Emefiele on the condition that his travel document, earlier deposited in respect of charge FCT/CR/577/2023, is attached as part of the conditions for the bail.

    The judge ordered him to produce two sureties, who must be residents of Abuja and own landed proper within the jurisdiction of the court, particularly in Asokoro, Maitama, Wuse 2 and Life Camp.

    Read Also: JUST IN: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    He said the property, cumulatively, must be of a value of billion. The judge ordered Emefiele to perfect the bail by Wednesday, failing which he would be remanded in prison.

    The sureties, the judge said, shall also undertake to produce the defendant in court all through the duration of the trial.

    Justice Yusuf added that in the event that the defendant jumps bail, the sureties shall be put in prison and the said property shall be forfeited to the Federal Government.

    He adjourned till July 11 for the commencement of the trial.

    The ruling was on the bail application moved by his lawyer, Matthew Burkaa (SAN), which was not objected to by the prosecuting lawyer, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), who urged the court to impose additional conditions different from the ones earlier given by the other courts.

    The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), in the charge marked CR/350/25, accused Emefiele of colluding with one Eric Ocheme, who is reportedly at large, to acquire the property and monies.

    The property is stated to be located at Plot 109, Cadastral Zone C09, Lokogoma District, FCT, Abuja.

    It spans 150,462.86 square metres and comprises 753 housing units.

  • JUST IN: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    JUST IN: 753 Abuja housing units: Court grants Emefiele N2b bail

    A HIgh Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) on Monday granted bail at N2billion to a former Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Godwin Emefiele.

    Justice Halilu Yusuf, in a ruling, granted the bail after Emefiele was arraigned on an eight-count charge in which he is accused of among others, unlawfully acquiring a housing estate comprising 753 units, allegedly stealing and taking control of billions of naira in proxy accounts.

    Justice Yusuf noted that Emefiele had been granted bail in three other criminal cases pending against him and that there was no evidence that he had jumped bail.

    Read Also: EFCC slams Emefiele with fresh charges over 753 Abuja housing units

    He then proceeded to admit the ex-CBN governorto bail on the condition that he must produce two sureties, who must own property worth N2billion in either Aolsoko, Maitama or Wuse 2  within the jurisdiction of the court.

    Justice Yusuf ordered Emefiele to submit his travel documents to the court and directed that he must perfect the bail by next Wednesday, failing which he would be remanded in custody.

    The ruling was on the bail application moved by his lawyer, Matthew Burkaa (SAN), which was not objected to by prosecuting lawyer, Rotimi Oyedepo (SAN), who urged the court to impose additional conditions deferent from the ones earlier given by the other courts.

    Details shortly…