Tag: Ese

  • Ese, for whom our hearts bleed

    The Ese Oruru story, simple as it looks, is an intriguing piece told in dark episodic flashes. She was a 13-year-old living with her parents in a rustic community in Bayelsa State. Then she was abducted to Tofa, another rustic town in Kano, forcefullhy converted to Islam and ‘married’ by her abductor as a child bride. In a brazen move to legitimatise an illegality, her captors even sought the imprimatur of the Emir of Kano right in the presence of her mother who had come with a contingent of police to whisk the child back to Bayelsa with no success in spite of a belated Emir’s directive that she be returned. It’s the kind of tales you watch on Nollywood.

    In fact, Ese wouldn’t have burst into our consciousness if one of the nation’s leading newspapers, The PUNCH had not boldly taken up her case to confront an uncaring elitist society and a docile populace that sniggers at every heart-wrenching rendition as merely another sad dent in the Nigerian narrative. But for providence and the angst in the social media, Ese’s case could have vaporised into thin air like many other countless cases before hers. Why should the society care about the tale of a 13-year-old that was allegedly abducted from the innocence of her Bayelsa home by a supposed lover, to a culture and religion which pounced on her seeming precociousness to wrought an everlasting damage on this child’s psyche. Is it not the same society that lived in denial for months until the Chibok girls’ abduction saga became a faint appendix in our national discourse? We may shy away from it for now, but something tells me that the Ese that was returned to her parents last Wednesday was a different person. This prodigal that reluctantly came back to her doting parents is a rebel at heart– -a child suddenly thrown into complicated adult roles!

    Still, we need to ask the hard questions. This is not just about castigating a ‘wayward’ teenager for allegedly eloping with a much older lover through enticement, inducement or hypnotism. Unless we want to change the rules or succumb to primordial sentiments, the Ese Oruru story is a clear case of criminal breach of trust. As far as I know, a 13-year-old is not fully mature to take informed opinion on issues of religion, sex or even marriage. Therefore, when Inuwa Yunusa Dahiru, alias Yellow, relocated to Kano with the Oruru’s daughter without their consent, he has clearly crossed the bounds of decency. Without impugning whatever role Yunusa’s religious beliefs could have played in the whole saga, there is an urgent need to put an end to this crass madness in which certain persons criminally perpetuate evil and tarnish the beliefs of millions of others. Under our law, there could be no justification for the outright abuse of our collective humanity. Reading through Mrs. Oruru’s experience in the hands of her daughter’s abductors, it was clear that some powerful forces gleefully supported Yunusa’s criminal conduct. She could have been by a mob who gathered at the Emir’s palace, daring her determined resolve to free her daughter from Yunusa’s grip! Some men of the Kano Police Command also have questions to answer.

    What was stolen from Ese with that singular act is not only her innocence but also her humanity. She is a victim of a deadly abduction surreptitiously packaged as love. She is caught in the trap of decethe it set by Yunusa and his band of demented supporters who think that she was a willing ally in a fairy tale of elopement. They forget easily, as someone puts it, that Ese is just a “pliant and impressionable teen” hoodwinked by a fully-grown man who, in less than seven months, changed her faith and her name without the consent of her parents. Add that to the rumour that she was handed back to her parents as an expectant mother at 14 and you would grasp the extent of damage wrought on the Oruru clan. By the way, what part of our laws empowers a stranger to commit such atrocity and justify it with his religious beliefs? From the little she has said, we now know that Rita Ese Oruru did not know how she got to Kano. It was not surprising that a routine meal of bread and rice in those seven anguished months had transformed her into an old woman even at 14. She could remember that she drank mixtures occasionally but could not recollect for what purpose. She was just there, a baby who was a full time housewife in a strange land where her opinion never counted. That’s her sorry tale.

    When I say I weep for Ese, it is because I could imagine the trauma of a parent whose child has been callously deflowered, diminished and dehumanized. We all have children living under our roofs and we know the depth of the bond that pulls us together. We are a critical part of the whole, forever foraging for fate. Like all parents, Mr and Mrs Oruru had lofty dreams for the teenybopper growing under them. They may have been crammed up in that nondescript structure called home but they trudge on, clinging onto hope. That was why Ese and siblings were put in school. They know that, with education, their story would change. All it takes is perseverance and a commitment to the dream. In their wildest imagination, they would not have thought that 24-year-old Yunusa was waiting in the wings to change the trajectory of young Ese.

    When he spoke, Mr Charles Oruru sermonized about the Ese he knew. He waxed lyrical like many fathers would. Listen to him: “I don’t think a 13-year-old who is just in her early puberty stage will do something like that. A girl that does not know how to bathe well! I don’t believe she could be in love. I am very joyful that she has been released. I am waiting patiently to see her. I have missed her dancing. She is fond of dancing whenever she hears the sound of music”.

    You know what hurts? It’s not the noise in the marketplace where sentiments are being whipped up over religion, cultures and the despicable roles believed to have been played by some notable Nigerians in the prolonged, nay shameful saga. What riles one is the fact that we have become too placid as a people to understand the damage we violently inflict on the psyche of our youth, especially vulnerable children. We give impetus to paedophiles to go away with their despicable act by our inaction. Therefore, it was enough that Ese knew Yunusa and ‘voluntarily’ eloped with him to become a child bride in hijab? Where then is our sense of shame, angst and utter disgust? How many of us struggling to exculpate Yunusa would do same were our daughters to be the victims of the heinous crime? In fact, how many of us still maintain this conspiracy of silence even when we know one or two families in our areas who keep child brides as mementos of their carnal rascality?

    Mr. Oruru spoke about Ese’s love for music and her passion for dancing. That, to me, is a very moving testimonial. Unfortunately, he was merely reminiscing about a daughter he knew some seven months back, before her innocence was plucked before it could mature. From the little we have heard from Ese, that anticipated family bonding might not be a smooth ride. The transformation of the last seven months haunts her. This girl is now a woman with a different orientation, beliefs, religions and ideology. Ese may still dance to music. But would she dance to the sound of music she was used to, post-abduction? She might as well still be that girl learning how to bathe. However, is it not possible that she will inevitably be on the verge of learning how to bathe the baby in her womb? The girl is the mother of the child. She may even desire to continue her education. However, what kind of education would she crave for having gone through a life-changing experience of fate and faith? Ese may still understand the significance of family love and bond. But now that she has ‘tasted’ a different kind of bonding outside her comfort zone, which one would she cling to?

    Yes, Ese may be back to Bayelsa. But can we, in all honesty, say that her spirit is back to her roots? Where is justice for killers of dreams who walk off without punishment due to prisms that are, at best, laughable technicalities. Will Ese, who said Mathematics was her best subject in school before August 12 last year, ever grow out of the double personalities that now struggle for a space in her soul due to the callous act of a criminal underling? Only time will tell as we pray for the Orurus in this moment of joy mixed with heavy dose of sadness.

  • Heavy security  in Yenagoa as  Ese returns

    Heavy security in Yenagoa as Ese returns

    Ese Rita Oruru, the 14-year-old girl who was taken from Yenagoa to Kano, converted to Islam and forced into marriage,  last night arrived in the Bayelsa State capital, under heavy police protection.

    Ese, who arrived with her mother under the cover of darkness, was driven to the Police Officers’ Mess.

    The police shielded her, preventing reporters from catching a glimpse of the girl whose abduction caused an uproar.

    Cameras were not allowed around the premises.

    Reporters were barred from the mess by security operatives.

    At the time of filling this report, reporters were still keeping vigil around the Mess, expecting either the police or members of the civil society groups to address them.

    The secrecy surrounding Ese’s arrival also fueled suspicion that she could be pregnant.

    Her father’s telephone number was switched off while some of her siblings allowed their phones to ring out without answering their calls.

    There were indications that the family members had been warned by the police  against speaking on Ese’s matter to reporters.

    It was gathered that Ese might either pass the night at the officers’ mess or taken home at a quiet time in the night.

    Bayelsa State Commissioner of Police  Peter Ogunyawo, confirmed that Ese was finally back to Yenagoa.

    The police boss emerged from the Police Officers’ Mess and told reporters: “I can confidently tell you that she is in Bayelsa and she is right where you are now, hale and hearty.

    “We are just trying to counsel her as you can see my wife just finished speaking with her. And that is what we intend doing in the next few days.”

    On reports that Ese is pregnant, Ogunyawo said: “About the pregnancy, I am a police officer and not a police doctor, so I wouldn’t know about that; It is for her parents to decide whether she will go for a pregnancy test or not”.

    Is 14-year-old Ese pregnant? That is one of the riddles the police will determine with the medical and psychological tests being conducted on her.

    Though her status remained unconfirmed last night, sources said the white Hijab she wore when she was taken to the Police Headquarters on Tuesday might have been used to cover her pregnancy.

    Her physical condition, it was learnt, gave her away as an expectant minor.

    It was learnt that her state might have compelled the Force Headquarters to change their trip back to Yenagoa from road to air travel.

    Ese and her mother, Rose, were reportedly directed by the police to undertake their journey by air instead of by road.

    The freed minor and her mother were expected to fly to the Port-Harcourt Airport, Rivers State, to complete the journey to Yenagoa by road.

    But Faith, an elder sister to Ese, said nobody had said anything about her sister being expectant.

    The police yesterday confirmed that Ese was undergoing tests before being released to go with her mother.

    They said Yunusa was in custody and “will be brought to justice”.

    Besides, there is an administrative inquiry to determine the role of some policemen in the abduction. Those found derelict in their duties are to be punished.

    A police source confirmed that Inspector-General Solomon Arase directed that Yunusa should be repatriated to the Bayelsa State Police Command for further investigations and possible prosecution.

    “Yunusa allegedly committed the offence in Yenagoa. So, he is expected to be moved to the state police command where further investigations will be carried out for possible prosecution,” the source who spoke in confidence said.

    Police spokesman Olabisi Kolawole said: “I am delighted to confirm that the Police have today secured the release of Ese Oruru , the girl-child victim from the Kano State Sharia Commission. She is currently in safe custody of officers of the Gender Unit of the Force.

    “The victim is being granted psychological and emotional support by officers of the Gender and Child Protection Unit of the Force which handles cases of this nature that touch on violence against children. In addition, a team from the Medical Department of the Force are also extending medical attention to the girl-child.

    “Upon certifying her medical status and emotional state, Ese Oruru will be re-united with her parents who are around to work with police professionals in this regard.”

    Explaining why Ese was not publicly handed over to her parents, Kolawole said the police were respecting an international convention.

    She said: “As we share the joy of the safe release of Ese, let me appeal to ladies and gentlemen of the press of the crucial need to respect the privacy and other protective rights of the girl-child and her family at this moment.

    “This is the minimum legal and international requirement in cases of this nature. As a civilised nation, this is a standard we should not compromise in the long-term interest of the girl-child victim and her traumatised family.”

    Ese’s mother, Rose Oruru, who spoke in pidgin English, said: “Good afternoon. I no get anything to say again because already, dna don try; the press people and all Nigeria people wey work hard so that I can get my daughter back. Now I don get my daughter back, and na to go house.  I thank policemen and everybody. God bless everybody.”

    Yunusa would soon be taken to court on three-count charge of abduction, incitement of public disturbance and act of gross indecency, The Nation learnt yesterday.

    Sources at the Police Prosecution Unit, which is compiling charges against Yunusa, told our correspondent that  efforts were being made to ensure that a watertight case is brought against him, “even if a case of abduction is difficult in the particular matter”.

    The source, who declined to disclose if Yunusa would be charged in Abuja or Bayelsa, said because of the religious dimension introduced to the case, Yunusa will also be defending himself against the charge of inciting public disturbance, in addition to committing an act of gross indecency, if it was discovered that he was having sexual relationship with a minor.

    She explained that the Unit will also need the results of the various tests to determine whether it will be appropriate to file a case of act of gross indecency against Yunusa, 19.

    “We are already rubbing minds on the charges that may be brought against the suspect, especially when the Inspector General of Police has given us the marching order. We are looking at three charges of abduction, incitement of public disturbance and act of gross indecency. I must confess to you that this is not as straightforward as you may think.

    “We will be charging him with inciting public disturbance because of the religious aspect. For example, his action has led to public outcry along religious divides and it could have led to religious crisis. This is why we feel this particular charge can be proven convincingly at the court in addition to the act of gross misconduct if tests show that the girl is 14, which means that she is still a teenager and, therefore, not mature to take such decisions about having sex with an adult.”

    Kolawole said: “I can confirm that the Force has also taken into custody Yunusa Dahiru (Alias Yellow), the abductor of Ese.

    “I can assure you that the abductor and all other actors in this abduction saga will be brought to deserved justice. This is the only way this nation can make a clear statement in unison that any individual that violates the sanctity of the rights of our children shall be dealt with in accordance with extant laws of our country.

     She went on: “Aside the prosecution of the actors directly involved in this case, the IGP has also ordered an in-house administrative enquiry designed to review the professional conduct of officers responsible for the initial investigation of this case and any officer indicted of professional dereliction will be firmly dealt with, accordingly.”

  • ‘We have missed Ese’

    ‘We have missed Ese’

    Schoolmates and friends of Ese yesterday said they were still in shock over her abduction and forceful marriage.

    When The Nation visited the Central Epie Secondary School, Opolo, where Ese was an SS1 student, normal academic and social activities were going on.

    There was an indication that Ese must have lived a quiet life as most of the students did not know her.

    After making inquiries, a student took The Nation to three students in SS1 whom she said are Ese’s friends.

    The friends, who identified themselves as Faith, Esther and Ebiyomi, expressed shock at Ese’s abduction. Faith said she was, however, happy that the puzzle had been resolved and she was on her way back.

    “We have missed her and I am happy we are going to see her again. I was very shocked when I heard the story though I did not believe it at first.

    “After school that day, I rushed to her parents’ house to confirm the story and I met her father who narrated the story to me. It was really sad,” she said.

    Faith denied reports that that Ese eloped with Yinusa, adding that she never discussed any subject of love with them.

    “I don’t believe them. Ese is my friend and we have been friends since JSS1. She is not like that; she is a hardworking and intelligent girl. I know her very well because we started together from JSS1 and we have been friends since then.”

  • ESE ORURU’S ABDUCTION Prosecute suspects,  says Kano govt

    ESE ORURU’S ABDUCTION Prosecute suspects, says Kano govt

    The government of Kano State has urged the police to prosecute the culprits responsible for Ese Oruru’s alleged abduction.

    The state also exonerated itself from the abduction, saying it was a private action which the  culprits must answer to individually.

    Commissioner of Information, Youth, Sports and Culture Mallam Muhammad Garba, in a statement, blamed the police for its laxity in handling such a crucial issue of national concern.

    Garba condemned the abductors and described statements linking the Kano state government to the issue as unfounded, untrue, misguided and mischievous, adding that the state was virtually unaware of the case until it was publicised.

    “In view of the gravity of the allegation, the need to protect the right of minors on matters of faith and marriage, as well as promote unity and peaceful coexistence among Nigerians, particularly in the face of incorrect, and skewed misrepresentation of the issue, the government of Kano state, for the purpose of setting the record straight, declares that:

    “The issue was handled with dispatch competently, courageously and with all sense of concern by the Emir of Kano, Muhammadu Sanusi II, since August last year when the case was brought to his attention by ordering that the girl, Ese Oruru, who has never ever been kept in the palace, be taken back to her parents in Yenogoa, in liaison with the office of the AIG Zone One, Nigeria Police Force.”

    “The government was concerned that its directive was not handled accordingly and, therefore, ordered an investigation into why the directive was not complied with by the office of the AIG.

    “The issue was never brought to our attention, we only knew of it in the media.

    “The state government condemns the actions of the culprit as it is against the provisions of the Constitution and teachings of Islam, which abhors abduction and forced marriage, even with the consent of parents of a girl, be her a minor or adult, and forced conversion to Islam as the Quran states that ‘there is no compulsion in religion’.

    “Security and other relevant agencies should expedite action to bring the suspect(s) to book and be dealt with according to the law;

    “The actions of the culprit are private actions, which he is personally responsible for, even before the law. The person is solely responsible for his action and should take responsibility for it.”

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

  • Free Ese now

    Free Ese now

    •The Ese Rita Oruru story reflects a deeper malaise and impunity in our society

    In this season of the rule of law, the story of Ese Rita Oruru, a 14-year-old girl, of Urhobo extraction from Delta State, has gained traction. She was whisked away from Bayelsa State when she was still 13 years old, without her parents’ consent, allegedly to the Emir’s Palace in Kano.

    The story which was, at press time still developing, has all the evil trappings of molestation, child abuse, sexual deviance, abduction, religious coercion, constitutional violation, a network of shadowy big men manipulating the law.

    While we are still bellyaching over the abduction of the Chibok Girls by a group of militant daredevils in the name of religion, the story of Ese Oruru gives us a cause not only for national rage and condemnation, but for all those in authority to rise up and save not only the law, but also decency.

    Mentioned in this gory tale are the Emir of Kano, Muhammadu Sanusi 11; the Kano Emirate Council, the Inspector- General of Police, the Bayelsa State Police Command, the Kwani police, the Kura Police Station, the chief of Tufa village, the Sharia Council and the Director of the Department of State Services. It conveys the story of either the paralysis of our big men and institutions that a 14-year-old can be abducted, and she cannot be released out of her captivity. Or it tells of shameless barbarity of complicity.

    These are the big individual and institutional names. But lesser names set the narrative in motion. A certain Yinusa, popularly known as ‘Yellow’, abducted the girl on August 12, 2015. The father, Charles Oruru and the mother, Rose Oruru, had no knowledge of their daughter’s whereabouts. They learned later from one Dan Kano, who was also a mainstay in the Hausa quarters in Yenagoa, Bayelsa State, that the minor had been ferreted away by Yinusa, whose full name is yet to be revealed.

    The parents have travelled to Kano, at least twice, and have visited the Emir’s palace, and they met brick walls of impunity. When the mother visited, the chief of Tufa village, reportedly queried the man known as Rabiu who accompanied her to the town, and he had the added audacity to tell the mother that her daughter had converted to Islam and was now married.

    He was also reported to have warned that if Rose touched or spoke to Ese, either she or her daughter would die.

    Top men in the emirate, including the Galadima and the adviser to the Emir, claimed ignorance. But the secretary to the Emir, reportedly said that the chief of Tufa village had secured an approval from the Kura Police Station in the state to take Ese to the Emir’s Palace and confirmed that she was now a Muslim convert.

    The reports also say that on August 17, last year, a meeting was held at the palace with the Emir of Kano presiding and it included the inspector from the Kwani Police Station, the chief of Tufa village and Ese Oruru who came in a black Jeep with two police escorts. But her mother was not allowed in. The Emir reportedly told them to go to the Sharia Court.

    Now, the news report has it that the Emir of Kano, Lamido Sanusi, has instructed the Sharia Commission to act in order “to repatriate and reconcile” the girl with her parents. The Governor of Bayelsa State, Chief Seriake Dickson, and his Kano State counterpart, Alhaji Abdullahi Umar Ganduje, have also intervened.

    The claim that she was not abducted by some partisans in the story is irresponsible. They claimed she eloped. A minor cannot elope with an adult. A 13-year-old cannot decide to elope because she has not reached the age of majority or consent. Whoever has a hand in this savage saga ought to answer to the law.

    So absurd was the story that someone in the palace thought she knew the girl’s age more than the woman who gave birth to her. They claimed she was 18 and that she was now a Muslim. Religion, whether Islam and Christianity, works by consent and conviction, not coercion.

    The mother said when she tried to speak with her daughter on phone, a hectoring voice stopped her from speaking in her native Urhobo language.

    This matter has been simmering beneath the public eye for about eight months, and civil society organisations like Child Protection Network and CEE-HOPE have been in the vanguard of the search for this girl’s release. But it took the effort of the news media to get this out before any sense of seriousness was attached to it by all the major institutions and persons, including the Emir of Kano. The Nigeria Police, the DSS, the Sharia Commission all acted as though no harm was done, whereas a grave injustice was being perpetrated against one of us.

    It is clear that the release of this girl is not only desirable, but it should not take any delay. The use of the word “reconcile” from the Emir implies institutional culpability. If the Emir’s secretary knew about this, how come the Emir did not?

    To free Ese Oruru is the first step. But beyond that all those who took part in this sordid tale should be prosecuted, and the full course of the law should be obeyed. Yinusa and Dan Kano are the duo who allegedly organised the abduction.

    What is really baffling is that for over a year the nation has mourned the abduction of school girls in the north. Many more have also been abducted by the dreaded Boko Haram. It does not reflect well on the Kano Emirate Council that its name should be sullied with such act of human abuse.

    The Child Right Act has been in effect since 2009, and most of the northern states have not signed it. Human rights organisations and civil society groups have constantly harped on the practice of underage marriage and abuse of nubile girls in that part of the country. The occurrences of vestico vaginal fistula in little girls are too rampant.

    We condemn roundly this practice; religion should not be used as a cover to abuse fellow human beings.