Tag: Sylva

• Judiciary has vindicated itself over my Appeal Court victory, says APC candidate

The Court of Appeal in Abuja has set aside the October 9 judgment given by Justice Donatus Okorowo of the Federal High Court, Abuja nullifying the nomination of Timipre Sylva as the candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the Bayelsa State governorship election scheduled for November 11.

A three-member panel of the appellate court held, in a judgment on Tuesday, that the Federal High Court, Abuja lacked the jurisdiction to have heard and determined the case filed by

Demesuoyefa Kolomo described himself as a registered voter and a member of the APC.

The court held that having not been an aspirant, who participated in APC’s governorship primary, Kolomo lacked the locus standi to approach the court to challenge the nomination of the party’s candidate.

In the judgment read by Justice Binta Zubairu, the court held that since Kolomo was not an aspirant and did not participate in the primary from which Sylva emerged as APC’s candidate and cannot be clothed with the requisite locus standi as provided under sections 285(14) of the Constitution and 29(5) of the Electoral Act 2022.

Speaking with reporters at the APC National Secretariat in Abuja, shortly after consulting with the Deputy National Chairman (North), Alhaji Ali Bukar Dalori on the outcome of the judgment, Sylva said: “I believe that the Judiciary has vindicated itself. Because I had suffered defeat because of this issue of locus. I took Governor Dickson as he then was to court. On this issue of locus, the Supreme Court decided then that since I didn’t participate in that primary, I didn’t have the locus standi to take the matter to court and I lost the battle.

“But when the High Court now said, the guy who didn’t participate at all in the process had locus standi, I was a little bit confused. But the judiciary has vindicated itself. I am quite happy. We are ready.”

While delivering the judgment, the court indicated that from the provision of the law, one must be an aspirant, who participated in a primary before he can challenge the conduct or outcome of the primary concerning the qualification of the candidate nominated for the selection process.

It found that Kolomo failed to establish he was an aspirant in the APC primary and, as such, clothed with the requisite locus standi to institute the action on which the judgment disqualifying Sylva was given.

“Having held that the first respondent is not an aspirant, he lacked the locus standi to have instituted the matter under whatever guise before the lower court.

Read Also: Oyedepo’s son breaks silence on ‘alleged’ resignation from father’s church

“Where a party lacked the locus standi to institute a case, the court has no jurisdiction to entertain and determine it, Justice Zubairu said and proceeded to hold that the Federal High Court in Abuja was without jurisdiction to have heard the case.

She proceeded to set aside the Federal High Court judgment, allowed the appeal filed by Sylva and granted all the reliefs sought.

The court also awarded N1million cost in favour of Sylva.

In his October 9 judgment, Justice Okorowo held among others,  that Sylva, having been sworn in twice and served for five years as governor of Bayelsa, would breach the  Constitution should he be allowed to contest again.

Justice Okorowo declared that Sylva was not qualified to contest the November election because if he won and is sworn in, he would spend more than eight years in office as governor of the state.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in the case of Marwa vs Nyako, the judge held that the drafters of the Constitution stated that nobody should be voted for as governor more than twice and that the parties to the suit agreed that Sylva was voted into office two times.

While arguing the appeal on October 27,  lawyers to Sylva and the APC  – Akinlolu Kehinde (SAN) and K. O. Balogun faulted Justice Okorowo’s position on Sylva’s qualification.

Balogun argued that it was wrong for the trial court to have entertained the suit by Kolomo because he lacked the locus to have approached the trial court.

He faulted the decision of Justice Okorowo, to the effect that Sylva took the oath of office twice as Governor of Bayelsa State.

Balogun said: “In 2007 he (Sylva)  was elected the Governor of Bayelsa State, but within eight months, the Court of Appeal (which was then the final court for governorship election petition) sacked him.

He added: “He contested again in 2008 and won. The eight months that he earlier spent in office was nullified, so he could not have said to have spent that with months because it was voided by the court.

“What he (Kolomo) is doing is fighting a proxy war. He cannot be a member of the APC and be fighting to destroy its candidate and chances at the election.

“What the first respondent (Kolomo)  is asking this court to do is to deem the nullified eight  months as 4 years.”

In another judgment on Tuesday, the same Court of Appeal allowed a similar appeal filed by the APC to challenge Sylva’s disqualification.

The court granted all the reliefs sought in the appeal marked: CA/ABJ/CV/1060/2023 and equally awarded N1m cost in favour of the appellant.

The deputy governorship candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the forthcoming Bayelsa governorship election, Joshua Maciver has come under attack for inciting violence ahead of the election.

Maciver, during a political campaign of the party in Twon Brass, Bayelsa State, called on supporters of APC to chase anyone opposed to the emergence of the party into the sea and kill people, as long as victory was secured.

In a statement, the Bayelsa Women Arise has condemned the comments. The statement by the Publicity Secretary, Ebibaratimi Atani, urged the Inspector General of (IGP) and the Director-General of the Department of State Services (DSS) to take immediate and decisive action to reassure voters of their safety.

The group argued that it was the duty of law enforcement agencies to protect the lives and property of all citizens, adding: “we believe that failure to address this issue promptly would set a dangerous precedent for our state’s political climate.

Read Also: Supreme Court verdict: First Lady hails ruling as the ‘Lord’s doing’

The statement said: “In light of the above, we urge the Inspector-General of Police to launch a thorough and swift investigation into the comments made by Mr Joshua Maciver, as a way of preventing bloodshed, which Mr Maciver and his co-travellers are determined to unleash on our people during the forthcoming election.

“Recall that a few days ago, our organisation expressed our fears and sensitized the people of Bayelsa for a violence-free Governorship election on November 11, during a Peace Walk where thousands of Bayelsa people participated.

“During his speech in Twon Brass, Mr Joshua Maciver shockingly advocated for the killing of supporters of opposition candidates, thereby inciting violence and creating an atmosphere of fear and intimidation in our beloved state.

“Such statements are not only unbecoming of a political candidate but are also a direct threat to the democratic process, which is built on the principles of peaceful coexistence and respect for the rights and choices of the citizens.”

The withdrawal of the names of its candidates from the November 11 Bayelsa State governorship election in the amended list was premature, the All Progressives Congress (APC) told the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) last night.

On its website late Tuesday, the electoral body withdrew the APC flag bearers Timipre Sylva and his running mate, Joshua Maciver from the off-circle governorship poll in the state.

INEC’s action was informed by an October 9, 2023, High Court order that disqualified Sylva as the APC candidate.

But APC National Publicity Secretary, Felix Morka, insisted that delisting the party’s candidates, in the circumstances, as INEC has done, preempts the outcome of the valid appeal in the matter.

In a statement, the APC noted that its candidate and party had promptly appealed the judgment and brought other processes seeking a stay of the judgment’s execution.

Morka further stated that the Court of Appeal, recognising the extreme urgency of the matter,  granted an order of accelerated hearing of the matter now fixed for definite hearing tomorrow, stressing that INEC is a party in this matter and has been served with all relevant filings and orders in this matter.

The APC spokesman complained that removing Sylva’s and running mate’s from the list of contestants would foist a situation of helplessness on the appellate court, the candidate and APC should the appeal succeed.

Read Also: Obaseki: Nigeria will be in deeper trouble if we don’t cut waste

He said: “The attention of the All Progressives Congress (APC) has been drawn to the updated list of gubernatorial candidates for the November 11 governorship election in Bayelsa State by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), which excluded the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate’s name, Chief Timipre Sylva.

“Delisting our Candidate, in the circumstances, as INEC has done, is premature, and preempts the outcome of the valid appeal in the matter. This flies in the face of INEC’s established practice of awaiting the decisions of appellate courts before taking action that may be prejudicial to the interest of the appellants.

“Furthermore, removing our candidate from the list of governorship contestants in Bayelsa would foist a situation of helplessness on the appellate court, the Candidate and our Party should the appeal succeed. We urge INEC to withdraw its amendment under reference in the interest of fairness.

“In the meantime, we appeal to the good people of Bayelsa State, especially our teeming members and supporters, to remain calm while the judicial process runs its full course. We have confidence that our candidate will be victorious both at the Court of Appeal and at the polls.”