Tag: Synagogue Church

  • ‘Synagogue Church fending for victims’ dependants’

    The Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) has been fending for dependants of those who died in its building that collapsed on September 12, 2014, a survivor told a Lagos High Court yesterday.

    No fewer than 116 persons died in the incident. The trustees of the church and the engineers who designed the building tried for alleged criminal negligence.

    The witness, Mr. Taiwo Taiwo, told Justice Lateef Lawal-Akapo that the church had never failed to discharge its duty to the dependants.

    The defendants are: Oladele Ogundeji, Akinbela Fatiregun and their companies – Hardrock Construction and Engineering Company and Jandy Trust Ltd.

    They are facing a 110-count charge of involuntary manslaughter, which contravenes Section 222 of the Criminal Law of Lagos State 2011.

    The registered Trustees of SCOAN, are facing a count of building without approval.

    The Lagos State Government said the trustees violated Section 75 of the Urban and Regional Planning Law of Lagos State 2010.

    The defendants were arraigned on April 19, 2016. They pleaded not guilty.

    Read also: Crazy billing, crazy DisCos

    Taiwo, who identified himself as a SCOAN volunteer guest worker, said he arrived at the building at about noon, before it collapsed.

    Led in evidence by Olalekan Ojo (SAN), he said: “I was unconscious and was only rescued a day after the incident.”

    He added that he felt a burning sensation on his back stating that when he opened his eyes, the environment was dark.

    Justice Lawal-Akapo adjourned till today.

  • Building collapse: ‘Synagogue Church fending for victims’ dependants’

    A survivor of the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) building that collapsed on September 12, 2014 killing 116 worshippers, on Thursday told a Lagos High Court in Igbosere that the church had been fending for dependents of the victims.

    Defence witness, Mr Taiwo Taiwo, testified before Justice Lawal-Akapo, during continuation of trial of four defendants – two engineers and their firms – for the deaths.

    The defendants are: Oladele Ogundeji and Akinbela Fatiregun charged alongside their companies – Hardrock Construction and Engineering Company and Jandy Trust Ltd.

    They are facing a 110-count charge of involuntary manslaughter which contravened Section 222 of the Criminal Law of Lagos State 2011.

    A fifth defendant, the Registered Trustees of SCOAN is facing a count of building without approval.

    The Lagos State Government said the Trustees violated Section 75 of the Urban and Regional Planning Law of Lagos State 2010.

    Read Also: Court remands pastor for defiling two boys

    All defendants were arraigned on April 19, 2016. They pleaded ‘not guilty’.

    At the resumed hearing of the matter on Thursday, Taiwo, who identified himself as a SCOAN volunteer guest worker, said “the church has never failed at any time to carry out its obligations,” towards the dependants of the deceased.

    The witness, led by Olalekan Ojo SAN during evidence-in-chief, told Justice Lateef Lawal-Akapo that he arrived at the collapsed building at about 12noon before the incident occurred.

    “I was unconscious and was only rescued a day after the incident,” Taiwo said.

    He added that he felt burning sensation on his back and when he opened his eyes, the environment was dark.
    Following the conclusion of his testimony, Justice Lawal-Akapo, adjourned till January 25, for continuation of trial.

  • Synagogue: Court adjourns ruling to November 9

    Synagogue: Court adjourns ruling to November 9

    A Federal High Court in Lagos on Monday fixed November 9 to rule on a suit by an engineer of the Synagogue Church, Mr. Akinbela Fatiregun, seeking enforcement of his rights.

    The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the suit, which was earlier fixed for ruling on a preliminary objection, was adjourned following the absence of the trial judge, Justice Ibrahim Buba.

    The court registrar announced to counsels that the court would not be sitting for the day.

    No reason was given for the adjournment.

    A new date, November 9, was therefore, fixed for the ruling.

    NAN reports that a guest house within the premises of the Synagogue Church collapsed on Sept. 12, 2014, leading to the death of over 100 persons.

    Following the collapse, the Lagos State Government set up a coroner’s inquest to ascertain the cause of death.

    The inquest, presided over by Chief Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe, in its verdict, indicted the church for criminal negligence and recommended that it be prosecuted.

    The coroner also indicted the church’s structural engineers, Mr. Akinbela Fatiregun and Mr Oladele Ogundeji, and recommended that they be investigated and tried for criminal negligence.

    Fatiregun filed the suit to challenge the verdict of the coroner’s court.

    Joined as respondents in the suit are; the Lagos State Commissioner of Police, Council of Registered Engineers in Nigeria (COREN), the Attorney General of Lagos State and Chief Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe, the Coroner.

    Fatiregun is seeking an order of perpetual injunction restraining the Commissioner of Police in Lagos from arresting, detaining, investigating or prosecuting him.

    He also wants an order of perpetual injunction to restrain the Lagos State Attorney General or any officer under his authority from initiating or commencing criminal proceedings against him based on the verdict of the coroner.

  • Ruling in Synagouge’s case Friday

    Ruling in Synagouge’s case Friday

    A Lagos High Court will on Friday decide whether to stop the coroner inquest into the last September 12 Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) collapsed building.

    Justice Lateefa Okunnu reserved  ruling yesterday after hearing a suit brought by SCAN’s founder Prophet Temitope Joshua and its board of trustees against the coroner, chief magistrate Oyetade Komolafe.

    She deferred the ruling, which was initially billed for yesterday, to enable the parties address her on whether the coroner is a “juristic” person that can sue and be sued.

    Justice Okunnu said she raised the issue because she considered it vital to the determination of the case.

    The parties will address the court on the issue before its ruling on Friday.

    SCOAN is praying the Justice Okunnu to suspend the inquest and the coroner’s invitation to Joshua to testify, pending the determination of his suit against Komolafe.

    It is seeking to bar coroner from exceeding his jurisdiction on the inquest into the death of unknown persons in the collapsed building.

    No fewer than 115 people mostly South Africans died in the incident.

    When the case resumed yesterday, SCOAN’s Chief Security Officer Mr Sunday Okojie told Chief Magistrate Komolafe that the church “is a secure haven”.

    According to the CSO, the buildings within the church premises have always been under security surveillance before and after the September 12 incident.

    Before the incident, security personnel and officials were deployed on their respective duty posts and in all the entrance and exit points.

    He said there was no side of the premises that was left unsecured.

    He told the court that Visitors Coordinators (VCs), a team in his department, was assigned to visitors and guests, adding that the jurisdiction of the VCs are not restricted, hence they have access into guests’ rooms to ensure their safety.

    The church, he said, has two entrances adding that for security reason, only one was now left open after the incident.

  • No approval for Synagogue collapsed building – Commissioner

    No approval for Synagogue collapsed building – Commissioner

    The Synagogue Church of All Nations building that collapsed on September 12, killing 116 people as well as the additional three floors on the main church auditorium were not approved, the Coronary inquest heard on Thursday.

    The Lagos State Commissioner for Physical Planning and Urban Development, Toyin Ayinde, made the disclosure while giving evidence before Coroner Oyetade Komolafe.

    Ayinde, who told the court that the only approval in government’s record for SCOAN was that of the main auditorium dated January 26, 2004, however maintained that three illegal floors have been added to the building which was assumed to be five floors.

    ‎The commissioner told the court that out of 42,358 electronic files that have approvals dating as far back as 1990, there was no approval for the collapsed building, making it an illegal construction.

    Ayinde also disclosed that from his observation during the visit of Governor Babatunde Fashola (SAN) to the site of the collapsed building, the column for the additional floors on the main auditorium started midway, which was an unusual practice.

    “The approval given to the church was in the name of the SCOAN dated January 26, 2004 and was for the main auditorium.

    “The approval was for five floors but at the site visit, I discovered the main auditorium have three additional floors making eight.

    The collapsed building by the record of the Lagos State government had no approval,” said Ayinde.

    The commissioner said the church did not reply the state’s letter, demanding various documents and details, just as he stated that he was informed by his personnel that they were not allowed access to the site of the collapsed building the first day until he called Rapid Response Squad (RRS) Commander.

  • Synagogue disaster: church produces manifest

    Synagogue disaster: church produces manifest

    A Coronary Inquest into the building collapse at the Synagogue Church of ‎All Nations (SCOAN) has  heard that the manifest of occupants had been filed.
    The disclosure came 47 days after the six-storey building collapse that killed 116 people at the church’s headquarters in Ikotun, Lagos.
    Issues surrounding the manifest had generated some tension between the church and the Lagos State Chief Medical Exam‎iner (CME) Prof. John Obafunwa, who on several occasions alleged that the church has refused to honour his request for the list to enable successful identification of the deceased.
    At previous sittings of the Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe led inquest, the court had emphasised the ‎importance of the manifest to the process, directing the church to make same available to Obafunwa.
    ‎Led in cross-examination by one of the church’s counsel, Olalekan Ojo, Obafunwa had insisted that the preliminary report already tendered and adopted before the court is a reflection of his position on the result of the autopsy carried out on the dead victims.

    Obafunwa informed the coroner that three pathologists team were on September 22, 2014 setup by him, ten days after the incident occurred.

    “I was a member of one of the teams, but I have to move around to play a supervisory role. We don’t need to designate a team by any name.
    “I carried out my functions at the Mainland Hospital at Yaba. We started carrying out autopsy on the dead victims at the Lagos University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH) on September 23 and other locations on September 24, 2014.
    “There is no way I can physically carryout autopsy on all the bodies. The bodies were embalmed immediately after they were deposited at the mortuary.
    “Embalment will not in anyway affect the result of the autopsy carried out on the dead victims. Forensic pathologists from South Africa only came to observe and did not participate in carrying  out autopsy on the dead bodies,”‎ stated Obafunwa.
    When asked when he first visited the scene of the disaster, Obafunwa said it was only on October 16 he visited, which was a guided tour.

    “It was a guided tour, I was shown locations of some CCTV cameras and seized the opportunity to handover a letter to the Chief Security Officer (CSO) of the church demanding the list of those trapped in the building.
    “It is not my duty to take debris at the collapsed site. It was also not my duty to know whether there is any detonation at the site of the collapsed building.
    “It was my job to ensure that things are done in accordance with the protocol that guides such practice.”
    Another witness, Ige Oladimeji representing the Nigerian Red Cross‎ told the court that the church assisted his team throughout their stay at the scene.
    “Synagogue provided ten ambulances to help evacuate casualties. In each of the ambulances, there were representatives of the church. Nobody prevented us from doing our job. 
    “We treated many injuries, arrest of bleeding and also resuscitation of some of the victims. My members participated in the search and rescue operation at the collapsed site.
    “I saw other stakeholders including NEMA and LASEMA while entering into the site of the collapsed building.
    “Members of the church were so compassionate to ensure that lives were saved. 

    “On the second day of the incident, members of my team who worked round the clock confirmed to me that everything went well and more bodies were evacuated since I had left.”
    The inquest continues on Thursday with the South African Ambassador, the Standard Organisation of Nigeria (SON) and ‎the Lagos State Emergency Management Agency (LASEMA) expected to give evidence.

  • Synagogue Church, others should  insure buildings, says NAICOM

    Synagogue Church, others should insure buildings, says NAICOM

    •Sympathises with victim’s families 

    Following the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) building collapse tragedy, the National Insurance Commission (NAICOM) has advised churches and mosques leaders in the country to consider insurance of their buildings to mitigate risks in the interest of innocent third parties.

    Commissioner for Insurance, Fola Daniel made this call, while expressing sympathising with families of victims of the collapsed building in Lagos.

    Daniel said insurance of public buildings except places of worship, is compulsory in Nigeria as defined in section 65 of the insurance Act 2003.

    He urged Nigerians to insure their risks against unforeseen disasters such as the Synagogue building collapse.

    He said: “Church and mosque leaders in the country should consider insurance of their buildings to mitigate risks in the interest of innocent third parties.

    “I sympathise with families of victims of the collapsed synagogue church building in Lagos and urge Nigerians to insure their risks against unforeseen disasters.”

    About two weeks ago, a part of a multiple storey building inside the premises of the SCOAN, collapsed leaving a total of 80 worshipers dead, while 131 were critically injured.

    The National Emergency Management Agency and the Lagos State Emergency Management Agency, which said the rescue operation at the site has been concluded, announced that they had reached “ground zero” as at Thursday, last week.

    Some of those rescued alive, according to them, have been discharged, while others are still receiving treatments for various degrees of injuries at some hospitals in Lagos.

  • Synagogue: 45-year-old woman walks out of rubbles alive

    Synagogue: 45-year-old woman walks out of rubbles alive

    A 45-year-old-woman on Tuesday walked out alive from the rubbles of the collapsed building at the Synagogue Church of All Nations in Ikotun, Lagos, a rescue worker has said.

    The building collapsed last Friday.

    Mr. Ibrahim Farinloye, the Public Relations Officer of the National Emergency Management Agency, South-West Zone, told journalists in Lagos that the woman walked out on her own at 2a.m.

    Farinloye did not give the identity of the woman.

    “A woman of about 45 years old walked out of the rubbles on her own around 2a.m today, while 10 more bodies were recovered, leaving 59 dead and 131 rescued alive,“ Farinloye said.

    He said that the rescue workers were likely to recover more bodies.

    The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the emergency responders at the scene of the collapsed building on Tuesday deployed three police sniffer dogs to help to locate trapped victims.

    The Lagos State Commissioner of Police, Mr Kayode Aderanti, had on Monday approved the use of the sniffer dogs for the rescue operation.

    Vehicles conveying the dogs to the scene reportedly broke down on its way.

    Farinloye said that the rescue exercise might be concluded on Tuesday.

    NAN reports that the police and other security agencies are still on ground to ensure safety of lives and property.

  • Photo: Collapsed Synagogue Church building

    Photo: Collapsed Synagogue Church building

     

    Scene of the collapse building at Synagogue Church, Lagos
    Scene of the collapse building at Synagogue Church, Lagos
  • Lagos takes sensitisation to Synagogue Church

    Lagos takes sensitisation to Synagogue Church

    Lagos State Government stepped up its surveillance on the Ebola virus yesterday, with its officials visiting a church in continuation of its enlightenment campaign.

    Officials of Lagos State Ministry of Health and the Federal Government visited the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN), seeking the cooperation of its General Overseer Prophet Temitope Joshua in ensuring Ebola victims are not brought to his church for healing.

    The SCOAN, a  church reputed for its claims of divine healing, is a popular destination for the sick.

    Commissioner for Health, Dr. Jide Idris, who led the delegation to the SCOAN, said it was in recognition that the church is an international Christian congregation whose members comprise people from all over the world, including the countries of West African sub-region already affected by the disease.

    The commissioner added that the visit is one of the state government’s strategies of sensitising faith-based organisations on the need to cooperate with the government to prevent the spread of the disease by educating worshippers to report health issues to medical experts.

    Idris said the Federal and state governments were working hard to prevent the virus from coming into the country.

    “We have our strategies that we intend to share with you. Again, we need to know the resources you have here because whether it is one or two cases, if they are allowed to get out, it is a major problem. We are here to work together on how to contain this disease,” Idris told the cleric.

    Another member of the delegation and Director, Centre for Disease Control (CDC), Professor Abdulsalami Nasidi, said the visit was to inform the church’s leadership about the deadliness of the Ebola virus and to ensure that it does not enter Nigeria.

    Nasidi, who is an epidemiologist and a virologist, said the meeting was a “positive engagement mission”. “We are here to engage you positively. We know the powers of this House and your powers and we are duty- bound to protect you and your congregation. We have no doubt the power God has given you; we can’t do that, but we want to help and make it work stronger,” he said.

    While the delegation came short of telling the cleric not to accept victims of the disease who may want to seek healing in his church, it however made it clear that the government would do everything to ensure the disease is not imported into the country under any guise, after a Liberian government official died of the virus in a Lagos hospital. He flew into the country to attend an Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS)  meeting in Calabar.

    Professor Nasidi said the government is worried as the Synagogue congregation comprises of people from around the world.

    He said government would provide technical and medical expertise to help the Synagogue team deal with any suspected Ebola case. “ We have experts from the World Health Organisation (WHO), Dr. Musa is an expert who has all the guidelines, we have Dr. Yaunti of the UNICEF, he has all the materials to work with you, to make sure your people know how to handle Ebola.”

    The experts are to work with the Committee on Technical issues and the church’s health team to “ train them on how to handle this dangerous situation, pass some materials to them, share knowledge with them and if need be provide some technical materials,” Nasidi said.

    The committee will also provide underground medical support to the Synagogue church laboratories to be able to diagnose the virus.

    The delegation also reiterated that the Ebola disease comes from a most deadly virus which “ spreads so fast from man to man especially those who come in contact with the victims, share body fluid during treatments.”

    Nasidi said: “ These are the areas we felt we should come and engage and work with you to ensure that members of your congregation, everybody in Lagos and Nigeria will be free of this disease.”

    Prophet Joshua promised to work with the government to ensure that the disease does not spread into the country. He said he would put some measures in place to ensure people from the affected countries do not enter Nigeria.

    According to the faith healer, one of such measures would be to visit any of the countries when necessary rather than allow their residents come into Nigeria. He would also suspend some of his church healing programmes for a few weeks. “I am ready to work with you, I love my country and I will be ready to work with you. Even if it is a rumour, there is need to secure our environment to ensure that it is safe,” Joshua said.

    On the team were the Special Adviser on Information and Strategy, Mr. Lateef Raji, his media counterpart, Mr. Hakeem Bello, and Dr. Frank Mahoney from the CDC.