Tag: Synagogue

  • Synagogue: Coroner suspends Joshua’s invitation

    Synagogue: Coroner suspends Joshua’s invitation

    Relief came the way of the founder of Synagogue Church of All Nations, Prophet Temitope Joshua, on Monday as he has been permitted to stay away from the coroner’s sitting.

    The coroner, Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe, said the invitation earlier extended to Joshua has been suspended.

    Komolafe said at the resumed hearing of the matter on Monday that the suspension of Joshua’s appearance is pending the determination of his suit before Justice Lateefat Okunnu of the Lagos High Court, Ikeja.

    Komolafe had issued witness summons on relevant individuals and institutions, including Joshua to enable them give evidence on the September 12 collapse of a six- storey guest house belonging to the church.

    At least 115 persons, mostly of South Africans died in the incident.

    The coroner had summoned the witnesses under the powers conferred on it by the Lagos State Coroner’s System Law No.7 of 2007.

    But the founder of the Synagogue Church had filed an application before Justice Okunnu, seeking to stay proceedings of the inquest.

    Joshua in the said application dated November 11, 2014, before the court and marked ID/188MJR/2014 had asked for a judicial review of the coroner’s proceedings, which began on October 13.

    He urged the court to declare that his invitation to appear as a witness before the coroner was a breach of his rights to fair hearing, as no case had been established against his person before the coroner.

    He further contested that the coroner had been extending his inquisitions into areas beyond its statutory purview.

     

  • Synagogue: Lagos coroner to rule on stay of inquest December 10

    Synagogue: Lagos coroner to rule on stay of inquest December 10

    The Lagos State coroner’s court will on December 10, 2014 rule on whether or not to stay proceedings on the inquest being made into the collapse building at the Synagogue Church of All Nations, Ikotun.

    The coroner, Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe took the decision after hearing arguments from Joshua’s counsel, Mr Olalekan Ojo and the Lagos State government’s counsel, Mr Akingbolahan Adeniran.

    Founder of the church, Prophet Temitope Joshua had filed an application before the coroner seeking a stay of proceedings on the inquest.

    A total of 115 persons died in the six-storey building that collapsed on September 12, 2014.

    Prophet T.B. Joshua had asked the court to stop further sitting of the coroner’s inquest into the building collapse at the church.

    In the application, Ojo asked the court for an order to stay proceedings on issues relating to calling of witnesses in respect of the building approval or material tests of the collapsed building.

    He had in addition,  asked for an order to suspend further action on the invitation issued to Joshua to appear before the inquest to give evidence.

    He posited that, the stay of proceedings is pending the determination of another suit he had filed against the coroner before Justice Lateefat Okunnu of an Ikeja High Court.

    While moving the application, Ojo argued that the application before the high court was for a judicial review of the inquest.

    He explained that it was intended to ascertain whether the coroner, Komolafe, had exceeded the statutory jurisdiction of the coroner’s court.

    “It is our view that the strict scope of the coroner’s inquest is to ascertain the cause and manner of death and it will be in the best interest of all of us to get a judicial interpretation from a superior court.

    “The best and reasonable cause of action for this court is to stay proceedings of the issues in contention, pending the time the high court will deliver its pronouncement one way or the other,” Ojo said.

    He therefore urged the coroner to accord the high court respect and dignity by not taking any further action that could prejudice the suit before Okunnu.

    But counsel to Lagos State government, Adeniran argued that Section 40 of the Coroner’s System Law empowered the coroner to investigate and determine the cause of death of an individual who died under suspicious circumstances.

    He maintained that the coroner has not exceeded its jurisdiction. “There is nothing in the Coroner’s System Law that reduces its jurisdiction.

    “This honourable court, in our opinion, has not exceeded its jurisdiction,” he said. Adeniran further argued that the suit before Okunnu did not translate to an automatic stay of proceedings of the coroner’s inquest.

    He said:” At the time the high court granted the applicants leave to apply for the judicial review, the judge was in a position to grant them a stay of proceedings but did not.

    “As it stands, there is no order from the high court for a stay of proceedings.” Adeniran also argued that Joshua and the church had not presented sufficient materials before the court to warrant the coroner to exercise his discretion in their favour. He therefore asked the court to dismiss the application.

  • Synagogue: Joshua asks coroner to stop inviting him to sittings

    Synagogue: Joshua asks coroner to stop inviting him to sittings

    The founder of the Synagogue Church of All Nations, Prophet Temitope Joshua, on Wednesday asked the coroner investigating the collapse of a building within the church to stop inviting him to give evidence during its sittings.

    Joshua told the coroner court presided by Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe to stay action on his invitation pending the determination of a suit before Justice Lateefat Okunnu of a Lagos High Court, Ikeja.

    Joshua through an application filed by his counsel, Mr. Olalekan Ojo, also asked the court to stay further proceedings on the inquest pending the determination of his suit against Komolafe before Justice Okunnu.

    In the application before Justice Okunnu, Joshua had asked the court to declare that the invitation asking him to appear as a witness before the coroner was a breach of his right to fair hearing, as no case had been established against his person before the coroner.

    The prophet also urged the court to order the coroner to suspend further proceedings pending when Justice Okunnu would either uphold or reject his prayers.

    “My Lord, most respectfully, we have applied for a judicial review of the proceedings of this honourable court so far. We may be right, we may be wrong, but what we are saying is that this coroner court has been extending and it is still extending its inquisitions into areas outside the statutory jurisdiction of the coroner court. That is our complaint, my Lord.

    “And what we are saying is, if the High Court agrees with us to set aside such portions of the proceedings that it adjudges to have been conducted in excess of jurisdiction, it should prohibit the coroner from further acting in excess of its jurisdiction,” the prophet said in the application.

     

  • Synagogue: Coroner threatens  to arrest absentee witnesses

    Synagogue: Coroner threatens to arrest absentee witnesses

    The Coroner investigating the cause of the building collapse at the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN), Ikotun, a Lagos suburb, yesterday threatened to issue bench warrant against witnesses absent at proceeding.

    At the resumed sitting of the inquest, Coroner Oyetade Komolafe, after taking a roll-call of witnesses present in court, discovered that only the police witness, Olusola Agoyi, was present to continue his testimony.

    The court asked the lawyers representing various agencies for the whereabouts of their witnesses; they assured him that they would turn up as the proceeded.

    Expected to give evidence before the Coroner were Prophet Temitope Joshua; the contractor who handled the project; Lagos State Ministry of Works; Standard Organisation of Nigeria (SON) and the police.

    An angry Komolafe, who said it was obvious his leniency was being trampled upon, added that he would not hesitate to issue bench warrant on any witness who failed to show up at the end of yesterday’s proceedings.

    However, the threat could not be executed as the court’s verbatim recorder developed technical hitch as SON’s witness, Bede Obayi, was giving his evidence.

    Less than two hours into the day’s proceeding, the voice recorder stopped working; hence, the court suspended proceedings for 10 minutes to enable technicians rectify the issue.

    When the court reconvened and the situation was the remedied, Komolafe adjourned proceedings today, but with the threat to issue arrest order of any witness who failed to turn up today.

    Earlier, Obayi, while submitting results of three laboratory findings carried out by SON, stated that the organisation’s findings could not be concluded because they could not speak to the contractor or site engineer of the building, who are crucial to their findings.

    Obayi said he requested to see the contractor and engineers to get information from them but was told they were with other agencies on similar request.

    “The results tendered in court are not enough to conclude because only the contractor and owner of the building have history of the construction and their input are germane.

    “When we visited the site, the church’s Chief Security Officer (CSO) Sunday Okogie conducted us round the place. We collected necessary samples including broken bricks, steel reinforcement bars, nails and other components of the building at the site.

    “Following the unique identification number on the iron rods samples got from the site, we traced the rods to four different companies. We took the samples  to three different laboratories to ensure accuracy of result. One sample was submitted to a neutral steel rolling company, not implicated in the accident; another to the four companies implicated and a third set of samples was submitted for analysis at the SON’s laboratory,” he said.

    Obayi said the laboratories where the tests were carried out were not disclosed to avoid undue influence.

    The police witness, under cross-examination by counsel to Nigerian Airspace Management Agency (NAMA), Opeyemi Ogunleye, said the collapsed building was about 72 feet.

    He said the aircraft flew “at a much lower rate” than the standard 1,500feet given by NAMA, which he said prompted the residents to raise alarm.

    Agoyi said the issue of  “strange” aircraft was incorrect, since it was established through NAMA’s letter that it was an Air Force craft.

    He said since investigations were still ongoing, he could not say which among the three suggested causes was responsible for the mishap. “It could be any of sabotage, aircraft or structural defect. But the investigation is still ongoing,” he said.

  • Synagogue: ‘Strange aircraft’ belongs to Air Force – Police

    Synagogue: ‘Strange aircraft’ belongs to Air Force – Police

    The Police on Wednesday identified the “strange ‎aircraft” that allegedly hovered over the collapsed Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) building was a Nigerian Air Force (NAF) CH 130 Hercules.

    ‎A police witness, Olusola Agboyi (DSP) while testifying before Coroner Oyetade Komolafe stated that the aircraft which was on a circuit training mission, flew at very low altitude.

    “I recorded statements from 34 witnesses who claimed the aircraft was flying very low and had caused panic among residents of the Ikotun area,” said Agboyi.

    He stated that preliminary reports suggested the foreign guest house might have caved-in as a result of internal saboteurs-visitors or lodgers at the premises.

    He said the saboteur, undetected, could have used explosives or chemical substances to bring down the building.

    Agboyi said he interviewed one of the survivors, Taiwo Temitayo Taiwo, who claimed he heard a thunderous noise and saw lightening moments before the building came crashing.

    The witness said he led the team that investigated the collapse and was also a member of the Federal Government’s panel.

    He, however, noted that the police did not rule out the possibility of structural defect but had not get a reply to the letter the agency wrote to the Lagos State Ministry of Works requesting a test on materials used at the site.

  • Synagogue: Court dismisses suit seeking to stop inquest

    Synagogue: Court dismisses suit seeking to stop inquest

    The Federal High Court in Lagos yesterday dismissed a suit filed by a lawyer, Mr Olukoya Ogugbeje, seeking to stop the inquest on the collapse of a building at the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN), Ikotun in Lagos.

    The collapse, which occurred on September 12, resulted in the death of over 115 people, mostly South Africans.

    Ogungbeje had claimed the inquest was constituted after the state’s agencies had indicted the church’s founder Prophet T.B Joshua by concluding that he added structures on the building without approval.

    According to him, the Joshua’s right to fair hearing will likely be unfairly trampled upon by the respondents, namely Lagos State, the Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice Mr Adeola Ipaye and the District Coroner Magistrate Oyetade Komolafe.

    Dismissing the case, Justice Buba held that the applicant lacked the locus standi to institute it.

    He said Ogungbeje’s fundamental rights has not been breached in any manner, adding that the church does not fall within the category of a “vulnerable” entity on which behalf a human rights action can be brought.

    “Are Synagogue Church and Prophet T.B. Joshua ‘vulnerable section of the society’? It is the society that has become vulnerable to the church by losing over 100 lives,” the judge held.

    Besides, he said the application was not brought on the church’s behalf or Joshua’s – and was not even in the members’ interest.

    “TB Joshua and Synagogue church are not in detention or incapacitated to come to court. This case must be distinguished from cases brought on behalf of deceased persons whose right to life are being enforced or sought to be established,” the judge said.

    Justice Buba said the lawyer completely misconceived the role of government’s agencies, saying the fact they indicted Joshua does not mean the coroner, which is not a court of law, has already made up his mind.

    He said if, for instance, the prosecution strongly believes that a person is guilty and brings a charge against him, it does not mean the judge must make a conviction or that the accused would not get a fair hearing.

    Justice Buba said besides the fact the coroner’s inquest is not a court of law but a fact-finding entity, Prophet Joshua and his church “are not complaining”.

    “Supposing they are satisfied with what was said or alleged, what is the right of the applicant being infringed upon that the court can proceed to protect?” he asked.

    According to the judge, Ogungbeje did not show any threat or injury he would suffer with the inquest, nor did he disclose a legal or justiceable right to protect.

    “A trial court will only have jurisdiction to enforce the fundamental rights of an applicant guaranteed under Chapter 4 of the constitution if the main reliefs involve a breach of the fundamental rights of the applicant,” he said.

    The judge said the coroner was set up by the state executive, and by the principles of separation of powers, the court would not ordinarily interfere in the workings of another arm of government.

    “After a calm consideration of all the issues and arguments, the applicant has failed to make a case for the enforcement of fundamental rights.

    “The case lacks merit, same be and is hereby dismissed,” Justice Buba held.

    The inquest was constituted on September 26 under the Coroner’s System Law No. 7 of 2007 to investigate the causes and circumstances surrounding the building’s collapse.

    Ogungbeje sought an order nullifying the inquest proceedings so far, as well as a perpetual injunction restraining the respondents from calling further witnesses.

    He prayed the court to stop them from sitting, investigating, embarking on fact-finding or taking any untoward action in any manner whatsoever on any facts connected to the case.

  • Synagogue: Bring back 11 bodies, South Africa demands

    Synagogue: Bring back 11 bodies, South Africa demands

    Efforts are now being escalated to ensure that the bodies of 11 people who died in the Synagogue Church of All Nations building collapse are returned to South Africa, that country’s Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa said in Pretoria yesterday.

    “We will intensify our efforts to ensure that the bodies still in Nigeria are returned without delay,” he said at a ceremony at the Waterkloof air force base, marking the arrival of the bodies of 74 victims.

    “President [Jacob] Zuma has made a commitment that we need to make sure that we leave no stone unturned, and that all 85 must be brought back home.

    “But that is dependent on the Nigerian authorities who are responsible for these DNA samples. We are going to work with them to ensure that eventually, [the other victims]… are brought back when it is humanly and scientifically possible,” Minister in the South African Presidency, Jeff Radebe, said.

    The sombre-looking families were glued to large television screens fixed near a stage.

    The family members arrived in batches, and were ushered to chairs decorated in black cloth.

    In the hangar, reporters were separated from the families by a rope.

    Soldiers stood by with R5 rifles. Numerous paramedics were also in the room.

    The SA Police Service brass band delivered a rendition of the 1862 American civil war song “Battle Cry of Freedom” written by American composer George Frederick Root.

    Paramedics rushed towards some family members who began to weep hysterically as director-general in the South Africa Presidency Cassius Lubisi read out the names of the dead.

    Only 74 of the expected 85 bodies of victims were returned to South Africa – apparently due to DNA sampling that still needed to be done by the Lagos State Government medical team.

    It has been nearly two months wait for the bodies of 81 South Africans, three Zimbabweans and one Congolese national using South African travel papers, among the 116 people  – who died in the building, serving as a guest house within the church premises in Ikotun on the outskirt of Lagos.

  • Synagogue: South Africa collects citizens’ remains

    Synagogue: South Africa collects citizens’ remains

    •Chief Medical Examiner, S/Africa team in face-off

    THE Chief Medical Examiner of Lagos State and Consultant Forensic Pathologist, Prof. John Obafunwa, has released 66 bodies  of persons that died in the September 12  collapse of the guest house, owned by the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN), in Lagos.

    The release of the bodies was done at the General Hospital, Mainland, Yaba under the supervision of the chief medical examiner, when 40 bodies were released to the team that represented the South Africa Government; while Dr. Soyemi supervised the second leg at Isolo General Hospital, where 26 bodies were released.

    Each of the 66 bodies released at the General Hospital,  Yaba was put in a three layer bag, consisting of a clear bag; normal body bag with continent pad linen and finally in an Insulated bag.

    The Nation gathered that two planes arrived in the country from South Africa at midnight for the recovery of the bodies from Nigeria and flown them back home. A cargo plane flew in four trucks and six pick up vans.

    The four trucks are disaster refrigerated vans and two were stationed at each of the hospital, while the six pick up vans were loaded with utilities, medical devices, water, edibles, two collapsible tents and other items needed in such exercise. Three of the pick-up vans were drafted to the two different hospitals, to enable the team from South Africa have every-thing that was needed, including edible and trash nylon bags to carry away the disposable personal protective equipment (PPEs) used for the exercise. The team flew in, in the second plane.

    Giving an insight into the decision of the South African Government to send four pathological trucks and six pick–ups, Obafunwa said it portrayed the  preparedness  of the South African government.

    He said, “The South African government took the samples of the relations that presented themselves and sent samples to the laboratory in South Africa. I have done my professional bit on the bodies here. Out of the 80 bodies, 60 are South Africans.  When the results came here, we only did identification (cross matched). The bodies have been labeled and once they get to South Africa, their relations will just pick them up.”

    Asked why South Africa had to send trucks, tents and other materials, Obafunwa retorted, “They brought in everything including trolleys, dustbins, and water. The South Africans decided to bring in all these. It is puzzling that Nigeria can conveniently provide 10 to 20 of this, yet, none is in existence. I don’t see any reason why each state cannot provide its own disaster refrigerated vans. It is highly useful in the scene of mass disaster. One doesn’t need to take in a  body into a building, but with this disaster refrigerated vans; one can carry out forensic analyses.”

    He, however, admitted that disaster management in Lagos State has improved.  According to him, “So many years ago, I talked about disaster management. The government set up a committee for managing disasters; we have been rehearsing for a situation like this. Each individual knows what role to play in disaster management, so that in less than 24 hours, there is response. Lagos State has improved on its Coroner Laws. We can no longer be doing mass burial. You recall the Dana crash where we identified 148 of the 152 bodies. And Associated Airline crash, where we associated all the bodies. With Synagogue’s case, we will know how many we have been able to identify. I also know that Lagos State has in the pipeline a Forensic Science laboratory. It has already acquired about five acres of land. The state has been able to put together a sketch of how the forensic laboratory would be. It is of note that South Africa has not complained about how we handled the forensic investigation.  We have been working together.”

    Obafunwa further added, “What we are dealing with here is a situation where over 60 South Africans are involved. Individuals could have come to collect their corpses, but the South African government said it is its responsibility to collect the over 80 bodies. In doing so, it decided to plan to do it this way instead of moving them individually in caskets. In my own judgment, I don’t see this South African government bringing in this paraphernalia as a show off, but this is just keeping to the standards. There are a lot of things we need to do in terms of managing disaster, in terms of response, a functional forensic laboratory for instance. Those are failure of a nation. Bringing in these things is not indictment, but something we should copy.”

    At this juncture, a South African told  Obafunwa, “You are obscuring the process of bringing out the bodies, Prof., mind moving away?”

    The renowned pathologist in response said, “I am not obscuring anything. I am part of the team involved in this. I repeat, I am not obscuring anything.”

    The South African went further, “We are saying… (Prof Obafunwa cuts in)

    But the South African went on to speak with some members of his team in South African language. To which Obafunwa replied, “Excuse me; don’t let us get in to that at all.”

    Members of both sides were getting agitated with the South African team later leaving the spot.

    The chief medical examiner now faced the reporter saying, “I have been working with them for some time. I have made them realise they can’t talk to me in those lines. I have had series of meetings with them and they were surprised at some of the facilities at LASUTH (Lagos University Teaching Hospital). There is something I’m proud of in Lagos State. The mortuary is far better than most mortuaries we have around the globe. That I can give credit to Lagos State Government for.”

     

  • Synagogue building: 66 South African corpses released

    Synagogue building: 66 South African corpses released

    Sixty-six corpses of South African victims of the September 12 collapsed guest house, owned by the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) in Lagos have been released.

    Forty bodies were released to South Africa Government officials by the Chief Medical Examiner of Lagos State Professor John Obafunwa at the General Hospital, Yaba and 26 others at Isolo General Hospital,

    The Nation gathered that two planes arrived the country from South Africa Friday midnight for conveying them back home.

  • Synagogue: Sabotage not ruled out – Police

    Synagogue: Sabotage not ruled out – Police

    Lagos rejects moves to stop inquest

    The Nigeria Police on Thursday said there is a possibility of controlled demolition of the Synagogue Church of All Nations building which killed 116 people in September 12.

    A police witness and the Divisional Police Officer of Ikotun Police Division, Haruna Alaba (CSP), said this at the ongoing Coronary Inquest into the cause of the mishap on Thursday.

    Meanwhile, the court has ordered the police to provide the certified true copy of the Ikotun police division diary of the incident, starting from September 12 to 18.

    Komolafe also ordered the church to provide the CCTV footages of activities at the scene from the day of the collapse to the last day of rescue operation.

    Alaba while testifying before Coroner Oyetade Komolafe said from the CCTV footage he watched, the building came down like a controlled demolition.

    The DPO told the court that the police had about 12 vehicles at the church premises on the day of the incident, including three that were donated by (Joshua’s) Emmanuel TV‎.

    He said all possibilities including structural defect and sabotage from external forces were being investigated, just as he admitted that the police did not demand for the manifest of occupants or the original CCTV footage in the course of his investigation.

    Alaba indicated that there were several security lapses at the church and area, which might have caused sabotage.

    He told the court that though it was not the first time aircrafts would fly in the Ikotun area, the “strange aircraft” according to eyewitnesses, flew so low that it mitigated unprecedented fear.

    The DPO said he was the first person to arrive the scene after receiving a call from the command control room, asking the Area M, Idimu command to investigate purported strange aircraft at Ikotun.

    He said they contacted police officers attached to the airport the same day to find out if there was any training but no reply was received.

    Meanwhile, Lagos State government on Thursday urged the Federal High Court to dismiss a suit filed by a lawyer, Mr. Olukoya Ogugbeje, seeking to stop inquest into the church’s collapsed building.

    The state government said the inquest was not set up to convict anyone, adding that the applicant lacks the locus standi (legal right) to institute the action.

    The state’s Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, Mr. Adeola Ipaye and the District Coroner Magistrate, Oyetade Komolafe are the respondents.

    The inquest was constituted on September 26 under the Coroner’s System Law No. 7 of 2007 to investigate the causes and circumstances surrounding the incident.