Tag: Taraba State

  • Taraba security has Improved significantly, says Kefas

    Taraba security has Improved significantly, says Kefas

    Taraba Governor Agbu Kefas said the sustained presence of Nigerian Army personnel has resulted in “visible and measurable improvements” in the security environment of the state.

    The Governor spoke when he, with federal legislators from the State and members of the Executive Council of the International Institute for African Defense Security and Governance, visited the Army Headquarters in Abuja, on Tuesday.

    The Governor applauded the “strong inter-agency cooperation” among security agencies operating in the state and highlighted areas requiring reinforced military presence. 

    He reaffirmed the State Government’s commitment to strengthening support for the Nigerian Army, including providing accommodation for deployed troops, and pledged to sustain a united, steel-hard front against insecurity.

    Read Also: ‘Why we charged Sowore over false claim against Tinubu,’ by DSS

    The Chief of Army Staff (COAS), Lieutenant General Waidi Shaibu,  emphasised the Army’s resolve to uphold its constitutional mandate to support civil authorities in maintaining peace and security nationwide.

    He noted that Taraba State occupies a strategic position within the nation’s security architecture, given its terrain and security dynamics.

    The COAS commended the governor for his “decisive leadership and effective coordination” with security agencies, stressing that enduring peace requires close collaboration between civil and military institutions.

    He described the State Government’s support, particularly the donation of land and the provision of operational equipment, as critical force multipliers that have significantly enhanced the tempo, reach and effectiveness of military operations in the region.

    The COAS appealed for continued partnership and requested the governor’s support in providing stable electricity to the 20 Model Battalion, Sarti and 93 Battalion. He noted that improved power supply would directly enhance operational efficiency, combat readiness and troop welfare.

    The COAS called for intensified public sensitisation across Taraba State, urging citizens to actively support security operations by providing timely and credible intelligence.

    “Community cooperation remains a decisive weapon in defeating terrorists and other criminal elements,” he said.

  • Eight shocking details in dismissal of police constable who stole a goat

    Eight shocking details in dismissal of police constable who stole a goat

    A shocking twist in Taraba State has exposed the embarrassing downfall of a serving police constable whose career came to an abrupt end, not in a blaze of glory but in the quiet theft of a goat.

     In what many have called a disgrace to the uniform, Police Constable Usman Mohammed, serving at the Mutum Biyu Division under the Taraba Police Command, was officially dismissed from the Nigeria Police Force on August 15, 2025, after being caught stealing a goat. 

    The incident, bizarre as it sounds, was not a social media rumor or an internal cover-up, it was handled through formal disciplinary procedures, and the result was decisive: immediate dismissal.

     8 Key discoveries from the incident:

    1. The theft happened on duty:

    PC Usman Mohammed reportedly committed the theft while still on active duty, raising serious concerns about discipline and integrity within the force.

    2. The target was a goat:

    The stolen item wasn’t money, drugs or weapons but adomesticated goat, which he allegedly stole for personal use.

    3. He was caught red-handed:

    Usman Mohammed was caught in the act by community members, not fellow officers. He was apprehended and the situation escalated quickly.

    4. Evidence was submitted:

    Photographic and eyewitness evidence played a role in confirming his guilt. Locals reportedly documented the incident before handing him over to police authorities.

    5. Disciplinary action followed immediately:

    Following due process under Regulation 370 of the Police Act (2010, as amended), a disciplinary panel found him guilty of gross misconduct.

    6. CP ordered immediate dismissal:

    The Commissioner of Police in Jalingo sent an official signal ordering his dismissal. The directive was firm and swift.

    Read Also: Fake soldier, serving police officer to die by hanging for armed robbery

    7. All Police items tetrieved:

    The constable’s uniform, ID card and any police-issued equipment were collected immediately upon dismissal. His access to official systems and pay was revoked.

    8. His service record updated with dismissal status:

    To close the chapter, his official police file was marked with dismissal status, which disqualifies him from any future government security appointments.

    This scandal, while seemingly minor compared to more serious police misconduct, struck a nerve with the public because of its symbolism, a law enforcement officer turning thief, even for something as small as a goat ,represents a serious breach of trust. It also raises broader concerns about the vetting, discipline, and welfare of officers in low-income divisions.

  • Constituent gives kudos to senator for impactful projects

    Constituent gives kudos to senator for impactful projects

    A constituent in Southern Taraba, Yamujeh Usman Ba’aga, has commended Senator Emmanuel Bwacha, for his “unparalleled record of development, empowerment, and responsive leadership” in southern senatorial zone of Taraba State.

    In a statement yesterday, Ba’aga said the senator’s work has “set a new standard for representation,” noting the broad array of infrastructural and humanitarian interventions that have reshaped lives and communities in the zone.

    “Senator Bwacha is not just a lawmaker; he is a builder of hope and opportunity,” Ba’aga said. “His name rings across the length and breadth of the zone not just for promises made, but for promises kept.”

    He listed developments facilitated by the senator—from rural electrification in communities like Nyivo and Mararraba, to rehabilitation of the once-neglected Donga–Mararraba road—as proof of a leadership model rooted in action.

    “In places where darkness once defined the nights, Senator Bwacha brought light. Where roads were death traps, he brought access and dignity. This is the kind of impact that cannot be erased from our memory,” Ba’aga noted.

    Education, healthcare, and digital inclusion were also cited as major areas of intervention. According to Ba’aga, Bwacha’s efforts to equip science laboratories at Federal University in Wukari, establish ICT centres, and provide scholarship to over 260 students have had ripple effects in families and future generations.

    “The youth are not left behind. Whether through scholarship, vocational training, or employment facilitation, he has kept them in focus,” Ba’aga said, referencing over 500 federal jobs and empowerment of more than 750 youths through skill programmes under National Directorate of Employment.

    The constituent further noted the senator’s robust security interventions, including establishment of new police divisions in Mararraba and Donga, donation of patrol vehicles, and installation of streetlights in towns like Takum and Wukari to improve public safety.

    In a zone plagued by communal tensions and infrastructural neglect, Ba’aga said the senator’s leadership has created a “blueprint for peace and development,” noting the provision of boreholes, grinding machines, tricycles, motorcycles, and other economic relief items as critical buffers against poverty and displacement.

    Read Also: Okoro launches “Go talent hunt season one” to discover Nigeria’s next photography talents

    Healthcare delivery received a boost under the senator’s watch, with construction of a modern primary health centre in Mararraba and support for maternal and child health.

    “In every corner—urban or rural—there is a footprint of Senator Bwacha’s service. He has responded to the pressing needs of people with thoughtfulness and resolve,” he said.

    The senator praised the senator for supporting the justice system through construction of a new magistrate court and transportation logistics for agricultural and community-based initiatives.

    Ba’aga concluded by urging upcoming political leaders to emulate the senator’s approach to public service, which he described as people-focused, inclusive, and sustainable.

    “In a time when trust in public office is low, Senator Bwacha reminds us that leadership can still be a force for good. He is a beacon of hope and a reference point for what democratic dividends should truly look like,” the statement read.

    Senator Bwacha, a former Deputy Senate Minority Leader, has served multiple terms representing the Taraba South Senatorial District. His development-oriented politics continues to draw attention both within and outside Taraba State.

  • Soldiers kill bandit, recover arms in Taraba

    Soldiers kill bandit, recover arms in Taraba

    Troops of 6 Brigade Nigerian Army/Sector 3 Operation Whirl Stroke (OPWS)  have gunned down a suspected bandit  and recovered some arms in Taraba State.

    According to the spokesman of the brigade, Olubodunde Oni, in a statement, on May 3, the troops at Gafar Village in Ussa Local Government Area, received information that bandits were exploiting a crossing point to harass locals and steal their motorcycles and other valuables.

    Read Also: 30% Value-Addition Policy – Nigeria’s great economic weapon 

    Troops moved to the area and engaged the criminals in a gun battle. One bandit died during the encounter, the others fled while an AK-47 rifle and a motorcycle stolen from a civilian were recovered.

    Oni added that troops also acted on an information that some suspected bandits were moving from Tongo and Garin Alkali in Adamawa State to Shana community in Bali Local Government Area of Taraba State.

  • Taraba State strengthens environmental conservation with private partnership

    Taraba State strengthens environmental conservation with private partnership

    Taraba State Government has strengthened its environmental conservation agenda through a strategic partnership with the Africa Nature Investors (ANI) Foundation.

    The Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed by the state and ANI focused on enhancing protection and sustainable management of the expansive Gashaka Gumti National Park, which spans Taraba and Adamawa states.

    European Union (EU) Ambassador to Nigeria and ECOWAs, Gautier Mignot, who paid a courtesy visit to Governor Agbu Kefas after visiting Gashaka Gumti National Park, had described the park as “jewel of nature” and a great asset for Taraba and Adamawa states. 

    The MoU between Taraba State and ANI positioned the park as a catalyst for development in the state and outlined collaboration between ANI and Taraba State on eco-tourism, culture, agriculture, pastoralism, education and health.

    The MoU also buttressed the state’s resolve to tackle deforestation, and the illegal wildlife trade.

    The new partnership complemented Taraba State’s efforts to achieve key Sustainable Development Goals by addressing climate change, improving education and healthcare access, while promoting inclusive economic growth.

    Taraba State Governor, Agbu Kefas, said the partnership demonstrated the state’s commitment to conservation that delivers tangible benefits for its communities.

    Read Also: World Bank meetings 2025: Enilolobo seeks single digit credit for young Nigerian entrepreneurs

    According to him, Gashaka Gumti National Park represents both an ecological treasure and a significant economic asset capable of generating employment and attracting investment to Taraba State.

    He noted how the national park had attracted the attention of the EU to Taraba State and prayed for more of such.

    “We will work closely with ANI to ensure that the park is effectively managed and that the benefits of conservation are shared equitably among our communities,” Kefas said.

    Executive Director, ANI Foundation, Tunde Morakinyo, said the collaboration would ensure the park becomes a model for sustainable development, balancing ecological preservation with economic progress.

    He said the MoU positions Taraba State at the forefront of Nigeria’s conservation efforts, showcasing how environmental protection can drive sustainable development.

    He noted that as the world marked the 55th anniversary of Earth Day with its focus on tripling renewable energy capacity by 2030, which is growing in Nigeria as well, some states in Nigeria are becoming more involved in the protection of biodiversity and effective management of national parks to drive economic development.

    According to him, Taraba State’s initiative highlights the growing recognition of biodiversity protection as a cornerstone of economic planning.

    He added that the partnership serves as a blueprint for other states seeking to harmonise environmental conservation with development objectives.

  • Taraba, blockchain giant to empower youths

    Taraba, blockchain giant to empower youths

    Algorand Foundation, with Taraba State, has initiated programmes to drive blockchain technology adoption and digitisation to enhance economic growth and empower youths.

    Country Head of Algorand in Nigeria, Ben Onuoha, spoke at the closing of a Regional Hackathon in Jalingo.

    He noted that the Algorand Hackathon would serve as an educational experience to build solutions and explore innovations towards development of Taraba and Nigeria.

    Onuoha said the workshop would equip web developers to understand how blockchain technology works and equip them with tech skills to be industry ready professionals.

    Read Also: EFCC fires two staff over corrupt practices

    Onuoha added the event, with over 100 participants, would end with a competition  where winners get prizes.

     He praised Governor Agbu Kefas for creating the Ministry of Digital Economy and Innovations, adding the impact would be great on youths.He advised  youths to take advantage of the partnership and the platform intended to stimulate economic growth.

    Commissioner for Digital Economy and Innovation, Gideon Nonso, hailed Algorand for its interest in the state, assuring them of government’s commitment towards enabling atmosphere for investors.

    He stressed need for collaboration and creativity in advancing technological growth towards  development.

    A participant, Philemon Yakubu, hailed Taraba and Algorand for the opportunity given to youths. Yakubu said the workshop would enhance the state’s digital economy.

  • Hope for Tiv, Jukun enduring peace

    New move by some stakeholders to broker peace between the warring Tiv community of Taraba State and Jukun community of Benue State yielded some level of success as the communities signed a peace deal that will lead to cessation of hostilities. FANEN IHYONGO reports that the 30-man committee insisted on a ceasefire between the communities to allow peace to reign.

     

    THE Jukun and Tiv ethnic groups of Southern Taraba have been at daggers drawn for some time now. Several efforts made in the past to bring about lasting peace between these two neighbours have been futile. For about six months, the two ethnic groups have been at war.

    However, fresh moves to resolve the crisis by stakeholders from Tiv and Junkun seem to bear fruits. The stakeholders succeeded in making the warring communities sign a new peace deal, even as they called for suspension of hostilities.

    The stakeholders have directed that all road-blocks in the affected communities should be dismantled and all local markets in the areas reopened.

    They also called for the release of all victims who were kidnapped during the hostilities. They also urged government to provide relief materials and ensure the return of all displaced people to their ancestral homes.

    At the two-day peace talks which held at the weekend, the 30-man committee insisted that there should be a ceasefire to allow peace to reign.

    The committee, set up by Governor Darius Ishaku, has 15 representatives from the Tiv and 15 from Jukun communities. The representatives were drawn from the affected areas which include Wukari, Donga and Takum.

    This is the second committee to be set by the governor since the crisis erupted on April 1.

    The first committee, which had five representatives from Jukun of Taraba and five representatives from Tiv of Benue State, was rejected by a Taraba Tiv youth group for the non-inclusion of Tivs from the affected areas.

    It was gathered that the committee, which was mobilised with N30 million to stop the violence, sat for most or all of the time outside Taraba and could not achieve success, as the killings continued.

    Hundreds of Jukun and Tiv have lost their lives to the crisis while properties, including homes and food stuffs estimated at billions of naira have been destroyed.

    The Federal University in Wukari was shut down as violence spilled to the campus.

    The crisis is an offshoot of a lingering feud based on a claim by the Jukun that the Tiv are “settlers,” in Taraba State, and therefore, have no ownership rights to the land they occupy.

    The conflict first erupted in 1959. It reoccurred in 1980, 1990, 2001 and this year.

    The latest crisis reached a crescendo when a 42-year-old cleric, Rev. Fr. David Tanko, a peace broker, was killed and set ablaze. The priest’s murder prompted President Muhammadu Buhari to call for a peace dialogue between Tiv and Jukun from Taraba and Benue states respectively.

    During the meeting, which was held at the Shehu Musa Yar’Adua Centre, Abuja, Benue State Governor Samuel Ortom proposed that the Federal Government should set up a commission of enquiry into the crisis.

    But Taraba State Governor Darius Ishaku strongly objected to the idea of bringing a “stranger” into the matter. He suggested that “the problem is ours; it’s an internal problem; we shall look into it and resolve it.”

    Upon his return to the state, Ishaku set up the new committee and gave the warring groups a seven-day ultimatum to sheathe their swords for the committee to work effectively.

    The new committee, which has been hailed by all as likely to succeed, is to examine and bring to an end all issues underlying persistent violent clashes between Jukun and Tiv ethnic groups.

    The committee held a peace dialogue in the Executive Chamber of Government House, Jalingo the Taraba State capital. In their midst were the Secretary to the State Government (SSG) Anthony Jellason, representatives of the police, army, Civil Defence Corps and the Department of State Services (DSS).

    Others in attendance included representatives of the Christian Association of Nigeria (CAN) and other religious bodies as well as representatives of the Jukun, Tiv and Etulo communities from the affected local government areas. All the attending groups made their presentations.

    The meeting was chaired by the Taraba State Deputy Governor, Haruna Manu, who, together with the SSG on behalf of the state government, signed the communique that was issued at the end of the meeting.

    Danjuma Adamu, Markus Ikitsombika and John Mamman signed the communique for the Jukun community while Jime Yongo, Kurason Kura and Isaac Waakaa signed for the Tiv community.

    The communique reads: “Speakers at the meeting condemned the crisis and stressed the need for cessation of all forms of hostilities between the two communities to pave way for the peace building effort being spearheaded by the state government.

    “The crisis had been hijacked by criminals from both the Jukun and Tiv communities and therefore, the two communities should expose the criminals among them.

    “We also resolved to, henceforth, stop reprisal attacks or revenge from both parties, but report all forms of security breaches to security agencies for appropriate action.

    “There is need for the government to take deliberate steps to encourage the Internally Displaced People (IDPs) to return to their homes, since adequate security operatives have been deployed in the affected communities to protect lives and property.”

    The committee advised the Jukun and Tiv communities to be wary of rumours that are capable of inciting them and destabilising the peace process.

    One of the signatories of the communique, Danjuma Adamu, revealed that during the peace meeting, the committee split into Team Tiv and Team Jukun to sketch their submissions.

    “We in the Team Jukun were just clapping as the Tiv made their presentation. The issues they raised were exactly the same with ours, as if they spied or copied from us.

    “So, it was not difficult marrying or harmonising the two submissions. We just adopted them.

    “That was victory number one. It means the problem is an internal one, and we know it. It means we can solve the problem by ourselves.

    “In doing this, we must be sincere to ourselves. Any criminal element among us must be fished out, punished and treated as a criminal. With this, the committee shall succeed,” he told The Nation.

    Also in a chat with The Nation on the telephone, Isaac Waakaa, a Tiv member of the committee, said the committee will achieve the needed result.

    Waakaa said: “The committee will succeed because it captured the actual environment of the crisis and the people that are directly affected.

    “If there is crisis in Taraba because someone is killed in Taraba, and you bring somebody from outside to resolve the matter, it will be an exercise in futility, because the outsider is not familiar with the terrain, the people and their cultures.

    “In this committee, we know all the people representing the Jukun community and they know us all.

    “Secondly, all the issues the committee has raised are genuinely correct. The next step is to look into the issues, which is what we have started.”

    Waakaa, however, noted that the Jukun/Tiv crisis is a “recurring feud” as such; the committee would need time in tackling the issues involved.

    “Our work is a peace-building process that is not achievable in a hurry,” he said.

    He observed that there are other personalities who were not invited to be part of the committee.

    “In trying to solve a problem, you involve everybody concerned. In this case, you involve them to aid the peace-building process, not to truncate it. That is why we are going to consult those out there who are not members of this committee whom we are convinced know better than we do.

    “So, everyone affected is involved. We are only representing them in tackling the issues. So far, I don’t think there is any shortcoming with the committee, and I am sure it will succeed,” he said.

  • Wadume: military, police tango over trial

    THE Army and the Police appear not to have found a common ground on the trial of suspects implicated in the killing of the Police Intelligence Response Team (IRT) operatives by soldiers in Taraba State on August 6.

    Suspected kidnap kingpin Hamisu Bala (aka Wadume) was being taken to the Police Command in Jalingo, the state capital, when the operatives were attacked by soldiers believed to be loyal to Wadume.

    They freed the kidnap suspect, but he was re-arrested.

    The army launched a probe, but some forces are said to be mounting pressure on the authorities to treat the investigative panel’s report as “classified”.

    It was learnt that the military has been reluctant to release its officers and men allegedly involved in the attack to the police for trial.

    Sources said the police and the military have not found a common ground on how to go about the trial.

    It was gathered that the military does not want to subjugate itself to the police, which is statutorily empowered to try the suspects.

    Besides Wadume, over 13 other suspects had been under investigation since a ring behind the killings was uncovered.

    Sources who know about the army-police rivalry said Wadume and other suspects might not be arraigned soon if the situation is not quickly resolved.

    They alleged that some forces do not want the report of the investigative panel released for “security reasons.”

    A source: “There seems to be a long silence and unusual delay in charging the suspects to court following refusal by the panel to make the outcome of its investigation public and hand over suspects to the relevant authority for prosecution.

    Read Also: Wadume is still in our custody – Police source

    “Efforts made in the past to know the outcome of the panel investigation has proved unsuccessful following refusal by the military and the police to speak on it.

    “The military has the suspected officers and men in its custody and the police have the civilian suspects in their custody.

    “Both agencies have to come together for the trial to take place. But there appears to be no synergy between them.”

    On what was delaying the prosecution, another source said: “The military does not prosecute; it is the police that do.

    “All the military needs to do is to hand over suspects to the police. The facts are clear. They are using the instrumentality of the panel to cause unnecessary delay. The question is: why is it taking them so long to investigate?”

    Asked why Wadume has not been charged, Force Spokesman Frank Mba said: “The right people to answer that question would be the panel members.

    “They do not have powers to prosecute but until they are done with everything, prosecution may not take place.

    “I am not a member of the panel and I don’t speak for the panel, so I am unable to speak about the panel, the status of their investigation, the contents of their report, the summary of their recommendations as well as other things relating to their activities.”

    On Wadume’s whereabouts, Mba said: “The only thing I can say is that Wadume is in the custody of government security agents but I will not speak as to which agency and as to his location.”

  • Taraba killings: Police, Army can’t go their separate ways, says Gambari

    ELDER statesman and former Nigeria’s Ambassador to the United Nations (UN), Prof. Ibrahim Gambari, on Tuesday said the recent killing of three police detectives and a civilian in Taraba State should not compel the police and the Army to go their separate ways.

    Gambari, who said there is urgent need for a national conversation on the nation’s security challenges, warned that if the police and the Army went their separate ways, security would be compromised.

    The retired ambassador called for continuous collaboration and dialogue between the police and the Army as well as among the nation’s security agencies.

    He said the civil society, traditional institutions and religious bodies should support and provide intelligence for the security agencies to tackle the security challenging facing the country.

    Gambari advised the Federal Government to adopt parts of the recommendations of the 2014 Constitutional Conference to address the myriad of challenges facing the country.

    Read Also: Taraba governorship tribunal adjourns for judgment

    The former ambassador noted that some recommendations of the conference would enable the government to tackle the nation’s security challenges, especially in the areas of community police or state police.

    He advised the government not to throw away the baby with the bath water.

    Gambari addressed reporters after delivering an address as the chairman of a security summit with the theme: Terrorism, Insurgency and Incidence of Electoral Violence in Nigeria: The Role of Security Agencies.

    It was organised by the Nigerian Army Resource Centre (NARC) and the New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD) at NARC office in Asokoro, Abuja.

    Gambari said: “We cannot leave everything to the police and the Army, even leaving highway patrols to Army. The level of the challenge will weaken the police and overstretch the Army.

    “There is need for continuous process of collaboration and synergy between the police and the Army to avoid the Taraba scenario in future. If everybody goes their separate ways, the security of the nation will be compromised.

    “Then, again, we need to assist the police and other security agencies with intelligence and all members of the society, including traditional rulers and religious leaders. We have to look at those institutions that worked in the past and try to really use them in collaborative effort because security is the business of all of us.

    “For community policing, we need a conversation in this country, very urgently, whether it is community police, whether it is state police.”

     

  • Tribunal dismisses petitions against four N/Assembly seats in Taraba

    THE Taraba State National and State House of Assembly Elections Petition Tribunal, sitting in Abuja on Saturday dismissed four petitions seeking to void election into four National Assembly seats from the state.

    The three-member tribunal, led by Justice Eyewumi Oritsejafor, in separate judgments, found that the petitioners failed to establish their cases against the respondents.

    The tribunal also observed some deficient  errors committed by lawyers in some of the petitions, among which were failure to pay the mandatory filing fees at the point of submitting the petition and non-inclusion of necessary parties.

    The four petitions include  one against the senatorial election in Taraba South Senatorial district and three against House of Representatives elections in Ibi/Wukari; Jalingo/Yorro/Zing and Bali/Gassol Federal Constituencies.

    The affected petitions include the one filed by Bauka Ishaya Gamgum of  the All Progressives Congress (APC) against the election of Senator Emmanuel Bwacha representing Taraba South Senatorial district on the platform of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), marked: EPT/TR/SEN/03/2019, and that filed by Prof Haruna Yakubu of the Action Alliance (AA) against the election of Usman Danjuma Siddi (aka Danji SS) of the All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA) for the Ibi/Wukari Federal Constituency in the House of Representatives, marked: EPT/TR/HR/01/2019.

    The third, marked: EPT/TR/HR/02/2019, was filed by Hassan Bappa of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), against the victory recorded by the candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in Jalingo/ Yorro /Zing Federal Constituency.

    The forth petition, marked: EPT/TR/HR/06/2019, was filed by Adamu Maikarfi Tanko of the PDP, against the candidate of the APC in the election in Bali/Gassol Federal Constituency.

    The first of the judgements was on the petition by Gamgum, the lead of which was delivered by Justice Oritsejafor, in which he held, among others, that the petitioners failed to prove their claim of over-voting and substantial non-compliance.

    Justice Oritsejafor, who noted that the petitioners’ main contention was over-voting, was hinged on their wrong understanding of what over-voting entails.

    The judge held that by the provision  of Section 53(2) of the Electoral Act, over-voting could only arise where votes cast exceeding the number of registered voters in a particular polling unit.

    He faulted the petitioners’ argument that a petitioner can establish over-voting once he/she shows that the  total number of votes cast exceed the total number of registered voters, through card reader results.

    Justice Orisejafor also faulted the type of witnesses called by the petitioners and held that they failed to call relevant witnesses.

    He said “the polling units agents are in vantage position to give direct evidence about what occurred in the polling units in question.

    “It is always better to calling officers, who were on ground at the polling units to testify as to what occurred at the polling units where the claim of over voting is concerned.”

    Justice Oritsejafor added that the petitioners’ failure to call polling units agents, who were present when the entries in the result sheets were made, as witnesses in their effort to establish their claim of over-voting, was a fatal error.

    The judge held that the petitioners failed to prove any of the grounds raised in the petition, and refused to grant the reliefs sought and proceeded to dismiss the petition.

    Earlier, the tribunal upheld the preliminary objection of the 2nd and 3rd. respondents – PDP and Bwacha – on the grounds that the petitioners did not pay the required filing fees as at the point of presenting the petition before the tribunal’s secretary on March 14, 2019.

    Other members of the tribunal, Justices Khadi Bello Raha and Fati Takuma agreed with the lead judgment.

    Justice Raha read the lead judgments in the other three petitions, in which held that the petitioners failed to prove their cases.

    In dismissing the petition by Prof Yakubu and his party, Justice Raha noted that the petitioners were in error in their approach to proving non-accreditation.

    Justice Raha said the petitioners’ reliance solely on the results of card reader to challenge accreditation was wrong, and held that card reader was not recognised as a means for accreditation either under Section 49 or elsewhere in the Electoral Act.

    *The petitioners failed to prove to our satisfaction that the 1st respondent (Shiddi) did not win with the majority of lawful valid votes.

    Read Also: Taraba killings will never happen again, Buratai assures

    “The 1st respondent is returned as winner, the reliefs sought in the petition are refused and the petition is hereby dismissed,” Justice Raha said.

    In the petitions by Bappa and Tanko and their party (PDP) Justice Raha dismissed them for two reasons.

    First was that the petitioners failed to lead credible evidence to establish their allegations that the elections were marred by irregularities and substantial non-compliance.

    The second reason, Justice Raha noted, was that the petitioners failed to include the necessary parties in their petitions.

    In the case of Bappa, he had included Aminu Malle (who contested the election held on February 23, 2019 as the APC’s candidate and was declared winner) as the first respondent in the petition.

    But, before Malle could assume office, the Supreme Court voided his candidacy in a judgment given on June 13, 2019 and ordered that he be replaced by Kasimu Bello Maigari, who was later issued with the certificate of return by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

    By virtue of the Supreme Court judgment, Malle’s name was deleted from the case as a party, without the petitioners replacing him with the Maigari (who was now the winner of the election).

    In its judgment on Saturday, Justice Raha held that it was a fatal error on the part of the petitioners not to have included Maigari as a party in the case after the name of Malle was deleted.

    He said since the petitioners were not a party in the case before the Supreme Court and Maigari, not being a party before the tribunal, it was wrong for the court to enter judgment against him and grant the reliefs sought against him by the petitioners without affording him the right to be heard.

    A similar scenario played out in the petition by Tanko, who the judge noted, failed to include Gambo Mubarak as a party in the petition after the Supreme Court, in an earlier judgment voided the candidacy of Garba Hamman Julde, who had contested and won election as APC candidate.

    Julde had contested as APC candidate and won, following which Tanko challenged his election, listing him (Julde) as a respondent in his petition.

    While the petition was being heard, the Supreme Court gave a judgment in a pre-election case filed against him by Mubarak.

    The Supreme Court voided Julde’s candidacy and ordered INEC to issue Mubarak with a certificate of return, following which Julde’s name was deleted as a candidate in the petition before the tribunal, but with the petitioners failing to replace him with Mubarak who became the beneficiary of the election.