Tag: Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen

  • Onnoghen: A postscript

    This piece is not about former Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen, per se — and for two good reasons.

    First, the man has appealed his Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT) conviction.  After a rash of immediate post-verdict comments, fairness demands everything be put on hold, until the higher courts concur or demur.

    Secondly, decency and good breeding demand you don’t kick a man already down.  It’s simple compassionate humanity, given the heights the former CJN had crashed from.

    But the rather puerile manner the Nigerian Christian Elders Forum (NCEF) tries to rationalize the Onnoghen conviction should well and truly alarm everyone.

    Ironically, both Onnoghen and NCEF are frightening symbols of contemporary Nigeria, perhaps in its worst-ever decadence.

    Onnoghen’s symbolism of rot has more to do with the shocking vanishing of honour in Nigeria’s public space; and less with law, even if the putrescence of our laws and lawyers — “lawyers” used in the widest generic form, to capture both the Bar and the Bench — is damning enough.

    An accused Onnoghen, head of the sacred Judiciary, ruins the critical code of a saintly conclave, come to bring to heel the rest of us.

    A convicted Onnoghen completely shatters all of that myth.

    Napoleon Bonaparte declared the throne no more than a bench covered with damask.  Our own Fela, the ultimate iconoclast, in the ultimate putdown, to the uppity Nigerian military: uniform na khaki, na tailor de sew am — and that, at the apex of their swashbuckling power!

    Perhaps a throne can soak such slur and reform itself?  Incidentally, the French monarchy never did.  Perhaps a political military could brush it aside, and still continue to corral power – another impossibility the Nigerian military learned the hard way!

    But no civilized society survives a debauched Judiciary without baiting anarchy.  That is the full and unvarnished tragedy of Onnoghen’s terrible judicial pass.

    But that puts, even in bolder relief, the greater danger of a critical moral centre, deodourizing such grave moral stink; because it plays the politics of ethnic hate and jaundiced faith.

    That is the unpardonable crime NCEF has committed on the Onnoghen question, when it suggested, in an infamous statement, that the troubled former CJN was removed by Fulani “stealth” — whatever that means!

    But then, the NCEF outburst would appear to climax the moral free-fall of Christendom Nigeria, as a moral force, in the anti-sleaze war, with all its un-Christian manoeuvres, unleashed on the political front.

    Bishop Matthew Hassan Kukah, the Catholic Bishop of Sokoto, fired the first salvo in 2015, when he pointedly told Nigerians to forget the nation-threatening sleaze of the Jonathan era and “move on”.

    True, he drew terrible flak from irate compatriots, shocked at the ringing illogic — not to add, the crippling immorality — of such a call.

    That was because it came from a distinguished scholar-priest; whose rippling logic and severe moral code ought to strike a hard blow for probity and public morality.

    But Kukah’s call would appear a Freudian slip.  Though no one gave it an official seal, the People’s Democratic Party’s bathetic campaign of 2015 was nothing but an emotive Christian-versus-Muslim sympathy-seeking stunt.

    Remember the “Janjaweed” quip, in regard to the then opposition All Progressives Congress (APC), by Femi Fani-Kayode, President Goodluck Jonathan’s chief campaign spokesperson?

    Father Kukah probably regarded Jonathan the closet “Christian” candidate.  After a drubbing by the “Muslim” one, the electorally vanquished sure deserved some post-defeat veneration, in holy sentiments.

    Well, if that was the case, it back-fired big time!

    Nonetheless, Kukah’s screeching whistle kicked off a virtual political match, in which leading lights of Nigerian Christendom would unleash, on the Muhammadu Buhari presidency if not outright on his person, personal bile cleverly pushed as Christian holy rile, to scam the gullible faithful.

    One of such has been Winners’ Chapel Presiding Bishop, Bishop David Oyedepo, and his periodic wail, against PMB and his government.

    In one of such, he got so worked up, over a mere satire.  That grand gaffe became a grand embarrassment to Nigerian Christendom — and Oyedepo himself, the butt of jokes.

    Prof. Olatunji Dare, celebrated columnist of The Nation, had satirized the hare-brained joke, that PMB was some cloned “Jubril” from Sudan.

    Like boiling ocean waves, the satire drove up the holy bishop’s darkest id (to borrow the language of Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalysis) — burying all his inhibiting ego and super ego; consuming his entire priestly restraints.

    Right there on the sacred pulpit, the triumphant bishop, bristling with holy rage, read out the entire satire to the cheering faithful; passing it out as concrete facts, to bury his quarry.  But alas, everything blew in his face!

    It was perhaps God Himself confounding the wise!  In Oyedepo, the hunter suddenly turned the hunted — for who would save, from the biting jokes to come, the chancellor of a thriving private university, who nevertheless couldn’t understand simple satire?

    Indeed, God would not be mocked!

    Perhaps that realization – that God would not be mocked – pushed the Christian Association of Nigeria (CAN), Nigeria’s apex Christian body, to some post-poll detente, of congratulating PMB on his re-election.   CAN itself had had its own fair share of pre-poll theatrics and rascality.

    But CAN’s possible morphing from Saul to Paul, after the blinding flash en route to political Damascus, NCEF won’t hear of; accusing CAN of some alleged sell-out!

    Which is why the CAN-NCEF tiff could well be likened to a contemporary equivalent of the Biblical Tower of Babel, when Jehovah scatter the tongues; and planted confusion, among a lobby locked in an illicit task.

    Both CAN and NCEF have wilfullly refused to press themselves into service, when their nation faced the most lethal moral crisis, opting to play instead some political hanky-panky.

    On that account, however, the Solomon Asemota (SAN)-chaired NCEF has become the most virulent; and the latest proof, aside from its sickening reading of “Jihad” and “Islamization” into everything, is its rather silly rationalization of the Onnoghen mess.

    Besides, NCEF’s emotive activism appears bereft of any strategic thinking.  If NCEF piles up so much bile and hate, against the “Fulani-Muslim rulers” of its troubled imagination, can its preferred “Christian” future rulers withstand future rabid Muslim bile?

    Where does that then lead the polity?  To Mogadishu or even Kigali, some vile killing fields, resulting from mutual faith intolerance?  And to think most of these elders could well be gone, when their present ill wind breeds the whirlwind!

    NCEF is, indeed, manifesting political rascality instead of the Christ-like propriety its name demands.  It’s high time, therefore, it changed tack.

    Still, NCEF is only a symptom.  The real disease is Nigerian Christendom, fleeing from battle, when the country sorely needs its corrective ammo, to survive a moral ruin.

    But history would dust its sandals, as dire evidence against the present Nigerian Christian order, for its epochal abandonment; just as Christ instructed the early disciples, against the willfully unreceptive to the gospel.

  • Onnoghen’s self-inflicted conundrum

    Suspended CJN has a case to answer

    One good thing about the suspended Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen’s saga is the way many Nigerians have risen to the occasion by taking on the senior advocates who like taking the rest of us for granted (for committing the sin of not reading law) whenever any of their own is caught on the wrong side of the law.

    The impression they give is that they are afraid of seeing the CJN go down over the matter because he is not likely to do so alone. Although Justice Onnoghen has reportedly said he made the money through savings from estacode and stuff like that, the courts will have to determine the veracity of that claim.

    But the earlier these senior lawyers realised that this country belongs to us all; and not to them alone, the better for them. There is no mystique about law; so, nobody should attempt to pull wool over our faces. Indeed, as I argued with a friend of mine a few years back, law is predictable; at least in sane climes. If it is not here in Nigeria, it is because those who should make it so are themselves complicit in mystifying it through their usual clinging to technicalities at the expense of substance. They thus constitute themselves to clogs in the anti-corruptuion battle. The truth is, my friend has for long been used to the way the legal profession is practiced here such that it took the explanation of a lawyer friend who happened to be in the car when we were discussing for my friend to agree that, indeed, law is predictable.

    As a matter of fact, I want to believe it is this predictability that has made many of our senior advocates to jettison the substance of many of the matters they handle for technicalities. They know that once the law is applied as enshrined in the statute books or even by precedence, technicalities that they have tended to specialise on would crumble in the courtrooms like a pack of cards. Of course, that assumes the issues will be decided by incorruptible judges.

    Let no one make any mistake about it; this country cannot fight corruption without first fighting some of these senior lawyers and judges who have judgments on the shelves, ready to sell to the highest bidder. There are many responsible lawyers out there who themselves know this as a fact. Unfortunately, they have allowed the voices of the very corrupt few to appear as the dominant voice in the Onnoghen affair as well as other sordid affairs involving the high profile clients of these lawyers. The other day when Senate President Bukola Saraki was arraigned at the Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT), a retinue of senior lawyers went for their gowns. How come we don’t see our senior lawyers file out anymore in defence of the defenceless?

    If these senior lawyers truly love this country, and if they truly love their profession, they should be worried about the fact that when Nigerians and foreigners are involved in crimes, as in Siemens, Halliburton, etc, their foreign accomplices quickly get their comeuppance in courts in their respective countries when back here at home, the matters would still be at the preliminary stages for years due to stalling tactics that many of these senior advocates are now trying to push forward as the law. If these lawyers are truly patriotic, what should be uppermost in their minds is how to improve on the legal system to make it faster and better, rather than how much stonewalling they can make the courts endure or how much funds (particularly illicit funds) they have in their bank accounts.

    One area they should be looking at is that dealing with proof. As things stand, the lawyers queuing behind the suspended CJN would have been asking the rest of us to prove that the hefty sums found in Onnoghen’s accounts are proceeds of corrupt enrichment if they have had their way. That would have been the next stage of their argument: technicality. Not how a public servant, and CJN for that matter, came about the money. Yet, they know that even if the suspended CJN had not spent a dime of his salaries, he could not have saved that much since the time he was employed.

    Here is the same Onnoghen that had himself ruled that the CCT is the one in charge of matters bordering on assets declaration now running helter-skelter, including to the National Industrial Court seeminglyto evade justice. What has the industrial court got to do with this? Meanwhile, the same NJC that some people say should sit over the CJN’s fate has had its meeting postponed by Onnoghen sine die (indefinitely). How then does it sit over the matter?  Mercifully, it finally sat and, hopefully, it would be able to do the needful at the appointed time. Those who are hammering on process should know that we might not have got here but for the uproar.

    We should all remember that President Muhammadu Buhari was hesitant in appointing Onnoghen as CJN. However, he had to bow to pressure when ethnic dimension was brought into the matter in the usual Nigerian character. We do not know what security or other reports the president had on the man then. Unfortunately, he too did not help matters by not putting anything in the public domain if he had such incriminating details on him. Perhaps he didn’t have enough evidence then.

    Again, it was difficult not to believe those who were reading ethnic dimension into the appointment because the president too did not help matters the way he was handling some of the crises at hand then, especially the herdsmen/farmers’ clashes, the issues of Babachir Lawal and others whose cases took the president so long to decide in spite of what seemed overwhelming evidence of wrongdoing against them.

    Nigeria must be the only country where a question as simple and straightforward as: ‘did you or did you not’ will lead to prolonged litigation in which senior lawyers would lead the way in legal rigmarole/gymnastic just to make sure that their very important criminals escape justice or sufficiently waste the time of the court and wear out the prosecutors.

    Then we have foreign countries and institutions that are complaining about the level of corruption in Nigeria and are at the same time trying to read unnecessary meaning into a matter as simple as Onnoghen’s. The suspended CJN himself had admitted that he forgot to declare a hefty $3million, among other things. Is that a defence? Will Onnoghen have pardoned an accused who made such a statement in his court? Alhaji Aliko Dangote may have to come to our rescue here. Is it not fit and proper that we know the source of that money for a public servant, particularly no less a personality than the CJN?

    We have seen how the British dealt with parliamentarians over what we would term ridiculous amounts, like a few hundred pounds sterling. Can the chief justice of America boast of $3million without hell being let loose? If this kind of scenario had occurred in the U.S. or Britain, will they be talking about anything else when the person involved did not deny ownership but says he forgot to declare the amount? For sure, no one would tell that Chief Justice to resign. He knows that is the next thing in the circumstance. So, why are these countries now trying to prescribe lower standard for Nigeria? Could they be doing this because their vaults are still safe havens to some of these slush funds?

    Anyway, if anyone expected that because the subterfuge and pressures worked at the initial stages of Onnoghen’s appointment, they would work again now; such persons should perish the thought. You cannot have the kind of evidence in the public domain against the CJN and then begin to pander to pressures, either from his comrades-in-crime or ethnic bigots who are never in short supply when it comes to matters like this. Justice Onnoghen himself should be ashamed that his matter has now become a subject of public protests for or against him. He is sufficiently damaged such that it is ridiculous to contemplate his return to his exalted seat. We would not have got to this sorry pass if he had done the rightful

  • Lawyers protest Onnoghen’s suspension in Calabar

    Lawyers in Cross River State, on Tuesday took the streets of Calabar to protest the suspension of Justice Walter Onnoghen as Chief Justice of Nigeria by President Muhammadu Buhari.

    The placard-bearing lawyers from the three branches of the Nigerian Bar Association in the state comprising Calabar, Ikom and Ogoja, converged on the state judiciary headquarters at High Court complex on Mary Slessor Avenue before proceeding to the governor’s office on Diamond Hill to present a six-point demand to the governor for onward transmission to the president.

    The Vice Chairman of NBA, Calabar Branch, Julius Idiege, read the communiqué before it was presented to the state Deputy Governor, Prof. Ivara Esu, who received it on behalf of the state Governor, Prof Ben Ayade.

    The communiqué issued by the lawyers read in part, “We condemn in the strongest terms, and wholly reject the unconstitutional suspension of Honourable Justice Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen by President Muhammadu Buhari, vide a black market ex parte order issued by the Code of Conduct Tribunal.

    Read Also: Pro, anti-Onnoghen protests rocks Abuja

    “We are horrified that the Hon Justice Tanko Mohammed submitted himself to be sworn in as Acting Chief Justice of Nigeria, thereby subscribing to this abuse of the constitution and we find the actions of the Code of Conduct Tribunal perfidious and fraudulent.”

    “Unless this abuse of the constitution is redressed immediately, the rule of law will be in jeopardy and this will drive the country towards anarchy. The constitution of Nigeria must remain supreme and sacrosanct. We call on the president to immediately retrace his steps and reinstate Hon. Justice Walter Onnoghen to his position as Justice of Nigeria, and preserve the constitution which he swore to uphold.”

    They urged the National Executive Committee of the NBA to take all necessary steps in defence of the constitution and the rule of law.

    Meanwhile, courts in the state were boycotted by lawyers throughout Tuesday. The boycott will continue on Wednesday as directed by the NBA at the national level.

  • Breaking: I’ve not resigned, says Onnoghen

    Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Walter Onnoghen has put a lie to the speculation that he has resigned.

    Justice Onnoghen has scheduled the swearing-in of members of the 2019 National Assembly, Governorship & State Assembly Election Petition Tribunals for January 26 (Saturday).

    The CJN’s spokesman, Awassam Bassey made this public in a brief statement on Friday morning.

    Bassey described as “fake news” the speculation that Justice Onnoghen has resigned.

    He said: “There’s absolutely no truth in the rumours making the round that the Hon. Chief Justice of Nigeria, His Lordship Hon. Mr. Justice Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen, GCON, has resigned his office. It is fake news!

    Read Also: Onnoghen reaffirms commitment of judiciary to ensure justice, peace

    “The Hon CJN was in the office all through yesterday and sat in court.

    “As part of his duties, the Hon CJN will be swearing in members of the 2019 National Assembly, Governorship & State Assembly Election Petition Tribunals tomorrow (Saturday 26th January 2019).