Category: Comments

  • Dana Air and its victims

    No doubt, emotions are running high to effervescent level over the recent decision by the Ministry of Aviation to lift the suspension imposed on Dana Air. The airline was suspended in the aftermath of the crash involving its aircraft at Iju-Ishaga, a Lagos suburb, on Sunday, June 3.
    Since the crash that claimed about 163 lives, the aviation industry has not been the same again. Quite a lot has happened ever since as passengers on domestic flights have been finding it hectic travelling with the few operating airlines. By the last count, only three airlines—Arik, Aero, IRS—were operating. It is obvious that they have been trying their best to cope with the volume of passengers but their efforts have not satisfied demand. Departure times are in several instances, not kept while there have been frequent cancellations of flights. All these point to the fact that the existing airlines have been spread thin to the limit of their elasticity.
    So, ordinarily, it is a great relief that Dana Air is coming back once again. But the wounds are still fresh. Very fresh. Some people might want to say that the timing of their re-entry is bad enough. Not exactly so.  For those who lost loved ones, there is no better time even if the suspension is lifted in another five or 10 years’ time. The memory of the dead will continue to be everlastingly fresh.
    My major concern here is the disdain with which the airline has been treating the victims’ families and other victims whose property and means of livelihood were destroyed in the crash. So much has been written about the plight of the bereaved families, some of who are even yet to take possession of the corpse of their relatives for a befitting burial. We are told that some of them have received $30,000 each as compensation, awaiting the balance of $70,000 each as stipulated by International Law.
    Last Friday, one of the victims, Daniel Omowunmi, the owner of the storey building, the warehouse and the factory destroyed by the ill-fated aircraft, granted an interview in one of the national dailies. Going through the interview, one could see ‘man’s inhumanity to man’ in its raw form. Unfortunately, but quite expectedly, some Nigerians, including lawyers and one or two Lagos State government officials, were fingered as collaborators. If three months after the crash, the owner of the building on which the aircraft landed before bursting into flames had not received a kobo as compensation, one wonders what type of a country is ours.
    According to Omowunmi, who said he had written the management of Dana Air, claiming about N500 million as damages for the destruction of his property and business, what the airline offered him was a miserable and ridiculous N500,000. The N500,000, he said, was referred to as “a temporary settlement”. What is more, the airline’s management brought some forms that suggested that anybody that took the money actually applied for it. The letter, he said, was such that it was addressed to Dana, looking as if it was Omowunmi who originated the form or letter to Dana’s management. Not only this. Dana’s management has not had the courtesy of acknowledging Omowunmi’s letter of claims in writing. All he has got was a casual, verbal acknowledgement.
    In a country that has a functional government, Omowunmi’s case and that of other bereaved families of the victims of the Dana Air crash should have been speedily pursued. I am not a lawyer, but even if Omowunmi’s house or property had been destroyed, say by earthquake, which is a natural disaster, it is incumbent on the government to provide respite. But this is not a natural disaster. An aircraft lost its twin engines and instead of landing at an airport designated for such, it landed on somebody’s house and destroyed his livelihood in the process.
    If Nigerians are up in arms against Dana Air today, it is because of the notoriety Indians have acquired by their predilection for cutting corners and not playing by the rules. I am sure if we have to visit all the bereaved families and listen to their stories, they all have sad tales to recollect about their encounter with Dana Air officials. This is why I believe that it is the responsibility of the government whether Lagos State gove

    DELE AGEKAMEH

    rnment or the Aviation Ministry to ensure that the right thing is done for the families of the victims of the crash. Precious lives have been lost and there can never be any replacement or compensation that will be adequate. But then, both Dana Air and the government can minimise the agony of the bereaved through prompt and adequate payment of compensation. The recourse to paying any ridiculous amount, as is being alleged, smacks of indifference and outright wickedness on the part of the airline. It stands condemnable by all right-thinking human beings.
    I am not against Dana Air reentering Nigeria’s airspace but the right thing must be done. Otherwise, no amount of public relations or propaganda will douse the tense situation now prevalent among the bereaved families.
    And the government officials and other Nigerians who are colluding with these Indians to short-change their fellowmen must all bear in mind that the incident could have claimed the life of anybody. That we are still living today is by the grace of Almighty God. Nobody knows tomorrow. I can give countless examples of people who inflicted unimaginable pains on people and ended up miserably and tragically themselves. That is where the law of karma or retribution comes in. Whatever you do in life, good or bad, there is a reward for it. The only thing is that when the time to reap the reward comes, no one would remember what had happened in the past.
    Surely, we need Dana to resume its services, although, as for me, I am still skeptical about its safety records. There is need for more players in the airline Industry, especially now that two others—Air Nigeria and Nation Airlines – have suddenly gone asleep. In the case of Nation, we were told that the aircraft in its fleet had gone for routine maintenance ostensibly to stave off any danger in the nearest future. As for Air Nigeria, the airline had been “wobbling and fumbling”, to use Coach Fanny Amu’s words, for quite some time until its management decided to do the needful – take a break and reorganise.
    While Nation airline had only operated for a couple of months before it disappeared from the skies, the case of Air Nigeria is quite pathetic. The airline had been around for some time. When it operated as Virgin Nigeria under the aviation wizard, Richard Branson, it was the toast of many a traveller both within and outside the country. Then came the bang: for one reason or another, Branson decided to pull out his investment. The airline was later renamed Air Nigeria. Since then, things have somehow gone awry. Many stories about the airline have been bandied but most of them border on uncouth management practices. A situation where the airline takes money in cash in ‘Ghana Must Go’ bags to purchase aviation fuel and all that cannot be said to be smooth administration after all. Now that the airline has been wheeled to the hanger for what its management termed “Corporate Surgical Operation”, Nigerians are waiting to see whether a truly improved airline will emerge at the end of the exercise.
    Until then, all hands must be on deck to ensure safety in the skies. We cannot afford another disaster after all we have experienced in this country. Not anymore. Our philosophy, for now and forever, should be: “No more air disasters”.

  • COMMENTS

    ‘CBN is only doing what it is supposed to do financially and economically. If those in the agriculture sector, manufacturing, mining, power are lagging in growth to earn Nigeria the required FOREX, blame not Sanusi, he has done and is doing enough to sanitise the banking industry today, and if not for his stabilising the naira as he has done,the exchange rate today would not be less than N250 to one US dollar. He called the bluff of the IMF in January. Why is it only Nigerians that refuse coins? From Lanre Oseni’

    For Olatunji Dare

    If Obama is now finding it tough going for the second term, it is simply because the Grace of God that threw him up to the presidency must have been withdrawn from him. God typically stepped against racial prejudice to have him elected the first African-American president to prove that with Him there should be no segregation. But it does appear Obama seems not to reckon with such divine favour when he thoughtlessly approved gay marriage in America under his watch – a big slap on the face of God. He may not have performed excellently in office, but that is not the issue. With the grace withdrawn even those things he did that usually attracted loud ovation are bound to earn him scathing comments and snobbery from the people. Hence, his bid for a second tenure has become slippery. Of course, it is our prayer that the God of mercy shall see him through. From Emmanuel Egwu, Enugu.
    I read your article on the US presidential election. Please, give me the full meaning of the abbreviation GOP. I have encountered it several times, recently. If Obama fails to make it the second time, he is the architect of his misfortune. I always love reading your articles and views on contemporary issues. Anonymous
    Sir, If such thoroughly unbiased notes had been taken on Nigeria’s political system, an opportunist somewhere would have condemned the writer as being too venomous to be constructive. Mercifully, truth is sacrosanct. Citizens of any country can only live freely and happily when those trusted with political power use it for the common good. From Adegoke O. O. Ikhin, Edo State
    Please, what is the meaning of GOP convention? Anonymous
    Point of correction, it was Bill Clinton v George Bush ( senior) not Bob Dole in 1996. Anonymous
    Re: Notes on the US Presidential Race. Notwithstanding the ‘pellets and bombs’ being thown at each other’s camp, campaign for the presidential election in US could be interesting and is still interesting till date, with justification on points and issues raised regarding tax, healthcare, and others unlike in Nigeria. One hopes that, we will learn at a faster rate in Nigeria. From Lanre Oseni.
    Your piece on the US presidential race is apt and revealing. The salient point is that this year’s election is not being fought along party lines, it is the most racial and nepotic, an opinion poll had 45 percent of the people thinking Obama is a Muslim. What was the basis for conducting the poll? If all African-Americans, Hispanics, Asia-Americans and other minority races would rally round Obama, the GOP facists will be shamed. From Kayode Ojinnaka, Owerri
    It is only in Africa that incumbents see second term as a piece of cake. Obama has failed Americans who expected so much from him but got disappiontment; he even refused to visit Nigeria, the giant of Africa. From Eguono, Port Harcourt
    Bill Clinton v George Bush (senior) 1992, Bill Clinton v Bob Dole 1996, Americans elect the most powerful man in the world so, people like to know the next world leader. Anonymous
    I read your column article “Notes on the U.S. presdential race”. I am not only shocked but speechless. What has come over America? The giant of democracy. Finally, you have left us to assess, analyse and appraise what the outcome of the US election will be. Anonymous
    I really appreciate your indepth knowledge of the intrigues of American politics.You are, indeed, not only a well informed, knowledgeable and highly enlightened columnist, but a journalist of international repute. I am highly impressed, sir! Accept my best wishes and regards to the family, sir! From P. Akila Kasham, Plateau State.

    For Gbenga Omotoso

    How are we sure she did not go there after Stella Obasanjo? Let us pray she comes back. Anonymous
    Please, the First Lady is not missing. She is with me at Yenagoa resting. From Uncle Bruce Bino.
    Like the case of Prince Phillip, it is not a big deal if the Presidency clears the mystery on the whereabouts of our number one mother. From Ikedi, Umuahia
    What is so special about the First lady, or did you vote for the office of the First Lady? Anonymous
    Prince Phillip not his son, Andrew, was hospitalised. From Yusuf G. Mshelizza, Kaduna
    I do not know the First Lady. I am just concerned about the mockery you have subjected her to. Freedom of expression does not mean freedom to disrespect and to put to public ridicule. To have a space to publish is not an opportunity to be reckless. From Clement
    Since I have been going through your columns, this is the one I enjoyed reading. Truly, the question on the lips of everyone is: where is our First Lady? From Alex Orbuter, Makurdi
    I read your piece and was left with the opinion that it was trite from the headline to the intro to the main body and to the conclusion! It was rather too cheap and full of sarcacism. Please, leave such non-serious issue to less- endowed journalists. Thank you! Anonymous
    Must we print our currencies in a foreign country? What is the reason behind setting up the Nigeria Security Printing and Minting Corporation in the 60s? Granted that the machines should have become obsolete by now, can the cost of procuring new ones be as high as N30 billion? If it is, once we buy it, will it not become our property for a long time? But then there will not be any avenue for the boys to maintain foreign accounts. Or will there be? From Adegoke Adeyemo, Lagos.
    Gbenga, you hit those deserving to be hit with stone covered with cotton wool. I always enjoy your column. Of recent, some of my friends who used to buy your newspaper have stopped because of the unnecessary Mimiko bashing. As the editor of the paper, do not allow it to be turned to the defunct “New Nigeria”. Try and moderate the political columnists. From Yinka Niyi, Epe Lagos
    Re: Where is the First Lady? You did not empathise or sympathise with the First Lady’s health challenge. On a very serious note, transparency is to declare the true position of those who govern us directly or remotedly. First Lady will sooner than later appear to us in a bigger way. One thing is clear, she is ok. There is no cause for any row over N5000 note and coins. If N5000 and coins are too much for me, I will go to my level -N200s and N100s. Our problem is not Sanusi and notes but low production. From Lanre Oseni.
    Re: Where is the First Lady. It is really a shame on our leaders that our health system is so dismal that the First Lady had to be flown abroad as alleged for treatment for food poisoning. This was possible because her husband is in power as Mr President. What of the masses who bear the brunt of the dearth of health infrastructure in this country? Where will they go to if they too come down with food poisoning? To hospitals starved of government funding and patronage? This country needs a rebirth. From Olumide Soyemi, Bariga.
    Thanks for the hilarious piece on your Thursday back page. Indeed, serious stories can be told with rib-cracking humour as you have always shown. Bravo! From Bassy esq.

    For Tunji Adegboyega

    Re: “N5000 note? Perish the thought!’ The thought should not be perished because all opponents of N5000 note and coins have not been given econo-financial reasons for their rejection. Rather, it has been the usual radical and rejection based on sentiment. Tunji, inflation and value of money are determined by level of productivity of citizens, level of production in agriculture, industries, mining and quantity of exports as well as FOREX earned. Brother, N20,000 note has no negative impact on our economy. Compare the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s value and exports to post-’85s. From Lanre.
    Don’t you think this N5000 note is one of the preconditions set by the West for Mr President for 2015? Think of same sex marriage. From Mazijos.
    Tunji, your thoughts on N5000 note are nothing buthard facts. You should write another article on the planned coinage of 5, 10 and 20 naira denominations. Anonymous.
    What is all this weeping and gnashing of teeth over a high denomination of the naira. When Ghana released its currency on July 1, 2007, the 50 cedis note had a value of 53.76 USD. How much is N5,000?The UK has a 50 pound note (N12,000). The USD note is about N16,000. The 10,000 fcfa in poor Cotonou next door is N3,000. When shall we grow up? Anonymous.
    Tunji, your comments and analysis have spoken for the masses of this country. The CBN wants the poor people to be poorer and the rich, richer. If not so, let Mallam Sanusi Lamido Sanusi tell the people the true picture of the N5000 in his mind. More of your incisive comments. From Akinleye, H.O.
    Tunji, your article on N5000 naira note was well researched and intellectually convincing. Honestly, Sanusi started well but is now derailing. I think Soludo was better. How would the President approve of it without wide consultation? Sanusi took advantage of Jonathan’s naivety or, else, how could Jonathan have approved it without consulting our economists and highly reputable bankers? A layman will know that it will not do us any good. Sanusi is only out to prove that it was his time as CBN governor that this higher denomination was introduced. This is a PDP agenda of bribing the electorate come 2015. Anonymous
    If today we mint N100 into coins, it would simply lose its value; that is the point. Let Sanusi and his CBN print even N10,000 note, it makes no difference to corruption, but the real problem is if N5, N10 and N20 notes are minted into coins. Welcome inflation! You and I know that within six months, they are no longer legal tender and that is the real devaluation. Our protest is currently misplaced. We should be against the coinage of those denominations. From Cliff.
    CBN is only doing what it is supposed to do financially and economically. If those in the agriculture sector, manufacturing, mining, power are lagging in growth to earn Nigeria the required FOREX, blame not Sanusi, he has done and is doing enough to sanitise the banking industry today, and if not for his stabilising the naira as he has done,the exchange rate today would not be less than N250 to one US dollar. He called the bluff of the IMF in January. Why is it only Nigerians that refuse coins? From Lanre Oseni.
    I completely agree with you that people seem unsatisfied at whatever moves by President Jonathan makes; nevertheless, going by his present works I believe he would emerge the best president of this soil ever in the end. I never cease praying for him to hit the expectation of the people. Anonymous
    Is it not strange that amongst the so-called NEMT members who supported the introduction of the N5000 naira note are those enmeshed in the oil subsidy scam? Make no mistake about this … From Akindele Kayode.
    It looks like the CBN is set to go ahead with it. Why do we not pressure Mr Sanusi and CBN to re-denominate the naira? Pray, what is this our hatred for coins, a media creation? Imagine if the present N100 were to be just N1.00 and you needed only N1.60 for one dollar. Imagine petrol going for just N0.97. Yes, we would gladly use coins. But we love illusion. Big figures excite us. Billionaires! Vanity. God bless. From Harry Dee.
    I am very surprised despite your being informed that you could not see that what the implementation of N5000 note is telling you is that the naira is over-valued and has to devalue. Like it or not, print N5000 or not, the currency will always find its true level. For as long as we have chosen the path of corruption in this country we shall continue to experience inflation manifesting in high denomination currency. That is the fact. Remember the cedi at the height of Ghanaians bad economy. Watch out, N10,000 note is coming and we shall see worthless minimum wage of N50,000 per month. Be prepared to buy bread for N1000 …. These are all rewards of corruption. Anonymous

  • Measuring success

    •2012 WASSCE results may have been better; there is no cause for celebration yet
    The results of the May/June 2012 West African Senior School Certificate Examination (WASSCE) released by the West African Examinations Council (WAEC) have turned out to be a departure from the disturbing downward trend in the performance of the candidates. This year’s results, the best in three years, showed that 649,156 candidates representing 38.81 per cent of the total candidates that sat for the examination obtained credits in five subjects and above, including English Language and Mathematics. Comparatively, these statistics represent an 8.9 per cent increase above last year’s performance, where 30.91 per cent made the same grades, and in 2010 where 23.71 per cent of the candidates met the standard. The Head of the Nigeria National Office of WAEC, Dr Iyi Nwadie, said the improved results this year marked a positive development, even as cases of examination malpractices reportedly declined compared with previous years.
    Considering the pervasive concern about educational standards in the country, the latest WASSCE results have brought a ray of hope. For some time now, there has been a huge public controversy over whether educational standards were falling or not, and the WASSCE results have certainly not been encouraging. The cheering news of improved performance in this important school-leaving examination, however, raises some questions which the released statistics failed to address. How well can it be established that the successful candidates indeed passed on merit? What about the geographical spread of these candidates? What about their institutional distribution? How many of these success stories were products of private or public schools?
    Amid the debate over academic standards, there has been a noticeable upsurge in the development of private sector-driven educational institutions, many of which are well funded and possess the necessary human resources and infrastructure. On the other hand, the public schools have been battling with an image problem arising from poor funding as well as inadequate staffing and infrastructure. In the public imagination, this situation has given private schools a comparative advantage over their state-funded counterparts, which may well be a factor in the released WASSCE results.
    However, it is commendable that against the background of challenged educational standards in public schools across the country, some state governments are actually focused on addressing the problems and creating an enabling environment in which public schools can thrive and satisfy the expectations of Nigerians. In Rivers, Lagos, Akwa Ibom, Delta and Edo states, to mention a few states, the people are witnesses to the transformative activities of the various governments in the education sector and the considerable investments they are making to uplift their public schools. Good governance in these pace-setting states gives a welcome priority to the development of the schools funded with public money. But it is not clear whether the WASSCE results reflect the changing pattern of educational investment in these states. It is more likely, though, that the fruits of the improved outlay on education in these states would need more time before the harvest. Even so, the importance of qualitative education at all levels for the progress of the country cannot be overemphasized, and there is no doubt that greater attention should be paid to the education of Nigerians.
    Although the latest WASSCE results show an improvement over those of the previous two years, it would be truly premature to celebrate the achievement as a reversal of the downward trend. The progress needs to be sustained, and greater levels of success recorded, so that this year’s results do not turn out to be a one-off. It should be pointed out that the percentage of successful candidates is well below 50 per cent, which, frankly, is not good enough.

  • The Better Economic Question

    Democrats have been nervous about the inevitable election-year question,“Are you better off than you were four years ago?” Gov. Martin O’Malley of Maryland even stumbled over it a few days ago, saying “no,” before quickly blaming President George W. Bush.

    There is really no reason for any hesitancy. The country is unquestionably better off than it was in 2008. The economy has added 4.5 million private-sector jobs since January 2010; even if you subtract the vast job losses in the early months of President Obama’s term, before his policies went into effect, the country is still ahead by 332,000 private-sector jobs.

    That level of job growth is close to the recovery following the 1990s recession, and it is actually stronger than after the early-2000s recession. But it doesn’t feel strong because the original hole was so deep and so many people are still suffering: 12.8 million remain unemployed.

    The contradiction between the plain facts of the data and the tepid feel of the recovery suggests that the recession created a more important question than the simplistic “are you better off?” Voters should ask themselves — and their leaders — how to keep this and future generations better off. How to prevent future recessions. How to design a tax code that promotes fairness and reduces inequality. How to make sure a safety net is in place for those who inevitably need more help.

    And when the question is phrased like that — looking forward rather than backward — it becomes obvious that the Republicans’ answer is inadequate.

    “When we vote in this election, we’ll be deciding what kind of country we want to live in,” former President Bill Clinton told the convention Wednesday night. “If you want a winner-take-all, you’re-on-your-own society, you should support the Republican ticket.”

    The damage Mr. Obama faced when he took office was far greater than any president, current or past, could repair in four years, Mr. Clinton said, yet Mitt Romney wants to return to the policies that caused it. “They want to cut taxes for high-income Americans, even more than President Bush did,” he said.“They want to get rid of those pesky financial regulations designed to prevent another crash and prohibit future bailouts.”
    At every step, when Mr. Obama and Democrats have proposed measures to reduce the risk of the kind of recession still haunting the economy, Republicans have opposed them. Mitt Romney regularly sneers at the most fundamental protections against Wall Street excesses and promises to repeal them.

    House Republicans, including Representative Paul Ryan, have passed budgets that gutted the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, hoping to prevent it from regulating toxic derivatives that undermined the economy in 2008. They have voted to withhold money needed by the Securities and Exchange Commission to enforce the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill.

    They have sent a clear signal to the corporate executives spending hundreds of millions to elect Mr. Romney that they need not worry about restrictions on their behavior, no matter how destructive to the economy or the lives of millions still struggling to get back on their feet.

    As Elizabeth Warren, the Democratic candidate for the United States Senate in Massachusetts, told the convention: “Mitt Romney wants to give billions in breaks to big corporations, but he and Paul Ryan would pulverize financial reform, voucherize Medicare and vaporize Obamacare.”

    Mr. Obama could have demanded even stronger regulation of the banks, but he at least clearly supports the need for government to step in when the financial industry threatens the rest of the economy.

    Voters should remember the days when the country was hemorrhaging jobs by the millions, but it is far more important to make certain they never have to remember another financial crisis.
    New York Times

  • Curbing fake drugs

    Action should be expedited on proposed law

    IF things go as planned, people involved in drug counterfeiting or importation of fake drugs into the country will soon begin to get life imprisonment, without an option of fine. Dr. Paul Orhii, director-general of the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC), who dropped the hint said the government was also considering confiscation of the property of people involved in the illicit and killer business to compensate the victims.

    Orhii, who spoke during a meeting of the West African Health Organisation to harmonise the process of medicine registration in West Africa said that experts working on the country’s anti-counterfeiting law have made significant progress on the document and that they would send it to the National Assembly after concluding work on it.

    This is good news. In India and China, the wages of the crime is death. And, one may be tempted to want to recommend that Nigeria toes this path in view of the fatal consequences of the actions of the criminals involved in the illegal business. Perhaps the realisation by those putting the proposed legislation together, that headache cannot be cured simply by beheading those suffering from it should also be welcome.

    Fake drugs are often manufactured in dirty, unhygienic warehouses and sometimes can contain little or none of the genuine active ingredient, or remarkably harmful industrial compounds. The least harm one could suffer from buying of such drugs is for them to be ineffective, i.e. when the active ingredients are below what is claimed on their containers. In many cases, people have died after taking such drugs; many others suffered permanent deformities.

    We understand the basis of the proposal to deny bail to suspects held for the crime; that is to prevent them from continuing their trade, thereby stopping them from further jeopardising the lives of innocent members of the public. But we wonder if that can stand in our legal milieu where an accused is deemed innocent until proven otherwise by a competent court of law.

    However, we urge those putting the law together to expedite action and forward it to the National Assembly. While we urge the law makers to scrutinise the document, with a view to making it water-tight; they should also expedite action on it when it gets to them so as to save their compatriots from untimely deaths or deformities arising from consumption of counterfeited drugs.

    But we also want to quickly remind the authorities that the problem is not about legislation per se. Right now, there are laws prescribed for people involved in drug counterfeiting; but enforcement is the problem. Even if death penalty is prescribed for the offence and the law is not enforced, there won’t be appreciable result. Again, it does not seem NAFDAC is well funded and equipped to do the job thoroughly. For the proposed law to be meaningful when it becomes operational, the agency must be provided the wherewithal to adequately cover the whole country.

    Fake drug business is big business and those involved in it have become too sophisticated to be trailed or monitored by an under-funded and ill-equipped agency. For the law to be effective, NAFDAC officials must always be a step ahead of the criminals. This implies that the whistle blowers should start to benefit from the incentives that Dr Orhii said were in the offing for them to further encourage them to put in their best.

    It is also important that the Federal Government expedite action on the Memorandum of Understanding between it and China to check the influx of fake and substandard drugs from that country. China is not just a major exporter of drugs to Nigeria; it is also one of the world’s biggest exporters of counterfeit drugs.

  • Forgotten monuments

    •Collapse of Bauchi wall reminds us of the need to regularly maintain such structures

    THE preservation and maintenance of historic buildings and monuments is rigorously undertaken by most serious nations. Apart from their great antiquity and tourist value, they are often regarded as encapsulating the norms and beliefs that countries hold dear. As in so many other aspects of national development, however, Nigeria seems to be an exception to this general rule. The recent collapse of the historic Bauchi wall is a case in point.
    Built around 1804, the wall is an outstanding example of indigenous architectural and engineering skill, and served primarily to protect the equally-historic Galadiman Bauchi House in the Bauchi State capital. It collapsed at about noon, falling on to nearby houses, resulting in the deaths of two persons and injuries to about four. Witnesses at the scene attribute the tragedy to a heavy downpour on the previous day.
    This was a tragedy waiting to happen. A wall of such size and age should have been subjected to regular checks of its structural integrity, especially given its historic importance. It is also clear that little or nothing was done to prevent houses being built too close to it. The blame for this oversight must be placed at the door of the National Commission of Museums and Monuments (NCMM), the Bauchi State Government and the local government council within which the wall is domiciled.
    The NCMM is a Federal Government parastatal tasked with the duty of ensuring that the country’s monuments and historical buildings are kept in good condition and raising public awareness about them. The collapse of the Bauchi wall is a clear demonstration of the lack of efficiency which it brought to its job. A serious organisation would have established a regimen of periodic checks and inspections aimed at ensuring that the wall and other monuments are kept in good condition and open to visits by interested members of the public. Indeed, given the general dilapidation of city walls and similar structures all over the country, it is actually surprising that they have not been collapsing with greater regularity.
    The state and relevant local governments also have a lot to answer for. Even if the commission was not living up to its statutory duties, they had a direct interest in making sure that such an important edifice is not only safe but marketable as a tourist attraction. As the state in which the famous Yankari Game Reserve is located, they should have been aware of its importance to Bauchi’s status as a major tourism destination. In other countries, regional and local authorities devote substantial resources to ensuring that monuments are properly maintained.
    The Bauchi tragedy clearly indicates the pressing need for an overhaul of Nigeria’s approach towards its historic buildings and monuments. NCMM must be strengthened to enable it carry out its regulatory responsibilities with greater efficiency. In particular, it must be given the wherewithal to properly maintain such edifices. There are walled cities and ancient buildings all across the country; their condition should be thoroughly assessed and remedial action undertaken where necessary. A comprehensive plan of action to market them as tourist attractions would help to defray the costs of their maintenance.
    The Bauchi State Government should conduct a census of all historic buildings and monuments in the state with a view to identifying those which are in need of maintenance or repair. The proper utilisation of such edifices will strengthen local pride in the state’s rich history and culture, and could become an important source of much-needed revenue.

  • Offodile: The limits of mischief

    Nshiko is a popular marine crustacean. When you put a thousand crabs in a pot, not one of them will come out because they will continue to pull down one another. It is another way of saying all motion; no movement. Having explained this, you will understand why I associate Nshiko mentality with Chudi Offodile.

    Anambra and the Limits of Propaganda; the Celebration of Mediocrity; and Peter Obi: Integrity Issues are three articles written by Offodile in quick succession attacking the governor of Anambra State, Peter Obi. He reduced what was going on in Anambra State to a reign of mediocrity.

    Not relenting, he published another article entitled: Anambra: Oil Projects, Brewery Scandal in The Sun of August 28.
    I first learnt about the publication from a former Senator, a good friend of Chudi Offodile. He spoke in confidence on what he called the scheming by Offodile and his friends to stop the President from visiting Anambra State. At first, according to him, they wanted to condemn everything the President will come to do. On Orient, they initially planned to say that Anambra’s shares were bought using another company’s name.

    Let it be on record that Obi has never claimed to have found Orient Petroleum; Dr. Chinwoke Mbadinuju did. However, the story of Orient will be incomplete without Obi. It was under him that the Government of Anambra State injected money into the company.

    In Anambra: Oil Prospects, Brewery Scandal, Offodile wrote a bit confusedly about SABMiller, not understanding that a mother company can use other names for businesses. SABMiller, for example, uses the name Pabod in Rivers, Ilesha Brewery in Osun, and Accra Brewery in Ghana. He tried to reduce the shareholding to Intafact, Anambra State and Next. He went on to write unadulterated falsehoods on how Anambra State revoked the Certificate of Occupancy of an International Steel Industry Ltd, Onitsha and allocated it to Intafact Beverages Ltd, a private company in “overriding public interest”.

    The claim that a company’s land was revoked and given to SABMiller is a blatant lie. For the record, the land where SABMiller built their facility was purchased by SABMiller from General Cotton Mills, the owners, at the cost of 550 million naira after relevant resolutions by the board – this is verifiable. The transaction was handled by a known estate agent, Okolo and Okolo, based in Onitsha. SABMiller paid for all the facilities of General Cotton Mill they are using. The International Steel’s land was truly revoked for overriding public interest, for they abandoned the land for years and it dilapidated a lot – but not for SABMiller.

    In his Anambra and the Limits of Propaganda, Offodile wrote: “Talking about investment in the state, the governor is known to be a successful trader before he became governor. If the state is so attractive for business, what informed the decision of his own company NEXT International to invest over N12 billion building the two largest shopping malls in Abuja, one in Mabushi and the other in Central Area, opposite federal ministry of transport? The governor announced proudly that this year, he will pay N32 million as tax in Anambra State. Why invest and create employment outside the state and then pay tax in Anambra State? It is a very strange way of doing things. Anambra State needs the investment and jobs that the governor outsourced to Abuja and other places.’’

    My interest in the quote is not to state that the mall at central area he referred to was long completed before Obi became governor. It is not to start telling him all over again that Obi resigned in all the companies he has interest in before being sworn-in as the Governor or debunk other lies of his, but to show how he criticized the governor that a company he has interest in is not investing in Anambra State.
    What actually does Offodile want? To destroy Anambra State and Anambra people in his senseless vendetta against Peter Obi, whom he described as an agent of light sent to Anambra by God, when he got the ticket to contest the senatorial election under APGA?
    This is more than double standard. He even failed to mention the names of five other companies, including the one owned by a Deltan and a Lagosian that invested in the company. He should also tell us if the investment is by Next or by Peter Obi as a governor.
    Next, for the avoidance of doubt, is a reputable company that has engaged in business for over 20 years with SABMiller and they needed it as part of the Anambra experience to boost their confidence. If they had invested in other states, who says that Next would not have been part of it? The important thing is that the transaction was transparent and above board.
    Reading Offodile, he is merely saying that Next, Fidelity, Nestle, Diamond Bank, Enterprise Bank and almost all the companies in Nigeria, for Obi has interests in many of them, should stop business in Nigeria because he is a governor. He could have as well asked the president not to commission Orient Petroleum because Obi has shares in it as well as most of his commissioners and aides, including this writer that answered to the call for all of us to invest in it and achieve the Anambra dream.

    On the allegation of Governor Obi personally handling all negotiations between Anambra State and SABMiller group and visited South Africa several times on the subject, as an insider, I accompanied the governor to South Africa and London. Since having made up their mind to invest in Nigeria, the question was where among competing locations. Each state governor pulled all strings for his state to be favoured. Now that Obi got it, see what this Offodile is writing!

    SABMiller has invested in other states in Nigeria, without their people trying in any way to jeopardize their business. Does it mean those states do not have an Offodile or could it be that their Offodiles are more patriotic and understanding to respect what will be of benefit to their people? We are talking of a Fortune 500 company that has investment in 75 countries, with market capitalization around 100 billion dollars.

    For Offodile’s information, the President commissioned Orange Drugs facility as well as Krisoral, the first company that is into manufacturing of Roll over Pilfer-proof caps and HDP caps. Added to SABMiller, the three companies have the capacity to employ over 1500 direct labour and over 10,000 indirect labour. Rather than celebrate this development, the likes of Offodile are agitated.
    The likes of Offodile belong to the old order being driven out of Anambra State; if they cannot attract anything to Anambra State, they have the honourable duty to commend those doing so or remain quiet.

    • Obienyem writes from Akwa, Anambra State