Category: Special Report

  • Chinese loans and Nigeria’s sovereign immunity

    Chinese loans and Nigeria’s sovereign immunity

    Many Nigerians are worried that the country is drowning in debt. There is hardly a month the Federal Government does not talk about borrowing either commercial loans or the concessionary type. However, what is giving Nigerians serious cause for concern is the possibility that China, one Nigeria’s creditors, may have planted a clause in the agreement that will force Nigeria to give up its critical national assets if it fails to repay the loans. ASSISTANT EDITOR NDUKA CHIEJINA reports on the status of the sovereign immunity clause.

    Nigerians once again suffered a panic attack when it was rumoured that the Chinese government was taking over the Ugandan International airport in Entebe.

    The basis for the alleged Chinese takeover of Entebe International Airport was the inability of the Ugandan government to meet its obligation to pay back the loan it collected from the Chinese government.

    In August 2020, there was a raging debate that the federal government has signed away the country’s sovereignty to China by endorsing a clause which suggested that Nigeria will waive its sovereignty and allow China to take over national assets it deems fit in place of the unserviced loan.

    One year after, the ‘Ugandan rumour’ has thrown up questions again about what Nigeria has pledged to China as collateral for the loans collected.

    What the government says

    The Director General of the Debt Management Office (DMO) Ms. Patience Oniha has assured Nigerians that there is no threat to the nation’s assets. To ensure the safety of these assets, Oniha said: “Nigeria prioritises debt service. Several measures which operate seamlessly have been put in place to ensure that data on debt are available and that debt is serviced as at when due.”

    She went on: “Provisions are made explicitly for Debt Service on External Debt and Domestic Debt in the annual budgets. The DMO maintains proper records of debts (Domestic and External), provides projections for Debt Service which are captured explicitly as Debt Service in the annual budgets, and processes the actual payments for the debt service in conjunction with the Office of the Accountant General of the Federation and Central Bank of Nigeria.”

    Government is so serious about servicing its debts so much so that proving funds for debt servicing takes utmost precedence when preparing the nation’s annual budget, while other segments of national life have to settle for debt service left over.

    Oniha stated that “before any foreign loan is contracted (including through the issuance of Eurobonds), they are approved by the Federal Executive Council and thereafter, National Assembly”.

    The terms and conditions of the Chinese and other loans she said are meticulously read through by officials of the federal ministry of justice before the federal ministry of finance signs off on the documents. According to her, “an important and extremely critical step is that the Loan Agreements are cleared and approved by the Federal Ministry of Justice and an Opinion is issued by the Honourable Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice before the Agreements are signed”.

    With regards to a party not meeting its end of the agreement, Oniha stated that “the Loan Agreements provide that where there is a dispute between the Parties, the first action is that the Parties should resolve it within themselves and if that fails, they go to arbitration. In other words, a lender, in this case, China would not just possess an asset at the first sign of a dispute including defaults”.

    Since June 2020, the DMO has been sensitizing Nigerians on the issue of China Loans through a publication on the DMO’s website and has since then published information (projects, loan amount, Interest Rate, etc.) on all China Loans to Nigeria on its website.

    How much loan has Nigeria taken from China?

    As of March 31, 2020, the total borrowing by Nigeria from China was USD3.121 billion (N1,126.68 billion at USD/N361). This amount represents only 3.94 per cent of Nigeria’s Total Public Debt of USD79.303 billion (N28,628.49 billion at USD/N361) as of March 31, 2020. Similarly, in terms of external sources of funds, loans from China accounted for 11.28 per cent of the External Debt Stock of USD27.67 billion on the same date. This data, the DMO said, “shows that China is not a major source of funding for the Nigerian Government”.

    What are the terms of the loans from China and what were they used for?

    The total borrowing from China of USD3.121 billion as of March 31, 2020, are concessional loans with interest rates of 2.50 per cent per annum, the tenor of twenty years (that is 20 years to repay the loan) and grace period (Moratorium) of seven years.

    These terms the DMO said are in accordance with “the provisions of Section 41 (1a) of the Fiscal Responsibility Act, 2007. In addition, the low-interest rate reduces the Interest Cost to Government while the long tenor enables the repayment of the principal sum of the loans over many years. These two benefits, make the provisions for Debt Service in the annual budget lower than they would otherwise have been if the Loans were on commercial terms”.

    The USD3.121 billion Chinese loans are project-tied. The projects, 11 in number as at March 31, 2020), include the Nigerian Railway Modernization Project (Idu-Kaduna section); Abuja Light Rail Project; Four Airport Terminals Expansion Project (Abuja, Kano, Lagos and Port Harcourt); Nigerian Railway Modernization Project (Lagos-Ibadan section) and Rehabilitation and Upgrading of Abuja – Keffi- Makurdi Road Project.

    The impact of these loans Oniha said “is not only evident but visible. For instance, the Idu – Kaduna Rail Line has become a major source of transportation between Abuja and Kaduna. Also, the new International Airport in Abuja, has improved air transportation for the populace, while the Lagos – Ibadan rail line, when completed, will ease traffic on the busy Lagos -Ibadan Expressway”.

    The projects also have the added benefits of job creation, not only by themselves but through direct and indirect service providers, a number of which are Small and Medium Enterprises. “It is widely accepted that investment in infrastructure is one of the most effective tools for countries to achieve economic growth and development. Using loans from China to finance infrastructure is thus in alignment with this position, the DMO boss said.

    What the lawyers say

    A former President of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Dr. Olisa Agbakoba (SAN), told The Nation last year that he believes there is nothing to worry about. He dismissed the claim that the sovereign immunity clause will oust the country’s immunity.

    The contentious clause states that: “the borrower hereby irrevocably waives any immunity on the grounds of sovereign or otherwise for itself or its property in connection with any arbitration proceeding pursuant to Article 8(5), thereof with the enforcement of any arbitral award pursuant thereto, except for the military assets and diplomatic assets.”

    Agbakoba described the clause as a standard contractual provision. “that is introduced when two sovereigns are doing business – like China and Nigeria – or a non-sovereign and a sovereign are doing business it is for the sovereign debtor, such as Nigeria, to have her credit assessed”.

    Speaking further, Agbakoba lamented that “Africa’s credit rating is sub-optimal. No bank in Nigeria will give a loan unless there are assurances of it being repaid. If you’re the governor of a state, the bank manager will ask: ‘If I give you a loan, will you not invoke your immunity?’ and you say no. Then the manager will say, ‘Let us have it in the contract that in the event you default, you will not invoke your immunity.’ So, it’s actually a waiver of immunity clause, not a sovereign immunity clause.”

    He added that “if you have good standing internationally, for instance, America will not waive its sovereign immunity because America is good for credit. Unfortunately, few African countries are not good for credit. So, it is the creditworthiness issue that is the problem.”

    When the controversy over the Chinese loans, and possible forfeiture of some critical national assets to China in the event Nigeria fails to pay back the loan, was raging, Agbakoba said: “When the National Assembly began to make all the noise, it beat me hollow; they absolutely got it wrong. There’s nothing like a sovereign immunity clause. It’s a contractual clause that simply says ‘if you don’t pay, we’ll go after your assets.”

    However, Mr. Norrison Quakers (SAN) who also spoke to The Nation on the issue last year, disagreed with Agbakoba. According to him, “no country will willingly cede its sovereignty to another country on the basis of a contractual arrangement.”

    He observed that the agreement seemed to put China in a position of power over Nigeria, Quakers said: “as far as I am concerned, I haven’t seen the agreement itself, but I’ve read some extracts here and there concerning the clause. The only thing I see there is like an unfair contract, a situation where someone has an upper hand, an edge over you. By saying ‘Ok, you want this facility, I’ll give it to you, but in the unlikely event of a default, you will not define assets that I will hold on to, to liquidate the debts.”

    What the analyst says

    Dr Uche Igwe, a Senior Political Economy Analyst and Visiting Fellow at the LSE Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa in his article “What do sovereign immunity clauses mean for Chinese engagement with Africa”, noted that while the economic relationship between China and many African countries is on the rise, speculations are rife that “the Chinese government has a hidden agenda. Many see sovereign immunity clauses in Chinese loan agreements as a ploy to re-colonise Africa from the back, while others ask whether these loans form debt-trap diplomacy”.

    Igwe noted that “Chinese engagement with African countries has spanned over two decades, traversing trade, investment, infrastructure financing and aid. During this period, China has catapulted from being a relatively small investor to the highest creditor in sub-Saharan Africa”.

    The nature of these loans as well as the processes of procuring them he said “are often opaque and confidential. Widespread allegations of bribery and kickback have continued to fuel acrimonious debates and political cacophony across the continent”.

    Speaking on the controversial sovereign immunity clause Igwe admitted that it is “included in most standard Chinese agreements. The apparent reason is to prevent countries from raising sovereign immunity as a defence in case of any legal dispute. However, many politicians and opinion leaders in Nigeria vehemently disagree”.

    Rather they insist that many of the loans are Trojan horses with hidden intentions that could lead to the surrender of choice sovereign assets” he said.

    Igwe said some “critics describe it as predatory lending and insist that the government in Beijing is deliberately on a global lending spree, showering African countries with billions of dollars in exchange for natural resources, long-term concessions as well as economic and political influence”.

    China is accused of systematically piling up “a debt burden on African countries to a point where they will be struggling to pay the money back. They are said to insist on juicy national assets as collateral for such loans. Yet China is reportedly reluctant to grant debt relief to Africa to enable these poorer countries to cope with the economic havoc wreaked by the pandemic”.

    Loans from China now $3.59bn, says DMO

    The Debt Management Office has clarified that loans from China to Nigeria, which presently stood at $3.59bn, constitutes only 9.4 per cent of the country’s total foreign debt stock of $37.9bn.

    The Director-General of DMO, Ms Patience Oniha, made this known in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria on Saturday in Abuja.

    She also clarified that the loans were largely concessional, as no national asset was tagged as collateral.

    NAN reports that in recent times, both the social and mainstream media have been awash with news about some African countries, including Nigeria, facing the threat of losing some critical national assets to the Asian country due to high level indebtedness.

    “Nigeria’s total debt stock as at September 30 was $37.9bn; this figure comprised the external debt stock of the Federal Government, 36 state governments and the Federal Capital Territory.

    “But total loans from China stands at 3.59 billion dollars, which is 9.47 per cent of the total external debt.  The loans did not require any national asset as collateral; they were largely concessional,’’ she said.

    Oniha urged Nigerians to always endeavour to verify sensitive information from official sources before disseminating it.

    She explained that before foreign loans were contracted, very sensitive steps were taken by multiple institutions of government to ensure that they were beneficial to the nation.

    “Before any foreign loan is contracted, including the issuance of Eurobond, they are approved by the Federal Executive Council and thereafter, the National Assembly.

    “An important and extremely critical step is that the loan agreements are approved by the Federal Ministry of Justice.

    “An opinion is issued by the Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice before the agreements are signed.

    “Several measures which operate seamlessly have been put in place to ensure that data on debt are available and that debt is serviced as at when due. Provisions are made explicitly for debt service in the annual budgets,’’ she said.

    Oniha explained that the loans agreements provided a number of steps to take to resolve dispute when they arise.

    “The first action is that the parties should resolve it within themselves and if that fails, they go to arbitration.

    “In other words, a lender, in this case, China, would not just pounce on an asset at the first sign of a dispute, including defaults,’’ the she said.

    She explained that the DMO maintained proper records of debts, provided projections for debt service and processed the actual payments for debt service.

    She pointed out that those functions were carried out in conjunction with the Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation (OAGF) and the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN).

  • COVID-19: Fears of surge over Christmas, New Year rush

    COVID-19: Fears of surge over Christmas, New Year rush

    By Moses Emoriken, Abuja and Sunny Nwankwo, Aba

    • Use of face mask ignored at markets, social gatherings

    • WHO: Exercise caution during holiday season; says Omicron cases hit 89 countries

    With new Covid-19 cases rising to a record 1,584 on Friday, the highest across the country in 10 months, there are now fears of a possible surge arising from unrestrained interactions during the Christmas and New Year festivities.

    Activities are on the rise at markets and shopping malls, according to our correspondents, while traffic is also increasing on the highways as a result of people travelling to their hometowns for the festivals.

    Although the federal government has repeatedly said it has no immediate plan to impose restrictions because of the rising cases of Covid-19, some foreign countries are not ruling out new measures to stop the surge.

    Scientists say the Omicron variant spreads quickly everywhere it lands.

    The World Health Organization (WHO) advised people to exercise caution during the holiday season, especially during the Christmas season, and warned that the Omicron coronavirus variant has already been reported in 89 countries.

    It said the number of cases is doubling in 1.5 to 3 days in areas with community transmission.

    Vehicular movement from other parts of the country to the South-East has been particularly heavy in the last one week despite the security challenge in the area.

    One of our correspondents who monitored buying and selling at the popular Oshodi market in Lagos yesterday observed that only about one person out of 10 wore a face mask.

    Social distancing appeared to mean nothing to the people, many of whom came for Christmas and New Year shopping.

    The various markets in the commercial city of Aba, Abia State have also been recording large turnout of buyers ahead of Christmas and New Year.

    Major roads such as Port Harcourt Road off Aba-Port Harcourt Expressway, Faulks off Aba-Port Harcourt Expressway, Tonimas Junction off Aba-Port Harcourt Expressway, Chima Nwafor/MCCJjunction off Aba-Port Harcourt Expressway, Osisioma Junction off Aba-Port Harcourt Expressway, Ikot Ekpene and Azumini leading into the heart of the economic town have also been busy despite their deplorable  conditions.

    Social gatherings, including parties, are no different and there are fears that nothing is likely to change in this regard during the coming festivities.

    Notwithstanding, the federal government has urged Nigerians who are yet to take the COVID-19 booster doses to do so to enable them  have extra-protection against COVID-19, especially the Omicron variant.

    The administration of booster doses started on December 10, 2021 but  only those from  18 years and above, and those who must have received their second dose of AstraZeneca, Pfizer Bio-N-Tech or Moderna at least 6 months ago are qualified for it.

    However, for Johnson & Johnson booster doses, a time interval of two months or more is required.

    It however stressed that the AstraZeneca vaccine is not to be used as a booster for individuals who have taken AstraZeneca vaccine as first and second doses. Only Pfizer can be used as a booster for those that have taken AstraZeneca vaccine as first and second doses.

    Speaking during the 4th quarter meeting of the Northern Traditional Leaders Committee (NTLC) on primary health care delivery, the Executive Director of the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA), Dr. Faisal Shuaib, asked all eligible Nigerians to take advantage of this opportunity to get their booster doses.

    He said: “As we are all aware, Omicron variant of COVID-19 virus has already been detected in Nigeria.

    “Although studies are still being conducted to determine the nature of this variant, what its presence means to us Nigerians is that we must strengthen our COVID-19 response and continuously observe all non-pharmaceutical measures to prevent further spread.

    “I want to assure Nigerians that the Federal Government has deployed the necessary logistics to halt and control this variant.

    “We do not need to start a fresh war against Omicron. It is just a variant of the COVID virus that can be handled if we all comply and take all recommended doses of the vaccines while continuing to observe protective measures such as wearing of face masks, regular washing of our hands and social distancing to protect ourselves.”

    Lagos recorded 906 of the new cases logged on Friday with FCT and Rivers following with 258 and 217 cases respectively.

    Others are Edo – 85, Oyo – 50, Ogun – 16, Ondo – 14, Bayelsa – 12, Osun – 10, Bauchi – nine, and Kano – seven.

    Turkey to send 15m Covid vaccine doses to Africa

    President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey yesterday told President Muhammadu Buhari and other participants at a summit in Istanbul that his country would send 15 million doses of COVID-19 vaccine to Africa.

    Turkey is developing its own vaccine known as Turkovac.

    He said: “We are aware of the global injustice in accessing the COVID-19 vaccine and Africa’s unjust treatment.

    “It is disgraceful for humanity that only six per cent of Africa’s population has been vaccinated.”

    Exercise caution during holiday season, says WHO

    The World Health Organization (WHO) advised people to exercise caution during the holiday season, especially during the Christmas season.

    “As we go into the holiday season, we are dealing with two highly transmissible variants, with the potential to overwhelm our already overstretched health systems,” Dr, Hans Henri P. Kluge, WHO Regional Director for Europe said.

    “But this does not have to be a repeat of last year when Christmas was cancelled for so many and families were unable to meet.

    “My message to the people of Europe and central Asia is to exercise caution this holiday season. Use the many tools we have at our disposal.

    “These stabilizers help us to manage the virus and keep people safe.

    “Get vaccinated as soon as possible, and with the full dose series. Vaccines remain the best way to prevent severe disease and death, even with the arrival of the Omicron variant. If you are eligible for a third dose and it is available to you, take it.

    “If you plan to attend social gatherings with friends and family, keep them small and if available, take a lateral flow/antigen or PCR test beforehand to make sure that you are not infectious.

    “Follow other preventive measures, even if you are fully vaccinated. Avoid crowded or confined places, wear a well-fitting mask, observe physical distancing of at least one metre, ventilate indoor spaces by opening windows and/or doors, and keep your hands clean.

    “Seek out reliable sources of information that provide advice based on the latest evidence and scientific consensus.”

    Omicron cases now in 89 countries, doubling three days in areas with local spread

    In a separate update yesterday, WHO said the Omicron coronavirus variant has been reported in 89 countries and the number of cases is doubling in 1.5 to 3 days in areas with community transmission.

    Omicron is spreading rapidly in countries with high levels of population immunity, but it is unclear if this is due to the virus’ ability to evade immunity, its inherent increased transmissibility or a combination of both, WHO said.

    “There are still limited data on the clinical severity of Omicron,” WHO said.

    “More data are needed to understand the severity profile and how severity is impacted by vaccination and pre-existing immunity.”

    It added: “There are still limited available data, and no peer-reviewed evidence, on vaccine efficacy or effectiveness to date for Omicron”.

     UK considers new COVID-19 measures

    Reports from London yesterday indicated that the U.K. was considering a two-week ban on people in England gathering indoors after Christmas to slow the omicron variant’s spread.

    Prime Minister Boris Johnson hasn’t approved the plan, and advisers are waiting for more data about the new strain.

    The BBC said it had seen leaked minutes of a meeting of the government’s scientific advisers calling for more stringent restrictions to be brought in “very soon” in a bid to stop the National Health Service from becoming overwhelmed.

    With Christmas fast approaching, the U.K.’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE) said when it met on Thursday that without further restrictions, hospital admissions in England could peak at 3,000 a day or more, according to the BBC. Hospitalizations are already rising sharply in London.

    French president cancels Mali trip over new COVID-19 wave

    President Emmanuel Macron cancelled a December 20 to 21 trip to Mali to visit French troops due to France’s deteriorating health situation over the spread of the Omicron COVID-19 variant, his office said.

    “This decision was taken in order for there to be coherence between national measures and the president’s international agenda, and in order not to expose troops,” Macron’s office said.

    With France in the grip of its fifth COVID-19 wave, Prime Minister Jean Castex announced a new push on Friday to get people vaccinated and said people would have to show proof of vaccination to enter some venues.

    Castex also said France would from next month reduce the time between second and third COVID-19 vaccination injections to four months.

  • Our bodies are oozing maggots, Abuja IDPs cry out

    Our bodies are oozing maggots, Abuja IDPs cry out

    Residents of the internally displaced persons (IDP) camp in Area One, Abuja are not only suffering from hunger as donations from public-spirited individuals get leaner and leaner, they are also contending with maggot and bed bug attacks resulting from the unhygienic environment they are kept in, GRACE OBIKE reports.

    • Battle outbreak of bedbugs in camp

    • Vow to return to Northeast homes even if they would get killed

    For many internally displaced persons (IDPs) who fled from insurgents and bandits in their homelands in the Northeast to seek refuge in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), it has been shattered hopes. Contrary to their belief that Abuja was was the Promise Land from which they would get respite from the hardship inflicted on them by the deadly groups, they have since realised their status in the FCT as uninvited guests who are not be eligible to much assistance from the FCT Emergency Management Agency  (FEMA) because the law that constituted it made no provisions for IDPs from other parts of the country.

    To worsen matters, there was an outbreak of the the COVID-19 pandemic and the economic hardship it imposed on everyone including the donors made up mostly of foriegn-based  non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and well-meaning Nigerians who had been assisting the IDPs since  their arrival.

    The situation is now forcing the IDPs to depend on cashews and mangoes in their vicinities. Now, their greatest affliction is no longer their displacement or hunger but the invasion of their camp by maggots.

     

    Horror tales

    “Aunty, please, I need your help but I feel too shamed to tell you.” Those were the words of Sa’adatu Salle, a heavily pregnant 25-year-old mother of two, to her neighbour and mother of eight, Hajara Suleiman, when she could no longer bear the excruciating pains that had restricted her movements for days.

    Although her trauma had persisted for days to the extent that moving her body was becoming impossible, Salle had refused to tell anyone, including her husband, because of the nature of her affliction. She had developed a huge boil in her private parts and only got the courage to ask for help when Suleiman visited to check up on her pregnancy.

    Seeing the feeling of  shame on the younger woman’s face, Suleiman convinced her to speak up. When she eventually did, Suleiman checked the boil and raised the alarm, prompting the older women to call the women leader in the camp for assistance.

    “We cleaned the affected part with hot water and salt, then we began to press it for the maggot to come out.

    “Her screams filled the camp as we did, because the pains she felt was worse than childbirth.

    “When the maggot eventually came out, It was the largest I had ever seen in my life.”

    But Salle’s plight was not an isolated incident. Investigation conducted by our correspondent revealed that virtually every  household in the camp had similar complaints on different parts of their bodies.

    Suleiman and her family members are one of the most afflicted in the camp. Five of her eight children have had to pass through the process of removing offensive maggots from different parts of their bodies, including the cheeks, necks and limbs. And she herself was not spared the ordeal as she has had to remove maggots from her side and lap.

    “It is not just the itching and scratching but the offensive smell that comes from the sore after the maggot is out. When it comes out, it leaves a gaping hole that takes days to close, and if not properly taken care of, it gets infected.”

    Another resident of the camp and mother of six, Aisha Umar, has also had a horrible encounter with the unwanted visitor. In fact, she had just removed a maggot from the body of one of her daughters less than an hour before our correspondent arrived.

    She disclosed that four out of her six children were afflicted this season and they go through the horror in the rainy and cold seasons.

    “We removed at least seven from different parts of my nephew’s body alone on different occasions. My children had three, two and at least one removed from their bodies,” she said.

     

    Why maggots?

    The infestation of the skin by maggots is known in medical terms as Myiasis. It is the parasitic infestation of the body of a live animal or human by fly larvae (maggots), which grows inside the host while feeding on its tissue.

    This infestation is done by different species of flies including the tumbu fly and human botfly. Many of the flies do not always lay eggs on humans. Instead, the flies lay their eggs on other insects such as mosquitoes, which help them deposit it on their hosts.

    “It can also occur through the swallowing of eggs or larvae deposited on food or objects such as wet clothes laid out to dry, which may come in contact with people’s skin. The eggs hatch into larvae, which burrow into the skin and develop into mature larvae.

    Former President, Nigerian Association of Dermatologists, Dr Grace Udo, explained that such an infestation is more likely to occur in tropical and padi areas.

    To prevent myiasis in humans, she said, “there is a need for general improvement of sanitation, personal hygiene, and extermination of the flies with insecticides. Clothes should be washed thoroughly, preferably in hot water, dried away from flies, and ironed thoroughly. The heat of the iron kills the eggs of myiasis causing flies.”

     

    Myiasis in Nigeria

    The only recorded investigation of widespread cases of myiasis was that of a research conducted in the Niger Delta region in 2009 and published on the website of the National Library of Medicine, by Ogugua Ogbalu.

    It was titled ‘Epidemiology of Human Furuncular Myiasis of Cordylobia Anthropophaga (Grunberg) in Nigeria’, in the report, 200 people were randomly selected for myiasis infection in each of the six states.

    In the result, 88 per cent of 200 patients examined in Rivers State had the Cordylobia infection, followed by Cross Rivers State (86%), Bayelsa (84%) while Edo, Delta, and Akwa Ibom states showed higher than 82% infection in that order.

    The findings showed that women, children, and infants are commonly affected by furuncular myiasis. The rate of infection is higher during the rainy season when humidity is normally higher. Most cases of human myiasis are not reported but treated locally.

    The findings showed that human furuncular myiasis affects neonates ranging from 3 to 11 days old, children and adults in Nigeria.

    For the IDPs in Area1, their camp is not located in a tropical region but close to a small padi area, which could be a huge part of their problems, because those at the Kuchigoro camp confessed to not having such an experience.

    A survey carried out by International Organization for Migration (IOM) showed an increase in IDPs from the Northeast since December 2020. A total of 2,184,254 Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) from the Northeastern region were identified in 447,628 households. This signifies a 1.6 per cent increase (or 34,011 individuals).

    Abuja alone has four camps in Lugbe, Area One, New Kuchigoro and Kuje IDP camps and they each have their peculiar problems.

    How they cope

    Although any visitor to the camp can testify to the fact that it is always clean with no visible heaps of refuse dumped indiscriminately or stagnant drainages, Suleiman’s three years old daughter Aisha and some other children in the camp also deal with other horrible skin conditions apart from infestation of maggots.

    Her three-years-old’s skin is covered in old and new scally sores, which the mother says bothers the girl.

    “She is always scratching her legs and the sores look so horrible. I have taken her to the chemist on different occasions and she has been prescribed with numerous medications but non of them has worked.

    “So far, I have spent so much money on her and right now, I have been told that I might need to take her to the hospital for her blood to be tested, but I don’t have that kind of money.” Suleiman lamented.

    Dr Udo said the case of Aisha might be due to bites from sand flies.

    She explained: “Sand fly bites are painful and may cause red bumps and blisters. These bumps and blisters can become infected or cause skin inflammation or dermatitis.

    “Sand flies transmit diseases to animals and humans, including a parasitic disease called leishmaniasis.”

    Udo further explained that in most cases, people develop immunity to the bites as they grow into their teenage years, adding that the bites are more frequent from 10am to 2pm.

    Apart from dealing with the different species of flies and their effects, residents now deal with a devastating case of bedbug infestation. Because of the struc ture of the camp where makeshift buildings or shacks are built close to one another, the infestation has spread like wildfire.

    Suleiman explained that she had done everything she could to spare her family, including spreading their belongings under the sun and dousing containers of insecticides in all corners of her house.

    “I have finished over 10 containers of insecticide in this house, but the bedbugs only take a break for a couple of days and return with more vigour.” Suleiman explained. Apart from the scares left behind by the flies, residents are equally left with secondary skin infection due to excessive itching caused by bedbugs.

    Resolve

    Suleiman said that with all the problems they face in Abuja, from hunger to their health conditions, many of them have resolved to return to their states of origin, not minding that they could get killed.

    According to her, Sa’adatu Salle and her family returned home after her ordeal and quite a number of residents in the camp are gradually looking for funds to return.

    “One of my neighbours and her family returned to Bama (Borno State) a few weeks ago. The next day, the husband decided to go to the farm to collect firewood for his family and he was killed by Boko Haram. But that won’t discourage us. It’s better we die in our lands with hoe in our hands than of hunger and diseases in Abuja.

    “We have been asking the government to assist in our relocation but no one is responding to us.”

    She said her fear as her oldest son who is 15 years old grows older is for him not to join a bad gang in his bid to provide for the family, seeing the amount of suffering they are passing through.

    “In our place, every child grows with a hoe In his hand. But here in Abuja, our children are losing the culture and getting themselves involved in bad things because there are no jobs to keep them busy,” Suleiman said.

  • DAKAR, Senegalese city where civilization meets history

    DAKAR, Senegalese city where civilization meets history

    Just back from Dakar, the capital city of Senegal, ADEOLA OGUNLADE reports on his visit to some of Africa’s biggest tourist attractions including the African Renaissance Monuments reputed as the biggest statue in Africa and The Point Of No Return, Africa’s window to the world through which slaves were transported to Europe in the heady days of the obnoxious slave trade.

    TRAVELLING from the airport to the centre of Senegal in a trip that takes more than one hour, the first thing that would strike a visitor from Nigeria is the clean, nylon-tarred roads devoid of potholes. Although the roads are tiny, they are never as chaotic as one would find in Lagos, Ibadan or other Nigerian cities because the motorists observe traffic rules to the letter. This, perhaps, explains the not too visible presence of law enforcement agents around the city, safe for a few spots.

    •Aerial view of Dakar

    Dakar, no doubt, is one of Africa’s most expensive cities. Daniel, a resident of the city and administrative staff in one of its prominent organisations, said that Dakar hosts a lot of foreigners because of its tourist attractions, accounting in part for the high cost of living. For instance, a room apartment costs 75, 000 CFA (about N53,000) monthly

    Transportation is equally expensive, costing an average of 1,000 CFA per drop in a public bus reputed for its unique nature as passengers have to board it from the back. To help passengers ferry their goods, a small carrier is built on top of the bus. Yet the most popular means of public transportation among locals is the station wagon vehicle known as ‘Sept Places’ because up to seven people can be packed into the vehicles at once.

    As an alternative to ‘Sept Places’, there are mini-buses painted white with carriers on top of them to carry loads belonging to passengers. But they are generally considered less comfortable as they could between 20 and 30 passengers at once. The driver could squeeze as many as seven adults into a row meant for three or four persons.

    Besides the discomfort, boarding the mini-buses could amount to wasting time as the driver would not leave the bus terminal until he has secured a sizable number of passengers. Members of the transport union are usually on hand in some of the terminals to help the drivers get passengers easily.

    Of course, the mini-buses are cheaper than the Sept Places and taxi. Dakar is the only Senegalese city with a substantial inner-city bus system, called Dakar Demm Dikk. Senegal’s main inter-city transportation system is made up of mini-buses known as Car Rapides. To board these white, blue or yellow vehicles, would be passengers must flag them down and call out their destinations. On getting to their destinations, passengers must bang loudly on the side of the Car Rapide or signal to the conductor.

    At about 12 noon every day, activities in most public and private organizations are at the lowest ebb and vehicular traffic begins to build because no fewer than 95% of the inhabitants of Dakar are Muslims and they have to go for prayers at 1:00pm.  People drive in to get to one of the Dakar Grand Mosques, the biggest mosques in Senegal situated at Allée Pape Gueye Fall, in order to be part of the afternoon prayer session.

    Unlike Nigeria, the city is averse to the use of tricycles as a means of transportation. That may partly be responsible for the high cost of transportation.

    “Here, tricycles are not allowed to be used for commercial purposes,” Daniel said.

     Fascinating places for visitors

    Dakar is not only about big corporations, religious centers, shopping malls and inter-governmental agencies; it has unique recreational activities for fun seekers. As an ocean-facing country, there is a wide array of water sports available from surfing and diving to fishing and swimming. Also, there are football clubs, rugby clubs, tennis courts, speed boats, motorcycle tours and golf courses.

    According to a report, Senegal has 530km of coastline of which more than half is the golden sandy beach. It is a beach lover’s paradise. But it is not just the ocean that attracts. Senegal is also home to deltas, lagoons, rivers and marshlands. There are dune-filled deserts and palm-tree-lined forests beside bustling cities and quaint villages.

    As in most of Africa, football is the most popular sport in Senegal, with the nation producing some of the most famous players on the continent, including Liverpool striker Sadio Mané and Napoli center-back Kalidou Koulibaly. Around 4 pm in the evening, young people would be seen playing around the shoreline. Some of them play football while others play basketball. There are also different sites across the shoreline where exercise can be done.

    According to Francis, a Nigerian based in Dakar, people use the shoreline for prayers and relaxation. In the evening, it is an exciting sight to behold.

    Dakar is home to the trendy and the traditional; Senegal’s old and new. It is a fascinating city for dancing, bargain-hunting and authentic culture. In the relaxed neighbourhood of Mamelles, La Calebasse is a good spot to sample traditional African cuisine.

    Monument of the African Renaissance

    Riding from Novetel Hotel in Avenue Abdoulaye Fadiga, the centre of Dakar overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, could be great excitement. It is a journey that takes about 30 minutes on tiny roads across Dakar. On the threshold of the venue are soldiers saddled with the responsibility of guarding the statue. On sight are a very lovely restaurant and beautiful Senegalese craft stores. Some neat graffiti of murals can also be found on walls at the parking lot.

    On hand are cameramen awaiting visitors who want to climb Africa’s biggest statue and one of the largest sculptures in the world. On one of the twin hills in the Mamelles District of Dakar lays this preposterous and magnificent edifice. It is called the African Renaissance Monument. The monument depicts the sculpture of man, woman and child. It is seen as a symbol of defiance and Senegal’s future prosperity. This statue is situated atop a 152-metre-high hill dominating Dakar’s skyline

    It is built on a rock and it will take over 200 steps to reach the monument’s base, making it terribly difficult and exhilarating to climb. Hence, resilience and courage are needed to get to the top. The edifice has two entrances — one for visitors and the other for the country’s President and his guests.

    The monument was built by Mansudae Overseas Projects, a North Korean state-owned construction company, with the support of some Senegalese’s. At the entrance of the monuments was an inscription written in French and interpreted to the writer by a tour guide. According to the tour guide, the monuments were built in memory of those who died in Senegal and other parts of Africa in the struggle against colonialism and slavery.

    The Senegalese monument project lasted for eight years including two years of construction. It began in 2002 when former president Abdoulaye Wade began planning a massive hilltop monument that would represent Senegal and perhaps Africa’s freedom from centuries of slavery and colonialism. It was completed in 2010.

    Entering the monument costs a visitor 3,000 CFA while an indigene pays 1,000 CFA. The monument has a lift that reaches the 15th floor. On the 15th floor, one can easily see the image of the boy and the woman in the monument. It also gives a visitor the opportunity to see the aerial view of Dakar city. However, visitors only have access to move around the monument from the ground floor to the second floor.

    Inside the monument are many historical materials donated from different African countries. About 12 Africa leaders were on the ground when the monument was opened in 2010.

    On the ground floor of the monument are moving pictures of how it was built and the various stages of the construction. It also has an artwork-canoe with the image of a man, a woman and three children seated in the canoe.

    The artwork depicts how Africans travel by sea to Europe in search of better life, according to the tour guide. Pictures of different African leaders who have visited the statue are also on display. They include that of the Vice President of Nigeria, Prof Yemi Osibanjo and those of some African leaders who contributed immensely to the continent’s emancipation.

    On the first floor are different artworks. It has different works that depict the various ethnic groups in Senegal. On sight are such images as a man with notable traditional musical instruments, a foreigner who is a farmer, a siege who was sitting down, among others. It also has a noise-proof event hall that can harbour about 50 people. Also on this floor is a room with ancient chairs and various other artworks donated from different African countries.

    The statue shows a giant shirtless man holding a naked baby while guiding forth a scantily clad lady. Another depicts a man holding an infant aloft in one arm and guiding a woman with the other. The infant pointing ahead, it is said, is an indication of the nation’s glorious future while the woman extending her arm behind shows she’s trying to acknowledge the nation’s troubled past.

    The African Renaissance Monument was unveiled to commemorate Senegal’s 50 years of independence from France. The view from the top is magnificent. One can see visibly from the top the city of Dakar. This magnificent view spreads out to the horizon. The airport is to the east, while Dakar itself stretches to the south

    The giant structure has continued to yield a great deal of revenue for the country from tourists and nationals. A giant-like structure which is perhaps the tallest statue in Nigeria is the Queen Moremi Statue of Liberty.

    The Point of No Return

    At the entry point of the avenue that leads to the Point Of No Return are various inscriptions indicating that the site is filled with history, particularly in respect of slavery and the emancipation of the Senegalese people.

    It has different buildings such as the museum and event halls. It has a big waterfall where different calf’s pots were seated together. Pictures of the founding fathers of the city which dates more than 200 years ago are on the walls. Also, different pictures of Africa leaders and their messages about the continent are displayed for visitors.

    The access to the Point Of No Return is a small pathway that leads to the seashore. At the point of the seashore is a beautifully carved map of Africa with the different flags of the countries that make up the continent.  The Point Of No Return was the place where most slaves captured from Senegal in the colonial era were taken to America through the Goree Island.

  • ‘Our raw deal with sexual predators’

    ‘Our raw deal with sexual predators’

    Predators know the crude sign language of sexual and domestic violence, but the criminal justice system has none yet for redress, GBENGA OGUNDARE reports.

    When Ronke met Mike in 2016, her hearing impairment was no disruption strong enough to make her miss the signs of Mike’s affection for her.

    “He even told me that was exactly the thing that swept him off his feet. And I was like really? Okay, no problem,” Ronke said.

    And, indeed, there was no problem. Even if there was any warning sign loud as hell, Ronke couldn’t heed it. Not her fault. Love wasn’t only blind then, it was hard of hearing too.

    She hardly introduced Mike to her grandma—who equally sounded him out if he knew what he was going into—when she got pregnant for him.

    But reality set in after she had her first child.

    “He changed,” Ronke said amid tears.

    “He would spank and isolate me. He would not take me out.

    “I felt depressed, useless, disappointed, regretful. He’d shout at me and I’d cry. I was lonely.”

    The clarity with which she poured out her anguish and described the emotional torture her husband put her through is part of what expert regularly tick up as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

    To relieve herself, Ronke just used all she had—venting all her morbid feeling.

    No word could console her that she could hear. She is a one-track person. She can only express herself, thanks to hearing impairment.

    Ronke said when depression set in, she heeded the advice to move out of the marriage. And she has sworn she’s gone for good.

    Why not? She has her son, 4, the only fruit of the marriage, with her.

    She was lucky. Unlike Adebisi, 34, a mother of twins that have been severed from her already. They are alive in the house of her equally deaf ex-husband—somewhere in Igando, Lagos.

    friends traced the children in her desperate search. “But they told me initially on the phone that he and his mother and my twins had relocated to Abuja,” she said.

    It is a nightmare, considering her dream when she met the man on Facebook in 2011.

    Her romance followed a similar pattern as Ronke’s. They met eyeball to eyeball in Ogun in 2012, and he had a chance to know who he was in love with—with all her blemishes.

    By 2015, she, too, got pregnant for him even before settling major issues: where to live, livelihood, duties and responsibilities.

    The language of love is different from that of reality. With gestures, waves of the hands, rolls of the eyes, and coos, Adebisi could communicate love. But it was hard for her to tell him her feelings about his laziness and womanizing in the single room they lived with her mother-in-law because of the fear of his proclivity for violence.

     

    What was life like in that hellhole?

    “He beat me for seven years. He didn’t provide anything while I was pregnant. It was my big mummy in the US that sent me $300 for hospital bills and baby wears. My mother- in-law, who had no job except begging, was the one feeding me, the babies and their father,” she said.

    When he trounced her, she had no way of airing her side of the story to her mother-in-law who does not understand the language of the deaf. Plus the mother-in-law would always take sides with her son (her only child), and rebuke her for nagging.

    Sometimes, Adebisi took the beating for protesting her husband’s plan to take a second wife.

    Sensing danger, Adebisi’s father suggested his daughter should leave the twins at home and get a job. But she tried hunting for two years without success.

    The father then suggested that she move out and get a separate apartment, but her mother-in-law objected.

    “She said I could not go with my twins,” Adebisi said.

    And that was how it eventually ended—on the note her husband was taking a new wife, and she would have to leave the twins if the decision was not okay by her.

    She never reported this forced separation and other instances of domestic violence she suffered to the police or any agency.

    “I didn’t even know of any,” she said.

    She lived through it with no protection, no defence, and no survival tactics.

    She was unlike Folake who is 13 years older. Folake’s situation, in terms of the available faculties, looks similar to Ronke’s: she can’t hear you talk love or spew hurt.

    Notwithstanding, she knows domestic violence. She suffered it in her marriage to a man exactly like her, but 10 years older.

    Over two decades ago, both Folake and David met at Festac in Lagos. They were immediately attracted to each other.

    Their circumstances, in spite of their auditory impairment, were not that bad for a marriage. They both had something to do for a living. David worked for an FMCG company on the Island, in Lagos. She was a catfish farmer.

    They eventually settled down and had a girl whom they supported through university. She’s now a graduate at 22.

    In those years of raising their child, the couple somehow waxed cold in their love and the brute in the abuser reared up.

    David, Folake said, manhandled her so many times, stripping her naked and kicking her out. “I could stay out for three days, two weeks, and sometimes a month,” she said.

    David punched out her front tooth during one of those beatings. He was bent on disfiguring her.

    “He said I am too fine—that men will be calling me. He doesn’t trust me because he himself is a womanizer,” Folake explained only in a manner a person like her can.

    Unlike Adebisi, Folake’s mother-in-law never took sides with her son. “She was always accommodating me each time her son sent me out,” she said.

    She reported to the police sometimes with her daughter interpreting. “But he didn’t change,” Folake said.

    “He even stopped supporting our daughter in the university because she invited the police to come intervene the last time he beat me in the public.”

    All the mental and physical violence was taxing her health. Her blood pressure hit the roof at a point. She might die. So she decided to flee from the abusive marriage—a troubled union with a fellow living with disability.

    “Since last year, I have not gone back.  I love my life,” she said.

    Amid the toothache, spiraling blood pressure, shame, nakedness, and gossip she could never hear, Folake devised some coping mechanisms.

    “I go into meditation. I create positive mantras to counter the negative one. I make up my mind to be happy. I create physical distance,” she said.

    Folake’s mum taught her how to survive sexual predation as a child. Age and experience are on her side; and she is the chairperson of the Deaf Women Association of Nigeria in Lagos. So she can’t help being a survivalist.

    Her case was unlike Lola who at 15, with no ability to hear or talk, had no idea how to cope with sexual predators in her environment.

    When Kingsley lured her into an uncompleted building on August 5, 2021 at Aratusi, Oke-Aro, Akure, she was fair game.

    The 54 year-old was caught penetrating the girl, and the mob that got him was going to lynch him, but the police came and took him away.

    Kingsley is now in police custody, as though it were enough to keep Lola from venting her pain the way she can to achieve closure.

    Mary, 20, is like Lola: easy prey, deaf, dumb. It was well figured out when Azeez Salau, according to the police, scaled a fence and entered a house where Mary fetched and carried as a maid at the Boluwaji area of Ibadan September 17 this year.

    Her mistress had left the house for work. So the 26-year-old bricklayer had his way—raped her. He, too, was caught and the police eventually arraigned the rapist before an Iyaganku magistrate court.

    But Magistrate Mercy Amole-Ajimoti claimed she lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit. She then ordered the rapist remanded at Abolongo correctional facility in Oyo town. Everything about the case has screeched to a halt now. Nothing heard from Mary the victim.

     

    Violence everywhere

    Lola, Mary, Folake, Adebisi and Ronke are just a handful among the thousands experiencing diverse degree of Sexual and Gender-Based Violence (SGBV) across communities in Nigeria.

    Lagos alone recorded 10,007 cases between May 2019 and August 2021, according to Attorney General Moyosore Onigbanjo.

    While the 2020 lockdown lasted, no fewer than 3,600 women and girls also suffered such violence, according to Women Affairs Minister PaullenTallen.

    The data of violence shared by AG Onigbanjo and Minister Tallen revealed nothing about disabled victims though. Cases involving this community, especially the hearing impaired, hardly get airtime.

    Even when reported, government agencies don’t bother sorting the cases out of the jumble of data, despite the victims’ peculiarities.

    Nonetheless, Titilola Vivour-Adeniyi, Executive Secretary of the Lagos State Domestic and Sexual Violence Response Team (DSVRT), said the agency recorded 11 cases of PWD’s complaints of sexual and domestic violence since January this year. Nine of them are female, and six have “auditory impairment”.

    “Once we have any case that requires intervention or we need the support of a sign language interpreter, we get in touch with the Lagos State Office for Disability Affairs to get it,” she said.

     

    So far, so mute

    How the DSVRT intervention leads to justice for Lola, Adebisi, Mary, and others will be a stretch.

    Folake said majority of members in her hearing impaired community who suffer the trauma of abuse are not aware an interventionist agency such as DSVRT exists. And those who choose to go report abuse at the police station have to hire an interpreter to help them.

    “They pay at least N5, 000,” she said.

    “If he or she can’t afford it, they can communicate by writing.”

    Not in the courts, however. Literacy level regardless.

    The deafness of the complainants—or even defendants living with similar disabilities—becomes a snag in the wheel of justice, according to Tobi Makinde, General Secretary of the Association of Sign Language Interpreters of Nigeria (ASLIN), Lagos State Chapter.

    “There are no sign language interpreters in Lagos courts, customary or magistrate,’ Makinde told this reporter, ‘so the deaf person will have to be the one to improvise an interpreter, otherwise he will lose out.”

    It has to be so, according to Samuel James, Southwest Coordinator of the ASLIN. “We do not work with the Lagos State judiciary. We only work as freelancers when called upon for services.”

    And such engagements come at a professional cost; charged against the deaf in search of justice.

    “Truth is that the N5000 you mentioned earlier isn’t our professional fee, but sometimes we consider it just as transport fare from the victim requesting our service,” said Makinde.

    The Lagos State Office of the Public  Defender (OPD) will not take the blame for the dearth of sign language interpreters in the court all the same. Prosecuting perpetrators, according to OPD director Jide Martins, is not OPD’s beat.

    “It is the office of Attorney-General that prosecutes. Office of Public Defender supports victims of sexual offences and assist in bringing the offenders to justice,” Martins said in a WhatsApp response to questions on how the OPD has helped to get justice in gender-based violations of deaf and mute victims.

    Nowhere else is the hole the buck-passing leaves remains as obvious as it is during prosecution. That is if the cases ever get to a court that has jurisdiction to try them.

    The Violence Against Person (Prohibition) Act 2015, Discrimination Against Person With Disability (Prohibition) Act, the Penal Code, the Criminal Code—all laws of Nigeria that punish SGBV never envisage how disabilities will get in the way.

     

    But that is a fact now.

    When she presided over the Ikeja Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Justice Sybil Nwaka confirmed this.

    State prosecutor Gbenga Alagbe put Emmanuel Umoh, a 48-year-old pastor accused of defiling a 13-year-old deaf and dumb girl, on trial in Nwaka’s court in 2020. While Umoh allegedly committed the crime in 2017 at Shapati, IbejuLekki, the peculiarity of the victim slowed down the prosecution of the case. And even many others similar to that in the court.

    “We need the attorney-general’s involvement because we have a lot of cases involving deaf and dumb children that are being defiled. We need to get the services of sign language interpreters and we need them as soon as possible,” she said.

    Justice Nwaka’s pleas simply ended there. And it might remain there because she has moved to the Appeal Court now, leaving her knowledge of the special court’s need on the shelf.

    This lack of due diligence on the prosecutor’s side has yet to become a matter of public interest in Lagos. And such dereliction remains the reason Lagos, which has adopted VAPP 2015, battles large scale SGBV, more than any other state in Nigeria.

    It’s better imagined when the deaf and mute sexually abused in Adamawa, Bauchi, and 24 others yet to domesticate the VAPP Act will catch a whiff of justice.

    Of the 11 provisions of VAPP 2015, rape, spousal battery, and incest deal more directly with SGBV. That is generally speaking. Likewise the provisions for protection and compensation. But neither of the provisions expressly guarantees access to effective representation in court for PWDs that suffer sexual abuse or domestic violence.

    This lacuna in itself is even some kind of violence, according to Women Enabled International in a  policy proposal to the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) on sexually abused PWD access to justice in Nigeria.

    There is no arguing the fact that communication barrier remains a hurdle for the deaf and mute victims and defendants in court.  Sign language service ties everything in here—not just in court, but also at home. The victims can then express themselves with it, before or after the violation.

     

    It’s part of justice.

    At least Ronke, a mass communication graduate, has expressed her travail audibly and coherently. At peace now, she has sworn off love with any able-bodied partner.

    “If I am going to have anyone again, the person must be like me. Or it must be somebody that is totally deaf,” she said.

    David is. Yet he gave his equally deaf wife Folake a hell of a marriage.

     

     

    • All the names of survivors in this story have been changed to protect them from revictimization.
    • Support for this story was provided by the Media and Gender Project of Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism
  • Digital Switch Over as catalyst for post-COVID-19 recovery

    Digital Switch Over as catalyst for post-COVID-19 recovery

    The creative industry remains one of the most impacted sectors in the country with the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the sector is gradually picking up with Digital Switch Over (DSO) revolution. VINCENT IKUOMOLA reports.

    Minister of Information and Culture Alhaji Lai Mohammed recently explained why the government is paying close attention to the creative industry, with the migration from analogue to digital broadcasting, otherwise known as Digital Switch Over (DSO), which is to herald Digital Terrestrial Transmission (DTT).

    The idea of DSO was reached at the meeting of 193 member states of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) in Geneva, Switzerland, in June 2006, where they all signed on to a treaty of digital broadcasting for 119 countries in Europe, Africa, the Middle East and Central Asia, with 2015 as the terminal or deadline date.

    Mohammed launched the pilot phase in Jos, while President Muhammadu Buhari anchored the Abuja launch in December of the same year.

    Other states such as Kaduna, Kwara, Osun and Enugu have been added to the process. Though the process may have been very slow, it was, however, believed that the current economic reality and the impact of the pandemic have thus added a renewed fire.

    If the trend is sustained, the DSO may turn out to be the country’s catalyst for economic revival for the industry and the economy at large. This could be better explained by the renewed vigour with which the second phase of the launch in major economic cities in the country is being pursued.

     

    DSO as a catalyst to country’s economy

     

    The DSO is expected to create a boost for the local content industry because of the availability of more channels, unlike the analogue era where there were only a few channels available to people. There will be a pluralism of channels and a lot of diversification as digital technology has the capability to carry over 60 channels/in populating these channels with contents, young people with creative ideas will have the avenues to put their contents together and give it expression. They will also be able to commodify them to make some profits.

    With quality content, advertising revenue will grow, bearing in mind that there is an Audience Measurement System (AMS) provided by the migration.

    With the DSO, there will be the proper measurement. People, especially advertisers, will be able to know who is watching what. With the absence of an audience measurement system, Nigeria is lagging behind South Africa and even Ghana and Kenya in maximising TV advertising opportunities.

    Hence, following the Lagos switch over in April, Kano State, with 44 local government areas, was recently switched on as part of the Federal Government’s comprehensive nationwide process of transitioning from analogue to digital television broadcasting.

    At the launch in Kano State, the Minister of Information and Culture said: “The Federal Government is vigorously implementing a comprehensive nationwide process of transitioning from analogue to digital television broadcasting, which is referred to as the Digital Switchover (DSO) project.”

    On other steps taken by the ministry to ensure that the creative industry becomes the livewire of the economy, the minister said: “A number of reforms have been instituted, some of them necessitating amendments to the Broadcasting Code which we have since carried out, with a view to encouraging investments in the broadcast industry in particular and the creative industry in general.”

    As part of the ongoing reform to make the creative industry attractive, the minister revealed that the Federal Government is also putting in place an industry framework that will ensure that content producers receive their just due for the value of the contents they create, as well as provide objective guarantees to the advertising community with regard to return-on-investment on media placements.

    “This will then have the overall effect of guaranteeing greater expend by advertisers, who are all seeking to grow their market share. The ministry, through the National Broadcasting Corporation (NBC) and Advertising Practitioners Council of Nigeria (APCON), has implemented a system to monitor the media purchases and ensure that advertising revenues are earned by the broadcasters in due time.

    “The collaboration between NBC and APCON is to guarantee zero- advertising debt for the broadcasting industry.”

     

    How to make Set-Top-Boxes (STBs) accessible to Nigerians

     

    One of the major concerns is the issue of availability and accessibility of the STBs to the majority of the populace, given the fact that the government has removed subsidies on the STBs.

    However, providing a workable solution for the immediate, the minister urged governors and other well-meaning Nigerians to assist the indigent in their states by providing them with STBs.

    “Those channels are also critical to the success of the DSO because they have the potential to attract many eyeballs to the DSO platform. Still talking about set-top-boxes, affordability is a key factor in making digital television available to all.

    “Indeed, set-top-boxes represent the very minimum entry point in the world of digital television broadcasting. At the same time, it is necessary to ensure a reliable supply of low-cost STBs for purchase by the general public.

    “I implore state governments to be at the vanguard of providing set-top-boxes to their people. This is because the provision of set-top-boxes is a social service that will take governance to the grassroots and bridge the information gap between the government and the governed, among other advantages.

    “For Kano State in particular, with a population of over 15 million, governance will be revolutionised if each of the 2.4 million television households can have a set-top-box.”

    Kano State Governor Abdullahi Umar Ganduje, who was present at the launch in the state, took up the gauntlet with an assurance that the state will rise to the occasion by supporting indigent and poor households so as to facilitate access to signal.

    Consequently, he said the state would make provision for 100,000 units of subsidised set-top-boxes.

    He said: “To facilitate access to signal for all, the Kano State Government is partnering with one of the licensed manufacturers of the digital set box in Nigeria in support of indigent and poor households in all the 44 local government areas in the state for the provision of 100, 000 units of subsidised FREE TV/STB, beginning with 10, 000 units for the first phase of the supply.

    “Accordingly, 700 units of the STB will be supplied to the 114 Ministries, Departments and Agencies, 70 to the 15 tertiary institutions, 1,460 units for Senior Secondary Schools, offices of public servants that included Special Advisers, Senior Special Assistants and Special Assistants, while the state government would continue to mobilise for the supply and acquisition of the STBs in the state.

    “Also, we have also directed the supply of 44, 000 STBs to the 44 local governments in the state at the rate of 100 per local government, where the following will be beneficiaries: Primary Health Care Centres, Community Viewing Centres, Government Education Authorities, Primary and Basic Schools, as well as Local Government Councils.

    “We have also in collaboration with the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC) trained over 100 technicians, installers and entrepreneurs; two each from the 44 local governments and 20 from the state government, while also being engaged in sensitizing the citizens to fully understand what the DSO is all about.”

     

    How ready are suppliers of the STBs?

     

    Another issue that has been of concern is the availability of STBs. There are fears that the over 13 registered STB producers may not have the capacity to produce the needed boxes. However, this fear was allayed by the Set Top Box Manufacturers of Nigeria, (STBMAN).

    Sir Godfrey Ohuabunwa, Chairman, STBMAN on behalf of the stakeholders, said they are ready to make the over 24 million boxes available despite the challenges.

  • Enugu tech hub: Nurturing tomorrow’s startups

    Enugu tech hub: Nurturing tomorrow’s startups

    The Enugu State Tech Hub and Youth Innovation Centre is creating jobs and contributing positively to the state’s gross domestic product, writes LAWRENCE ANI

    At the inauguration of the Enugu State Tech Hub and Youth Innovation Centre in March this year, the state’s commissioner for science and technology, Sir Obi Kama, was confident the centre can create at least three thousand direct jobs in three years and contribute no less than a two-digit percent positive increase to the state’s gross domestic product.

    Anyone not familiar with the potential of digital technology and the quantum economic leap it can inspire might dismiss the commissioner’s statement as typical political bombast. But those who know can only sit back and observe as the seeds of what is certain to have a profound impact in the near further are planted. Forget that the centre teems with backpack-strapped youths with a somewhat hippie visage, the world of ICT is itself a self-effacing one whose dominant figures are hardly ever as elegantly suited up as the wealth they create might suggest.

    Understanding the preeminence of knowledge in an increasingly digital world is often an important step to growing an economy either at national or sub-national level. For instance, rather than be despondent, and perpetually lament the “ill fortune” of becoming a governor in a recession – as was the norm in 2015 – Governor Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi instead saw streaks of silver amid the gloomy overcast cloud.

    This bracing positivity shone through in his inauguration speech. “Since it is a knowledge-driven economy and not oil-driven economy that rules the world, I believe that this is another great opportunity for Enugu State and Nigeria to look inwards and harness those potential, which free oil money has blinded us from exploiting. It is an opportunity to live to our full potential and leave the feeding bottles of the federalism syndrome.”

    The statement drew a rousing applause. But it wasn’t simply a soapbox rhetoric. His administration set out with the formulation of policies that will help make a knowledge economy thrive. The inauguration of the Enugu State Tech Hub and Youth Innovation Centre is a nod to that emerging reality. The presence of the tech hub in Enugu, and the likely emergence of startups it would spur, will further cement the city’s image as an innovation-friendly city.

    This enabling air for businesses championed by the governor has increasingly bred a generation of tech-savvy youth in Enugu eager to tap into the vast opportunities offered by ICT. For the many youths who throng this centre, the popular line that ICT is the new oil has become a lived experience.

    Just like the University of Lagos and the Yaba College of Technology made Yaba a preferred location for tech startups in Lagos, the Enugu Tech Hub’s proximity to a talent pool like the Institute of Management and Technology (IMT) is expected to further boost its potential. The flourishing of digital startups hoped for in launching the ICT Hub may be difficult to track, especially at this early stage, but a report contained in an annual global startup index offers a refreshing insight.

    The report published few months ago by StartupBlink, a Swiss-based research centre that publishes an index of global startup annually, shows that Enugu is ranked 978 in the global 1,000 cities with the most vibrant startup ecosystem. The report further lists Enugu as Nigeria’s fifth biggest startup city behind Lagos, Ibadan, Abuja and Port Harcourt.

    Besides the number of startups, the organization used parameters such as the presence of support services that “provide resources, networking, and access to capital” in its ranking. The ease of doing business in startups’ operational location  was also an important indicator considered by the research organization whose chief executive officer is Eli David, a former accountant and business consultant at KPMG.

    In addition to the training and mentorship it offers youths, the Enugu Tech Hub’s physical space creates an opportunity for persons who share similar interests in technology to work together on projects. “The beneficiaries are not just trained, they will also be offered a temporary office space in our co-working tech cluster, where they are packaged, mentored, groomed and branded for idea synthesis and business innovations,” Kama added.

    Enugu’s global recognition shows that the true test of any policy can be gleaned from the outcome it yields, not the measure of applause or publicity its announcement attracts. Its recent honour as the Tech Innovation Hub of the Year at the Nigeria Tech Innovation and Telecom Award is further proof of that. So, it is thus fitting that Governor Ugwuanyi was adjudged the ICT Governor of the Year at the annual awards which has been dubbed Nigeria’s ICT Oscar Awards.

    • Ani is a senior communications aide to the governor of Enugu State.
  • Redressing infrastructure  deficit in Delta communities

    Redressing infrastructure deficit in Delta communities

    The Delta Oil-Producing Areas Development Commission (DESOPADEC) was established in 2007 by Chief James Ibori-led administration. Saddled with the responsibility of developing oil-bearing communities through the provision of critical infrastructure, the state-interventionist agency’s record has been below average. However, OKUNGBOWA AIWERIE reports that since 2019 when the current board of the commission was inaugurated, it has intervened in critical sectors such as education, health, housing, power and transportation and human capital development

    Delta Oil-Producing Areas Development Commission (DESOPADEC) has had a chequered history since 2007 when it was first established by the Chief James Ibori administration.

    Saddled with the responsibility of developing oil-bearing communities through the provision of critical infrastructure, the state-interventionist agency’s record, since its creation, has been less than stellar.

    It has been characterised by a bloated inefficient workforce and corruption and was often criticised for failing in its core mandate.

    But under the Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Bashorun Askia Ogieh, the current board in the last two years has delivered some impactful projects across the three senatorial zones in the state.

    The commission has, since 2019 when the current board was inaugurated, intervened in critical sectors such as education, health, housing, power and transportation and human capital development.

    One of such projects in the riverside areas is the provision of 40,000 capacity solar-powered water scheme at Obodo Community in Warri South Local Government Area of Delta South Senatorial District.

    In a chat with reporters, a community leader, Omatseyin Olley praised the commission for embarking on the project, stressing that the community, prior to the installation of the water scheme, accessing potable water was a huge challenge.

    According to him, residents had to rely on the nearby streams for their domestic chores.

    Olley said: “We are happy for the provision of the water scheme as it has reduced the difficulties we faced getting water in the past. We plead with the commission that the water scheme is extended to the other two quarters by connecting pipes to the area. This is so because, as of this moment, they still must walk some distances in order to fetch water.”

    For Mr Omare Leleji, the water scheme has improved their standard of living. He wants the capacity of the water scheme increased to enable the water in the overhead tanks to last longer.

    In Osubi Community in Okpe Local Government Area Delta Central Senatorial District, the Osubi Community Civic Centre is a testimony to one of such people-oriented projects; the edifice meets the social needs of residents of the community.

    A youth leader, Obukhowo Efe, said the community civic centre provides a modern meeting place to congregate and discuss issues affecting the community.

    He praised the agency for listening to their pleas and demands, during the agency’s town hall meeting in 2019, for a community civic centre, stressing that “we feel a sense of belonging with this project.”

    At the Youth Corps Lodge in Osubi, a stone throw from the civic centre, some youth corps members expressed their happiness over the amenities at the lodge.

    Bukola Adeyosoye, a 25-year-old corps member, who shared her experience, stressed that the lodge, a six-classroom block, converted into the lodge, offers them many modern amenities and security.

    In Delta North, two road projects, the 8-kilometres Abavo/Obi-Anyima road project, and the ongoing Ofagbe-Ibrede Road project linking Isoko North to Ndokwa East Local Government Area, shows an agency resolutely poised to touch the lives of rural dwellers.

    A community leader, Ogbueshi Alfred Esume, said the construction of the Ofagbe/Ibrede Road linking Isoko Communities in Delta South was a proper example of reaping the benefits of oil wealth.

    He said: “Hopefully, this road, when completed, will foster the bonds of friendship and enhance trade among us and the Isoko communities. This is an example of benefitting from our oil wealth. This is a commendable project. We thank DESOPADEC for this project.”

    In a recent media briefing in Warri, its Managing Director/CEO, Bashorun Askia Ogieh, highlighted the commission’s model for the development of infrastructure in its mandate areas.

    He said the commission has entrenched a new culture of communal engagement which adopted a bottom-up model where communities decided their projects while discarding the era of imposition of projects.

    Ogieh noted that within the past two years, the interventionist body received the “ regime in crude oil receipts from the Federation Account,” noting that this has made redressing the infrastructure gap even more challenging.

    He said low crude oil receipts and the unpredictable COVID-19 challenges notwithstanding, the current board has adopted creative solutions to cost reduction.

    Ogieh said the cost-saving biometrics system introduced by the board has saved N380 million from its rebranded biometrics system, adding that upgrading of its personnel/payroll system has eliminated “all loopholes of human factors and infractions.”

    According to Ogieh, the savings realised from the biometrics system has been deployed into the construction of a four-storey DESOPADEC Tower in Warri, Warri South Local Government Area.

    He said a staff management database for administration, saved in a cloud system, has been developed to check age falsification and tampering rife in the commission.

    Ogieh noted that the operations of the interventionist agency have been brought into the Delta State Public Service, adding that this has addressed the issue of members of staff stagnation.

    He lamented the untoward effects of low crude receipts from the Federation Account in the past two years on the operation of the commission, even as he praised the board for creatively redressing the challenge of cash crunch.

    He said the challenge of ghost workers and an environment not conducive to work has been tackled by the commission frontally with improved members of staff welfare and technology.

    Ogieh said the commission has invested in critical infrastructure in sectors such as education, health, power, housing, transportation and commerce.

    He said the body invested heavily in its human capital development by empowering youths, and women through the DESOPADEC Skills Academy.

    His words: “I am glad to announce that the pioneer students of our innovative DESOPADEC Skills Academy (DSA) have just completed their six months training programme in various vocational fields such as catering/confectioneries, electrical repairs and solar energy works, fashion design/tailoring, hairdressing and makeover,” among others.

    He said the commission has delivered numerous community-driven projects in its mandate areas and as a result, agitations in riverside areas have reduced significantly.

  • AfCFTA: Maximising potential for economic development

    AfCFTA: Maximising potential for economic development

    Economic and tax experts gathered at the Sheraton Hotels, Lagos to ruminate on how benefits could be maximised for Medium Small and Middle-Scale Enterprises (MSMEs) with the African Continental Free Trade Area Agreement (AfCFTA) at a one-day stakeholders’ sensitisation and consultation forum. The forum was organised by the Civil Society Legislative Advocacy Centre (CISLAC) and OXFAM Nigeria in collaboration with the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria (CITN). CHINAKA OKORO reports.

    In 2018, 54 of the 55 countries that make up the African Union (AU) established the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA). It was created by the African Continental Free Trade Agreement. It was aimed at being a free trade area to fast-track economic development on the African Continent, especially through the small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).

    Nigeria is a signatory to the agreement and President Muhammadu Buhari signed the agreement early this year.

    However, nine months after President Buhari signed the AfCFTA, it seems as though Nigeria is still foot-dragging with the agreement’s implementation. While the AfCFTA has great potential to support economic development on the continent and Nigeria by extension, some enterprises may not be able to take advantage of the agreement or compete with an influx of new competitors from other countries within the free trade area because of internal inefficiencies within businesses or sub-optimal business environments.

    These potential challenges for businesses sparked some opposition to the AfCFTA in Nigeria and led Nigeria to be one of the last countries to sign the agreement on July 9, 2019.

    Bothered about this development, three concerned bodies, that are players in the business of accountability for growth, and development came together in a conference where they did a breakdown of the AfCFTA agreement and expunged certain inhibiting technicalities that only the professionals could understand. This is for the purpose of clarity and usable material for the layman in business.

    It was so planned that no one will be left behind as the rest of 55 African countries moved to finally save the continent from the embarrassing under-development status to a final collaborative socio-economic growth and development in no distant time with the implementation of the agreement.

    No doubt, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are the backbone of many developed economies. They are important contributors to employment, output growth, and trade expansion and in Nigeria, they remain critical constituents of the economy.

    According to the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) and the Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN), SMEs in Nigeria accounts for about 96 per cent of registered Nigerian businesses, employ about 75 per cent of the national labour force and contribute 48 per cent to the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

    The government is currently at the third phase which is the implementation phase and on its part has made a concerted effort towards positioning SMEs to harness the numerous benefits of the AfCFTA on implementation through formalisations and engagements with public sector agencies to strengthen the capacity of SMEs to harness available opportunities.

    Despite sensitisation and consultation campaigns in all the geo-political zones, there is a seeming lack of mass enlightenment on the AfCFTA with only 30 groups and 2, 317 people sensitised and consulted on the AfCFTA.

    A 2020 survey of 1,804 MSMEs across Nigeria by the Nigerian Association of Chambers of Commerce, Industry, Mines, and Agriculture (NACCIMA) showed that more than 50 per cent of those surveyed were most concerned about the threat posed by imported cheaper goods competing with local products due to the AfCFTA, while only 20 per cent were aware of the existence of the AfCFTA.

    In the circumstances, the above statistics formed the background of discussions at the one-day stakeholders’ sensitisation and consultation forum whose theme was “Maximising the Benefits of the African Continental Free Trade Area Agreement” held on Tuesday, December 7 at Sheraton Hotel, Ikeja Lagos.

    The discourse jointly organised by Civil Society Legislative Advocacy Center (CISLAC), OXFAM Nigeria in conjunction with The Chartered Institute of Taxation Nigeria drew experts from the Civil Society Organisations (CSOs), the academic community, corporate organisations and the media.

    The Executive Director of CISLAC, Auwal Musa Rafsanjani said the impact of the AfCFTA cannot be determined by the government policies alone but also by how much the private sector leverages the abundant opportunities available in the free trade area.

    “In Africa, despite sensitisation and consultation campaigns in all the geo-political zones, there is a seeming lack of mass enlightenment on the AfCFTA with only 30 groups and 2,317 people sensitised and consulted on the AfCFTA.

    “Without an active strategy to ensure that MSMEs are aware of the AfCFTA and put in a position to capitalise on the agreement, the AfCFTA’s positive impact on the Nigerian economy will remain minimal,” the CISLAC boss said.

    Also, the CITN President, Adesina Adedayo, noted that the AfCFTA has the potential of contributing greatly to the movement of capital and natural people and facilitating investments across borders by laying the foundation for the establishment of a continental Customs union at a later stage.

    He said: “AfCFTA was established primarily with the objective of deepening African economic integration through a single market for goods and services and to promote industrial development through diversification and regional value chain development.

    “The advantages of this agreement are quite enormous. It has the potential of contributing greatly to the movement of capital and natural persons, facilitating investments across borders by laying the foundation for the establishment of a continental Customs union at a later stage.

    “MSMEs remain critical constituents of the Nigerian economy as they represent 96 per cent of Nigerian businesses and contribute 75 per cent to national employment. MSMEs will benefit from access to new markets and the economic transformation that competition promotes.”

    On concerns about the effect the AfCFTA would have on the Nigerian economy, Adedayo said the concerns can be addressed by the government putting in place safeguards to ensure the protection of vulnerable industries.

    According to him, these safeguards include improving transport infrastructure and enforcing policies that would see a reduction in the cost of production with much consideration and easier access to credit facilities by the MSMEs.

    “This would, in turn, make goods export competitive and promote rapid growth in industrialisation which, in return, boost our country’s economy.”

    On benefits of AfCFTA to MSMEs and Nigeria, the keynote speaker and Professorial Chairman, Babcock University and Tax Commissioner at the Tax Appeal Tribunal, Prof. Ishola Akintoye took a cursory look at the continent, the prevailing situation on the ground in Nigeria and called on the government of the country to get serious with its implementation because, according to him, if it took Africa’s most populous country that long to carefully check and study the AfCFTA before it signed, it will not be in a good place to find Nigeria wanting among 55 other countries at its implementation.

    He said: “AfCFTA is simply an idea to have a single plan for all African countries to come together under an African integration developmental authority that will make all the member countries grow together,” he said noting, however, that some members will lose because “when you open your doors, you will lose some fiscal benefits.”

    Akintoye said the AfCFTA will allow African-owned companies to enter new markets, facilitate economic growth, encourage foreign direct investment, reduce input cost, and also increase efficiency and sales, minimise the threats and improve her competitive advantages under the AfCFTA.

    Akintoye said there was a need for critical evaluation and concerted measures in key areas. According to him, the government must “carry out an impact assessment to determine likely effects of AfCFTA implementation on government revenue, identify required changes to existing laws and regulations, including local content rules, and areas of competitive and comparative advantages.

    “Build institutional capacity to lead the implementation of AfCFTA and identify key stakeholders and agencies with key responsibilities, expected outcomes and performance indicators.

    “Using the provisions of AfCFTA, systematically improve the capacity of the Nigeria Customs Service to secure and enforce Nigerian borders to prevent dumping, transhipment, smuggling and other detrimental cross border activities.

    “Systematically address infrastructural gaps and improve the general ease of doing business in Nigeria especially through a concerted focus on power and access to affordable finance.

    “Protect and strengthen business sectors and infant industries that could be endangered by AfCFTA in line with Article 24 (under Protocol on Trade in Goods).

    “Isolate, support and stimulate sectors and businesses with identified capabilities to increase export volume and create jobs locally through coordinated governmental efforts at all levels

    He added that the government must address regulatory and policy impediments and promote small-scale industries in local machine tool manufacturing, fishing and crop production, livestock, forestry, audiovisual and financial services through the extension of focused Venture Capital and skills enhancement under AfCFTA.

    “The FIRS and the JTB should leverage technology and the new TIN system to improve the quality and integrity of taxpayers’ data, enhance tax intelligence gathering and initiate reforms to ensure appropriate taxation of nonresident individuals and businesses with sufficient connections to Nigeria.

    “Ensure policy coordination and alignment among monetary, trade and fiscal policies. Most importantly, conduct regular, extensive and robust scientific studies on different aspects of AfCFTA as it affects Nigeria in terms of potential benefits and probable losses to inform policy decisions on future withdrawal, review and modifications of the AfCFTA treaty.”

    Corroborating Akintoye’s views, former Director-General Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI), Dr Muda Yusuf, noted that countries with strong productivity and competitiveness will benefit more.

    He said: “Benefits and costs would vary from country to country. Countries with a quality investment environment would emerge as key destinations for investment; countries with weak investment environments will be market destinations.”

    He, however, highlighted the multiplicity of membership, slow ratification of protocols and reluctant implementation of agreed plans, lack of complementarities of African economies, socio-economic policy divergence, inadequate infrastructure, limited national and regional capacities, and lack of full private sector involvement at both planning and implementation stage, as part of challenges of the AfCFTA.

    As Nigeria finally rises to begin the implementation of the Africa Continental Free Trade Area Agreement (AfCFTA) after taking many times to consider the pros and cons months ago, the discussants noted that there is a need to wake up the consciousness of citizens, particularly those in Micro, Small and Media Enterprises (MSMEs), of their respective duties to, rights from the agreement, and how they can leverage on the inherent opportunities to maximise the benefits it has necessitated.

    The participants were also exposed to the inherent benefits of the AfCFTA for value addition and improved export trade revenue derivation.

  • ‘How we saved our children from bullies in schools’

    ‘How we saved our children from bullies in schools’

    Many vulnerable students have had to deal with trauma for the good part of their school life owing to bully by older or stronger school mates. Many schools are not unaware of the despicable act only that they often treat it with kid gloves thus further emboldening the bullies. With the death of Sylvester Oromoni last Tuesday as a result of alleged brutalisation by older school mates at Dowen College, Lekki, Lagos there is a clamour for the National Assembly to make a law criminalising the ugly act as it is done in other parts of the world, INNOCENT DURU writes.

    The death of Sylvester Oromoni a student of the elite secondary school,  Dowen College, last Tuesday, the issue of bullying in schools have been brought to the front burner.

    The 12-year-old Dowen College student was alleged to have died while nursing multiple internal injuries allegedly sustained after he was bullied by his fellow students.

    The nephew, Perry Oromoni, had alleged via his Twitter handle, that the deceased was attacked for declining to join what he termed the secondary school’s “cult group” dominated by older boys at the institution located in Lekki.

    Contrary to the school’s defence that the deceased was injured while playing football with his colleague, the father  according to an onlinepublication, ‘The Cable’, said that Sylvester, revealed before his death that he neither played the ball nor tripped as claimed.

    He also alleged that the deceased stated before his death that five boys in the school barged into his room, put off the lights and beat him up in the presence of other students.

    “Mummy, I didn’t play ball; I didn’t fall,” he was quoted as saying moments before he passed on. He was said to have jumped off his hostel bed while his attackers were kicking him and matching his waist. Other students,  terrified by what was going on, took to their heels, particularly because the attackers threatened to kill them all if they spoke a word to the school staff. They allegedly warned Junior to say that he sustained injuries while playing football.

    Shortly after the story of Sylvester’s predicament went viral, a mother recounted how her  child  who attended the school suffered a similar fate. She spoke  during a zoom meeting organised by the Concerned Parents and Educators’ Network – a group of about 200,000 parents and educators. The programme was started by education branding specialist, Mrs. Yinka Ogunde, on December 4.

    The mother in question  said: “My son was a victim. They did exactly what they did to Sylvester to my boy. They put off the light and beat him. They were dancing around. They put a box on his head, seven of them.

    “They forced my son to kneel down and  they put a suitcase on his head.  They were dancing around him like an acoustic thing.

    “Everything Sylvester Oromoni said is the truth. The principal told me that she saw my son’s video as he was being bullied but she did not think it was important to act because it was not yet online. So she slept on it.

    “The school was collecting N3 million and they could not put ordinary CCTV camera? 11-year-old boy that just left them in September and they bullied him – seven boys.”

    Our correspondent who had been following a group, @ArewaMeToo on twitter,  reports how a young boy has been living a traumatised life after he was bullied and initiated into homosexuality  by a senior school mate.

    “It all started when I was attending a boarding school. It was a typical northern Nigerian English school.

    “I was a straight male before this dude ruined my life and coded this worst sexual orientation in my brain.

    “My first year in JSS (Junior Secondary School) class was hell. I was sluggish, naive and dumb. I was bullied by everyone, even those in my class until this asshole entered my life.

    “His name is Mubarak. He was huge and among the honoured bullies at that time in the school. He was in SS1, but even SS3 students were scared of him because he was strong,” he said.

    “Did you know what this motherfucker did to me? He protected me from being bullied and I thought he cared for me as a brother until one night after Isha prayer.

    “I was in the bathroom and someone grabbed my butt. It was Mubarak. I thought it was the normal rough play that boys used to do in the dorm until he started asking me some strange questions

    “He grabbed my crotch numerous times and then he pointed a small knife at my neck and said he and I would enter trouble if I told  anyone  and he would kill me.

    “From that day, I was really uncomfortable and also kind of scared of the guy.

    “He forced me to watch gay porn with him. I was 13 and I knew nothing about sex. He started asking for blow jobs, hand jobs, whatever. He penetrated me about four times or more. I couldn’t speak up or tell anyone. Things started getting out of hand. I was seriously ill and  was taken back home.”

    Following the ugly experience, he said, “I begged my parents that I didn’t  want to go back to the school and they agreed. It’s been eight years now. Mubarak is off my life but he is always in my memory.

    “There is so much that I don’t want to remember and want to tell, but there is also so much I will never, ever be able to forget.

    “I’m not doing good these days, but I am talking to a Muslim therapist online. Allah ya sa mudace.”

    Nkechi Odebiyi, founder of Virgins Pride Foundation, shared stories of how bullies almost wrecked the lives of some students.

    She said: “There was a boy who was sick and taken to the hospital, but he refused to go back to school thereafter. The parents insisted  and took him back to school by force.

    “Later, he fell sick again and was taken back to the hospital where it was discovered that his anus had been messed up by his schoolmates who warned him not to tell anybody about it.

    “There was also a case of a girl that was bullied by 13 of her school mates.  She was big and beautiful. The school mates ganged up and went to tell the school counsellor that she was wayward.

    “The counsellor did not try to investigate. Rather, the counsellor kept calling her names. The mother said each time she went to see her, she wasn’t looking happy.

    “It was recently that we learnt that one of the girls confessed and  apologised to her about what they had done to her. Imagine bullying a child for that long.”

    President and founder of TRY Initiative, a non-governmental organisation, John Wesley, MFR, in a chat with The Nation, told of how a young boy he counselled narrowly escaped death in the course of being initiated into a cult group by his schoolmates.

    He said: “The boy’s parents are financially better than his schoolmates’ parents. He has a huge physique and the opposite sex liked him .

    “The school mates always wanted him to be a part of them but he never associated with them. That made them to become aggressive towards him.  As a result, they would either meet him on the road or do something annoying to prompt him to fight back.

    “Sometimes they would tear his book, collect his bag and throw it on a tree and tell him to go and pick it.  On some occasions, they would eat up his food or collect his money.

    ” Eventually, we realised that the day they were even going to initiate him, they were beating him up and the boy collapsed.

    “When he collapsed, they were going to leave him there and go but some other people saw them.  In the course of trying to escape, they were caught.”

    Concern as parents resort to crude tactics to save children

    Following the failure of school authorities to address the complaints of their children, some parents have been employing crude tactics to stop their children from being bullied.

    Lateef, a Lagos-based journalist,  said he stopped his children from being bullied after the school authorities failed to check the bullies.

    He said: “My two children, a male and a female, were always bullied by students in higher classes in their school. We reported the complaints of our children to the school many times but nothing was done about it.

    “They were always eating my children’s food. The girl bullying my daughter started doing that when my daughter was made the queen of the house she was representing in their inter-house sports competition. She was angry that they chose my daughter when she had looked forward to being made the queen.

    “When the issue was getting out of hand, I called my children and packed stones in three stockings for each of them and gave them another set of heavy stones and told them anytime the bullies were approaching, they should stone them close to their eyes before they (the bullies) got close to them.

    “The next day, I followed my children to school and asked the principal to bring forward the bullies. Before the principal and the bullies, I repeated what I asked my children to do any time they wanted to intimidate them.

    “The principal shouted and immediately sent for the parents of those bullies. That was how my children had their peace. One of the bullies was the bursar’s child. They had kept mute all along until I took that drastic step.”

    Dare, a public analyst, told our correspondent how he went to his son’s school to personally beat up the bully.

    Said he: “My son was always bullied by another who was a class ahead of him. When the complaints became unbearable, I went to the school and asked my son to show the boy to me.

    “Incidentally, the boy was passing along our way that moment and immediately he saw me, he attempted to run.

    “Before he took off, I pounced on him and thoroughly beat him. When the principal saw me, he was shocked and I told him it was important to invite the boy’s parents at that point to discuss the whole issue. That was how the bullying stopped.

    “If I hadn’t taken that decision, my son would have remained in bondage.”

    Speaking on a television show during the week, Yeni Kuti, daughter of Afrobeat legend, Fela Anikulapo, said she and other members of her family practically went to his nephew’s school to save him from those that were bullying him.

    She said: “One of my brother’s kids was bullied by five boys. We don’t take that kind of thing.

    “Once dey talk like this, action don happen. Immediately, everybody don go the school. I asked him today, are you still being bullied and he said no. With our action, the school and the students knew that these ones don’t tolerate bullying.

    “I asked if other kids wer still being bullied and he said yes. I told him that if he should see anybody being bullied, he should report to his school and also report to us.

    “If my child is being bullied in your school and I don’t go there to solve the problem, other children would be bullied.”

    A Facebook user, Adeola Osho Akinrinola, posted about  how they equipped their son to physically confront  the school mate that was bullying him.

    Osho said: “There was a boy who was quite big in my children’s former school and who was also a relative to the school director. He would conveniently bully almost every student in the school,  includeing my first son and daughter.

    “He went to the extent of using belt to whip my children on a particular day, but we kept insisting that our children should always report to the school authorities and we also contacted the school.

    “Although they assured us they would take necessary action, the boy stopped for a while but resumed his bullying act again. This was when their dad decided it was time to fight and resist the bullying

    “So we decided to ensure they learnt mixed martial arts. After some basic lessons, they were equipped enough to defend themselves.

    “On a particular occasion, the bully came to do his usual bullying towards my children. He started throwing punches at my first son, but he was able to block the punches and returned to him very intense punches that resulted in him going on his knees and saying, ‘Olamide, please, please!

    “This got the other children excited and they said to him, “Don’t mess with Olamide again”.

    “The boy stubbornly came back again after a few days, bragging that he was now a master in karate. So he started a fight again, but  my son resisted and gave him a very sound beating.

    “He was literally floored. This was what quenched the buand eventually he became friends with my son.

    “This is not always the ultimate solution, but in some cases, it can go a long way.”

    Reps decline comment on making anti-bullying law

    The House of Representatives has declined comments on the need to make laws to stop bullying in schools.

    House Committee Chairman on Basic Education, Hon Julius Ihonvbere,  neither  answered  the calls made  to his mobile number nor replied to a text message requesting his comment on the issue.

    France and other countries across the world have made laws to this effect to curb the act of bullying among students.

    The Guardian,  in a report, said the French parliament had voted to make school bullying a criminal offence punishable by up to three years in prison, as MPs said society needed a wake-up call on the seriousness of children targeting their peers.

    The proposed law was supported by Emmanuel Macron’s education minister, Jean-Michel Blanquer.

    Blanquer said the law sent a strong message to society that “we will never accept the lives of our children being shattered”.

    As many as one in 10 French children are estimated to have been affected by bullying, and social networks are increasing the potential for public taunting and humiliation. Blanquer said the draft law was “a way of enforcing the values of the republic”.

    The new crime of “school bullying” applies to children and adults in schools and universities, including students as well as staff such as canteen service teams and break-time monitors. It would carry a maximum three-year jail term and a fine of up to €45,000 (£38,300). If a victim of school bullying kills themselves, or attempts to, the maximum penalty could rise to 10 years and €150,000.

    Macron’s wife, Brigitte, who is a former teacher, has made combating bullying a focus of her charity work at the Élysée

    ‘Bullying begins from home’

    The act of bullying among students has been blamed on family orientation. According to Nkechi, “bullying as you see it in schools starts right from homes.

    “Some children see their fathers bullying their mothers. They also see their mothers bullying their fathers.

    “Children bully themselves according to what they see in the lives of their parents. When a father insists on having sex with the daughter before paying her school fees or giving her pocket money  or the necessary things she needs to go back to school, and the girl submits to the father, it is bullying.

    “Some  of the students in boarding schools are dumped there by their parents who have not been able to give them a solid moral, emotional and spiritual  foundation.

    “The few good ones get corrupted before they come back.  They carry the bullying from home down to school and begin to recruit others to join them to perpetrate these evils.

    “They collect their mates’ food, money, force them to watch pornography and dance for them and beat them up. Some of the girls who have big butts are asked by the senior girls to dance and tweak for them.”

    On his part, John Wesley blamed the absence of discipline for the rising cases of bullying.

    “One of the measures that will put a check  on bullying is a whole lot of discipline. Discipline has left our schools, and even the home.

    “In America and Great Britain now, you would notice that they have reintroduced discipline because their children have gone haywire. They now kill and  do all sorts  of things.

    “That is becoming unbearable even for the government and for the communities. So discipline is the solution.”

    Psychological effects of bullying

    Speaking on psychological effects of bullying on victims, a United States based Crisis Clinician/Senior Therapist, Dr Lateefat Odunuga, said people with bullying scars are mostly incapable of repairing the damage sustained. “This often leads to various behavioral manifestations being misinterpreted and diagnosed as psychological disorders such as adjustment disorder, mood disorder, or even other triggering conditions. Bullied people are often frightened of reporting their worries, which creates severe anxieties and irrational preoccupation about the threats that might be carried out by the bullies.

    Bullies might appear to themselves as strong and limitlessly expressing some grandiosity that they cannot be reprimanded by anyone reinforcing their behavior of intimidating another person. Despite appearing vulnerable and weak, recent studies show that bullied victims are capable of non-violent as well as extremely violent behavior which is dependent on so many factors such as prior violence history, family support, socio-economic status, and self-esteem etc.

    “A bully gets reinforced by attention-seeking behaviors which mean a lot to them indicating that most bullies have underlying issues that contribute to their maladaptive behavior such as dysfunctional families, poor parenting practices, negligence, poor impulse control, highly impulsive behavior, and immediate environment in which the bully resides.”

    Speaking from her experience with victims, she said: “While working as private practitioner and other clinical practice, I have seen several cases where bullied students report to school authorities or teachers that they have been bullied, and the bullied student is then referred for psychiatric treatment after making homicidal threats. Based on previous cases, it seems that the system that is responsible for educating and instilling appropriate behaviors is not conducive to the needs of bullied victims. In fact, we have seen cases of bullied victims who have consciously and unconsciously transitioned into becoming bullies themselves through a behavioral approach called ‘modeling’. Bullied victims who enjoy watching other kids beaten up and assaulted are likely to also become a part of the transitional bullying.

    “A person who bullies and bullied victims needs professional assistance, not the case where a victim is subjected to unnecessary evaluation because they have threatened to hurt their person who bullies them. Post-Bullying syndrome is likely to develop in early adolescence into early adulthood. It has been shown that young adults who were bullied are likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder later in life. Bullied victims on the other hand, are also likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, panic attacks, including other psychological disorders that can be triggered because of current stressors beings faced. On the other hand, children who bullied others are also likely to become a danger to themselves or others in the society and are likely to encounter psychological conditions such as adjustment disorder, anti-social personality, narcissistic personality disorders, anxiety, PTSD etc.”

    Nigeria, she said  is doing well with regard to child discipline and actions; however, “we could accomplish more if governmental agencies involved in the protection of children’s rights cooperate with schools, parents and other organizations involved in the fight against bullying and create more awareness on the benefits of condemning such maladaptive behavior.”