Tag: Betta Edu

  • Ex-minister Edu urges social workers to amplify voices, drive collective action

    Ex-minister Edu urges social workers to amplify voices, drive collective action

    Former Minister of Humanitarian Affairs, Dr. Betta Edu, has called on Nigerian social workers to continue serving as a platform for amplifying diverse voices, sharing actionable insights, and inspiring collective action for national development.

    Edu made the call in her keynote address at the opening ceremony of the 40th Annual National Conference and Annual General Meeting of the Nigeria Association of Social Workers (NASoW), which also marked the association’s 50th anniversary. 

    The event was held from Tuesday, October 14 to Saturday, October 18, 2025, at Leisure Spring, Osogbo, Osun State.

    The conference was declared open by Osun State Governor, Senator Nurudeen Jackson Ademola Adeleke, who was represented by the Commissioner for Information, Barrister Kolapo Alimi, and the Commissioner for Women Affairs, Children and Social Welfare, Hon. Ayobola Elizabeth Fadeyi Awolowo.

    The gathering attracted a large number of participants, including practicing social workers, educators, students, top government officials from across the six geopolitical zones, and international delegates from India, Russia, Mexico, Bangladesh, Italy, Egypt, and Nepal.

    In her address, Dr. Edu emphasized the need for strengthening intergenerational solidarity to promote enduring well-being and inclusive growth.

    “As we celebrate 50 years of NASoW, let us recommit to developing age-inclusive policies, bridging gaps between generations, and sharing experiences and wisdom across age groups,” she said. “By fostering mutual respect and understanding across generations, we can unlock the potential for transformative change and drive progress toward the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).”

    Edu urged NASoW to continue serving as a catalyst for unity and social transformation, adding that intergenerational collaboration should remain a cornerstone of efforts to achieve the SDGs by 2030.

    The lead paper was presented by Professor Solomon Adebola, Vice Chancellor of Adeleke University, Ede, Osun State, who was represented by the Deputy Registrar and Director of Human Resources, Mrs. Oladayo Aliu. 

    His presentation, titled “Building Resilience among Social Workers in Nigeria,” highlighted the importance of professional strength and adaptability in addressing emerging social challenges.

    At the end of the conference, participants resolved that social workers play a crucial role in addressing the complex challenges facing individuals, groups, and communities in Nigeria. 

    They emphasised that the primary purpose of social work remains to promote problem-solving strategies that enhance social well-being.

    The association commended President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s administration for policies aimed at mitigating hardship but noted that social workers continue to face major challenges — including the absence of a regulatory body, poor funding, weak policy implementation, lack of recognition, and limited involvement in key national programmes.

    NASoW therefore called for urgent government action to strengthen the social work profession, ensure adequate regulation, and promote synergy among related sectors to better serve vulnerable populations across the country.

    The conference also observed that the absence of council to regulate social work practice is undermining the progress of the profession in Nigeria. We also commend some state governments for involving social workers in their activities and also enjoined other states to emulate them. 

    The association appealed to the federal government to constitute and inaugurate the Nigerian Council for Social Work. 

    The association appeal to the governments at all levels to involve Social Workers in the formulation, execution and implementation of policies and programmes of the government. 

    The conference advised members to update their certificate, attend more trainings and seminars so as to update their knowledge and compete favorably with their peers across the globe. 

    The association called on all social workers to make wise use of information and communication technology (ICT), mass media platforms and other modern tools for effective service delivery. 

    The conference enjoined the federal government to put all necessary machineries in place in order to address the level of insecurity in the country. 

    The association observed the level of insecurity in the state and enjoined the governments at all levels to put policies, programmes and machineries in place to tackle the problems. 

    NASoW also urged the governments at all levels and stakeholders not to neglect boy child while promoting the right of the girl child.

  • Nigeria will prosper in 2025, Betta Edu assures Nigerians

    Nigeria will prosper in 2025, Betta Edu assures Nigerians

    Former Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Disaster Management, Betta Edu, has assured Nigerians that Nigeria is poised for prosperity in 2025.

    In her New Year message released on Wednesday to mark the beginning of 2025, Edu expressed optimism for the country’s future, describing the year as a time of restoration and opportunity. 

    She highlighted that 2025 would be a year where to perfect President Bola Tinubu’s Renewed Hope Agenda.

    “2025 stands before us like a chapter in a book waiting to be written. It is incumbent upon us to pen optimism and hope into it, believing that the New Year offers us a refreshing new dawn to turn our dreams and aspirations into reality,” Edu said.

    She added, “I have no doubt that 2025 will bring full restoration from the hardships and trials of 2024. It will be a year for the optimisation of President Bola Tinubu’s Renewed Hope Agenda.”

    Edu continued by stressing that 2025 holds immense promise for Nigeria. 

    “It is a year when Nigerians will take charge of their great future as current economic challenges give way to a horizon of hope, leading to the blossoming of prosperity,” she noted.

    She urged Nigerians to stay committed to their love for the country and remain confident in the current administration’s efforts to overcome economic difficulties.

    Read Also: She is gone, presidency confirms Betta Edu’s exit

    “Mr President means well; good intentions need time to yield results. I believe in the Nigerian project. I have always given my all to Nigeria and Nigerians, and nothing will ever change that,” Edu said.

    In closing, she fervently encouraged Nigerians to approach the future with confidence, believing that the nation is moving closer to overcoming its challenges. 

    “I fervently urge Nigerians to approach the future with confidence and an overwhelming sense of assurance that we are inching closer to the end of our trying times as a nation,” Edu added.

  • A not-so humanitarian ministry

    A not-so humanitarian ministry

    • SCANDALS OF THE YEAR
    • By Bolade Omonijo

    Corruption is no longer strange in this country. Nor is scandal unusual. The Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation was the earliest indication that the Federal Government could have it rough in 2024. The minister, Dr. Betta Edu by her conduct, had given indication soon after inauguration that she could be the poster girl of the administration. She had the poise and the grace. She appeared on many television programmes laying out programmes by which the vulnerable would be rescued from the clutches of poverty.

    Yet, by the first month of the year, she was dragged in the media for allegedly diverting N585 million earmarked for the most vulnerable citizens in Ogun, Lagos, Akwa Ibom and Cross River States into a private account. It appeared impossible. She was young, still under 40 years of age, a medical doctor who had served in the government of Cross River State for almost eight years and was very visible during the campaign period last year as women leader of the All Progressives Congress (APC). She was so close to the First Lady that she represented the former Senator at functions both during the campaign period and after inauguration. Many were already speculating that she was being prepared for a more prominent government role in 2027.

    But, it did not take long for the bubble to burst. No one could save her from the dangling sword. The President ordered her suspension.

    Unfortunately, almost one year after, no one can say all that happened. The probe ordered into that scandal is yet to yield result as no report has been published, even if it had been submitted. The only indication that she failed the test is that by the time a reshuffle of the executive council was announced last month, she was not reinstated. But, for a government that has vowed to stand by integrity and probity, the people deserve to know all that happened, all who participated in the alleged malfeasance, if only to prove that the administration was determined to take a different route.

    Another minister was almost caught in the web. Hon. Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo of the Interior Ministry was linked with a consultancy contract worth N438 million. But, the Interior Minister was able to quickly extricate himself by proving that he had resigned his position as chief executive of the company in 2019. Again, even though he was invited for questioning by the Code of Conduct Bureau on January 16, all that got back to the public was through rumour. Neither the CCB, nor the presidency deemed it necessary to inform the public of the outcome of the investigation.

    Yes, Mr. Tunji-Ojo technically explained away his relationship with the company, he remains the largest shareholder and his wife still runs the firm. Whether that amounts to conflict of interest, or the contract was even worth that much is still left in the realm of speculation.

    Read Also: Akpabio flags off medical outreach to support Tinubu’s Renewed Hope agenda

    The “Betta Edu Scandal” was not the only one that qualifies the Ministry as the cesspool of corruption in the year. Edu’s predecessor, Hajiya Saddiya Umar Farouk too, was invited by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to explain how funds budgeted to take care of the needy were allegedly mismanaged under her watch. Hajiya Umar Farouk who was Minister of Humanitarian Affairs, Disaster Management and Social Development under the preceding Buhari administration was seen many times personally handing out cash to some visibly deprived persons. How such could be accounted for remains to be seen. Besides, no sooner did Dr. Edu assume office than she pointed out the vulnerability of the social register being used by the ministry. Federal legislators and state governments also complained about the scheme. Yet, till now, the N37 billion said to have been mismanaged by her ministry is yet to be fully accounted for. Another high official of the ministry, the first to be picked by the EFCC was Mrs. Halima Shehu who was running the National Social Investment Programme Agency (NSIPA). She, too, is yet to be exonerated or indicted.

    These have raised so many questions. What has happened to the civil servant into whose account Edu allegedly got the money paid? Now that the President has announced recommencement of the scheme, has the social register been tidied up? Shouldn’t the Secretary to the Government of the Federation address the public on the state of affairs in the ministry, especially since another minister has been appointed? What was the scope of the investigation? Did it cover other allegations including money earmarked for a trip by air to Kogi State? Beyond the money for Ogun, Lagos, Akwa Ibom and Cross River allegedly misapplied, what about other states.

    Governments in Nigeria have always disregarded the people. The President should get personally involved and publish the report. All involved in this scandal should be named and prosecuted where found culpable, if only to deter others from travelling along the same route. Most importantly, processes and systems should be put in place to ensure that public funds are judiciously expended. It is most unfortunate that the money in question is for the most vulnerable, to keep them warm from the harsh weather of the moment.

  • She is gone, presidency confirms Betta Edu’s exit

    She is gone, presidency confirms Betta Edu’s exit

    Presidential spokesperson Mr. Bayo Onanuga has said that suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Reduction Betta Edu has been formally relieved of her ministerial duties after President Bola Tinubu’s recent cabinet shuffle.  

    He said this during an appearance in Sunday’s edition of Channels Television’s Politics Today.

    This announcement ended months of conjecture that she might be reinstated to her former position.

    The Nation reported Tinubu suspended the Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Betta Edu, from office, over an alleged N585m scandal in the Ministry.

    The President also directed Chairman of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to conduct a thorough investigation into all aspects of the financial transactions involving the Federal Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, as well as one or more agencies thereunder.

    Read Also: Betta Edu hailed for humanitarian services at 38

    Onanuga said on Edu’s permanent exit: “I think there is another person from Cross River in the cabinet. Betta Edu is gone. Don’t forget that she was suspended in January, and this is October.

    “No, she is gone. Her position has been taken over by someone else — that’s the man from Plateau (Nentawe) who is now assuming the role. For this government, there is no place for her in the cabinet.”

    Onanuga added: “The EFCC has not shared whatever they have, but if you consider the president’s action, it suggests that the EFCC may have submitted something that justified the president’s decision.”

  • Betta Edu hailed for humanitarian services at 38

    Betta Edu hailed for humanitarian services at 38

    Friends and well wishers of former Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Dr. Betta Edu, on her 38th birthday. 

    Rasheed Olanrewaju Zubair, in a tribute, praised her for exceptional contributions to public service and humanitarian work. 

    “Since her appointment in August 2023, Edu has become the youngest member of President Bola Tinubu’s cabinet, actively leading initiatives to alleviate poverty and provide support to vulnerable communities across the country.

    “Edu’s tenure was marked by her proactive approach, including visits to conflict zones and internally displaced persons (IDP) camps in states such as Borno and Benue, where she distributed essential relief supplies and spread messages of hope aligned with the Tinubu administration’s Renewed Hope Agenda. 

    Read Also: Betta Edu threatens BBC with $50 million suit over alleged libel

    “Her dedication has earned her recognition from several quarters, with figures like the Shehu of Borno commending her commitment and visible impact on those affected by humanitarian crises.

    “With a background as the former health commissioner of Cross River State and educational qualifications from the University of Calabar and the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Edu’s career trajectory continues to inspire, particularly among Nigeria’s youth. 

    “Her journey from state leadership to a national position underscores her dedication to service, unity, and poverty alleviation.

    “As she celebrates another year, Dr. Edu’s impact resonates across Nigeria, solidifying her role as a transformative leader in humanitarian affairs and an inspiring figure for young Nigerians.”

  • Betta Edu threatens BBC with $50 million suit over alleged libel

    Betta Edu threatens BBC with $50 million suit over alleged libel

    Suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation Betta Edu has threatened to institute a $50 million libel suit against the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) over a recent report on its website. 

    In a letter to the BBC on April 9, 2024 by Ojukwu Chikaosolu and Co Law firm,  Edu demanded retraction of the report stating It put her in a bad light. 

    The law firm said the report titled: “Betta Edu probe: Nigeria recovers $ 24 m in Poverty Minister investigation- EFCC” was tweaked to make the Minister appear guilty of corruption. 

    It stated Edu has neither been indicted nor found culpable of any act of financial impropriety, adding neither N30 billion nor any amount whatsoever has been traced to or recovered from Edu’s bank accounts. 

    The firm insisted no proceed of crime has been traced or recovered from her to warrant the scurrilous article under reference.

    It demanded retraction of the story as well as an apology to Edu failing which a libel suit will be instituted against the media organisation.

    “Should BBC fail and/or neglect to comply with the above demands, Edu has vowed to initiate swift legal action(s) before the appropriate Courts to obtain redress for the alleged injurious falsehood peddled in the BBC’s article, and to seek punitive and exemplary damages for $50 million against the BBC for the damage and injury suffered by her.

    “Recall that BBC recently published an article on its website: www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-Africa (Last accessed on 9th April 2024 at 17:40 GMT) titled: “Betta Edu Probe: Nigeria Recover $ 24 m in Poverty Minister Investigation- EFCC” with the sub-heading “Nigeria Has Recovered 30bn Naira ($24m; £19m) as Part of an Ongoing Corruption probe Into a Suspended Minister, the Financial Watchdog Says”.

    “The aforesaid article, which presents information purporting to relate to an ongoing corruption probe into the activities of the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation in Nigeria, is replete with innuendoes and insinuations which suggest that N30 billion has been recovered in the course of the ongoing investigation by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) from her and that the 50 bank accounts connected with the recovered sums are linked to her.

    “Furthermore, your article proceeds to cast aspersion on our client by referencing her earlier suspension (to allow for unfettered investigations) in the following terms: Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation Minister Betta Edu was initially suspended in January over the alleged diversion of $640,000 of public money into a personal bank account.

    “First and foremost, the language used in describing our client’s purported involvement in the alleged corruption case suggests guilt without allowing for the presumption of innocence, which is fundamental in any fair and unbiased reporting. 

    “The reckless manner in which the article was crafted, without providing our client with the opportunity to respond to the allegations before its wide publication, is a clear breach of journalistic fairness and due process and demonstrates a complete disregard for journalistic integrity and professionalism. 

    “The headline, content, and tone of the article imply guilt on the part of our client, without any concrete evidence to substantiate such claims. This is a blatant attempt to tarnish our client’s reputation and undermine her credibility which she has earned throughout her distinguished career in both private and public life,” the letter stated.

    Read Also: Betta Edu: EFCC recovers N30bn, probes 50 bank accounts

    It added: “Suffice it to say that in the aftermath of the publication of this scandalous article (which the BBC caused to be disseminated to millions of persons across the globe), our client has been inundated by calls and messages from friends, associates expressing their shock and consternation. Our client has suffered immeasurable reputational damage, psychological trauma and anguish as a direct consequence of the publication and dissemination of the article..

    “Furthermore, we demand that the BBC, within 48 hours from the receipt of this correspondence, issue and publish an immediate and unqualified retraction of the aforementioned article and a public apology to our client, for the false and defamatory content published. This retraction and apology must be given the same prominence as the initial offensive article,” it explained. 

    “Should the BBC fail and/or neglect to comply with the above demands, the law firm posited that it would take legal action against the media platform. “We have our client’s instructions to, without further recourse to the BBC, initiate swift legal action(s) before the appropriate Courts to obtain redress for the injurious falsehood peddled in your article, and to seek punitive and exemplary damages for $50 million against the BCC for the damage and injury suffered by our client.”

  • Betta Edu: Imperatives of protecting those who expose corruption

    Betta Edu: Imperatives of protecting those who expose corruption

    • Dr Micheal Ogbonna

    In the fight against corruption, whistleblowers serve as courageous guardians of integrity and accountability, often risking their livelihoods and personal safety to expose wrongdoing.

    This is evident from the bold and courageous move by Dr Betta Edu to expose the sleaze in her ministry which exposed the illegal transfer by the disgraced former National Co-ordinator and Chief Executive Officer of the National Social Investment Programme Agency, Halima Shehu, who was arrested in connection with ₦44billion missing money from the coffers of the agency.

     However, despite Betta Edu’s crucial role in uncovering malfeasance and promoting transparency, she was however been subjected to myriads of criticism and paid propaganda against her which led to her suspension.

     This article delves into the compelling reasons why whistleblowers on corruption must be protected, and the far-reaching benefits of safeguarding those who dare to speak out like the suspended Humanitarian Minister, Dr Betta Edu.

    It is also a clarion call on President Bola Ahmed Tinubu not to play to the gallery of disgruntled political neophytes and some unscrupulous elements within his party who are hell-bent at ensuring that his presidential ratings and assessment are nothing to write about.

    First and foremost, protecting whistleblowers is essential for deterring corruption and promoting a culture of transparency and accountability. Whistleblowers play a pivotal role in uncovering fraud, embezzlement, bribery, and other forms of misconduct that undermine public trust and erode the foundations of democracy. 

    By providing legal protections and safeguards for whistleblowers, governments can incentivize individuals with insider knowledge to come forward without fear of reprisal, thereby facilitating the detection and prosecution of corrupt practices.

    Moreover, protecting Betta Edu is crucial for enhancing the effectiveness of anti-corruption efforts and strengthening institutional integrity. Whistleblowers often possess valuable information and evidence that can lead to the prosecution of corrupt officials, recovery of stolen assets, and implementation of corrective measures to prevent future abuses. By shielding whistleblowers from retaliation and ensuring their confidentiality, governments can empower them to cooperate with law enforcement agencies, anti-corruption bodies, and other oversight mechanisms, thereby bolstering the credibility and efficacy of anti-corruption initiatives.

    President Bola Ahmed Tinubu should know that protecting the passionate Betta Edu is instrumental in promoting a culture of accountability and fostering public trust in government institutions. When individuals witness corruption or misconduct within their organizations, they face a moral dilemma between remaining silent or risking their careers and personal safety to expose wrongdoing. 

    Edu chose the latter yet, 11 weeks after, nothing has been done to recall her to her position. President Tinubu’s administration no longer has highlights. None of the Minister’s seems to be working because of the fate that befell the star girl of this administration.

    By providing legal protections, whistleblower hotlines, and support mechanisms, governments can signal their commitment to upholding the rule of law and protecting those who act in the public interest. This, in turn, encourages greater transparency, ethical conduct, and accountability among public officials and private sector actors alike.

    Additionally, protecting whistleblowers is essential for safeguarding democracy and promoting civic engagement. Whistleblowers are often hailed as heroes for their bravery in speaking truth to power and holding those in positions of authority accountable for their actions. However, without adequate protections, whistleblowers are vulnerable to retaliation, harassment, and ostracism, which can have a chilling effect on freedom of speech and dissent.

     By enacting whistleblower protection laws and fostering a supportive environment for whistleblowers, governments can nurture a culture of civic responsibility, democratic participation, and public engagement in governance processes.

    In conclusion, the investigation by the EFCC should be made public and Betta Edu, if found innocent should be reinstated.

    Read Also: Betta Edu: Don’t link Gbajabiamila with financial scam, CSO warns

    President Tinubu should muster the political will to right the wrong done by his hasty decision to relieve Betta Edu of his Ministerial position.

    The imperative for protecting whistleblowers on corruption is unequivocal and far-reaching. Whistleblowers play a vital role in exposing corruption, promoting transparency, and holding the powerful to account. 

    By safeguarding whistleblowers from retaliation and providing them with the necessary legal protections and support, governments can bolster anti-corruption efforts, strengthen institutional integrity, and foster a culture of accountability and democratic governance. 

    It is incumbent upon governments, civil society organizations, and international stakeholders to prioritize the protection of whistleblowers as an essential component of the global fight against corruption and the promotion of a more just and equitable society.

    And the likes of Dr Betta Edu should be encouraged and reinstated fully as the Honourable Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation in Nigeria.

    Ogbonna, a public affairs analyst wrote from Lagos.

  • Betta Edu: Beyond artifice

    Betta Edu: Beyond artifice

    It is impossible to observe the shenanigans of the Betta Edu herd and not laugh. Yet you may be driven to relive their theatrics with a stunned combination of amazement and disgust.

    Call it a daemonic aria, a flight of effete imagination. If contemporary politics thrives as musical artifice, the recent falsetto of Betta Edu’s herd could be her cipher, the fault in her organ valve rendering her artful melody a frantic fustian dross.

    The recent videos of a ragtag group of women singing Edu’s praises and calling for her reinstatement and the frantic tweets by some “social influencers” equally supporting the suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation and calling for her recall, affirm that Nigerians nurse a hankering for extremes.

    The brazen resort to tribal sentimentality and gender asserting sophistry by Edu’s apologists seem simultaneously connected to a moral apocalypse and a proclivity to live above the law.

    Their wacky verses mock the solemn solitaries Edu initially uttered in rebuttal of allegations of wrongdoing in the scandalous fraud bedeviling the Federal Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation.

    That ‘Edunian’ pathos lends itself so easily to parody suggests there is some real excess in it. In all, common sense and morality suffer the mean grope of indecency. The palsied pat of her supporters, their shrill chants and plea to President Bola Tinubu to “Give Betta a second chance” become grotesque restraints, confining and corrupting emotion instead of ennobling and deepening it.

    So far, no one has jeopardised Edu’s interests more than the ragtag squad seeking to assert her innocence through sponsored protests and cheap emotional blackmail. Just recently, a Facebook page titled, Dr Betta Edu’s Supporters Group – with 1,800 members – took up the campaign to save the embattled former minister from blame and prosecution.

    Yet, the weight of the allegations against Edu rests on the sturdy beams of the following facts: that she was fingered in an alleged diversion of more than N585 million naira ($640,000; £500,000) of public money into a personal bank account; that she was suspended by President Tinubu soon after local media buzzed about a leaked document that allegedly showed the minister instructing a senior treasury official to transfer the money to the personal account of Bridget Oniyelu, the accountant for the government’s Grants for Vulnerable Groups initiative instead of a government account.

    At 37, Edu was the youngest minister in President Tinubu’s cabinet. Her appointment as the Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation Minister seemed revolutionary, depicting Tinubu’s administration as a force with a strapping innate promise. But no sooner did Edu get fingered in the alleged diversion of public fund into a personal bank account than she was suspended by Tinubu.

    The President subsequently ordered an investigation of Edu’s ministry and called for a reform of government institutions that run the National Social Investments Programmes Agency (NSIPA) stressing the need to “win back lost public confidence.”

    Edu, who lost her job barely six months after she assumed office, has denied any wrongdoing even as she submits to grilling by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC). Also being grilled at the EFCC headquarters is a former Minister of Humanitarian Affairs, Disaster Management and Social Development, Sadiya Umar-Farouq, over alleged fraud in handling N37.1 billion social intervention funds during her tenure under then President Muhammadu Buhari. Halima Shehu, the suspended chief executive officer of the NSIPA, is also under investigation by the EFCC.

    Read Also: The Betta Edu in us all

    Yet Edu is the only one with a curious band of die-hard supporters who have resorted to more desperate measures across physical and social spaces to demand her reinstatement.

    Edu has, however, disowned groups purportedly fighting for her reinstatement claiming that she did not sponsor any public activity. She said, in a recent press release, that she did not authorise groups organising public prayers and protests to seek her reinstatement to President Tinubu’s cabinet, stressing that she is cooperating fully with her investigators.

    The shenanigans of the Edu-herd commands an exercise of the eye, not of the mind. At best, they should be accorded the passing tribute of a sigh. While they defend and stroke their infinite delusions, such characters secretly suppress, perhaps, their mind’s wars with treacherous nature.

    Nigeria’s culture of corruption remains a vast behavioural gash across successive administrations.Even as hope sprouts on the margins through the daring of the incumbent government, Nigeria has begun to look like an immense illustration of chaos theory and corruption.

    In the face of comatose industry and a distressed economy, public officers have been found to repeatedly loot public money that would otherwise provide infrastructure and fund social intervention programmes.

    How President Tinubu handles the Edu case, among others, would determine the consequent trajectory of his anti-corruption campaign and public opinion about his administration.

    The burden of proof of his fabled sagacity rests on his response to social crisis or opportunity in real time.

    It took a great deal of spirit for him to assert the legend of his sagacity, en route to the presidential polls. As President, it is easy for him to trash his repute and all of his associated mystique. He probably wouldn’t.

    From the get-go, President Tinubu dared to assert his mettle, making an earnest wish to serve the people from the trenches of governance. Just two weeks into the job, he made rousing pirouettes signing the student loan bill into law and promising to review the N30,000 minimum wage to reflect current global realities thus tugging on the people’s heartstrings.

    From dousing the threat of industrial action by a partisan and corrupted labour union, suspending the heads of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) and the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Godwin Emefiele and Abdulrasheed Bawa respectively to investigate weighty allegations of abuse of office, to his appointment of key State House officers, President Tinubu expressed his eagerness to hit the ground running with the right calibre of staff.

    While his opening acts seem emphatic of his will, the citizenry impatiently seek the manifestation of the promised dividends of his policies in their lives. They earnestly await the implementation of the new minimum wage, student loan bill and promised reduction in fuel price at the operationalisation of the refineries.

    More importantly, they await his urgent intervention and enthronement of justice in scandalous cases of corruption and abuse of public office, involving crucial government organs like the Federal Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation.

    From his swearing-in, Tinubu cut the image of a leader eager to to rid Nigeria of the affliction of the parasitic cabal that hitherto misappropriated the fortunes of the oil and finance sectors and Nigeria’s commonwealth.

    Yet passion is never enough to survive the storms outside and within the corridors of power. Tinubu must assert his integrity of intent, unwavering in the face of random subterfuge and organised animosity. If he intends to be taken seriously, he must shun subtle and barefaced artifice.

    As he supervises the Betta Edu inquisition, among others, Nigerians are counting on him to prevent the miscarriage of justice, hoping he understands that no matter how adroitly a leader cartwheels on moral fibre, if he feigns integrity as a rite of perfidy, he would fall splat in the court of posterity.

    President Tinubu must shun such recreant retreat. If not, he would be forging a bad karma, for himself and the country.

  • Betta and other matters

    Betta and other matters

    Even without the benefit of the findings and recommendations of the team empanelled to probe the suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Dr. Betta Edu, the unofficial jury across the board would seem to have turned in a verdict of guilty as charged on the embattled minister. Talk of a case being messy through and through; if ever there was yet another instance in which an accused public officer is presumed guilty until he or she is able to prove his or her innocence as against the standard prescription of innocence until proven otherwise, this latest case would be it.

    Understandably, Nigerians are angry. The particulars of the alleged offences, as contained in the leaked memo, would ordinarily be unnerving enough without the whiff of embedded criminal intentions. The outline is something that Nigerians have become only too familiar with: a public officer, who should ordinarily know better, flouting service conventions; going far outside of the rules of the Bible of the civil service– the Financial Regulations and the General Orders – to commit the treasury to such ends that are neither transparent nor entirely licit.

    Truth however, is that there are other aspects of the story – still unheard. Sure, while all the attention is currently focused on Betta Edu and all that she allegedly did wrong – ostensibly because she was a high profile public official; it is hoped that the committee empanelled by President Bola Tinubu to probe her and the ministry will in the end do justice particularly in helping to understand all that went wrong.

    By the way, the so-called Official Secrets Act, to which all levels of functionaries are sworn to its fidelity both in letters and spirit, would seem gone, forever. Not when, with a few kilobytes of data, and individual can, armed with a phone, choose to bring down careers built over decades, or if it comes to that, take down the impregnable walls of government secrecy at whim. Welcome to the new age. The sad part is that only a few are yet to appropriately read and digest the signs. Trust me: it is a raging inferno that is unlikely to be put out anytime soon!

    Read Also: Tinubu explains reasons for cabinet size

    To get back to Minister Edu; she was of course unlucky. Her crime, as it appears, was the route she chose. She requested Oluwatoyin Madein, the accountant general of the federation, to transfer the sum of N585.2 million from the account of the National Social Investment Office to the private account of one Bridget Oniyelu, the accountant in charge of the poverty intervention project –Grants for Vulnerable Groups – supervised by her ministry, last December. That was her mistake.

    Of course, the latter, a thoroughbred civil servant, refused to honour the request, noting that payments like N585.2 million “are usually processed by the affected ministries as self-accounting entities.” Advising the minister on the appropriate steps to take in making such payments in line with the established payment procedure”, she was mindful enough to put in a rather strong caveat: “No bulk payment is supposed to be made to an individual’s account in the name of the Project Accountant.”

    My question – would the case have been different had she not sought the payment from the wrong quarters as against her ministry where the funds were actually domiciled? In other words, where did the original advice on the funds request come from? Was she acting out of ignorance or plain naivety?

    And then her mistake number: failure to carry the hierarchs of her ministry along. Now, the question is – where in the world were her ministry officials? I mean those officials – the body of directors with the permanent secretary at the apex – that should have guided her to ensure that due process was followed in the processing of the payment? Like Pontius Pilate, their hands are supposed to be squeaky clean? Really? 

    How about the service rules, which designates the permanent secretary as the chief accounting officer of the ministry? And what role(s) did the official play in the entire affair?

    More pertinent: how was it possible for that powerful individual to have been shunted aside in the entire transactions?

    Better still, how did the N585 million manage to get through the layers of bureaucracy without the process being flagged at any point? Assuming the minister so directed that the sum be paid as conveyed in the memo, could she have forced the career officials to flout the rules when they are fully aware of the consequences? Could it be a case of quid pro quo?

    The best we can say at this point is that laws were broken. As to the extent, we do not yet know. However, thanks to  Jim Obazee, the President Tinubu-appointed Special Investigator of Emefiele’s CBN, we are finally coming to terms with the fact that the financial services sector is a major pillar in the national rot. In fact, the sector stinks to high heavens.  Unfortunately, few Nigerians recognise this let alone appreciate that no level fraud of any serious scale can succeed without the complicity of those entities. Call them the off-takers of all stolen funds; whether it is the story of Abdulrasheed Maina of the defunct Pension Reform Task Team (PRTT), and his theft of N2 billion in pension funds, or the similar one involving the one-time Accountant-General of the Federation, AGF, Ahmed Idris and his alleged pilfering of about N84.7billion from the treasury; it seems obvious that the roles of the banks in the continuing rape of the treasury is yet to be fully understood. Now we hear that some N44 billion somehow managed to disappear from the accounts of the National Social Investment Programmes Agency, (NSIPA), under the watch of its top gun, Halima Shehu as well as the laundering of another  N37.1 billion by officials of the same Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs during the tenure of its immediate past minister, Mrs Umar-Farouk.

    How come that none of the banks could flag the suspicious movements of the huge sums from the government accounts?

    It is unfortunate that not a few Nigerians still believe that a lone powerful official – in this instance, Minister Edu – actually pulled off the mess in question without the complicity of some individuals and institutional enablers. It explains why they want the minister kept behind bars with the writ of Habeas Corpus kept in abeyance until all matters – from investigations to her possible trial are concluded.

    Mercifully, the president sees things differently. A thoroughbred system’s man, he knows more than the mob currently baying for an individual’s blood that a thorough and dispassionate inquiry will, in the end, deliver more results than the current mob chants for crucifixion. In the end, there must be a world of difference between fundamentally changing the way things are done and a mob’s demand for instant justice. While the latter, as we have seen all too often, leads nowhere, the former could be sometimes too slow and tortuous. Yet, it is the one that best serves the society.

  • The Betta Edu in us all

    The Betta Edu in us all

    Does the seeming outpouring of outrage over the alleged request by the suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Dr Betta Edu, that the sum of over N585 million meant for vulnerable groups in Ogun, Akwa-Ibom, Lagos and Cross River States be paid into the private account of a civil servant indicate a strong aversion by the vast majority of Nigerians to corrupt practices by public office holders? It is unlikely. If true, the leaked memo in which the Minister directed the Accountant General of the Federation (AGF), Dr Oluwatoyin Madein, to pay the said sum into the private account of one Bridget Oniyelu said to be the Project Accountant responsible for Grants for Vulnerable Groups (GVG) in the four states, imply clearly that an infraction was indeed committed. The AGF gave an indication to this effect when she declined to carry out the Minister’s directive because it contravened extant public sector financial regulations.

    In her immediate reaction following the widespread rage caused by the leaked memo, Dr Edu insisted she had done no wrong and that her integrity was intact. It is obvious that the impression she had was that the fund involved could be transferred into the private account of the purported Project Accountant in charge of the Grant for Vulnerable Groups in the five states. But the private account of the Project Accountant in question is not the public corporate account of the GVGs in Lagos, Ogun, Akwa-Ibom and Cross River states.

    In an investigative report, the respected online newspaper, Premium Times, cited Chapter Seven, Section 713 of Nigeria’s Financial Regulations that states thus, “Personal money shall in no circumstances be paid into a government bank account nor shall any public money be paid into a private account” and that “Any officer who pays public money into a private account is deemed to have done so with fraudulent intention”.

    It is obviously with regard to the relevant Public Service Rules as that cited by Premium Times that respected human rights lawyer, Mr Femi Falana (SAN), insists that a breach of the law has indeed been established. He thus submits that “However, notwithstanding that the Accountant General of the Federation has successfully frustrated the criminal diversion of the said sum of N585.18 million from public treasury; it is crystal clear that the offense of an attempt to commit a felony has already been completed”. On this basis, Mr Falana urges the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) “To speed up the ongoing investigation of the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs with a view to charging all indicted persons before the High Court of the FCT as soon as possible”.

    Read Also: Reducing cost of governance (2)

    The distinguished SAN takes a strictly legal and technicist view of the issue. It is understandable. However, other key questions arise in my view which must be taken into consideration. First, when the AGF declined to act on Dr Edu’s directive on the ground of its illegality, did she get back to the Minister either verbally or in writing to properly educate her on the position of the law and public sector regulations on the banking and expenditure of public funds? Equally, did the Permanent Secretary or other senior civil servants in the Ministry of humanitarian affairs advise the Minister appropriately on the provisions relevant public financial regulations to guide her actions which is one of their key responsibilities?

    More importantly, even from Mr Falana’s submission, the N585 million in question has not been released from government coffers. No funds are thus yet to be diverted and no damage done. That ought to have a mitigating effect on whatever action is ultimately taken as regards the Minister in my view.

    All this, of course, is without prejudice to the ongoing probe of the entire affair by the EFCC on the directive of President Bola Tinubu. So significant is the decision of the President to suspend the Minister pending the outcome of investigations, order the anti-graft agency to probe the allegations and set up a ministerial committee headed by the Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Mr Wale Edun, to exhaustively audit the various programmes under the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs that even some key opposition figures have, quite uncharacteristically, commended him for this proactive disposition.

    Beyond the immediate Dr Betta Edu affair, the EFCC is also beaming its searchlight on the alleged diversion of N44 billion from the accounts of the National Social Investment Programmes Agency, (NSIPA), leading to the suspension by the President of the agency’s Chief Executive Officer, Halima Shehu, as well as the alleged laundering of about N37.1 billion by officials of the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs during the tenure of its immediate past Minister, Mrs Umar-Farouk.

    President Tinubu’s suspension of Halima Shehu and Dr Betta Edu most certainly does not amount to an indictment of these public officers. It is evidently to give the anti-graft agency the environment to do its work without impediment by the officers whose agencies are under investigation. The ultimate decision on them will thus depend on the efficiency, credibility and reliability of the investigations carried out by the EFCC. This is why the anti-graft agency cannot afford an unduly prolonged and open-ended probe.

    Its investigation should be done with the same kind of swiftness, forensic precision and professionalism exhibited by the Special Prosecutor, Mr Jim Obazee, in his probe of the finances of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) under its immediate past governor, Mr Godwin Emefiele. Again, the EFCC has a responsibility not to subject those it is investigating to trial by media so as to downplay sensationalism as much as possible and safeguard the integrity of its final report.

    It is no less significant that the Code of Conduct Bureau, (CCB), has invited the high-flying Minister of Interior, Mr Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo, for an interview over allegations that a company in which he has an interest, New Planet Projects, benefitted from a contract from the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs to the tune of N438.1 million for the verification of the National Social Register compiled under the previous administration. The Minister has explained at various public fora that, even though he formed the company in question with his wife, he resigned as a Director and was no longer involved in its day-to-day running since 2019 when he was elected into the House of Representatives. What is critical is that the government has not prevented the CCB from beaming its searchlight on the conduct and activities of one of its best performing Ministers. It is unprecedented.

    Some have called for the suspension of the Minister on the basis of still unfounded allegations. Did he truly resign as a Director of the company in 2019? Is he involved in the day-to-day running of the company? Does it contradict the law for a public officer to own shares in companies? Was due process adhered to in awarding any contract to the company? Does the company have the requisite capacity to implement whatever contract it was awarded? Without the requisite accurate information, it is impossible to come to any informed position on the culpability or otherwise of the Minister.

    Again, some have pronounced authoritatively that the amount of N3 billion approved for the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs to verify its National Social Register was exorbitant. How can we credibly come to such a conclusion without a knowledge of the scope of work involved or the intricacies involved in its implementation? What all of this suggests is that the agencies mandated by the President to investigate the various allegations must be allowed to thoroughly conduct and conclude their work before judgements are made.

    It is of course disturbing that the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation is at the centre of such allegations of misappropriation and diversion of incredibly humongous amounts of money. The Ministry is supposed to be at the vanguard of government’s efforts to alleviate poverty and bring immediate succor to the teeming numbers of the poor. All of the funds suspected to have been diverted and being investigated are meant for this purpose. And it is probably because they are believed to be the more compassionate and caring gender that those entrusted with managing these funds as heads of the Ministry or agencies under it are mostly women.

    But to deprive the millions groaning under the weight of poverty of the funds meant to ease their pain is the very negation of compassion. Rather, it is the very essence of wickedness and heartlessness. Perhaps issues of humaneness and integrity in public office have less to do with gender or age than with the values held and espoused by the individual. But we must suspend judgement until the investigative agencies complete their task.

    At the beginning of this piece I asked if the outrage against Dr Edu’s alleged financial misdemeanors is reflective of a national culture that loathes corruption. I answered the question in the negative. All too often those who most vehemently denounce acts of corruption by public office holders do so not because of a principled opposition to corruption but because they are not the ones benefiting from the opportunities to criminally privatize public funds. If the allegations against Dr Edu are confirmed to be true, it does not mean that she is an exception from a norm of pervasive honesty and integrity. Rather, there is a Betta Edu in most of us only waiting for a lifetime opportunity to have access to public resources in their trust and line their pockets.

    There is a dialectical relationship between poverty and corruption. The pervasive corruption amongst Nigeria’s political elite responsible for the incessant, reckless plundering of the National commonwealth is the function of a deep-seated spiritual poverty that places undue premium on material acquisition by all means and at all costs. This is motivated by a desperate desire of public office holders to escape the debilitating poverty of our society not only for themselves but for their future generations. But ironically and paradoxically, the industrial scale corruption among the political elite deprives the country of funds for development and worsens the problem of poverty.

    Of course, if Dr Edu ultimately does not return to her office, it would do little to dent the prevalent culture of corruption so badly ruining the country. She would only make way for some other members of the elite to avail themselves of the opportunity to come and chop. It is just that her case is so pathetic. She worked so hard for her party as National Woman Leader during the elections. A medical doctor with multiple degrees including a PhD, she is a woman of high intellect. She is obviously a go-getter no matter what her all too human flaws.

    She has acquired valuable experience as a Commissioner of health in Cross River for four years. She must surely have learnt some valuable lessons from this experience to make her a better human being and a wiser public office holder. She is a beacon of hope for youth having made such impact at just 37. I pray that she can be given a stern warning for any infractions and given a second chance. Let he who is without sin throw the first stone.