Tag: Metuh

  • N500m defamation claim: I have no case to answer, says Metuh

    N500m defamation claim: I have no case to answer, says Metuh

    Fireworks were being thrown yesterday between the National Publicity Secretary of the All Progressive Congress (APC), Alhaji Lai Mohammed and his Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) counterpart, Olisa Metuh.

    Both spokesmen for the ruling and main opposition party are locked in a battle over an alleged defamatory and libelous statement credited to Metuh.

    In a letter written by his counsel, Wahab Shittu on September 22, 2015, titled: “Demand for unreserved apology, retraction and N500 million compensation over defamation of character”, Lai Mohammed  alleged that the PDP spokesperson defamed him in a press release issued on September 20. The APC chieftain said Metuh “willfully and maliciously made false, destructive and defamatory statements,” against him in the following words:

    “Nevertheless, as we restate our commitment in providing issue-based opposition as well as our support for the fight against corruption, our final word for the APC spokesman on this, is that being ethically challenged, includes embezzling funds meant for fencing of an airport in an APC-led Southwest states. It also includes when one fraudulently refuse to supply ambulances after collecting monies from another APC South West State.

    “It is then a comedy of roles when Alhaji Lai Mohammed speaks on corruption, a topic he practices and has well learnt, being a personal aide to one of the most corrupt politicians to ever bestride the political landscape of the country.”

    Mohammed said the statements as published by Metuh are “utterly false and without merit, and they are defamation per se.”  The APC chieftain also said by the publication, Metuh has portrayed him as a fraudster, a man who must not be entrusted with money, a man of dubious character, corrupt and an economic saboteur.”

    He denied that any of his companies had ever been involved in any alleged embezzlement of funds meant for the fencing of any airport or in contract for supplying ambulance for any state government including Southwest states.

    In what could be described as bold demands, Mohammed asked Metuh for a retraction or public apology within seven days and to cease further defamation of his character and reputation. He also demanded for  N500 million  as damages for the “unquantifiable damage done to his reputation and integrity.”

    But in a swift response through his lawyer, Emeka Etiaba, (SAN), Metuh said he will not accede to any of the demands made by Mohammed as he never made reference to Mohammed in his press release nor insulted anybody insisting the statement was made in national interest.

    In a letter dated September 25, and signed by Etiaba, Metuh also alleged that Mohammed in his response to the press statement had made “unprovoked vituperations” against him in the following words:

    “ The party said that for the PDP’s National Publicity Secretary himself, the persistent onslaught against the Buhari administration is neither altruistic nor informed by any belief in higher values, because the allegations of corruption hanging on his neck, from within his own party, is a clear indication that he is mortally afraid that the wind will soon blow hard enough to expose the fowl’s rump.

    “May we therefore assure you that our client does not intend to accede to any of your demands”, Emeka wrote in the reply for his client.

     

  • PDP urges Buhari to pay attention to economy

    PDP urges Buhari to pay attention to economy

    The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has urged the President Mohammadu Buhari to pay urgent attention to the management of the nation’s economy.

    The party said its worry stemmed from the fact that the economy has remained on rapid fall since the last four months, apparently due to the absence of clear-cut fiscal policy direction and an economic team to deal with the domestic and global challenges associated with a developing economy.

    A statement issued on Monday issued by the party’s National Publicity Secretary, Chief Olisa Metuh, said the PDP was in full support of the President’s efforts in tackling corruption and insurgency.

    The party, however, expressed concerned about what it described as “the grave economic situation we now face,” as well as indices from global economic watchers, which it said, the administration had failed to give deserving attention, despite its predictable negative impact.

    The PDP said it was duty-bound, beyond politics, to draw the President’s attention to the fact that under the prevailing circumstances, the nation is evidently heading to economic doldrums.

    The statement said, “Mr. President, this is no longer about politics and partisanship. It is about the economy of our dear nation and the wellbeing of the Nigerian citizens.

    “Recall that we have severally in the past, drawn attention to official reports showing that the unemployment situation in the country as well as inflation rate are growing at frightening dimensions, not to talk of the continued decline in domestic and direct foreign investments, all due to uncertainty created by the lack of economic direction of APC-led administration.

    “The situation has become even of utmost concern following the failure of this administration to articulate any interventionist policy at this critical moment, when credible global economic monitors have continued to predict that oil price may fall as low as $20 per barrel.

    “It is worrisome that whilst other countries are taking deliberate steps to enhance their investment profiles and hedge their economies at this time, the APC-led federal government has done nothing in that direction, but has centered on partisan politics and witch-hunt of perceived opponents, while the economy remains vulnerable and unattended to.

    “We caution strongly that this approach to governance is not healthy for our nation. Indeed, the time has come for Mr. President to end the apparent lethargy in his administration and take urgent step to set up a crack economic team of experts to immediately swing into action and salvage the situation by opening up all economic outlets, which have been stagnated in the last four months.

    “In managing this economy at this time, we urge Mr. President, as the father of the nation, to look beyond partisan politics and ensure that the policy frameworks and populist economic projects laid by the PDP administration, especially in the non-oil sectors are not allowed to rot, but adequately utilized for the good of all.”

  • PDP backs Buhari’s anti-corruption campaign

    PDP backs Buhari’s anti-corruption campaign

    We didn’t send anybody to steal money – Party

    The Peoples Democratic Party said on Thursday that it is willing to support President Muhammadu Buhari‘s administration in the fight against corruption, saying it did not ask any of its public officers in the last regime to take money.

    The National Publicity Secretary of the party, Olisa Metuh, who stated this in on Political Platform, a Radio Nigeria political programme monitored in Abuja, also said the party believes in the sincerity of President Buhari in addressing problems of insecurity, corruption and the economy.

    However, the National Publicity Secretary of the APC, Alhaji Lai Mohammed, who was also on the programme, said it was difficult to distinguish between seriousness and sincerity, pointing out that President Buhari has been able to restore the confidence of Nigerians in the system.

    Metuh said, “On security, we believe that this President should be serious. We give it to him that he is serious, being a General and the President and an expert in the management of crisis, we give it to him that he is serious about addressing the security challenges.

    “We believe that he is sincere as well. We want to give it to him that he is sincere in handling it. We don’t want to raise the fact that when he took over, the last administration had driven back the insurgents and there were no bombing.

    “We don’t want to go into the issue of security. We are presenting a more robust opposition to this government. That is why the improvement in the system we have now is because we have a responsible opposition that is not distracting the government from governance.

    “On the issue of the economy, we believe that the President is sincere in trying to do something about the economy. But is he serious about it? We don’t believe so because we have not seen any seriousness on the part of the present administration.

    “When you want to be serious, you should have an economic team. You should have people that advices you and a road map. There is absolutely no policy or programme that we have seen from this government that shows they are ready for governance except saying PDP is corrupt, N2 trillion is missing here and N500million is missing there.

    “A lot of people know why we lost the election and we know why we lost the election too. So, we don’t want to go in there. My advice to the government and the APC is that politics has ended and it is time for governance. We have ceded the seat and this is the time for APC to show Nigerians that change mantra that they campaigned with. We are not contesting this thing, but they think they are still in opposition.”

     

  • Wailing Metuh

    Early enough, Femi Adesina, chief presidential spokesperson, dropped a cyber-bomb that set the social media howling: wailing wailers!

    That two-word bomb sent presidential supporters cheering, presidential opposers jeering and neutrals rather disturbed at the rather cavalier dismissal of presidential opposition.

    But in truth: Mr. Adesina would appear prescient, at the shape of malicious, bordering on utterly senseless, anti-Buhari criticisms to come — from those who appear to suffer from acute post-power belligerence syndrome (APPBS).

    Reacting to the Buhari 100 days in office, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) provoked a storm on twitter, when it claimed the president’s first 100 days were “wasted 100 days”.  That drivel provoked such an ire you could feel the virtual heat.  But those who reacted ought to have shown some empathy: that irrational judgment was triggered by the abyss of APPBS.  Instead of fury, they should have reached for the dial, to ring up a doctor: Nigeria’s former ruling party needs very, very urgent help!

    On this score, Olisa Metuh, PDP spokesperson, is chief and unfazed wailer.  Tell him he needs a consultant in post-power psychosis, and he would probably wail and scream even louder. But the holy truth: the decibel of Mr. Metuh’s hysteria would appear going a notch too high, a function of acute political agitation that needs rather urgent poli-medicare.

    Hear Mr. Metuh’s take on President Buhari’s asset declaration, just made public: “We have noted the release of a flimsy list of belongings of President Muhammadu Buhari and Vice President Yemi Osinbajo by the Presidency, who wants such to pass as the public declaration of assets as pledged by the President.  Nigerians are not deceived by this poor attempt at window-dressing, designed by the Presidency to hoodwink the unsuspecting populace in a desperate bid to shore up its diminished image.”

    Really?  Assuming without conceding (as Mr. Metuh’s learned friends would say) his claim is true, what was the situation when the doomed Goodluck Jonathan was at the same presidential juncture, even with the stellar example of his late principal, President Umaru Yar’Adua?

    The man, whose personal good luck spectacularly exposed the country’s bad luck, only snapped: “I don’t give a damn about what anyone says; I’m not doing any public declaration of asset”.  That set the tone for criminal opacity that would clean out the national till, doom the Jonathan presidency and banish PDP to the power wilderness, from which Mr. Metuh and co now wail.

    If the Metuhian metaphor claims Buhari’s effort is “poor attempt at window-dressing”, in the Jonathanian cave, there was even no window to dress; and Mr. Metuh still spun such crass opacity as the best of global presidential practices.  Sure, the Metuh gibberish is still alive and well.  The difference, however, is it is getting, by the second, more and more ridiculous.

    Oh, talking about caves reminds Hardball of the Plato allegory of the cave, making pith-darkness the nadir of ignorance; and dazzling light, the summit of knowledge.  That was why the soul in the allegory, after snapping free of the chain at the bottom of the cave, got the scales off his dark eyes at the sight of  light and went near-berserk at the sight of glorious sunshine!  That is the exhilarating liberation of knowledge!

    If Mr. Metuh’s wailing wailers (apologies to Mr. Adesina) still dismiss the Buhari’s first 100 days as “wasted”, it is because they are still chained to the pit of Jonathan-era cave.  On the electricity supply front alone (and every pun intended), that shows how Metuh and co languish in their Jonathan cave, while everyone else has moved on.

    Pity!

  • APC plotting to snatch victory in Rivers, A/Ibom – PDP

    APC plotting to snatch victory in Rivers, A/Ibom – PDP

    The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has described the statement by the All Progressives Congress (APC), that it was obstructing justice at the Rivers State governorship tribunal, as failed cheap blackmail and an infantile attempt to cover their illegality of using state security apparatus to attempt to subvert the victory of the PDP in the governorship election in the state.

    The party said APC’s reaction to the petition written to President Muhammadu Buhari by 16 PDP federal lawmakers from Rivers State, showed its desperation to grab power through the back door, in a state where it was roundly rejected by the electorates.

    PDP National Publicity Secretary, Chief Olisa Metuh, in a statement on Thursday said the APC’s statement was aimed at blackmailing judicial and electoral officers in the state as well as to justify the “reprehensible” use of the security agencies to intimidate and attempt to arm-twist them to do its bidding.

    “The PDP invites Nigerians to continue to note the various antics of the APC in its desperate scheme to corrupt the judicial process and steal the mandate freely given to the PDP by the people of Rivers State, including the use of operatives of the Department of State Services (DSS) and the military to hound and intimidate INEC and judicial officers to get them to do their bidding.

    “We are also aware of all the clandestine moves by the APC to capture power in Rivers and other PDP states, including Akwa-Ibom, Delta, Abia and Taraba States by all means, using such ploy.

    “Our answer to the APC is that their antics cannot yield any results. These states are core PDP states and no amount of propaganda, blackmail, threats and intimidation can overturn the resounding verdict of the people as expressed in the governorship elections,” the PDP stated.

    The party called on security agencies and other critical stakeholders in the electoral tribunal process in the affected states to be on the alert and ensure that they do not succumb to the antics of the APC.

    It also charged its members in affected states to remain vigilant and continue to use all legitimate means available within the ambits of the law to resist attempts by the APC to undermine their will as expressed at the polls.

  • PDP nullifies suspension of Metuh

    PDP nullifies suspension of Metuh

    . Reverses impeachment of Shelle

    The National Working Committee (NWC) of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) had announced the nullification of the purported suspension of the party’s National Publicity Secretary, Chief Olisa Metuh.

    This is contained in a statement signed by Mr. Victor Kwon, the PDP National Legal Adviser on Thursday in Abuja.

    It noted that contrary to the suspension of the national publicity secretary, the party‘s NWC at its Wednesday meeting reiterated its implicit confidence in his ability and actions that had stabilsed the party so far.

    “The NWC restates its implicit confidence in the National Publicity Secretary and expresses satisfaction with his commitment toward the progress and development of our great party at all levels.

    “The NWC of the PDP notes with concern, misleading reports in some section of the media that a certain group in Anambra, unknown to our party, has purportedly suspended Chief Olisa Metuh.

    “For the avoidance of doubt, the NWC reiterates that Chief Olisa Metuh is a member of the National Executive Committee (NEC) and as such can only be disciplined by NEC.
    “He can be disciplined in accordance with Sections 57(7) and 59(3) of the PDP Constitution 2012 (as Amended), and that is in the event that a need for such arises.’’

    It therefore said “the purported suspension is therefore a nullity.’’

    In the same vein, the NWC also declared as a nullity, the purported “impeachment” of Capt. Olatunji Shelle, the Lagos State Chairman of the party by the Lagos State Executive.

    It added that Shelle was also a member of NEC and could only be disciplined by NEC as prescribed by the PDP constitution.

    It stated that members of PDP in Lagos with genuine complains and grievances on the running of the chapter were at liberty to channel such to the NWC for appropriate action in line with the provisions of the party’s constitution.

    “The NWC urges all party faithful to go about their normal activities, in accordance with the constitution of the party and extant laws of the land,’’ the statement said

  • Ettu, Metuh?

    Ettu, Metuh?

    This is clearly not the best of times for the National Publicity Secretary of the Peoples Democratic Party, Chief Olisa Metuh. The official megaphone of the deflated and defeated behemoth, which once declared 60 years’ invincibility against any form of electoral loss before ending its 16 years of impunity in power, now faces a Herculean battle on two broad fronts – within and outside the party. For a man who has taken up the challenge to engage the ruling All Progressives Congress toe-to-toe in the arena of political propaganda, this lonely voice in the wilderness could end up being a victim of the same system that propped him into national prominence. In truth and until now, Metuh has made a good job of shouting himself hoarse even as President Muhammadu Buhari’s administration effortlessly exhumes rotten secrets that passed on as governance in the last 16 years of the PDP’s rudderless leadership. No doubt, Metuh relishes his bird with a broken beak job.

    However, there is some sort of wicked twist in the Metuh tale. Instead of getting decorated with a crest of honour for standing tall for all that was bad with the self-styled ‘Africa’s largest political party’, Metuh might just be on his last step into the hall of infamy if the allegations made against him by employees of the party’s secretariat are anything to go by. Perhaps, Metuh would not have been the issue today if all the matters relating to the financing of the 2015 general elections by the party had been settled when the issue had come up earlier in the year. Recall that Metuh, who had initially threatened fire and brimstone, was the same person that told an anxious public that the matter had been settled within the family. Now, the aggrieved workers in Wadata House have decided to open the can of worms concerning the financial malfeasance that crippled a party with a lofty dream of constructing a skyscraper as its National Headquarters. If we were to use the workers’ exposition as a template for determining how bad the books were in Wadata House, it would deepen the way we grasp the shocking realities of the mind-boggling figures that the Buhari administration has been reeling out as funds that were illegally siphoned in the last five years.

    Here, we are talking about an embattled Metuh struggling to launder his ‘integrity’ before employees who describe him as nothing but a blubbering ”repulse to professionalism and a source of embarrassment to party members.” Interestingly, while a clear and present danger was brewing under his watch as the party sinks into deeper crises, Metuh was busy blaming the APC for the self-inflicted misery afflicting his party. He said the aim was to hound him out of circulation as his “outspokenness” has discomfited the ruling APC. A statement signed by Metuh’s aide said the APC found a willing tool in a “handful of disgruntled PDP staff who are attacking him with a view to bringing him to public odium, distract him and deny our party a credible voice to propagate its positions.” That notwithstanding, Metuh has vowed to trudge on in his role “in the rebuilding of the PDP and in providing firm, credible and issue issues-based opposition to the ruling party.” Oh, how delusions can pervade the human mind!

    For those who value informed discourse, Metuh’s stance should be a welcome development because it provides an opportunity to unravel the hidden truth about how the PDP had vended deception as governance for close to two decades. With his vast experience as ”the longest serving member of the National Executive Committee due to hard work and the confidence members of the party reposed in him as an individual”, it would be an act of blind injustice for the party to ease off Metuh just because some common office employees are ranting. By the way, who is better qualified than Metuh to puncture the basket of lies being peddled by the APC on the callous manner the treasury was looted and raped by the last administration?

    So, I wait with bated breath to see how Metuh would defend the latest accusation by the ‘uncomfortable’ APC that the last administration spent over N4.8 trillion on subsidy payments which dramatically jumped from a paltry N300 billion in 2010 to N1.9 trillion in 2012. I am sure this brave spokesperson is also studying the books to debunk the claim by the Nigerian Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative (NEITI) in its latest report that the country lost about 160 million barrels of crude valued at $13.7 billion to oil theft between 2009 and 2012. What tale would he tell us to disprove Buhari’s claim that the government is in possession of verifiable information on the banks where the billions of looted oil funds were stashed? Would Metuh also disprove that as one of the many lies of a President who is trying to make sense out of a mumbo-jumbo handover notes by a PDP-led government? Would Metuh also take the former Chief of Defence Staff, Air Chief Marshall Alex Badeh, to task on his claim that the war against terror in the North-East was difficult to prosecute because the military lacked the relevant equipment and motivation in spite of the humongous money Jonathan claimed to have spent on re-equipping the military? What exactly would be his response to all the scandalous revelations of the blind, daylight looting being unearthed daily as Buhari clinically dissects the PDP’s padded shibboleths of treachery?

    Okay, let us give it to Metuh. He has not allowed the domestic tiff with his co-workers in the party to weigh him down. After all, he still managed to issue a statement in which he described the government’s economic agenda as something lifted from the communist bookshelf. He speaks of a ‘unilateral imposition of new regulations” to firm up the naira against a skyrocketing dollar as archaic and outdated. How marvellous! Question is: how workable is the modern and digitalised system that the PDP left behind for Buhari to deal with some two months back? What checks did the PDP’s corrupt- proof administration place on the illegal freighting of slush funds to foreign accounts owned by top members of that government and their hangars-on? Why were piles of audit queries, including the ones addressed to The Presidency left unanswered?

    By the way, let us not forget the fact that the brouhaha started when the National Secretary of the PDP, Prof. Wale Oladipo, signed a circular indicating that they planned a 50 per cent reduction in the secretariat staff in addition to a 50 per cent reduction in the salaries and allowances of retained lucky staff. Could it then mean that the National Working Committee members were expecting the hands-on staff, who claimed to have worked in the Secretariat for 16 years, to accept the grim news with stoic equanimity? So, do we take it that the APC influenced the job-cutting strategy for a party that has been gloating since it lost out in the last election?  Somehow, we need not blame Metuh if he chooses to ignore some of these questions. Sometimes, it is quite nerve-wracking when those who have worked with you in the same office for 16 years decide to take you up on your stewardship. That is exactly what the band of ‘disgruntled’ staff is doing. They not only dismiss Metuh’s plea of APC’s romance as “absolute bunkum, clumsy, and blundering blackmail,” they said their boss’ gloating was a ‘weak shot from a mortally crippled arsenal’ (Well, I am sure it is not my own Arsenal FC!). Instead of begging the question, they simply tabled their own set of audit queries, moral and financial, before Metuh.

    They want him to defend an alleged endorsement of a rival party’s candidate when Prof. Charles Soludo was gunning for the Anambra State governorship seat and Metuh was National Chairman, South-East. They spoke of his open endorsement of an APGA candidate in the 2013 Anambra governorship election. As entrenched staff with deep knowledge of the party’s operational manual, they seek an explanation into how ”a whopping sum of N450 million media fund earlier approved for the office of PDP Publicity Secretary by President Jonathan” was spent. They said it would not be out of place for Metuh to explain how he has been spending the N70m he allegedly collected in July this year, to prosecute a media war with the APC. Could it be true that the leadership of the party squandered the N12 billion being proceeds from the sale of nomination forms in the last general elections? Was another N1 billion that was realised from a compulsory levy of N10, 000 paid by delegates frittered by the NWC? What exactly was the role Metuh played in the widely-reported money-for-governorship-ticket bribery scandal involving a former House of Representatives member and the leadership of the party? What transpired in Kogi State at the party’s congresses in which some persons were said to have demanded another whopping N1 billion bribe to ensure the return of the incumbent governor as the state’s gubernatorial candidate in the forthcoming November elections?

    Questions, questions and more questions. Surely, it is not enough for Metuh to brush the allegations off as witch-hunt by persons who are envious of his intimidating profile as the critical voice in a party that is just learning the ropes of what it takes to be an opposition party. No one learns that from the books. It comes with the sort of experience that resulted in the birth of the APC after fighting from the trenches for 16 solid years. Anyway, now that Metuh is insisting on standing up to be counted, he must first debunk the derisive jibes of the secretariat staff.  No punch could be deadlier than the insinuation by the staff that Metuh’s trajectory in the PDP “in 1999 as a zonal youth leader, then National Ex-officio, Acting National Auditor, Zonal Vice Chairman and now publicity secretary” suggests that, “either his umbilical cord was buried at Wadata Plaza or that he can’t survive on any other thing except the PDP.” This is not simply a joke carried too far but also one that the self-styled anti-corruption tsar within the PDP should not stomach. The law of equity demands no less. Will Metuh burst the pipe this time or would he wait for the usual under-the-table ‘family affairs’ crisis resolution mechanism to shut out the aggrieved workers’ complaints and thereby bury the rotten truth? We wait for time to unravel the question.

  • PDP backs Buhari’s anti graft campaign

    PDP backs Buhari’s anti graft campaign

    The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has expressed support for President Muhammadu Buhari’s anti corruption campaign, but stated however that due process must be followed in the fight against corruption.

    In a statement issued on Tuesday by its National Publicity Secretary, Olisa Metuh, the party warned against using the campaign as a guise to victimise innocent citizens and curtail the freedom of Nigerians.

    The PDP said the clarification became necessary in order to remove any misconception that the party was against Buhari’s decision to probe some past government officials, who are mainly members of the PDP.

    The statement said, “The PDP supports the decision of the Federal Government to fight corruption in our country. However, we make bold to state that it should not be used as a guise to victimise innocent citizens.

    “Democracy has come to stay in Nigeria and no citizen, irrespective of political, religious or ethnic affiliation should be denied access to due process and the rule of law in the process.

    “In the same vein, we want to state categorically that the anti-corruption war, whilst targeted at the immediate past administration, should not by any means be blind to the impunity of the present leaders of the country either in terms of borrowing and spending without recourse to the statutory arms and organs of government and dictates of transparency and accountability, or in terms of nepotism in appointments in key institutions such as INEC and the DSS.

    “The anti-corruption effort must not be blind to the corrupting of the security system resulting in the intrusion by over-zealous operatives on issues bordering purely on politics, the hounding, arrest and detention of Resident Electoral Officers and members of election tribunals in Rivers, Akwa-Ibom and other PDP states.”

     

     

  • PDP accuses Buhari of seeking $2.1bn World Bank loan

    PDP accuses Buhari of seeking $2.1bn World Bank loan

    The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has accused President Muhammadu Buhari of seeking a $2.1 billion loan from the World Bank “for purposes unknown to Nigerians.”

    The party challenged Buhari to explain the terms and projects for which the alleged loan is being sought even as it called for the publication of details of public expenditure by the two-month old administration.

    At a press conference in Abuja on Sunday, the National Publicity Secretary of the PDP, Chief Olisa Metuh, further alleged that the Presidency was acting alone in the alleged loan arrangement.

    “What is the loan for? What are the terms and who are those working the papers? Who are the people to decide on how the money will be spent? Is it true that the $2.1 billion loan is meant to pay back huge contributions for the APC Presidential campaign expenses?

    “If truly this government is transparent, it should come out clear on this loan as well as publicise details of its expenditure in the last two months.

    “This is more so as we have information that the Presidency acting alone, has gone into discussions with the World Bank for a loan of $2.1 billion for purposes unknown to Nigerians,” Metuh stated.

    The party also expressed worry over what it described as “ineptitude, avoidable inactivity, lack of policy direction and absence of ministers” to coordinate government affairs.