Tag: STATE POLICE

  • State police: the timing is wrong –  Bagudu

    State police: the timing is wrong – Bagudu

    What is your mission in Benin City?

    We visited Oko Prison in order to review what has been happening in particular with regards to the prison facilities, security of the prisons, the training facilities that are there for inmates because the Senate is concerned about a number of issues. The Senate is concerned about the number of people who are awaiting trials; many people are in prison who ought not to be there, in fact yesterday, one of the most glaring and distressing report we had from the Comptroller of Prison was the case of four detainees who had been kept there since 1997 and they are said to be kept there on the order of the military administrator and we found it strange that there is this class of people who are detained in prison and that is an area of concern for the Senate. Secondly, we are concerned about the security situation of our prisons; we had a number of prison breaks and we wanted to ensure that staff and inmate who are complying with the rules and regulations are not harmed by people who have mischievous design; so we are interested in what we can do to strengthen the security in the prisons and additionally we want to see that training facilities are available for the inmates such that when they leave prisons, they will be better citizens, well trained and we are very happy at what we saw. We saw a number of tailors and the women confirmed to us that they have been taught skills, and we have people who have been trained as electricians, plumbers and we think that this should be the case and we want to have more of that. The authorities also complained to us about shortage of manpower even though it’s increasing since the recent jail breaks and we believe we will support any measure that will improve the manpower and security level in Nigerian Prisons.

    You have spoken about prison reforms, but if you look critically at the number of inmates there, you observed that there were perhaps more inmates in the 608 Medium capacity facilities, what is the Senate doing about decongesting the prisons.

    If you listen to what I said about the awaiting trial detainees, like you rightly said, the prison capacity ought to be 608 Beds but they have 1005 detainees as at yesterday when we visited and 932 of these are awaiting trial and so if the Judicial process is improved, yesterday one of the areas the Controller mentioned was that the Directors of Public Prosecution (DPP) in different states, it takes a long time before the investigations are finished and these people are taking to court, the trial takes place and concluded. So in most Urban Prisons, you find that the numbers of awaiting trial detainees are more than the numbers convicted. In fact Nigerian prisons population is about 49,000 and out of these, about 36,000 are awaiting trial detainees. The Senate in the last four months has considered prisons reform; we have considered many motions to deal with expediting the processes such that the trials period will be enhanced; we have spoken about the need for the police to finish their investigations quickly, the Directors of Public Prosecution and Ministry of Justices to review their files and advice one way or the other promptly; the Chief Justices of the state should undertake periodic visit to the prisons so that they can review some cases on the spot because there are people who ordinarily ought not to be in prison.

    Is the Senate Committee on Internal Affairs worried about the rising security problem in the country; Boko Harram, kidnappings, etc?

    The Senate has been in the forefront of increased funding to the security agencies because we recognised that our security agencies have been doing a great job but the challenges is multi-faceted and the most obvious one which the Senate has paid attention to is to increase funding and increase interactions with the security agencies so that from time to time, we are appreciative of those areas that need to be enhanced. Last year, we passed the Anti-terrorism Act, which we also believe will strengthen it and with other Acts that we believe will enhance the state of readiness so that the security services are not limited by legalism so that they move faster and arrest crime wherever it is happening, whether it is Kidnappings in the East, Boko Haram in the North or it is people threatening to break away or whatever.

    What is your take on the proposed introduction of N5, 000 note by the CBN?

    I am not speaking on behalf of the committee; I am speaking as a Senator and a Nigerian. I am one of those who are critical of the reasoning behind the introduction of the N5, 000 notes by the CBN. Because in about 8 years ago, the Central Bank introduced new currency denominations and we thought that was a well thought out policy, so to quickly come in a very short period and say we are replacing these with coins, we think it reflects hasty reasoning on behalf of the Central Bank. Because if they had thought it out, they would have convinced us then whether we needed new coins or new currency because these things are expensive to print, and therefore the nation is bearing a huge burden and cost. Second issue is that over a decade there has been little use of coins in Nigeria and I am sure that none of you here today has seen coins in the last five years or has any in your pocket. Therefore if we don’t have the culture and it has not been explained to us why the nation should revert to currency for a significant number of denominations knowing that in our places where currencies are used heavily, we don’t see coins being used. The N5, 000 naira note is equally strange because the Central Bank has come out with policies that all Nigerians are commending them for; that is cashless society and we know that more Nigerians are using debit cards and points of sale are increasing everywhere, so I can’t see the rationale for a higher denomination currency which might affect the value of the currency.

    How would you react to the agitation for the creation of state police?

    As a member of the Constitution Review Committee, my view is simply personal because I am not supposed to be partisan on these issues. There have been pros and cons on these arguments and people are saying even if it is desirable, it doesn’t look it is time because of the various security challenges we are facing. Even though some of the arguments are cogent, the time is wrong.

     

  • On regional integration and state police

    On regional integration and state police

    SIR: Regional Integration is not national disintegration. A nation is a system that has many parts in which any malfunction or dysfunction of a part will affect the other parts and the whole system. Nigeria is not functioning, and this is glaring, because the regions are not functioning well due to poor financing, maladministration at the centre and lack of visionary and transformation leaders. Regional integration will will turn around the fortune of the nation. Regional integration means the coming together of components regions in a state to benefit from economy of scale.
    The present administration has neglected security as a critical component of national transformation. The country is today in fear of attacks by terrorists who are bent on running the country down. Nigeria is endowed with vast natural resources like iron, lime, tin, gold, petroleum, water sources, arable land and highly informed human resources, yet we lack food security and other infrastructures that can make life meaningful because of dearth of visionary and transformation leaders.
    The central government lacks the capacity to influence the regional parts on the kind of development necessary to move the region and the country forward. While states like Edo, Lagos, Osun, Ekiti, Rivers, Oyo and Ogun are doing well, the central government refuses to show signs of development. Regional integration will ginger developments and healthy competition among the regions like we had in the first republic.
    The establishment of state police will improve the security of the country and help to prevent crime. The recent disapproval in some quarters, especially the elites, who should know better, is expected and welcomed. In 1822, Robert Peel, a wealthy member of the Britain’s Parliament, strongly believed that London’s population, crime rate and crime nature merited a full-time, professional police force. But many English, especially the politicians, objected to the idea. They feared possible restraint of the liberty and atrocities.
    They also feared a strong police organisation because the criminal law was already perceived harsh (by the early 19th century there were 223 crimes in England for which a person could receive capital punishment). Indeed, Peel’s efforts to gain support for full-time, paid  police officers failed for seven years. Peel finally succeeded in 1829. His bill to Parliament – entitled “An Act for Improving the Police In and Near the Metropolis”, which culminated in the establishment of the Metropolitan Police – was popularly known as the Metropolitan Police Act of 1829.
    The intention of policing a community is the prevention of crime. Nigeria has changed socially, economically and demographically from the time the Nigeria Police Force was created by the colonial masters. Nigeria is an amalgamation of different states with different cultures.  Creation of state police is inevitable if we want to maintain peace and other and care for national development.
    Different states have some different security challenges and different states have different priorities for crime prevention and control. A state that is ready to spend more for its security should be allowed to do so.
    • Ademola Adebayo
    Lagos
  • On state police, divided  we stand

    On state police, divided we stand

    Rising insecurity in the country has led to renewed calls for the establishment of state police. Many believe unitary police is antithetical to federalism. Others say state police will be abused, writes LEKE SALAUDEEN reports

     

    The Nigerian Governors’ Forum (NGF) is the umbrella body of governors in the country. On this platform, they have met to take stands on issues.

    But for the Governor Rotimi Amaechi-led group, one issue its members have been unable to take a stand on is the desirability or otherwise of state police. It is a matter that has divided the forum along geo-political lines.

    Governors in the South are for the establishment of state police. They believe it is the answer to the worsening security situation. But their colleagues from the North think otherwise. They allign with the Presidency, which believes the country is not ripe for regional police formations.

    The governors of the North and the Presidency have allies in former Inspectors-General of Police, who have said state police was an invitation to anarchy.

    The Arewa Consultative Forum (ACF), led by Gen. Jeremiah Useni, also believes state police would be misused by governors.

    Gen. Useni, on Tuesday, said: “State police will be tools for governors to deal with the opposition.”

    But for Senate President David Mark, there is wisdom in setting up state police. Mark advised those kicking against the establishment of state police to think twice about the issue.

    A former Head of State, Gen. Ibrahim Babangida, also supports the establishment of state police. He said its establishment would help curb violent and crimes.

    Former Lagos State Police Commissioner Mr Young Arebamen (rtd) believes the security challenges have grown beyond the competence of a centralised police. He advised the Federal Government not to politicise the issue of state police.

    “I can’t understand why some people are afraid of state police. If we have done something for 50 years and we still have problem of insecurity in the system, it is high time we began to think differently,” he said.

    On the perceived fear that the state police will be misused by state governors, the former police boss said it’s neither here nor there.

    He said: “If you eat eba that contained poison in the 60s, will you because of that stop taking eba? The answer is No. All you need to do is to avoid poison. Similarly, control measures should be spelt out in the constitution to avoid abuse of state police by state governors. We should learn lessons from history and proffer solutions for today and tomorrow.

    “I wouldn’t know the flaws in the system (state police) in early 60s but history must have treated those flaws. It is expected that we should learn from those flaws to project for tomorrow. If you are living in the past and doing some unnatural things you should not expect better result.”

     

    Funding the police

     

    On the insinuation that the state police will constitute a financial burden on state governments, the question to be asked, according to Arebamen, is: Who is funding the police? He said the state governments are mostly responsible for the material and financial needs of the federal police. Using Lagos State as a case study, Arebamen said the state government provides police with patrol vehicles, maintain and fuel the vehicles, bullet proof vests, arms and ammunition, telecommunication gadgets and also pay special allowance to those serving in the anti-crime squads.

    He said: “If Fashola had not provided these things, how would Lagos be secured? We should take politics out of security problems and face the reality of time.”

    Former Senate Minority Leader Senator Olorunnimbe Mamora spoke in favour of the establishment of state police. He said the demand for state police by some state governors is legitimate and desirable.

     

    Who is the Chief Security Officer?

     

    Mamora condemned the situation in which the state governors as chief security officers of their states have no powers over the state police commissioners on law enforcement in their states. The police commissioners won’t take directives from governors unless directed to do so by the Inspector General of Police.

    He said: “Look at what happened in Ogun State under Gbenga Daniel. He ordered the closure of House of Assembly for more than a year. If such governor had the opportunity of setting up state police, he would have turned the state into an empire.

    “The federal police too is subject to abuse by its principal-Federal Government. Remember what happened to Chris Ngige when he was governor of Anambra State. He was abducted by the police on the instruction of the Presidency. If that could happen to a sitting governor who relied on federal police for his personal security, then who is safe?

    “When you juxtaposed this experience with state police demand, the main issue is the capacity of the politicians to manipulate and abuse. Nevertheless, the advantages of the state police outweigh the bad side of it. To avoid misuse, we must put in place checks and balances that would make it difficult for politicians to manipulate for political gains.

    “We must also restructure the police so that it can respond promptly to circumstances in the states they are policing. State governors should have some level of powers to act promptly in time of emergencies without looking up to Abuja.”

    A Special Adviser to Osun State Governor Rauf Aregbesola, Adekunle Amos, said it is wrong for anyone to say that state governments cannot fund state police. He said states are responsible for 70 per cent of police’s needs.

    He said: “In Osun State, we provide them patrol vehicles, Armoured Personnel Carriers, bullet-proof vests, fuel and maintain police vehicles and even pay them special allowances on monthly basis.”

    He dismissed the argument that the state governors would manipulate the state police for political gains, adding that the functions of the police and the relationship with governors should be stated in the constitution.

    “Can we say because the Federal Government has been using the police to rig elections and intimidate the opposition, we should scrap it? No. The issue is that the governors as chief security officers of the states should have their own police since we are operating a federal system. If there is riot in Osun, the governor has to wait for directive from Abuja to quell it. The present arrangement is not normal.”

    Abuja-based lawyer Mr John Uyigue told the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) that the establishment of state police was long overdue.

    He allayed fears that the state governors would wield undue influence on state police and probably use them to intimidate or oppress their perceived opponents.

    “State police do not mean that they would operate without any supervision or that they would be law unto themselves.

    “In other developing democracies the world over, state police always complement the federal police, just like you have in India and the United States. There are federal laws and there are state laws,’’ he said.

     

    State police in another form

     

    Uyigwe observed that a resemblance of state police already existed across the country, as most of the states had created special security squads from the police to respond to specific crisis situations.

    “We have ‘Rapid Respond Squad’ in Lagos State, we have ‘Operation Zuma’ in Niger and we have ‘Operation Yakin (war)’in Kaduna State. Besides, we have ‘Operation Desert Storm’ in Yobe,’’ he added.

    He recommended that instead of opposing the creation of state police outright, the citizens should brainstorm on the modalities of setting up state police, as it was somewhat a necessity.

     

    States’ support for police

     

    As a result of the gross underfunding of the police by the Federal Government, some state governments have had no choice but to provide logistics and financial support for police serving in their states.

    Lagos State has, through its Security Trust Fund, provided equipment for the police and other security agencies. These include 20 Armoured Personnel Carriers (APCs), 400 patrol vehicles, 44 police authority motor cycles, five police patrol boats, 1,000 AK-47 assault rifles 1,500 bulletproof vests, over 500 walkie talkies. The state government is responsible for the maintenance of the equipment. Police serving in anti-crime and anti- robbery squads are paid special allowance every month by the state government.

    Osun State has procured five Armoured Personnel Carriers, 30 Patrol vehicles, crash helmet, motor bikes and bulletproof vests for the state police command. About 300 policemen involved in crime fighting in the state are paid monthly allowance by the state.

    Ogun State has set up anti-robbery and crime squad code named Quick Response Squad (QRS). To ensure effective policing of the state, government has donated 175 Hilux vehicles, five APCs, bulletproof vests and communication gadgets. Special allowances are paid to officers serving on QRS and OP-MESA. It was learnt that Governor Ibikunle Amosun has made funds available to repaint police barracks.

    Ekiti State has also provided Hillux Pick-Up vans and APCs and telecommunication equipment to the police to ensure effective patrol and prompt response in case of emergencies. The government is responsible for fuelling and maintenance of the police vehicles.

     

     

    Police in other lands

     

    Two types of police exist in United States. They are Federal and State Police. Federal police is tasked with enforcing Federal laws. There are over 70Federal Law Enforcement Agencies. Some of these agencies employ uniformed police officers who provide security and conduct foot patrols around federal property. Other agencies hire criminal investigators called special agents who conduct investigations. Any federal law enforcement officer can arrest someone who committed a federal crime.

    State police is unique to each state in the United States. It has state wide authority to conduct law enforcement activities and criminal investigations. They perform functions such as enforcing traffic laws on state highways and interstate expressways, overseeing the security of the state capitol complex and protecting the governor.

    The police forces in UK are classified into two: Territorial Police and Special Police Forces.

    Territorial Police Forces have jurisdiction in one of the distinct legal systems of United Kingdom either England and Wales, Scotland or Ireland. They have powers of a constable throughout their own legal system but limited powers in other two legal systems. Central Scotland Police, Cleveland Police, Durham police, Lancashire constabulary and Bedfordshire police fall under Territorial police.

    Special Police Forces are national police that have a specific, non regional jurisdiction.They are distinguished by having duties and responsibilities associated with particular legal or illegal activities rather than geographical areas which are used by a single territorial police. Examples are British Transport Police that overlook National Rail network and Ministry of Defence Police that cater for military establishments.

  • Centre challenges Jonathan on State Police

     THE Raymond Dokpesi Centre for Media Development at the weekend called for the creation of State Police to check insecurity in the land.
    It was during the centre’s yearly endurance trek christened: “Security is Everyone’s Business in Lagos.

    It was a prelude to lectures and award ceremonies that would take place later in the month. The centre urged President Goodluck Jonathan to heed their call.

    The Centre’s Director, Christopher Ebuetse said: “The Federal Government must carry the citizens along in security matters.

    The population of policemen in Nigeria is not up to one million in a country of over 160 million people. Individuals must be police and SSS themselves.

    Individuals must be ready to expose those who commit crime.

    If we compare the number of policemen we have in Nigeria with that of America and other developed countries of the world, we would see that we don’t have enough policemen.”