Tag: xenophobic attacks

  • Senate wades into permanent secretary’s suspension

    Senate wades into permanent secretary’s suspension

    The Senate on Tuesday waded into the suspension of the Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Amb. Danjuma Sheni.

    President Goodluck Jonathan ordered the suspension of Amb. Sheni over his alleged role in the recall of Nigeria envoy to South Africa.

    The Federal Government claimed that Sheni recalled the envoy without clearance from President Jonathan.

    The Envoy, Martin Cobham, was recalled over the controversy trailing the xenophobic attacks on Nigerians in South Africa.

    Deputy Senate Leader, Senator Abdul Ningi, brought the suspension to the attention of the Senate on Tuesday.

    Ningi, (Bauchi Central Senatorial District) pleaded passionately for the Senate to prevail on the Federal Government to recall the permanent Secretary.

    Ningi said, “Recall that this Senate through a motion which all of us endorsed asked the Presidency to recall the Nigerian High Commissioner in South Africa over the Xenophobic attacks in that country.

    “Recall too, that the Permanent Secretary Ministry of Foreign Affairs has been suspended and placed under an investigation for recalling the Ambassador without jurisdiction and without the clearance of the President who is the Commander-In-Chief of the Armed Forces.

    “Aware that the President and Commander-In-Chief is responsible for such recall and also aware that the Permanent Secretary has no powers whatsoever to recall an Ambassador without a clear directive by the government.

    “Knowing the anger and the mood of this country and believing that the Senate and indeed the National Assembly did the right thing in suggesting and urging the executive to recall the Ambassador.

     

    “I therefore want this Senate not to look the other way but to urge the President, Commander-In-Chief of the Nigerian Armed Forces to tamper justice with mercy.

    “It is indeed his responsibility, powers and jurisdiction and I think it is important at times like this that the Senate President should urge the President to tamper justice with mercy, so as to say the Permanent Secretary should not be dismissed.

    “He did the wrong thing at the wrong time and he should not have done it because of the mood so the President, a humble man should tamper justice with mercy.”

    The Senate did not debate of the issue but Deputy Senate President, Ike Ekweremadu, said the issue would be conveyed to President Jonathan.

    Ekweremadu added that “the recall of an Ambassador is a very sensitive matter.”

  • ‘Power shift, reason for xenophobic attacks

    ‘Power shift, reason for xenophobic attacks

    Prof. Opeoluwa Adekunle, a recipient of the Officer of the Order of the Niger (OON), comes with an intimidating resume that has seen him traverse the world practising his calling: Medicine. A retired Professor of Surgery at the College of Medicine, University of Ibadan and former Chief Medical Director of the Lagos University Teaching Hospital (LUTH), the octogenarian, who was also formerly a World Health Organisation (WHO) Adviser to the South African government, in this interview with Remi Adelowo, provides fresh insights into the recent xenophobic attacks in the former apartheid enclave and the way out.

    Would you tell us how your relationship with South Africa began?

    It all started shortly after 1976, during the uprising after Steve Biko was killed. And you know Steve Biko was a medical student and the medical community was outraged. And at that time, I was very active in the Nigeria Medical Association (NMA). In fact, I was the Secretary of the Western State branch of NMA. We, together with the other state branches decided to protest against the murder of Steve Biko. We had a military government at that time that supported our action, and as you know at that time, Africa was the centerpiece of the country’s foreign policy. So, we started to make contact with the black doctors in South Africa and we formed an association, though there was an existing association of World Medical Association at the time of which South Africa was a member. And of course, NMA was also a member with other African countries including Ghana, Kenya and Egypt. And therefore, we decided to form an African group known as the African Region of the World Medical Association and I was elected that day as Head of the region. I started thus started attending meetings in different parts of the world to represent Africa. Initially we had a lot of resistance, especially from Western countries, because South Africa was also a member of the WMA; so they did not welcome me because it was white-dominated. The blacks were excluded from this association, so they formed their own association and we made contacts with the association. That helped us to relate with South Africa. Then in 1980, things had reached a head and we asked that South Africa Medical Association be expelled from the World Medical Association and we mobilised many other countries of the world to support our move. In fact, the Scandinavian countries agreed with us; you know they are very liberal. The UK was ambivalent; Australia was on their side, while the US was a bit dilly-dallying, but then they couldn’t ignore the black population in South Africa. Of course we were not racist, but you’ve got to use what you have to achieve your objectives. So, we then mobilised enough support and of course, Maitama Sule was the Chairman of anti-Apartheid Committee of the United Nations at that time and he invited me over to New York to address the committee on the evils of apartheid in South Africa sometime in 1979. And that enabled the UN to take a stand on Apartheid. Then in 1981, I was invited to the World Medical Assembly in Lisbon, Portugal, where I raised a motion that South Africa should be expelled from the World Medical Association. And to our surprise, most countries present voted in favour and they were expelled. And of course, having been expelled from the world stage, it became difficult for them to operate. And then we formed what we called the Confederation of African Medical Association and Society and they also elected me as their Secretary General. And for 10 years, we fought this battle. I was fortunate that I had the support of the Nigerian government from the Murtala, Obasanjo, Shagari, Buhari and even Babangida regimes. It was quite tough. Most times when I travelled to South Africa to have meetings with the black doctors, they would tell me at the airport, “Look, you are on your own here. If anything happens to you, it’s your problem.” Later, the majority rule came and Mandela was released. But before then, I went to Robben Island on a few occasions to see Mandela. So, that was the beginning of my association with South Africa. In the meantime, because I had gone to Harvard University to study Health Management Policy, the World Health Organisation (WHO) became interested in my development sort of. So, they sought to bring me over to both Geneva and Brazzaville, which was the regional headquarters of WHO in Africa. So, they used to bring me over to consult me on health issues concerning Africa. After 1994 when majority rule was established in South Africa, the country was still unsure of itself and started looking for experts all over the world especially in Africa. WHO approached me and asked me to go there and advise them on the training of specialist doctors, especially among the black population, because hitherto these blacks were not allowed to undergo any specialist training. They had to leave the country for the US, Canada and other countries to get their training and even at that, they had problems returning to the country. That was why they invited me over and negotiation began in 1996 and eventually in October 1997, WHO wrote to me that South Africa wanted me as their Adviser on the rapid production of specialists especially among the black population. Luckily, I’ve been a Professor of Surgery, and formerly Chief Medical Director in LUTH; I mean I was quite experienced in training. I was Chairman, Faculty of Surgery of the West African College of Surgeons; I was an Examiner in England. And that is being humble, because sometimes when I look back, I asked myself ‘you mean you’ve done all these things?’ I went there in 1997 to the University of Transky now known as Walter Sisulu University, which was just 30 kilometers to Mandela’s hometown. I used to be one of those who went to look after him during weekends, if there was an emergency. That was how I met senior people both in government and the academia. And when my WHO contract ended, they didn’t want me to come back, but I said I’ve had enough, because I have trained enough people to take over.

    Most Nigerians believe that South Africa has not reciprocated Nigeria’s immense support particularly during the apartheid regime. What is your take on this?

    I think they did initially. They welcomed our first generation Nigerian doctors, professors and what have you. Many even rose to become Vice Chancellors in South Africa even after Mandela became the President. So, I believe they reciprocated. But what happened down the line was partly our fault and partly theirs. Our fault was that there was no restriction on the caliber of Nigerians going to that country. South Africa is not an ECOWAS country where there was free movement of people. And of course when a situation like that arises, both the desired and the undesired would get visas. And I imagine that because of the economic situation here, many Nigerians wanted to travel to South Africa, which is a country of immense opportunities. Over there, the system is well organised. The system that was left behind by the apartheid people was being maintained. Now, if things are so easy, then don’t exploit it for God’s sake. I have a feeling that the wrong types of Nigerians have flooded South African and therefore started to transfer our own inadequacies to that country. But on their part, you can identify two main groups of South Africans. There are those who lived abroad and were part of the apartheid struggle and recognised the role of African countries and the role of Cuba. Cuba is highly respected in South Africa today, because the country regulates which Cuban goes to South Africa. If you are a Cuban wishing to travel to South Africa, the government has to give you permission. They don’t allow just anybody to go there. You must have a mission for travelling there. There is also a generation of South Africans who are now the political elites. This group never experienced the contributions of African countries to the eradication of apartheid. They suffered cruel indignity of apartheid including suppression of education opportunities. And because they have not gone through the mill, they have problems relating with other people, including Nigerians. So, you’ve got to understand where they are coming from and be understanding. The political elite is more or less dominated by this generation of people and therefore, the people behind them, that is those people demonstrating against foreigners have nobody to look up to in terms of behaviour. Some people continue to say the body language of their leaders support xenophobia; of course you can see that, because they just don’t know the contributions we made to stop apartheid.

    Do you think the South African government should have done more to prevent the xenophobic attacks, because this is not the first time this is happening?

    Certainly! But like I said, power has shifted. People who should have done more to stop this are no longer in control. Again, South Africa is beginning to have economic problems. When you introduce capitalism in a country of many poor people, the vision of capitalism says you are always on your own. It’s about how much you can do to determine how much you have in your pocket at any point in time. So, you’ve got to have a take-off point to even trade or start a business and many of these people don’t just have anything. The government initially tried to solve this problem by providing all sorts of social benefits like unemployment allowance and so on. There was even a time when if you have HIV, you get an allowance. But now the chicken has come home to roost. I was in South Africa last week; I go there every three or four months and I could see that (President) Zuma was at his wits’ end, not only on how to satisfy the international community, but also his own people. And of course, the whites themselves are partly aloof. A white man even told me that when the blacks finish with themselves, they would come after us. They want a solution to this problem, but they don’t have a way out. Nigeria can help them to do it on a government to government level. We would benefit a lot by being with them.

    The controversial recall of Nigeria’s High Commissioner and his deputy has generated divergent comments from several quarters. Do you think the decision was hasty or justified?

    It was hasty, uncalled for and unwarranted. The situation has not got to that stage; no Nigerian was killed….

    But do we have to wait until that happens….

    Of course we don’t have to wait, but as at that time, the protest was being controlled by the government. Though they were not alert enough to respond immediately, but then as soon as they took action, the protest was curtailed. So, when things were getting better was not the right time to recall our ambassadors. That is the point I’m making. What should have been done was to ask people from Nigeria to go there and study the situation and advise appropriately. It was a wrong diplomatic move to recall them openly even though they have denied it. Luckily for me, I’ve been involved in a lot of inter-government issues that I know that when a country takes an action, I know the purpose for taking such action.

  • Xenophobia: Permanent secretary suspended over envoy’s invitation

    The Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Amb. Danjuma Sheni, has been suspended for his alleged role in the controversy that trailed the invitation of Nigeria’s envoys from South Africa to Nigeria.

    Media reports at the weekend had claimed that Nigeria has recalled its envoys from South Africa over the xenophobic attacks in the country.

    The South African government has already reacted to the report, describing it as unnecessary.

    The Special Adviser to the President on Media and Publicity, Dr. Reuben Abati, had on Monday maintained that there was no truth in the report.

    Claiming that there was a mix up and misinformation on the matter, he said that Nigeria’s Charge D’Affairs to South Africa was invited for consultation.

    A reliable source, who spoke with State House correspondents on condition of anonymity, said that a query has already been issued to Sheni by the Head of Service of the Federation, Danladi Kifasi, on the order of President Goodluck Jonathan.

    The source said that Sheni’s offence was that he did not get clearance from the President before inviting the country’s Charge D’Affairs in South Africa for consultation.

    The President, he said, was miffed that the ministry embarrassed him again, few weeks after a diplomatic row between Nigeria and Morocco over whether he indeed spoke with King Mohammed VI as claimed by the ministry.

    He said Sheni would have been dismissed if not for the civil service rule.

    He said, “The permanent secretary in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has been suspended and queried for embarrassing the President by not clearing from him before inviting the Charge D’Affairs.”

    “The President on Monday directed the Head of Service to query him and he has 24hours to respond to the query.”

     

    “You will recall that that was the second embarrassment, this one coming shortly after the Morocco saga.”

    “The permanent secretary was to be dismissed immediately but for the civil service rule. Even at that, there will still be further consequence.”

    “His offence is that he invited the Charge D’Affairs without clearing from the President. The truth is that in this age and time, the ministry can make clarification from the Charge D’Affairs without necessarily inviting him. There is what is called diplomatic dispatches. They can also speak with the envoy on the telephone.

    “As at now, a new permanent secretary has been redeployed to the ministry to replace him.”

  • Still on the xenophobic attacks

    SIR: South Africans have been up in arms against foreigners, mostly black immigrants since 2008. If care is not taken, such hostility could become the defining feature of the relationship between Africa’s most industrialised nation and the rest of the sub-Saharan Africa. The series of violent attacks have resulted in the death of about 10 people who were either stabbed, lynched, wounded or set ablaze right in their places of abode while many others, who were lucky to survive have been displaced and rendered homeless. The world also watched in horror, as gangs of weapon-wielding youth descended on hapless people by killing, maiming and destroying their property. Shops and restaurants were reportedly looted with the law enforcement agents accused of looking the other way.

    We recall that such hostility played out some years back when some South Africa-bound Nigerians were turned back at the Oliver Tambo International Airport, Johannesburg for allegedly attempting to enter the country without the possession of valid yellow fever vaccination cards. At that time, the measure attracted a retaliatory action, as Nigeria turned back about 130 South Africans after their plane had touched down at the Murtala Muhammed Airport in Lagos. Not only that, the humiliation Nigerians face when applying for South African visas is unbearable, particularly when nationals of similar countries that supported apartheid are allowed to enter into South Africa without entry visas.

    The South Africans are said to be irked by the business competition offered by foreigners and Africans who seem to be more successful than them. Due to South Africa’s culture of entitlement, the entrepreneurial spirit and hardwork so evident in immigrant communities has become a source of resentment for them. The culture of entitlement that tends to propel South African natives to become lazy and complacent, believing that many of their unemployed township dwellers cannot do much on their own to improve their situation without state assistance. Not only that, immigrants from Somalia and Ethiopia are also feared and hated because they do much better than their South African counterparts. These immigrants – out of sheer business ingenuity – co-operate with each other by forming business networks to buy goods together in bulk and undercut competition by excelling as entrepreneurs.

    King Zwelithini’s provocative utterances undoubtedly fuelled the latest impasse and as such, his reprimand and the call by many, including the Nigerian government for his prosecution at the International Criminal Court are not out of place. There can be no valid excuse for or defence of the horrors playing out. It is shameful for a big country like South Africa to behave like the former apartheid state where rights violations were rampant. The patience of Nigerians who rather opted for protest – rather than resorting into violence in the face of provocation – is highly commendable.

    The Nigerian government should rise up to its obligation of protecting its people in South Africa and elsewhere. Necessary legal actions should therefore be initiated to ensure that South Africa pays adequate compensations for the losses incurred by the immigrants. If the South African government cannot guarantee the safety of Nigerians in their country, the Federal Government should put the necessary logistics in place to evacuate its citizens.

    Finally, it is time we looked inward and reflect deeply on how to discourage Nigerians from fleeing their country for greener pasture. The perennial problems of unemployment, insecurity, harsh business climate, epileptic power supply and bureaucratic corruption should be seriously addressed. The incoming administration of General Muhammadu Buhari should ensure that Nigeria regains its pride of place among comity of nations and to become a true home for all its citizens.

     

    • Adewale Kupoluyi

    Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta.

  • Xenophobia: Presidency denies recalling Nigeria’s Envoy to South Africa

    The Presidency on Monday denies recalling Nigeria’s Charge De Affairs to South Africa over the xenophobic attacks in the country.

    The Special Adviser on Media and Publicity to the President, Dr. Reuben Abati, in a statement said that there was a mix up and misinformation on the matter.

    He said the Charge De Affairs was only invited by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for routine consultation.

    He said: “It is not true that Nigeria has recalled its envoy in South Africa on account of recent xenophobic attacks in that country.”

    “There is a mix up and misinformation on the matter. The truth is that Nigeria has not recalled his envoy from South Africa.”

    “What has been done is to invite the Charge De Affairs in that country for routine consultation by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.”

    “Recall of envoy is a serious and sensitive matter and that has not happened.”

  • Xenophobic attacks ’ll never happen in  S/Africa again, says Zuma

    Xenophobic attacks ’ll never happen in S/Africa again, says Zuma

    South Africa has assured other African countries that xenophobic attacks will never happen again in the country.

    The country also said that adequate security had been put in place to ensure safety of lives and properties.

    South African High Commissioner to Nigeria, Mr. Lulu Louise Mnguni, made these known in Abuja yesterday during a joint briefing with Ambassador Danjuma Nanpon Sheni,   Permanent Secretary, Nigerian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

    He said: “Our president, Jacob Zuma, has briefed the affected countries  on the current attacks and gave them the assurance that never again we would have the situation occurring. And of course, he fully indicated what our government has put in place to guarantee their safety. Well, of course, we know here and there there may be challenges, but the loopholes have been closed. And of course, resources will be put in place.

    “Our police are very much up to the task. We have deployed the army to complement the efforts of the police in creating a peaceful environment.  We want to see South Africans and other Africans as one people. That is what we are doing.”

    He added: “We are also saying no matter where these people are, they cannot engage our brother Africans in violence.

    “We are meeting this afternoon to brief you on the development in South Africa, the development has been a source of concern and frustration to Nigerians and opther Africans.

    “Nigeria fought in our support when we were fighting the apartheid regime which had wanted to make us to remain in perpetual bondage. Of course, it was aborted by the most powerful countries, like Nigeria.

    “So we have no reason to allow such things to happen, especially with this glorious history we share with our Nigerian friends.

    “Our government has sent  all members of the parliament to their constituencies to talk peace to those communities.  We have also tried to provide succour to those people that were  affected to make sure they do not find themselves in a terrible situation. We  are  providing water and other things that can make them comfortable.”

    On his part, Amb. Sheni said “Nigeria is fully engaging the South African authorities  as part of the efforts to ensure that the situation is brought under control.”

  • Xenophobia: AFBA threatens to drag South Africa to UN

    The African Bar Association has threatened to file criminal complaints against the South African government at the United Nations Security Council if the country fails to prosecute perpetrators of xenophobic attacks.

    It said adequate compensation must be paid to affected persons as well as murder charges being preferred against the culprits.

    This was contained in a press statement issued to journalists in Benin City and signed by President of AFBA, Hannibal Uwaifo.

    Hannibal stated that the body would constitute a team of lawyers to file its findings to the UN Security Council.

    He said it was sad that the South African Government was reluctant to deal decisively with the criminal acts, which according to him emboldened the miscreants to further desecrate the African hospitality and brotherhood.

     

  • MTN provides succour for  xenophobic  attacks victims

    MTN provides succour for xenophobic attacks victims

    MTN Nigeria yesterday said it has provided financial support to the transit camps where victims of xenophobic attacks in South Africa are being resettled.

    It said the attacks were needless.

    Its Corporate Services Executive, Akinwale Goodluck, who spoke with reporters at the company’s head office, Falomo, Ikoyi, Lagos, said the carrier condemned the attacks, saying they lacked justifications in the modern age.

    He said though the attacks were limited to certain parts of the country, they were nonetheless symptomatic of poverty, illiteracy, stressing that MTN was concerned not because of its business but largely because of the fatalities that had occasioned the lawlessness.

    Goodluck, who spoke against the backdrop of inciting postings on social media platform urging reprisal attacks, said there was no basis for such a call, arguing that MTN Nigeria is a Nigerian business with about 98 per cent of its workforce being Nigerians beginning from its Chief Executive Officer, Michael Ipkoki.

    According to him, only about 12 expatriate workers draw their pay cheques from MTN Nigeria while over 6,000 Nigerians are employed as permanent workers while about one million others support the value chain, eking out their living form the telco.

    Goodluck said the carrier, which supports businesses such as the financial institutions, has invested $15 billion over the past one decade to build infrastructure  and expended another N10 billion on its corporate social responsibility (CSR) through the MTN Foundation that has supported providing health services to complement government’s efforts.

    In terms of support to the economy, the telco which has over 60 million subscribers said it is the second largest tax payer to the Federal Government only next to the multinational oil companies.