Category: Lead

  • Drama as LP factions clash in court

    Drama as LP factions clash in court

    There was drama at the Presidential Election Petition Court (PEPC) yesterday during proceedings on the petition by the Labour Party (LP) and Peter Obi, who are challenging the declaration of President-elect Bola Tinubu as the winner of the February 25 election.

    Before the court commenced sitting, members of the two factions of the LP, led by the Acting National Chairman, Lamidi Apapa and the suspended National Chairman, Julius Abure, engaged in open confrontation owing to disagreements on where to sit.

    It took the prompt intervention of some court officials to restore peace, with Apapa saying afterwards that he was almost killed.

    When their case was called, Peter Obi announced himself as the first petitioner, while Mrs. Dudu Manuga, who said she was the party’s National Women Leader, announced herself as the LP representative. Apapa also stood, saying he is the party’s acting National Chairman.

    Justice Haruna Tsammani, who led the court’s five-member panel, said the court would not recognise anyone as representing the party, noting that it seemed that the party is not at peace.

    Shortly after the court adjourned, loyalists of the opposing faction prevented Apapa from speaking with the press.

    They created a rowdy atmosphere, which informed why security personnel on the ground had to force them out of the court premises.

    Outside the court’s gate, the elderly Apapa, whose team appeared to have been outnumbered by the opposing faction, was physically assaulted, with his cap removed and slammed on his head by members of the opposing factions.

    While addressing journalists later, Apapa, who was rescued by security officials, blamed Obi’s alleged insincerity and disregard for the rule of law for the crisis in the party.

    Apapa said the trouble in the party would have been averted if Obi had withdrawn recognition from Abure, who was suspended based on the order of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory.

    Read Also: No end in sight to Labour Party crisis

    Apapa, however, asked Obi to wade into the dispute objectively to amicably resolve the lingering crisis, adding that Obi must be unbiased to resolve the dispute.

    He described as disgraceful the attack on him by members of the opposing faction, noting that it showed Obi’s leadership style because he witnessed the incident and preferred to stay aloof.

    Apapa said that the leadership crisis would have been put behind them had Obi respected the order of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) restraining Abure and three others from parading themselves as national officers of the party over their alleged indictment for forgery and perjury.

    He said that it was wrong of Obi to recognise Abure despite the court order and as a presidential candidate seeking justice from the court of law.

    Apapa denied receiving N500 million or any money or being influenced by anybody or any group to work against the party.

    He also said it was wrong of Peter Obi to have claimed not to know him, adding that he worked closely with and even travelled on the same flights with Obi throughout his Presidential electioneering campaign.

    He, therefore, appealed to Obi to be open-minded, neutral and objective to be able to stop the crisis.

    Obidients almost killed me, says Apapa

     Apapa alleged the crowd that mobbed him was hired to kill him.

    He told reporters after he was released from protective custody by security operatives that he was in court to assert himself as the Acting National Chairman.

    He said he sensed trouble after the Director-General of Obi Campaign Organisation, Akin Osuntokun, refused to vacate a chair reserved for the chairman of the party.

    “I went to him and inquired to know in what capacity he was sitting on the seat. I told him that since I am in court today, I am the right person to sit on that chair.”

    On how he was mobbed, Apapa said: “They pounced on me, removed my cap and I am very sure that if not that you people (journalists) were there, I would have been dead by now.

    “They threatened that if I appear in court that something would happen.”

    Osuntokun: Apapa is obsessed with recognition

     Osuntokun accused Apapa of suffering from an obsession for recognition.

    Speaking on Channels Television’s Politics Today, he said Apapa and his group were mercenaries doing the bidding of some disgruntled politicians.  

    Osuntokun said Apapa and his team will fizzle out after the court case.

    He said: “Lamidi Apapa is a liar. He is obsessed with recognition.

    “I don’t blame them. They have hit a jackpot. These are people who don’t have clear means of livelihood and who are now tools in the hands of those who desire to scuttle democracy in this country.

    “You can extrapolate from their conduct that they are being sponsored. If it is true that they are supporting the party and Peter Obi, why are they dragging the same man through several breaches?”

    “It is likely that the APC was sponsoring the Apapa group because it has a vested interest in a weak LP.

    “Obi was cheated and that is so conspicuous. He was nakedly rigged out of the election. That is why he is the target. Up till now, Obi is a newsmaker and he is the most compelling.”

    He said that Apapa and his group were bent on scuttling the chances of the party and therefore, there is no room for reconciliation with him.

    “There is an ulterior motive behind what they are doing. They have been going everywhere to scuttle the LP’s chances.

    “As it stands now, there is no room for reconciliation with these people.

    “You can only reconcile with somebody who wants the progress and wellbeing of the party. These people do not mean well for the party at all.

    “The whole drama will fizzle out after the court case and nobody can subvert the petition of Peter Obi in court.

    “It is unimaginable that a man (Apapa) of his age wants to create a nuisance everywhere he goes. They are mercenaries,” he maintained.

    The Deputy National Chairman of the party in the North, Mike Auta, denied the allegation that APC was behind the crisis, adding that it was baseless.

  • Doctors’ strike grounds teaching hospitals

    Doctors’ strike grounds teaching hospitals

    • Families plan evacuation of patients •Govt negotiating with NARD leaders

    Ailing patients were left in pains yesterday as the five-day warning strike by residents doctors grounded activities in teaching hospitals nationwide.

    The worst affected facilities  were the Nationa Hospital and Federal Medical Centre, Abuja; University of Lagos Teaching Hospital (LUTH), Lagos State Teaching Hospital (LASUTH), the University of Benin Teaching Hospital (UBTH),   Irrua Specialist Teaching Hospital,     Federal Medical Centre, Asaba;;  Nnamdi Azikiwe University Teaching Hospital (NAUTH),  the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, and   National Orthopedic Hospital, Enugu; Delta State University Teaching Hospital, Oghara and the Federal Medical Centre (FMC), Yenagoa, Bayelsa State,

    Others were the  University of Calabar Teaching Hospital, Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital (ABUTH), Zaria; the University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital (UITH);  Modibbo Adama University Teaching Hospital (MAUTH); Yola; Jos University Teaching Hospital (JUTH),  Federal Teaching Hospital, Katsina; Benue State University Teaching Hospital,   Makurdi,   Federal Medical Centre, Birninkudu;  Federal University Dutse Teaching Hospital and  Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University Teaching Hospital, Bauchi.

    The Federal Government, however, said it was negotiating with the leadership of the doctors’ umbrella body,  the National Association of Residents Doctors (NARD), to end the strike which enters its second day today.

    NARD had NARD    warned on Monday that the strike would commence since the Federal Government had remained silent on the demand it made on   April 29, 2023.   

    Chief among the demands are a 200 per cent review of their Consolidated Medical Salary Structure (CONMESS), payment of the 2023 Medical Residency Training Fund (MRTF), and issuance of a circular by the House of Representatives jettisoning a bill seeking to stop doctors from leaving the country without a mandatory five-year service period.

    Others are the issuance of a circular by the Federal Ministry of Health for the replacement of doctors and nurses that have left the system, the payment of salary arrears and improvement in hazard allowance by states. 

    President of the association, Emeka Orji, had shortly before the strike commenced, called on President-elect  Bola   Tinubu to bring his experience to bear by crisis resolution. 

    He stated that Tinubu’s intervention would send a message of hope to its members, and other Nigerians, that his government would not be a strike-mongering administration.

    He said: “We issued a 14-day ultimatum expecting that the government will address many of these issues or at least call us for negotiation. But the  Federal Ministry of Health did not bat an eyelid or make any attempt to resolve these issues. 

    “We know the capacity and the experience of President-elect Senator Bola Ahmed Tinubu to resolve issues like this. He is going to be sworn-in in about two weeks. As far as we are concerned, this is the time for him to step in because we have been going around to engage this government, but their body language is that they are packing up.”

    At nearly all the hospitals, activities were at a  low ebb as only specialist doctors/ consultants and nurses were seen attending to worried patients.

    In some of the hospitals visited by The Nation correspondents, families were making plans to evacuate their hospitalised children and kin. In a few others, overburdened nurses and security guards turned back new patients and those on appointment. 

    ABUTH management, however, said it would by Monday deploy the services of Locum doctors to attend to patients. Locum doctors  are medical professionals whose standing for regular doctors for a period of time

    In many of the hospitals,  many patients experienced delays in accessing healthcare services, as only consultants and nurses attended to them.  Also, only those in an emergency were treated while patients on appointment were turned back by nurses and security guards.

      The Nation also gathered that many of the hospitals were preparing to discharge those recuperating due to a lack of manpower. 

     Some parents and relations of patients on admission were heard saying that they had no option but to seek alternative treatment places.

    At LUTH,   NARD President, Kemi Abiloye, who confirmed  that members complied fully with the strike directive,  said: “Only consultants attended to some patients.”

    Also at   LASUTH where doctors worked half day,  only a few patients were attended to, leaving many distressed.   

    Read Also: FG warns resident doctors against planned strike

     A NARD executive  member, who asked not to be named, said: “We are being asked to come to Alausa   over the matter.” 

    In Katsina, the Director of Corporate Affairs of the Federal Teaching Hospital, Bishir Idris said the management had to put in place, strategies to fill in the created by the strike.

    “We have consultants, medical officers, physiotherapists, nurses, midwives and other health personnel on the ground, carrying out their (resident doctors) duties,” Idris added.

    But NARD members in Osun State University Teaching Hospital (UNIOSUNTH), did not participate in the strike yesterday, following the intervention of Governor Ademola Adeleke 

    A source at a meeting between Adeleke  and NARD leaders yesterday, said: “We are going to hold our congress tomorrow(today) to know whether we are going to embark on  the ststrike did not also hold in federal hospitals in Ondo and Yobe states

     Fed. Govt negotiating with NARD leaders

     Health Minister Osagie Ehanire says the ministry is in close talks with stakeholders in the health sector to address the demands of the resident doctors.

    Ehanire, who spoke at a news conference to commemorate this year’s World Hypertension Day in Abuja, said the issues at stake would soon be resolved.

     “With respect to the doctors’ strike, I believe that at this time, the leadership of the Ministry will as usual be engaging with the Ministry of Labour, relevant stakeholders and the resident doctors to resolve what the issues are. We hope that these issues will be resolved quickly,” the minister,  said.

    He was represented at the event by the Director of Public Health at the Ministry,   Morenike Alex-Okoh.

    Ehanire explained that “the situation with the doctors’ strike is of concern to the government,” and the negotiations had been ongoing and therefore would continue.

    Minister of Labour and Employment Chris Ngige yesterday accused the resident doctors of being disrespectful to the government.

    He expressed surprise that the doctors could embark on the strike when negotiations were ongoing.

    Ngige, who was featured on Arise Morning Show, said: “The resident doctors are part of NMA. They are young doctors in training.

    “So if NMA is negotiating on their behalf as the parent body, what these young people (resident doctors) are doing is disrespecting the NMA. They are crying wolf when there is none.”

    He warned that  Ehanire might instruct teaching hospitals to employ and pay ad-hoc staff with the money meant for the striking doctors.

    “It is incongruous for students doctors to embark on strike when consultants training them were already negotiating with the Federal Government,” Ngige said.

  • JUST IN: Man City cruise past Real Madrid to reach Champions League final

    JUST IN: Man City cruise past Real Madrid to reach Champions League final

    Manchester City delivered a relentless performance laced with outstanding quality to overpower holders Real Madrid and reach the Champions League final against Inter Milan in Istanbul.

    City have lost two previous semi-finals to Real but they made no mistake here at a joyous Etihad Stadium to now stand one step away from claiming the trophy that has always stayed tantalisingly out of reach for Pep Guardiola’s team.

    And their display in a magical first half, in particular, will live long in the memory as the masters of this tournament were left bewildered by City’s brilliance.

    It maintained a seemingly unstoppable march towards a treble of Champions League, Premier League – which can be won with victory at home to Chelsea on Sunday – and the FA Cup, where they play Manchester United in the final at Wembley.

    Read Also: Man City close to league title with 3-0 victory at Everton

    Real keeper Thibaut Courtois performed heroics to save two Erling Haaland headers early in the first half but he was powerless to stop Bernardo Silva’s close-range finish after 23 minutes, the Portugal midfielder scoring a looping header for the second eight minutes before half-time.

    City faced the occasional threats from Real after the break, Ederson saving well from David Alaba and Karim Benzema, but they were no match and when Manuel Akanji’s header deflected in off Eder Militao 14 minutes from time the celebrations started.

    Substitute Julian Alvarez then wrapped up the dominant win with a late strike after latching onto a brilliant Phil Foden pass.

  • Sultan: Tinubu will take over on May 29 ‘whether they like it or not’

    Sultan: Tinubu will take over on May 29 ‘whether they like it or not’

    The Sultan of Sokoto, Alhaji Muhammadu Sa’ad Abubakar, has assured the President-Elect Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu will take over on May 29 ‘’whether they like or not.’’
    He tasked Nigerians to pray for the incoming administration to succeed in steering the affairs of the country.

    He spoke during a roundtable engagement with traditional and religious rulers on Wednesday in Abuja.

    The event organised by the World Bank was to fashion a way out to increase human capital development in the country especially, the girl child education.

    The Sultan, who was urging attendees not to abandon the advocacy of ending child marriage and other impediments to the growth of the girl when they get to their community said: “There must be change because in the next few days or weeks there will be a new government, what can we contribute to that government to stabilize?

    Read Also: ​US Secretary of State Blinken to Tinubu: we’ll strengthen partnership with Nigeria

    “Whether anybody likes it, it must take place, a new government is coming on 29 May, so what can we do besides prayers because we believe in Almighty, we believe in God that gives and takes.

    “After that so what? What do we do to help the government stabilise and move the country forward?”

    He added that it is an opportunity for religious and traditional leaders to work together for the betterment of the country.

    “Let us continue to work as one big family with different mothers and fathers or whatever it is, but our main father and mother is Nigeria. As religious leaders, there must be equity and justice in whatever is being done and that is what I think we need to talk about the most,” Sultan said.

  • LP crisis: Obidients almost killed me in court, says Apapa

    LP crisis: Obidients almost killed me in court, says Apapa

    The factional National Chairman of the Labour Party (LP) Lamidi Apapa has alleged the crowd that mobbed him on Wednesday at the venue of the Presidential Election Petition Court (PEPC) was hired to kill him.

    Apapa told reporters after he was released from protective custody by security operatives he was in court to assert himself as the Acting National Chairman of the party.

    He said he sensed trouble after the Director-General of Obi campaign organisations, Akin Osuntokun, refused to vacate a chair reserved for chairman of the party.

    “I went to him and inquired to know on what capacity he was sitting on the seat. I told him that since I am in court today, I am the right person to sit on that chair.”

    On how he was mobbed, Apapa, said: “They pounced on me, removed my cap and I am very sure that if not that you people (journalists) were there, I would have been dead by now.”

    Read Also: Labour Party crisis deepens as court affirms Apapa chair

    He alleged Obi was aware he would be attacked, stating that members of the presidential campaign group of the party in a meeting on Tuesday to broker peace among the warring factions, vowed to deal with him should he attend the court session.

    “They threatened that if I appear in court that something would happen,” he stressed.

    He also denied he collected N500million to scuttle Obi’s petition against the President-elect, Asiwaju Bola Tinubu.

    While branding Obi “a liar” for saying that he does not know him, Apapa said he actively participated in all the campaigns before the presidential election and flew back to Abuja with him in the same aircraft on one of the occasions.

    “I want to tell the whole world that he is a liar. I have been in the party for over 21 years while he is not even up to one year in the party.

    “I have never taken any kobo from anybody and I have challenged anyone that has any evidence to bring it forward,” he added.

    He said he has contributed more to the party than Obi, denying he was in court to withdraw the petition against Tinubu.

    “Apart from money, what else does he (Obi) have that I don’t have?” Apapa queried.

    He accused Obi of refusing to respect the court order that suspended the Julius Abure-led executives of the party.

  • JUST IN: Labour Party factions clash after tribunal proceedings

    JUST IN: Labour Party factions clash after tribunal proceedings

    There was serious drama within the leadership of the Labour Party after the court proceeding on Wednesday after a faction of the party strongly resisted journalists from interviewing the Lamidi Apapa-led group.

    The group waited to block the interview with Apapa and booed him while chanting “ole”, “thief” and other uncomplimentary words.

    Read Also: Labour Party crisis deepens as court affirms Apapa chair

    The police quickly intervened as Apapa was swiftly taken outside the court premises even as the chanting continued.

    The Nation reports that drama ensued at the Presidential Election Petitions Tribunal on Wednesday when officials of the two factions of Labour Party clashed.

    Before the court began proceeding, the factions of the Labour Party could be sighted at the PEP Court, engaging in a war of words over which faction is the authentic one.

    Details Shortly…

  • BREAKING: Court adjourns Obi’s petition against Tinubu

    BREAKING: Court adjourns Obi’s petition against Tinubu

    The Presidential Election Petition Court has adjourned the pre-hearing of the petition against the President-elect Asiwaji Bola Ahmed Tinubu, by the Labour Party and its presidential candidate, Peter Obi to Friday, May 19.

    Read Also: JUST IN: Drama as LP factions clash at election tribunal

    The court headed by Justice Haruna Tsammani fixed the date, following the failure of parties in the petition to agree on documents among other reasons.

    The Nation reports that drama ensued at the Presidential Election Petitions Tribunal on Wednesday when officials of the two factions of Labour Party clashed.

    Details shortly…

  • ​US Secretary of State Blinken to Tinubu: we’ll strengthen partnership with Nigeria

    ​US Secretary of State Blinken to Tinubu: we’ll strengthen partnership with Nigeria

    By Olukorede Yishau, United States Bureau Chief 

    The United State​​s Secretary of State, Antony J Blinken, has told President-elect Bola Ahmed Tinubu that the Joe Biden administration is committed to strengthening ties with Nigeria.

    Blinken, according to a statement by Matthew Miller called Tinubu on Tuesday.

    “Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken spoke this morning with Nigerian President-elect Bola Ahmed Tinubu to emphasize his continued commitment to further strengthening the U.S.-Nigeria relationship with the incoming administration.

    “The Secretary noted that the U.S.-Nigeria partnership is built on shared interests and strong people-to-people ties and that those links should continue to strengthen under President-elect Tinubu’s tenure.

    “Secretary Blinken and President-elect Tinubu discussed the importance of inclusive leadership that represents all Nigerians, continued comprehensive security cooperation, and reforms to support economic growth,” the statement reads.

  • Labour Party and its leadership crisis

    Labour Party and its leadership crisis

    There is no end in sight yet to the leadership crisis rocking the Labour Party.

    Signs of crisis in the party emerged during the build – up to the general election.

    The party has been struggling to maintain a united house after the general election this year.

    How the crisis started

    A former National Publicity Secretary of the party, Abayomi Arabambi had accused the suspended National Chairman of the party, Julius Abure of forgery and other crimes.

    Arabambi alleged that the leadership of the party forged the signature of the Appeal Court judge to insert names of candidates for National Assembly election in Lagos state and presented the list to the Independent National Electoral Commission.

    The national publicity secretary had made the allegations when he featured on the Morning show aired on Arise Television on December 3, 2022.

    He said he had sent a petition to the Inspector General of Police and also wrote the Chief Justice of Nigeria about the matter.

    Speaking on the alleged forgery, he had said: “Very soon, police will swoop on the Labour Party headquarters. I have written to the Nigeria Police over it, I have complained to the Chief Justice of Nigeria and I have filed a suit in the Supreme Court over the matter.

    “Our party leadership was involved in a forgery of a Court of Appeal judgement. I am not going to be a part of that criminal infraction.

    “I have written to the police. I don’t want Nigerians to think that it is APC or PDP that sent police to our office. No. It is what our people did.

    “Just because they wanted some candidates to run for election, they manipulated and presented false information to the court of appeal and INEC and I told them no because criminal infraction doesn’t have years. And at any given time the police can knock at your door. Because I was involved in that matter at the Federal High Court I have to set the record straight.

    “I don’t want anybody to say I am an accessory to the case. I have my facts and figures and I will publish them in the dailies.

    “We didn’t have this kind of thing in the Labour Party until Doyin Okupe came in with his bandwagon of people because they are the ones involved in this thing. I have forwarded their names to IGP, I have reported to the CJN and I have asked my lawyers to write a letter to INEC not to publish the names because they were falsified.

    “Our members are giving them safe landing, security or cover up, I am giving them the assurance today that all of us will soon go to Louis Edet House to explain what happened.

    “When they came to appeal they changed some names in the judgment of the Federal High Court and that is a criminal offense. You don’t change a name. The parties from a Federal High Court are the ones that will go to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.”

    Acting on the forgery allegations, a Federal Capital Territory (FCT) High Court, in April this year, restrained Abure from parading himself as the National Chairman of the Labour Party.

    The court also restrained three officers of the party along with Abure.

    The Presiding Judge, Justice Hamza Muazu, also ordered that the originating processes of the court be served on the restrained officials – Abure, the National Secretary, Umar Farouk Ibrahim; the National Treasurer, Oluchi Opara; and the National Organising Secretary, Clement Ojukwu.

    The three other officials restrained were also replaced by Alh. Saleh Lawal- Acting National Secretary, Rawland Daramola- Acting Treasurer, and Prince Reuben Favour – Acting Organising Secretary.

    Apapa takes over leadership of party

    Following the court ruling, National Vice-Chairman (South), Lamidi Apapa took over affairs of the party following the court order barring Abure from parading himself as chairman of the party.

    According to Apapa, Abure and the three others must vacate the order of the Federal High Court restraining them before further action can be taken on the leadership of the party.

    Seven members of the National Working Committee of the Party announced the replacement of Abure as chairman of the party.

    The three other officials restrained were also replaced by Alh. Saleh Lawal- Acting National Secretary, Rawland Daramola- Acting Treasurer, and Prince Reuben Favour – Acting Organising Secretary.

    During the meeting, Lamidi also reversed the suspension of Eragbe Anslem as the National Youth Leader and Arabambi as the National Publicity Secretary.

    The emergence NWC meeting also reinstated Executive Council members from Ogun State, Rivers State, and Gombe State.

    It would be recalled that apart from Abure, the court also restrained three other officials of the party over alleged forgery.

    The Presiding Judge held that the ex parte application for interim injunction restraining the four officials by aggrieved members of the LP before the court had merit and granted the same.

    Speaking further, Apapa said the NWC also reviewed the suspension of party members and exco that had earlier been suspended by the party leadership.

    He said: “The NWC equally reviewed that recently there are some cases of suspensions that were badly handled. And this National Working Committee meeting as reviewed them, and the suspension all over are hereby reviewed and the officers are reinstated.

    “With effect from now, the so called officers whose the court had barred should not parade themselves as officers of the party until cases against them are treated or handled by the party.”

    Abure’s NWC holds emergency NEC in Asaba

    However, defying the order of the court, the Abure led National Working Committee proceeded to hold a National Executive Council meeting in Asaba, the Delta state capital.

    During the NEC meeting, the party announced the suspension of Apapa and five others for anti-party activities.

    Those suspended during the Asaba NEC meeting included: Alh. Saleh Lawal- Deputy National Secretary; Rawland Daramola- National FinancialSecretary; Prince Reuben Favour – National Vice – Chairman, South – South; Secretary; Samuel Akingbade, National Legal Adviser and Mohammed Akali, National Vice – Chairman, North- East.

    The NEC also reaffirmed and upheld the decision of the Akure convention which expelled the National Publicity Secretary of the party, Abayomi.

    The NEC meeting, which the Apapa faction described as illegal, was attended by the Presidential candidate of the party in the February 25, 2023 election, Peter Obi and some lawmakers elected on the platform of the party.

    It was gathered that the meeting was called by Abure and the former National Secretary of the party, Umar Farouk, who has been restrained by the court from parading themselves as executive members of the party.

    The NWC has the power to summon a NEC meeting. Abure and Farouk are members of the NWC.

    The Abure – led faction, through the Acting National Publicity Secretary, Obiora Ifoh, claimed the NEC meeting had been scheduled before the court ruling barring Abure and three other members of the party from parading themselves as officials of the party.

    Latest court ruling

    On May 12, a High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) in Maitama, dismissed the objection raised by the suspended chairmen of the Labour Party (LP), Abure and three other national officials of the party against a suit seeking their sack over alleged forgery and corrupt practices.

    Justice Hamza Muazu, in a ruling on Friday held that his court had jurisdiction to hear and determine suit filed by some aggrieved members of the party.

    The ruling was on the preliminary objection filed by Abure, and the suspended National Secretary, Alhaji Farouk Ibrahim. Justice Muazu faulted the argument by Abure and Ibrahim that the subject matter of the suit was within the realm of the internal affairs of the party on which no court could adjudicate. The judge held that it was no longer the law that the court could not adjudicate on issues relating to the party’s internal affairs.

    The judge noted that had the party been at peace with itself, there would not have been any need for the court to interfere in its affairs. “When there is no crack on the wall, there will not be need for an outsider to come mend it,” he said. Justice Muazu held that plaintiffs’ case was justiciable contrary to the argument by lawyer to Abure and Ibrahim, Alex Ejesieme (SAN), adding that the plaintiffs were right to have instituted the case via an originating summons.

    Following the April 5 ex-parte injunction made by Justice Muazu, stopping Abure, the National Secretary of the party, Alhaji Umar Farouk and two other national officials, Ejesieme had on April 20 argued that the court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the matter.

    The senior advocate had submitted that the matter before the court bordered on the internal affairs of the Labour Party, adding that criminal allegations made by the plaintiffs in the case, could not be ventilated in an origination summon.

    He added that the eight plaintiffs that brought the case before the court were not members of the National Executive Council of the party and as such lacked the locus standi to institute the case. “Our contention is very clear that those criminal allegations cannot be ventilated in an origination summon. The issue of locus standi is there. When you refer to LP’s constitution, the claimants are not members of NEC or the party. They have a duty to present their membership cards to the court which they didn’t,” the counsel argued.

    Abure heads for appeal court

    Following the ruling of the court, Abure expressed optimism of getting justice in the Court of Appeal.

    “I am ready to go for an appeal. We will be submitting our notice of appeal to the court and we will move all the matter from that court and take it to the court of Appeal. I believe that I will get justice in the Court of Appeal. I believe that the Labour Party will get justice in the court of Appeal,” Abure said.

    Going by the ruling by the court, the Apapa-led faction has retained the leadership of the party pending when the Court of Appeal will rule on the matter.

    Is this the end of Abure as national chairman of the LP? Time will tell.

  • Poll petition: INEC, President-elect oppose live telecast

    Poll petition: INEC, President-elect oppose live telecast

    The President-elect, Bola Tinubu, and the Vice President-elect, Kashim Shettima, have urged the Presidential Election Petition Court (PEPC) to dismiss the application by Atiku Abubakar and the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) for a live broadcast of proceedings.

    Tinubu and Shettma described the application as frivolous and a bid to waste the court’s time.

    Besides, they said the court is not a soapbox, stadium or theatre where the public should be entertained. 

    “With much respect to the petitioners, the motion is an abuse of the processes of this honourable court,” the respondents stated.

    In a joint response filed on Monday by their team of lawyers, led by Chief Wole Olanipekun (SAN), they wondered why a petitioner desirous of a prompt hearing would file an application intended solely to distract the court and waste its precious time.

    They argued that the relief sought by the applicants are not such that the court could grant.

    They stated, in the counter affidavit, that the application relates to policy formulation of the court, which is outside the PEPC’s jurisdiction as constituted. 

    “The application also touches on the powers and jurisdiction invested in the President of the Court of Appeal by the Constitution, over which this honourable court as presently constituted cannot entertain. 

    “The application touches on the administrative functions, which are exclusively reserved for the President of the Court of Appeal. 

    “The application is aimed at dissipating the precious judicial time of this honourable court. 

    “The said application does not have any bearing with the petition filed by the petitioners before this honourable court. 

    “It is in the interest of justice for this honourable court to dismiss the said application filed by the petitioners,” they said.

    In an attached written address, the respondents faulted the applicants’ reference to the fact that virtual proceedings were allowed during the COVID-19 pandemic.

    They argued that Atiku and his party failed to draw the court’s attention to the fact that practice directions were made by the respective courts for the exercise.

    They also noted that it was only the heads of courts, rather than individual judges or Justices, who drafted the practice directions. 

    “Another angle to this very curious application is the invitation it extends to the court to make an order that it cannot supervise. 

    “The position of the law remains, and we do submit, that the court, like nature, does not make an order in vain, or an order which is incapable of enforcement,” the respondents stated.

    Tinubu and Shettma added: “At the very best, this application is academic, very otiose, very unnecessary, very time-wasting, most unusual and most unexpected, particularly, from a set of petitioners, who should be praying for the expeditious trial of their petition. 

    “Petitioners have brought their application under Section 36(3) of the Constitution which provides that the proceedings of a court/tribunal shall be held in public. 

    “The word ‘public’ as applied under Section 36(3) of the Constitution has been defined in a plethora of judicial authorities to mean a place where members of the public have unhindered access, and the court itself, sitting behind opened doors, not in camera. 

    “Even in situations where a class action is presented, the particular people constituting the class being represented by the plaintiffs or petitioners are always defined in the originating process. 

    “Here, in this application, the public at whose behest this application has been presented is not defined, not known, not discernable. 

    “Beyond all these, it is our submission that the court of law must and should always remain what it is, what it should be and what it is expected to be: a serene, disciplined, hallowed, tranquil, honourable and decorous institution and place. 

    “It is not a rostrum or a soapbox. It is not also a stadium or theatre. It is not an arena for ‘public’ entertainment. 

    “With much respect to the petitioners, the motion is an abuse of the processes of this honourable court.” 

    Also, in its counter affidavit filed last on Monday, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) raised similar arguments and prayed the court to reject the application by Atiku and his party.