Category: Northern Reports

  • Kogi stakeholders warn against Cashew export ban 

    Kogi stakeholders warn against Cashew export ban 

    Stakeholders in the cashew value chain have warned that Nigeria may face massive unemployment, collapsed farms and a crippled agro-export economy if the Federal Government heeds recent calls by the Cashew Processors and Packers Association of Nigeria, to ban the export of raw cashew nuts.

    CAPPAN, in a recent advert signed by Air Vice Marshal Tunde Awoyoola (rtd.), Managing Director of Nutslink Limited, had claimed that foreign buyers were dominating the farm gates and starving local processors of raw materials, thereby justifying a proposed ban.

    Similarly, Alhaji Makama Ademu warned that the country lacked the processing capacity to handle more than five percent of its annual production.

    He said, “If the government bans raw cashew export, 95 per cent of what we produce will be left to rot. We don’t have the processing capacity to handle even a fraction of Nigeria’s output. This will destroy the farmers, destroy the value chain and eliminate three major segments — sub-buyers, licensed buying agents and merchants.”

    Ademu added that such a ban would immediately trigger massive unemployment, especially in rural communities.

    “This value chain employs farmers, women, rural youth and thousands of workers who dry, bag and prepare h cashew. Once exports stop, these jobs disappear overnight. A lot of businesses will be destroyed and many farms will fold up because it will no longer be economical to farm cashew.”

    Vice Chairman of the Kogi Cashew Dealers and Stakeholders Association, Dr. Idrisu Yakubu, said the implications of the proposed ban are “enormous and dangerous.”

    He stated, “All the cashew processing factories in Nigeria combined cannot process what Kogi State produces in just one day of cashew season. If they cannot handle one day’s output in a whole year, what happens to the remaining 364 days? Should farmers burn their harvest?”

    Read Also: 10 die, 21 injured in Lagos, Kogi, Enugu crashes

    Yakubu dismissed the claim that processors were ready to absorb local production.

    He also warned that the policy could aggravate insecurity.

    “In the current security situation, discouraging farmers from going to their farms can trigger new unrest. A ban on export will have serious social and economic consequences.”

    Board of Trustees Chairman of the Kogi Cashew Dealers Stakeholders Association, Alhaji. Mohammed Demo, said the processors’ demand threatens livelihoods.

    He said, “Because of their lateness or inability to establish viable factories, they now want to suffocate the entire industry. Farmers will suffer. We cannot allow people who don’t have functioning processing plants to dictate policies that will destroy a major economic hub.”

    Mohammed insisted stakeholders from major producing states would resist the move.

    “We will disassociate ourselves publicly. If anything goes contrary, it could lead to tension, and with the security challenges in the country, this is not the time to provoke farmers.”

    The stakeholders questioned why CAPPAN singled out cashew when Nigeria also exports cocoa, sesame seed, ginger, soybean and other agro-products.

    Ademu asked, “Have they banned the export of cocoa? Have they banned sesame or coffee? Why cashew? It shows their agenda is not in the national interest.”

    Yakubu added, “Before exporters came into the market, cashew had no value. Farmers were burning it in their farms. Export revived the industry. Killing that market now will reverse all progress made.”

    “We support industrialisation. “But not by destroying farmers and traders. You don’t build factories by killing the market,” Yakubu said.

    Kogi Cashew Farmers Association, spokesperson, Nuhu Adaji, said the organisation is committed to transparency and accountability, noting that every decision taken is aimed at improving public trust. 

    He explained that ongoing reforms are designed to strengthen internal processes, enhance service delivery, and ensure that stakeholders receive timely and accurate information. 

    Adaji urged the public to remain calm and assured them that further updates would be provided as developments unfold.

    The group urged the Federal Government to ignore the recommendation and instead invest in power, infrastructure and incentives that can help processors build real capacity over time.

  • Jiwa Emirate to confer traditional title on Lois Andrew Ihwo December 7

    Jiwa Emirate to confer traditional title on Lois Andrew Ihwo December 7

    • …to celebrates her leadership and service in FCT

    The Jiwa Emirate Council will on Sunday, December 7, 2025, confer the traditional title of Tauraruwan Matan Kasar Jiwa (Shining Star Woman of Jiwa Land) on Lois Andrew Ihwo.

    The ceremony, scheduled for 11:00 a.m. at Government Senior Secondary School, Jiwa, FCT, is expected to be attended by traditional rulers, government officials, community leaders and other invited guests. 

    The title will be conferred under the authority of the Emir of Jiwa, Alh. Dr. Idris Musa.

    According to the Emirate Council, the honour recognises Ihwo’s contributions to business, philanthropy and community development. 

    Ihwo, founder and CEO of Deeutensils and Deescent Global, has built a presence in the kitchenware and lifestyle sectors, with operations in Abuja and customers across parts of Africa.

    Her philanthropic initiatives through the Dee Ihwo Foundation include women’s empowerment programmes, support for widows, educational scholarships for underprivileged children and health-related community projects in Plateau State and the North-Central region.

    Ihwo has also received several recognitions in 2025, including an Honorary Doctorate Degree from American Management University, California, and the “Most Inspiring Entrepreneur of the Year” award at the 15th Peace Achievers International Conference and Awards. 

    She was recently honoured at the Business Day Newspaper Awards 2025.

    The Emirate Council said the forthcoming ceremony aims to highlight the role of traditional institutions in acknowledging contributions to community development and social welfare.

  • Don to Fed Govt: develop investment – friendly policies to drive industrialisation

    Don to Fed Govt: develop investment – friendly policies to drive industrialisation

    Former Dean, Faculty of Administration, Bingham University, Karu Nasarawa State, Prof Nuhu Gado has urged the Federal Government to develop investment – friendly policies to drive industrialisation.

    The don also said foreign investors should be allowed to bring funds and also to take them out.

    Prof Gado said this while delivering the 10th inaugural lecture of Bingham University, Karu, Nasarawa State on Tuesday in Abuja with the theme: “Strategic Management of Nigeria’s Industrial Sector and Economic Development: From Dumping, slumping to Japa Syndrome.”

    Gado, a former Director Academic Planning and current representative of Senate to the 6th Governing Council of Bingham University, noted that infrastructure like roads, land, power and others needed by manufacturers to drive industrialisation should be prioritised.

    He stated: “Investment-friendly policies should be developed and be consistent. Foreign investors should be allowed to bring funds and also to take them out. Also, investment in exports should be encouraged by providing funds and assisting in upgrading quality to meet international standards.

    “Infrastructures like land, roads, power, water and communication should be provided for industries. Infrastructures needed by manufacturers should be prioritised

  • Matawalle remains asset to Tinubu’s security governance agenda, says group

    Matawalle remains asset to Tinubu’s security governance agenda, says group

    …warns against politicising minister’s old video

    A citizens-led advocacy group, the Coalition for Truth and National Interest (CTNI), has urged Nigerians to ignore what it described as “selective outrage” over an old video of Bello Matawalle, Minister of State for Defence.

    In a statement issued on Wednesday in Lagos, the group, led by its national president, Comrade Olatokunbo Olawoyin, defended the minister and warned against attempts to politicise a years-old clip for narrow partisan gains.

    The civic group said the renewed attacks against Matawalle were “opportunistic and stripped of the broader security realities” faced by the country at the time the video was recorded. 

    The statement emphasised that public debate should focus on verifiable contributions rather than emotionally charged fragments taken out of context.

    “Recycling old footage for political point-scoring undermines reasoned discourse and distracts from pressing national security issues. It does not reflect the minister’s longstanding commitment to stabilising Nigeria or his current role in the nation’s defence architecture,” Olawoyin said.

    The coalition highlighted Matawalle’s recent efforts in national security, citing his instrumental role in the successful rescue of schoolgirls abducted in Kebbi State. 

    The operation, it said, required coordination, tact, and a deep understanding of Nigeria’s security environment, underscoring the minister’s capacity to act decisively in critical situations.

    “Look at the recent rescue of abducted students of the Government Girls Secondary School in Maga, Kebbi State; that successful operation was not by accident,” Olawoyin noted.

    “It was the result of experience, careful planning, and a thorough understanding of the complexity of insecurity in the North-West. Those who focus solely on past footage are ignoring his current contributions to national stability,” 

    The coalition further urged Nigerians to differentiate between understanding the causes of insecurity and condoning criminality, cautioning that conflating the two could lead to unfair vilification of public officials actively engaged in security management.

    “At a time when the country faces multiple security pressures, the government needs competent hands—people who understand both the operational demands and the human dimensions of conflict. Minister Matawalle is one such asset,” Comrade Olawoyin said. 

    The group also appealed to the media and the public to prioritise the national interest over sensationalism, warning against allowing social media narratives to distort perceptions of public servants’ performance.

    “Nigeria is at a critical juncture. We cannot afford to be distracted by manufactured controversies. This is not the time to weaponise old videos or pursue narratives that undermine those committed to stabilising the nation. What the country needs is unity, sober analysis, and a commitment to facts—not outrage theatre,” the statement added.

    The coalition concluded by urging citizens to focus on current evidence of service and leadership, reiterating that Matawalle remains a valuable member of President Bola Tinubu’s cabinet and a key contributor to ongoing efforts to strengthen the nation’s defence and internal security.

  • FACT-CHECK: Claim that Dauda Lawal ‘pardoned, freed convicted bandits’ false

    FACT-CHECK: Claim that Dauda Lawal ‘pardoned, freed convicted bandits’ false

    On November 28, 2025, a group called Human Rights Watchdog in Africa (HRWA) issued a press statement, signed by its Executive Director, Samson Adamu, calling on President Bola Tinubu to declare a state of emergency in Zamfara after accusing Governor Dauda Lawal of “pardoning and releasing convicted bandits.”

    — CLAIM —

    The HRWA’s statement, which was used by some sections of the media, claimed that Governor Dauda Lawal authorised the release of 69 convicted bandits in September through what it described as a “secret state pardon,” reportedly processed through the Zamfara State Zakat and Endowment Board, under a programme tagged “Religious Amnesty.”

    The group further urged President Tinubu to invoke emergency powers under the Nigerian Constitution to suspend Lawal, overhaul the state’s security apparatus, and launch a federal probe into the alleged pardons.

    “Strip away his authority before more blood is spilt. HRWA stands with the voiceless victims of Zamfara; we will not rest until accountability prevails,” Adamu said.

    — VERIFICATION —

    In order to verify this claim, this newspaper tried to obtain the original statement issued and signed by the Human Rights Watchdog in Africa, which was the source of the story published by some online platforms. However, this newspaper couldn’t get the original statement issued by the group.

    Our correspondents tried to reach out to Samson Adamu, the so-called executive director of the group, who signed the statement according to the published stories. Checks with journalists in Zamfara, Kaduna and Abuja, where the purported statement was allegedly released, couldn’t yield any tangible result, as no journalist could confirm receiving any statement by the said group or from Samson Adamu.

    Our reporters deployed open search tools to see whether the group has a registration with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) or any office, website, contact, or physical address. The results from the online searches were all negative.

    This newspaper’s fact-check team has tried checking the identity of Samson Adamu through online tools. Like the group he purportedly represents, there was no name matching his online before November 28, 2025. He has no digital footprint or social media identity, nor any virtual or physical address or phone number.

    The Human Rights Watchdog in Africa, it was found, first appeared in late November 2025, through news coverage in Nigeria for urging President Tinubu to declare a state of emergency in Zamfara State. Before this time, there was no mention of the organisation online or anywhere.

    On the validity of the group’s claim, a team of fact-checkers deployed by this newspaper uncovered that the Zamfara State Zakkat and Endowment Board had facilitated the settlement of DEBTS and subsequent release of 909 inmates between 2024 and 2025.

    This was revealed by the Executive Secretary of the board, Alhaji Habib Muhammad Balarabe, during the 2025 End-of-Year Activities held at the Board’s premises, Bypass, Gusau, recently.

    Mr Balarabe said the board secured the freedom of 473 inmates in 2024 and this year released ₦67.2 million for the settlement of DEBTS owed by 436 inmates, bringing the total beneficiaries to 909 within two years.

    The board also empowers 200 women small-scale business owners, who received ₦50,000 each, to strengthen their enterprises. Another set of 100 women were presented with starter packs, completing a three-week poultry production training to enable them to start their own businesses.

    Checks with the officials of the Zakkat board have further revealed that their scope of humanitarian activities, which includes paying up the debts of persons convicted of civil cases, and have proven to be of worthy character while in prison, DIDN’T include bandits, who are convicted of criminal activities.

    “We don’t have such a mandate. And no convicted bandit was pardoned or released. It is laughable for someone to say the Governor of Zamfara, who, time without number, declared publicly that he won’t negotiate with bandits, would turn back to release them from prison after their conviction. This is a huge joke,” the official, who was not authorised to speak to the press, said on Tuesday.

    Further checks have shown that the Zakkat board paid the debts of the convicted debtors after a thorough process in collaboration with the officials of the Nigeria Correctional Service (NCS).

    This newspaper has further confirmed that in the last two years, Governor Dauda Lawal has been consistent in insisting that his administration won’t negotiate with bandits.   

    On October 29, 2025, while serving as a guest lecturer to participants of the Executive Intelligence Management Course (EIMC) at the National Institute for Security Studies in Abuja, Governor Lawal warned against the ongoing federal government peace deal with bandits.

    The governor further stressed that Zamfara State strongly frowns on the ongoing, unregulated peace efforts being undertaken in parts of the North-West with violent non-state actors.

    “Dialogue can aid conflict management, but true peace requires disarmament, and reconciliation without control equates to surrender. Allowing armed groups to keep their weapons while setting peace terms simply delays violence and compromises state sovereignty.”

    “At this crucial time, peace efforts should be strong, coordinated, state-led, and backed by legitimate authority. The State must show it has both the capacity and the will to enforce peace. Sustainable peace arises when armed actors acknowledge the rule of law and the Government’s commitment to protect its citizens.”

    Lastly, our reporters reached out to Governor Lawal’s spokesperson, Suleman Bala Idris, to establish whether his principal had actually pardoned and released convicted bandits. Mr Idris said there was no time Governor Lawal pardoned or released any bandit.

    He said, “The story is a juvenile work of fiction. It is a figment of the imagination of some failed politicians in Abuja whose political career is in jeopardy because of their links with bandits. As that haunts them, they would continue to catch straws, including manufacturing puerile lies, to tarnish the Rescue Mission revolution being undertaken by Governor Dauda Lawal in Zamfara state. It is a desperate attempt to distract Governor Lawal, but that has also failed, as it did before.”

    — VERDICT —

    After a thorough investigation by our fact-check directorate, it has been established beyond doubt that the Human Rights Watchdog in Africa (HRWA) and its executive director are fictitious. The claim that Governor Dauda Lawal of Zamfara State had pardoned and released convicted bandits is found to be FALSE.

  • Gusau Airport to deepen investment opportunities — Official 

    Gusau Airport to deepen investment opportunities — Official 

    Zamfara state airport will open more investment opportunities in the state, Zamfara State Commissioner for Works and Infrastructure, Lawal Barau Bungudu, has said.

    The commissioner revealed this on Tuesday while speaking with journalists after inspecting the ongoing construction of the Zamfara International Airport.

    According to him, by the end of January 2026, the terminal buildings and other components of the airport would be completed, God willing.

    “I highly appreciate the quality of the work. Everything is going according to plan and, God willing, from what I have seen, both the terminal buildings and other sites will be completed by the end of January,” he said.

    Mr Bungudu added that the present administration is committed to delivering an international-standard airport that citizens will be proud of.

    “Our government under the leadership of Governor Dauda Lawal is constructing this airport to open more investment opportunities in Zamfara,” he stated.

    Also speaking during the inspection, Engineer Nicholas said the terminal buildings for both domestic and international operations were almost completed.

    He said the construction of the main fire station had reached 50 percent completion, while the control tower had reached 60 percent.

    “We are working to meet the contractual agreement. By February 2026, we are confident of achieving 90 percent completion.

    “The 3.4-km runway with shoulders has reached 80 percent. Things are moving well, and we hope to meet the deadlines,” he said.

  • Lawal showcases Zamfara’s agribusiness potentials in Morocco

    Lawal showcases Zamfara’s agribusiness potentials in Morocco

    Governor Dauda Lawal reiterated to global investors that Zamfara State holds a comparative advantage in agriculture. 

    The governor participated in the Africa Investment Forum (AIF) Market Days 2025, held from November 26 to 28, 2025, in Rabat, Morocco.

    A statement by the governor’s spokesperson, Sulaiman Bala Idris, disclosed that the Africa Investment Forum Market Days effectively united African investors, facilitated deal negotiations, and supported investment realization across the continent.

    The statement added that the summit, led by the African Development Bank in partnership with six founding institutions, positions the Africa Investment Forum as a strategic and multidisciplinary platform designed to streamline and accelerate the financing and structuring of projects for Africa.

    During the summit, Governor Lawal participated in high-level dialogues on enhancing private investment through enabling environments, a panel on scaling investments through public-private partnerships, and a session on mobilizing domestic capital to drive Africa’s growth. 

    “Other activities undertaken by Governor Dauda Lawal on the sidelines of the Africa Investment Forum Market Days in Rabat, Morocco, include signing a strategic Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between Zamfara State Government and the Ministry of Finance Incorporated (MOFI) to promote large-scale agricultural transformation in the state.

    “The agreement positions Zamfara State as a key beneficiary of the INTEGRANIUM Agricultural Transformation Initiative, a national programme focused on mechanized farming, agro-processing, post-harvest systems, and global market access.

    “Under the MoU, Zamfara State will provide land, infrastructure, security, and an enabling policy environment, while MoFI will lead financing mobilization, investor engagement, and project development support. 

    “The partnership is expected to deliver jobs, boost food security, strengthen value chains, and accelerate inclusive economic growth in Zamfara and the wider North-West region.”

    In his remarks at a roundtable with investors, Governor Lawal described Zamfara State as an agricultural hub, noting that the state is experiencing rapid progress across all sectors under his administration.

    He said, “I am glad that the African Development Bank is here with other leading global potential investors. Agriculture is the way forward for Africa, Nigeria, and Zamfara State in particular, due to the many opportunities available. 

    “In Zamfara State, our comparative advantage is Agriculture. We grow all crops in the state; we are not limited to soybeans. We have the land, and it is fertile. 

    “I am inviting all global investors to come to Zamfara. We are in the final stages of finishing our international cargo airport, building a five-star hotel, and undertaking extensive urban renewal projects in Zamfara State.” 

  • University of Ilorin honours Governor Lawal for outstanding leadership 

    University of Ilorin honours Governor Lawal for outstanding leadership 

    The University of Ilorin has conferred an Award of Excellence on the Governor of Zamfara State, Dr. Dauda Lawal, in recognition of his outstanding leadership, unwavering commitment to public service, and notable contributions to national development.

    The honour was bestowed during the University’s 50th Anniversary Celebration held on Thursday in Ilorin, the Kwara State capital.

    In its citation, the University described Governor Lawal as “a model of principled leadership whose actions reflect the values of excellence, integrity, and service to humanity.” 

    It further stated that the Governor’s reforms in governance, education, economic revitalization, and security align with the institution’s vision of nurturing leaders committed to knowledge, character, and nation-building.

    Parts of the citation reads, “This distinguished accolade is a fitting testament to Your Excellency’s exemplary leadership, dedication to service, and significant contributions to the socio-economic and educational advancement of Nigeria. 

    “The University—renowned for its academic rigour and integrity—has recognized in you the very qualities it strives to instill in its students.”

    Receiving the award on behalf of the Governor, the Secretary to the Zamfara State Government, Malam Abubakar Mohammad Nakwada, expressed profound appreciation to the University of Ilorin for the prestigious honour. 

    He noted that the recognition would further inspire Governor Lawal to intensify his efforts in rebuilding institutions, empowering communities, and advancing inclusive development across Zamfara State and Nigeria.

    The SSG also congratulated the University on its 50th Anniversary, commending its legacy of academic excellence and its impact on generations of Nigerians. 

    He urged the institution to continue championing the values of excellence, integrity, and national service that have earned it a distinguished place in the country’s educational landscape. 

  • First Lady distributes welfare packages for Christmas 

    First Lady distributes welfare packages for Christmas 

    Wife of the Zamfara State Governor, Huriyya Dauda Lawal, has distributed comprehensive welfare packages to women drawn from various groups, organisations, unions and security formations to cushion economic hardship during the 2025 Christmas

    At the event held at Government House, Gusau, representatives of some beneficiary groups, including Mrs Martila Udowella of the Christian Association of Nigeria (CAN); Lolo Ugueze Theresa Obijiaku, wife of the HRH Chief of Igbo Community, Gusau; and Mrs Esther Ariyo of the Yoruba Women Community, expressed gratitude for the gesture.

    The welfare packages included bags of rice, cash support, pasta, sugar, cooking oil and other essential items aimed at easing the festive season burden on families across Zamfara State.

    Beneficiaries were drawn from a broad range of groups, including the Christian community, Yoruba and Igbo groups, Gidan Zala community, non-indigenes, as well as security and uniformed agencies such as the Army, Immigration, Customs, Police, Civil Defence, DSS, Road Safety, NDLEA, Prison Service, Zarota, Red Cross, teachers, nurses, doctors, market women, youths, NYSC members, scouts, vendors, fire service personnel, media organisations and banks.

    In her remarks, Huriyya Dauda appreciated the support given to Governor Dauda Lawal’s administration, noting that such solidarity strengthens ongoing efforts to improve citizens’ wellbeing. She described women as pillars of peace, stability and development, adding that their contributions remain vital to the growth of the state.

    “The strength of Zamfara lies in the resilience and commitment of its women. They are the backbone of our society, and your contributions continue to drive the growth and progress of our state,” she said.

    She explained that the gesture was intended to ease the burden on women during the festive period and ensure they celebrated Christmas with comfort and dignity. 

    She urged beneficiaries to share the items equitably within their groups, stressing that the initiative promotes compassion, unity and collective wellbeing.

    “I pray that this season brings peace, blessings and prosperity to every household. May we continue to work together to build a harmonious and prosperous Zamfara State,” she added.

    Hajiya Huriyya reaffirmed her commitment to promoting programmes that uplift women, strengthen families and enhance community development.

  • Hub seeks to redefine information use

    Hub seeks to redefine information use

    The maiden edition of the KM and Comms Village has debuted in Abuja with a bold mission to transform how organisations generate, interpret, and deploy information for smarter decision-making and impact.

    Designed as a multi-day, multi-format convening, the new initiative seeks to shift institutional thinking by treating knowledge as a central driver of strategy rather than a support function, by featuring expert roundtables, solution labs, knowledge clinics, storytelling hubs, micro-masterclasses, and curated showcases of tools and innovations, each aimed at fostering co-creation, better information use, and practical problem-solving.

    The Convener, Dr. Adeshola Komolafe, said the Village was conceived as “a needed space for collective thinking and problem solving,” noting that many institutions struggle not because they lack information but because they lack systems that convert data into actionable intelligence.

    She said: “The KM and Comms Village debuted from a simple but urgent question. How do we turn raw information into intelligence, and intelligence into action? This Village is a living community of practice where people can explore those questions together.”

    A key highlight of the debut was its intentionally curated physical environment, designed to reinforce the Village’s purpose of demonstrating how knowledge and communication shape organisational impact.

    She said: “We created the KM and Comms Village to demonstrate that knowledge and communication are not support functions. They are strategic levers that shape how organisations think, respond, and create impact.

    “Every installation, every visual, every object in this Village is intentional. We want participants to experience what it means to communicate with purpose, to see how knowledge can be translated into clarity, and to understand that systems of learning and communication must be built deliberately.”

    She added that the Village was designed as an open, cross-sector meeting point saying, “This space is not reserved for experts. It is a place where programme leads, researchers, policy specialists, data analysts, storytellers, civil society actors, government representatives, creatives, students, and curious minds can come with questions and leave with clarity. That is what a true community of practice offers.”

    According to her, today’s development and governance challenges require breaking down silos.

    “To address complex issues, we must dismantle silos. The Village is designed as a meeting point for diverse perspectives to engage, challenge assumptions, and build better systems.”

    She emphasised that the long-term vision was to build a leading platform for thought leadership, capacity strengthening, and innovation at the intersection of knowledge and communication.

    “The Village aims to produce actionable prototypes, documented insights, strengthened networks, and a living repository of tools, stories, and lessons.

    “We are nurturing an active community of practice committed to continuous learning, creativity, and collaboration. With this debut, we are not just hosting an event; we are opening a space where ideas breathe, where knowledge becomes usable, and where communication drives meaningful transformation.”

    Describing the experience as a game-changer for the field, one of the participants, Joseph Mutah called it “the beginning of something important that will influence how institutions approach knowledge and communication,”

    Another participant, Khadija Monguno said “the Village brings learning, creativity, and strategy into one coherent space. It shows what becomes possible when ideas are allowed to breathe and when communication is treated as a craft.”